Winkers The Fraud Triangle Case Study

Improved Essays
Mogel’s Incorporated had multiple issues that produced the opportunity for Stefan Winkler to commit the crimes that he carried out. The main issue was the amount of access to Mogel’s assets Winkler had. As a result of this access and know how, Winkler had all opportunities in the world to steal as much as he did. If Mogel Inc. would incorporate a few tactics to strengthen their internal controls they could prevent this type of fraud within their business. Stefan used multiple types of skimming in order to carry out his crimes. The majority include Skimming and lapping of Accounts receivable, which are a result from poor collection procedures and poor supervision from higher management. By applying the basics of Cressey’s study to analyze winkers …show more content…
The first consist of situational pressure, which include personal or work related stressors. Stefan’s pressures included the recent loss of his home, and other financial downfalls. Leg two consists opportunity, involving direct access to assets. In this case Winkler had control over many cash assets, along with extensive know how to cover his tracks for the time being.(Hall, 2013) The last portion of the fraud triangle involves rationalization, or the ethic views of the perpetrator. (Hall, 2013)/(Wells, 2014) Clearly Stefan had a terrible conscience, he made unethical decisions and it cost both Mogel and Winkler. Ten suggestion that could help the Mogel Inc. Include the following:
1) Mogel collection system creates a big issue, which gave Stefan the chance to commit his crime. Because Stefan has access to both area where revenue, he was able to steal from the company. Page 62 in wells text book, explains that by providing extra oversight presence skimming opportunities should decreases would should prevent future criminal
…show more content…
(Wells, 2014) Because of his position Winkler had access to multiple different financial statements. By stealing and destroying the documents he made it tough to prosecute. By adding an electronic filing system and backup copies non accessible to anyone other than top management, Mogel Inc. could have avoided this issue, and prevent it from happening again.
9) By adding computer programs that regularly audit the companies statements is another preventive control that could be set in place to detect fraud. Although Computer programs are only as good as the program itself, it still one step that could truly help prevent Winkler’s crime from happening again.
10) Running trend analysis on aging of customer accounts can also be used to detect skimming. (Wells,2014) A rise in the number or size of overdue accounts could be a sign of an employee skimming from the company.(Wells, 2014) By running this program, Mogel Inc. could detect Skimming earlier before it’s too late and employees like Winkler walk off with over 350,000 dollars of their

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    1. Common law fraud. HOLO issued false financial reports and hided the embezzlement on purpose, Tony willfully expressed the unqualified opinion on financial statements and internal controls. This was a fraud.…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Many white-collar crimes occurred in the past and today, but not all of them compare to the Wells Fargo case. In a large company like Wells Fargo, checking employees every so often to ensure that they are fulfilling the quality and legality of their position is vital. Success of a company depends on the honesty and dedication put into it by its employees. Wells Fargo not only violated moral values, but also American laws. This white-collar crime will never be forgotten in American history if business values, laws, and policies continue to remain…

    • 1195 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Relevant social issues involved. Standards must be in place to aid society. There must be standards that prevent an agent from negating responsibility for tort liability simply, because he or she was acting on someone else behalf. There must be safe guards for a principle to recover loss due to negligence or criminal acts. The law offer at least two remedies for Romanelli remuneration against Schor; criminal proceeding and Tort liabilities laws. Embezzlement Sec. 174. “A person who as the agent… converts to his or her own use, … without the consent of his or her principal, any money or other personal property of his or her principal … that is under his or her charge or control by virtue of his or her being an agent…is guilty of embezzlement”.…

    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Polycom Fraud Case Study

    • 1573 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The auditors should assess the company’s environment and market in order to determine whether there is a possibility of the management fraud. The auditors could gather an understanding by investigating the management’s background, look for any factors that signal a motivation for fraud and the management’s influence in making decisions for the organization. (© 2016 Cengage Learning).…

    • 1573 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “Of the accounts on the company’s books, which are the most vulnerable to fraud, and why?”…

    • 1707 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Just out of high school, Minkow made his carpet cleaning company look profitable by stealing money in every way possible (Investopedia). He prepared burglaries to obtain money for insurance, he borrowed $2,000 from his grandmother and then stole her pearls, and when he wanted physical cash, he would forge money orders of around $13,000 from a local liquor shop (Ciulla). All of these actions made Minkow’s company look profitable when it really was not having any business at all. In 1985, Minkow extended his stealing by opening a fake merchant’s account in a local bank giving him the ability to accept payments through credit cards (Ciulla). For the following years after this action, whenever he needed money, he would create a phony charge on a customer’s credit card and take their cash from the bank for himself…

    • 637 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The desire to achieve self-gains is one of the factors that drive the actions of a fraudster who engages in corporate fraud. Financial strain is also a major motive concerning the presented unethical behavior in the workplace. Evidently, fraud can lead one to amass a large amount of finances…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Leslie Fay Case Summary

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages

    This is because a person who dominates the accounting function, can easily perpetrate and conceal the wrongdoing. This leads to increased inherent risk and control risk, and the same should be carefully assessed by the auditors. A high control and inherent risk means that the auditors will have to do more substantive testing in order to reduce their detection risk. Detection risk must be reduced to lower the overall audit risk to such a level that the auditors consider acceptable, in order to proceed with the audit. Also, Leslie Fay’s manual system of accounting, keeping the earnings and revenue high despite of the recession phase and distribution of exorbitant bonuses on the basis of sales, should have caught the auditor’s attention to believe it to be a motive to commit fraud. The auditors should have taken such circumstances into consideration, while planning the audit.…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Each of these false employees had the same mailing address. If you refer to exhibit A, you will notice that Marie McAulley, Terry Talbot and Paul Owens all shared the address of P.O. Box 384, Woodville. A request was made to ADP for access to the checks and it was noted that all checks were endorsed by a Jessica Keller, see exhibit B. We were able to locate and interview Ms. Keller, who is currently in San Antonio, TX. She stated that a while back, when she was passing through Tallahassee, a man matching Mr. Hill’s description approached her and asked if she would open an account at SunTrust in exchange for $100. She also stated that the number to the P.O. box would be 384, which she remembered easily as it was her locker number in school. Please see the attached correspondence in Exhibit C. A subpoena was requested and granted for access to the bank account records from SunTrust. The results are seen in Exhibit D. The sum of the deposits on each date are $148.23. These match the pay dates of April 6, April 28, May 17, June 10, June 29 and July 14. This fraud resulted in a loss of…

    • 1242 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Nashwinter Case

    • 448 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Goodwin & Company, the auditor, took a lax approach even when faced with evidence that the final numbers were suspect. If they had known that William Nashwinter, the general manager responsible for the inventory account balance, was under pressure to improve performance, perhaps they would have taken more care during the audit. Instead of simply accepting Nashwinter’s excuses without following up on them, the auditor should have challenged Nashwinter to explain the discrepancies. Second, Analytical procedures would have shown the rapid growth in the inventory account over the three-year period. This should have instructed them to seek an explanation from the company that showed why Nashwinter’s division alone was growing inventory at that rate. Finally, Thomas Wilson and Frank Pollard, the lead auditors, didn’t fully count the inventory because they felt that the freezer was too cold. Because of this, they were not able to fully verify the accuracy of the inventory account balance. There is no excuse for the pitiful job that Goodwin & Company did on this audit. However, if the auditor had known the full extent of the situation that William Nashwinter was in, they could have realized that he fit the three categories of the fraud triangle. This would have hopefully led to a more thorough…

    • 448 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    White-collar crimes, although not discussed very often, are on rise. When one hears the word crime, they are inclined to think violence or an unethical abuse of some sort. However, people rarely take corporate crimes such as fraud, theft, forgery, or embezzlement into a higher regard, as they do not highly affect the common citizen personally. Studying these executive crimes is important to raise awareness of deceit within society, and to protect and prevent unethical practices from occurring. The latent impact of these white-collar crimes is the emotional trauma, blackmail, and loss of finances. This is very critical, as some of the victims of this crime end up loosing their life savings and their confidence in humanity. There…

    • 1228 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Peregrine Fraud Case Study

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages

    At Peregrine, the risk factors, especially those aligned with control environment factors and the “tone at the top” are discussed. The risks included having a paper based confirmation system for the entire business; no segregation of duties, which meant that only one or very few people were working on the financial statements, and in this case Mr. Wasendorf was the only one and had altered all bank documents using only Photoshop, excel, scanners, and printers. Continuing on, time off was not required at Peregrine, which could have ultimately discovered this fraud much earlier, by allowing someone else to sit in the absentee’s seat and review all of their work. Additionally, Peregrine lacked internal auditors or an audit committee at the time. The presence of the internal auditors could have decreased odds of misstatement incentives to commit fraud by management, called fraudulent financial reporting, and overseen…

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the most important things I learnt from this class, is to specify the definition of the “white-collar crime” first whenever I want to talk about it. There are two major approaches to define the white-collar crime, one is offender-based, and the other…

    • 1120 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A justification for secret trusts based on fraud is considered as a reason why the secret trustee should not take the testator’s property as an absolute gift, but not by itself a reason why secret trusts ought to be enforced for the interest of the genuine beneficiates. A possible way round this problem is to give the term “fraud” a wider meaning. According to Allan’s analysis, case laws have shown that “the view that fraud must involve the secret trustee gaining personally was rejected outright”.…

    • 851 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some of the fraud risk factors at Peregrine include; the nature of transactions (cash), Separation of duties, Complexity of transactions, dominance, and expectations. The fraud triangle includes three portions in order for fraud to take place; these portions are opportunity, rationalization, and pressure. The risk of fraud decreases significantly when multiple employees are involved in different phases of a transaction. During the embezzlement Wasendorf, was the only one in the company who was able to see each transaction from the bank. This would give him the opportunity to forge the notes to show the public, he had the pressure on him to continue what he had started in order to keep the company afloat, as well he was rational in…

    • 1322 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays