Anti Trafficking Protocol

Great Essays
Title

Law and immigration officials play a direct role in how potential trafficking victims are treated. Because of this, their perception of these victims in light of anti-trafficking protocol and legislation should be understood.

Introduction

As a global phenomenon, human and sex trafficking receive attention from a variety of sources. There are several controversial issues surrounding trafficking, such as the criminalization and misclassification of victims as ‘illegal immigrants.’ The definition of trafficking is to some extent responsible for this, as anti-trafficking protocol usually define it in terms of criminal activity rather than a human rights violation. Anti-trafficking protocols make it difficult to classify female sex workers
…show more content…
How do law enforcement officials define trafficking?
2. Who qualifies as a victim of trafficking?
3. Where do law enforcement officials draw the line between a sex worker and a victim of trafficking, if such a line exists?
4. How does anti-trafficking legislation or protocols effect enforcement officials’ perception of trafficking
…show more content…
As a high number of trafficking victims are females exploited for the sex industry, there is much time spent discussing the rights of woman in these situations and the legislation surrounding them. Julia O’Connell Davidson focuses on misclassification of victims of trafficking as illegal migrant workers or illegal immigrants. Despite the trafficking industry growing on a huge scale and the creation of a special project to support victims of trafficking, “the number of people who have been identified as ‘victims of trafficking’ (VoTs) and assisted as such is very small” (Davidson, 2006 p.5). Davidson (2006, p.6) suggests this is occurs because many VoTs are seen as illegal immigrants who must be deported. The source of the problem of misclassification appears to the high standard which woman are expected to meet to be seen as VoTs. The standard is essentially physical suffering. Feminist abolitionists have insisted that sex trafficking results in routine rape, beating, and torture, but this has had the unintended consequence of altering the narrative of who counts as a victim. Women are therefore only seen as victims if they have received intense physical suffering, which many victims of trafficking have not. Julia O’Connell Davidson quotes an observer of anti-trafficking campaigns, “Trafficked women [in the anti-trafficking campaign literature] are dis-identified from

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Sex Trafficking Summary

    • 1004 Words
    • 5 Pages

    An aspect that links these two approaches together is the dynamics of supply and demand (Hughes, 2008), this includes the demand for sex workers, as well the individuals that are the consumers of commercial sex (Hughes, 2008). Although both the victim-centered and perpetrator-centered approaches are extremely vital to the fight against human trafficking, there needs to be an assessment into the systemic/personal background issues that produces the ‘supply’ aspect, in terms of the women that are trafficked. For example, an analysis into how the ongoing legacy of colonialism (Grant, 2016), renders Indigenous women to be at a high risk to being trafficked, due to systemic racism, poverty, poor housing, and limited education among other issues (Grant, 2016), can be targeted in such a way that understand the layers of vulnerabilities, decreases…

    • 1004 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sex Trafficking Vs Labor

    • 1993 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The victims of sex trafficking are targeted by the use of violence, threats, lies, false promises, debt bondage, or manipulation (Polaris Projects, 2007). These forms of control are used in the controlling of other persons so that they stay involved for “their” own profit (Polaris Project, 2007). Most think that sex trafficking involves a little room where a person is trapped, tied, or even caged and they are beaten when they do not do what they are suppose to. That is true, but that is not always the case. Sex trafficking exists in diverse and unique areas of where sex trafficking actually happens.…

    • 1993 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sex trafficking violates the human rights of these men, women, boys, and girls. Feminists argue that human trafficking against women in the form of sex trafficking is very harmful to their bodies, and their general wellbeing. They find an issue with victims’ protection when it comes to sex trafficking. On the other side of this debate, according to Duong (2014), “The others, who support prostitution as a legitimate work, want to compromise with the legalization of prostitution as a way to reduce sex trafficking.” (p. ) People in charge of sex trafficking institutions are very experienced with the industry and they know just how to hide it. Also, many victims of human trafficking do not seek help because they don’t want to be seen as less pure or weak.…

    • 1946 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    By all means, strategies aimed at trafficking should focus on trafficking and the criminal nature of this activity and those involved in this conduct rather than on the activity of the victims of trafficking. To my own point view, legislations should focus more on the demand and educate the buyers as much as they do attempt to educate potential victims. It is important to let them know what they are feeding. Perhaps, the EU should consider to put into place campaigns that target clients to consider the legality of the women they visit . Or even from a more extreme point of view sanction buyers like we punish traffickers .There is many ways to reduce world wide trafficking of persons for sex-exploitation but the most immediate is…

    • 2739 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Truly, sex trafficking is an omnipresent issue that violates several human rights including the right to human dignity, the right to work without being forced, the right to personal autonomy, the right to enjoy physical and mental health, and the right to a just and favorable wage (Allais). Trafficking is a petrifying process that involves physical, sexual, and psychological abuse and violence. It also exposes the victims to HIV and other sexually transmitted diseases. When people hear about sex trafficking, they usually think of faraway places, but the reality is sex trafficking is occurring in their own backyards. Sex trafficking is the most common form of modern-day slavery.…

    • 1763 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Typically, people correlate sex trafficking and prostitution, when they are not one in the same. To believe that the correlation is relevant would require ignorance and unawareness. The feminists approach are vital for opposing and understanding the phenomena. Their most significant influence lies in the examination of the social structure of human trafficking (Lobasz, 2009). The beliefs that trafficking is easily noticeable and obvious are falsely portrayed.…

    • 1845 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This form of collaboration will go a long way in combating trafficking. With regards to sex tourism, there is a need to combat it from the root which is building capacities of women especially young single mothers who are forced out of their homes to fend for their children. While in the trade, the women are easy to lure into drug trafficking with the quick money that it promises. It is after they are in the trade that they get ensnared and are trafficked for monetary gain by the drug lords. Fighting Drug Trafficking Considering that the illegal drug trade is the major financial backbone in human trafficking, cutting off funding can be a solution to ending human trafficking.…

    • 1681 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A Review of Current Policing Practices in Relation to Human Trafficking. Introduction Background; There are many policing practices and regulations in place regarding human trafficking. These are in place for the safety of those who have been a victim to this. Human trafficking is when a person or persons are trafficked between countries illegally. The National Crime Agency states that human trafficking ‘is the movement of a person(s) from one place to another into conditions of exploitation, using deception, coercion, the abuse of power or the abuse of someone’s vulnerability.’ (National Crime Agency, 2014) Not only does trafficking mean international crossing over the border, but a victim could also be trafficked within their own country…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Forms Of Human Trafficking

    • 1527 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Some countries purposely avoid these and continue to allow human trafficking. One of the main arguments about human trafficking is the cause of it. Pinpointing the cause is important because that can help prevent the trafficking from occurring. Some of the most popular causes are poverty, famine, and the traffickers themselves. An argument that was made about the cause of human trafficking was, “human trafficking is caused by human traffickers—criminals who commit criminal acts against victims and vulnerable people.” (United Nations Inter-Agency Project on Human Trafficking).…

    • 1527 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    for a long time, although, for some it has been and is still a well-hidden crime. It is considered an organized crime because the victims are not free to choose their destiny. Victims are subject to the command of others who completely control their time and body as a business. This implies that people are voluntary or involuntary controlled under conditions of violence in most cases to perform labor and sex services, especially women and children. Trafficking, especially sex trafficking of young girls, has become a major problem for the United States.…

    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays