Essay On The Atomic Bomb Dbq

Improved Essays
During WWII there was one major discovery that not only changed history then, but also continues to change how wars are fought to this day. Yes, this discovery was the atomic bomb. Harry Truemen is credited with saying, “It’s (referring to the atomic bomb) production and its use were not lightly undertaken by this government.” To the general public this might seem like a typical wartime statement. He goes on (in document H) to say that since we had the technology we used it to decimate Japan and stop them from attacking the U.S, but is that all the bomb was used for? From an astounding amount of examples against the idea that the U.S. only used the bomb to attack japan the answer is no. The bomb was used also, to intimidate the Soviet Union. In document H, as stated before Truman talks about why we must use the bomb to stop japan, but everything he says could also be applied to a future war, one with the Soviet Union. …show more content…
The difference between them; however, is how they present the idea of why we would use the atomic bomb in this circumstance. Document B, leaves the ending more open, letting the reader infer why we would drop the bomb. The author, a commander in the air force, would have known the true reasons, but yet again, like Truman, does not want to scare the public. He ends his argument in saying that “atomic bomb or no atomic bomb, the Japanese were already on the verge of collapse.” He wants the reader to understand what he is saying, which is that the U.S.A. was strictly doing this to scare Soviet Russia. Document F on the other hand, written by a physicist states this fact blatantly, that we need to do this to scare the Soviet Union. He comes right out in saying this because he has no ties to the government and can come right out, without fear, to say what others can’t, we must stop the influence of Communism by the Soviet Union now, to prevent problems

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Beside President Truman motivations which was to end the war, he was still new to this idea of the atomic bombs. Stimson Secretary of War brief him on the topic and advised Truman to drop the bombs. Stimson reasoning for doing this was to first end the war with Japan and secondly to scare the USSR. Since Truman wanted to know more so that he make the right decision and with Stimson they help formed the Interim Committee. It included high ranking military officials and top scientist from the Manhattan Project as advisor like Oppenheimer, Fermi, Lawrence, and Arthur Compton.…

    • 1049 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The bombing of Hiroshima, Japan in 1945 proved to be a controversial ending to the Second World War. There were several reasons why the bomb was dropped, but it still remains that the main reason given to the public was to end the war. However, the US used this opportunity to initiate a sense of power over the Soviet Union in order to discourage the spread of communism. President Harry Truman spoke of this bombing at the White House to inform the American public of his reasoning for this atomic bomb, and how it will be known for much more than “the size of the enterprise, it’s secrecy, [or] its cost.”. The immense amount of destruction and devastation seen by the innocent people of Hiroshima is unbearable to come to terms with.…

    • 1517 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In his essay he argues one of the reasonings for the use of the bomb was to scare the Soviets and to prevent an invasion of the Red Army in Manchuria. He also uses diary entries from Stimson and Byrnes to prove his argument. “And at the end of May, according to Szilard, Byrnes saw the bomb as a way to make Russia more manageable in Europe”(Alperovitz, 411). Then using the primary sources such as Stimson’s journal entries it is clear to see his second thoughts over the use of the bomb. He states “In many quarters it [America’s development of the atomic bomb] has been interpreted as a substantial offset to the growth of Russian influence on the continent”(Stimson, 1945).…

    • 1359 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Not to mention that they wanted the debut of the atomic bomb to be ¨sufficiently spectacular¨ and for the whole world to see America’s power (Wellerstein). This being the one of main reasons for targeting Hiroshima is not morally right, and the U.S. should’ve chosen an area that was strictly military and/or industry.…

    • 1709 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Not only did America have the strongest army, navy, and air force, but also the atomic bomb, a secret weapon capable of such vast destruction that no one had a defense against it (Capio 65). Dropping the bombs ended the war quickly before the Russians could become involved. Truman and his advisors did not want Russia to enter the fighting, and have a chance to demonstrate their power. Diary entries by Secretary of State Henry Stinson detailed these thoughts at the time. Stinson referred to the bombs as the “master card” in dealing, not just with Japan, but with the Soviet Union as well (Messer 50).…

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The USSR and United States both had chances to send nuclear bombs to the other nation, but neither did. They did not because they feared what would have happened if they did. As the leaders of the two nations kept their fingers over the button to send the bombs over they kept Hiroshima and Nagasaki in the back of their minds. Imagine if the Allied powers won the war without the use of the atomic bombs. Would the cold war have been a cold war, would weapons have been used instead?…

    • 1031 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Thus, in Dr. Strangelove it is emphasized that, “Yes but the whole point of the doomsday machine…. is lost if you keep it a secret! Why didn’t you tell the world, eh?” In addition, Failsafe dramatizes cold war anxieties about the meaning of automation when it comes to the detonation of the atomic bomb. Anxiety was increasing because people were involved in the judgment and decision process which would activate the machines. The possibility emerged that nuclear war could be triggered by a mechanical error in the automated systems.…

    • 1273 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This simply means that he had to consider all other aspects, but mainly focus on what was right in terms of war. Because of the conflict and fighting that had already been occurring, including the surprise bombing of Pearl Harbor a few years prior, Truman did have the justification he needed to give the order. The atomic bombs would make an end to the war much quicker, but would also provide vengeance to those of the Pearl Harbor attacks and give justice to the funding and time put into creating it. Alternatives had been brought, most suggesting that bombing a less populated area would be enough to intimidate them. However, Truman dismissed this and stated it wasn’t go to be enough to force them to surrender.…

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This summarizes his position on the attacks on Japan. To be able to say whether or not the bombings should have happened, you must first understand the thought and planning that came behind this action. Walkers believes that if Truman truly didn’t want to use the bomb, he somehow could have found a way to not use it. Walker also states that he believes that any president in Truman’s positon would have found the use of the atomic bomb to be necessary. This being said, we can more clearly depict that Walker thought that the use of the atomic bomb was in a way necessary.…

    • 989 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In other words he agreed that sending the bomb would help the United States in not only win against Japan also it would move the U.S. into a leading position in the postwar world. In the book of Created Equal, it tells the readers that President Truman was hoping to send the message to the Soviet Union that the United States “would be the dominant power in the postwar world” he wanted to avoid “an invasion of Japan that would have cost the lives of many America soldiers”. However scientist that help in the development of the atomic bomb gave another option to President Truman, they wanted to do a demonstration of the atomic bomb to the Japanese in an isolated place just to scare them but no cause any harm to…

    • 1728 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays