Utilitarianism In Social Media

Improved Essays
It is reasonable for an employer to use social networking websites to screen job applicants and to use what they find as the basis for not hiring them, as long as the applicant 's information is public. This idea is supported by the Utilitarianism theory of ethics. The Utilitarian seeks the greatest amount of good for the greatest number of people. They would argue that an individual 's rights, while important, are not as important as the consequences are to the entire business organization. A Utilitarian would conclude that screening is ethical when choosing whether to hire someone. Screening applicant’s social media websites enables managers to understand more about the potential applicants, prevents potential damage to the company’s image …show more content…
Employers are well aware that individuals who are involved with inappropriate actions or behavior on social media are a substantial risk. Employees with social media posts or favorites about drugs or alcohol, racist or sexist remarks, or inappropriate political, sexual, or personal information can severely harm a company’s image. Pictures and comments that contain drugs and alcohol may drive some clients and investors away. Also, employees that exhibit tendencies of racism or sexism will hurt the company. In addition, an employee 's derogatory comments will weaken relationships with coworkers and managers resulting in a poor corporate culture. Inappropriate political, sexual, or personal information that is posted on employees social networking websites is available to be viewed by anyone. One post can cause major publicity allowing for competing companies or potential clients to view this post and use it against the company creating losses in many of its departments. For instance, customers may accuse a company of having an extremist working for them causing other consumers to stop using that company which leads to investors pulling out. The Utilitarianism approach to ethics would argue that one employee ruining a company’s reputation could have negative consequences on stakeholders. It would morally be correct to put thousands of people’s well being …show more content…
Prospective employees who routinely post pictures or comments about being under the influence of drugs or alcohol may come to work impaired. This inappropriate behavior makes them less effective and efficient in their job. There may also be increased monetary costs related to their poor choices including: medical and insurance costs, work-sponsored treatment programs, and time off. This hurts the productivity of the company on all levels; the coworkers who have to pick up the additional workload or the human resource department and managers who have to deal with the problem. Reduction in productivity and additional expenses could not only hurt the financial situation for the employees of the company but also thousands of stockholders. The teleologic beliefs held by a Utilitarian would say that these possible financial consequences would override any moral dilemma about checking applicant’s social media websites. Companies who screen social media accounts hope to eliminate a future employee’s substandard performance and to reduce potential financial

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The authors agree that, “It is imperative to use this tool in a manner that will not expose employers to discrimination lawsuits,” (Reinsch, et. al. 156). This statement is true because even though Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act is in place, there is still a majority of gray area that employers need to distinguish for themselves. For instance, if someone is caught with the murder weapon in a crime scene, there is a reasonable assumption that he or she is guilty. This type of guilty assumption is the same type of scenario as with social media and employment processes. If the employer retrieves discriminatory information from social media profiles and decides not to hire that applicant, it can be assumed that the employer used the disclosed discriminatory information against the applicant in the hiring decision and be at risk for a lawsuit. Ultimately, if an employer does choose to use social media in the employment processes, they must be careful not to use the information they retrieve…

    • 1021 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Alfred Edmond Jr’s “Why Asking for a Job Applicant’s Facebook Password Is Fair Game,” Edmond explains his reasoning behind why he thinks that employers should be able to ask for the social media passwords for the applicant’s accounts. In his article Edmond argues the case that an employer should be able to ask a job applicant for their Facebook password as a consideration for employment from a prospective employee. Edmond raises some valid points about asking for an employee’s Facebook password, however his some of his supporting points do not connect to his main argument and his argument suffers as a whole because of it.…

    • 1331 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Social media in the workplace has been controversial for a while. There are different sides, the good and the bad. The cons involve problems with the law and bans. Like the case of a man working at a health care place and getting fired after posting a threat. He said that he was only venting about the patient (Horowitz, 2014). Bans are getting made on social media to prevent people from using technology from work to use for personal or non-business use (Lyncheski, 2010). The pros involve the rights of the employees while on social media. This is the case when a company didn’t allow their employees to discuss wages or employment to a third party. A national board then fined the company because this is unlawful (Horowitz, 2014).…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Inequalities In Society

    • 1178 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Companies are now able to easily access a lot of personal information of their workers and even potential job candidates. This is a severe limiting factor to what people can post online on a social media site. Companies understand that, “modern capitalism has become a complex game, and those who win at it have to have more than a little smarts” (Stiglitz 400). Companies need to resort to shady practices to get advantage over competition and to ensure that their employees are loyal. Essentially, blackmail and leaking information is incredible at unfairly degrading rival companies and the internet has become quite the battleground for big business. The company who has a greater web influence and presence will be able to dominate a potential market. A company that, “controls the wires or airwaves can control the Internet” (Wu 545). Corporations are trying their best to have the most amount of control of information on the internet. Social media sites that provide the ability to spread ideas and opinions now become a provider of information directly to large corporations. Currently, the large businesses are only using the information gathered online to develop efficient targeting advertising. However, these companies may realize how much power they have over the people of society, and use their opinions and actions against…

    • 1178 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    A similar case at Lougheed Imports v. Local was undergone in 2010, where employees posting a few comments about their employer on Facebook was deemed proper cause for the termination of their employment. By contextualizing the following dilemma with similar happenings, it is evident that Ethan’s public assessment of the retirement home as well as their management acted as a trigger for the supervisor to confide in the human resource department; ultimately beginning the conversation of his termination.…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    As the progress of technological innovation marches on, it brings a new layer of complications to the labor relations process. More than ever, the challenge of balancing employee privacy with employer interests presents immense difficulties, especially with regards to social media. The two cases examined in the following pages form a framework for a cursory investigation of workplace privacy and an employer’s interest and legal rights to restrict the digital activities of their employees. In the first case, First Alert Medical Response (First Alert) ambulance service exercised those rights when they fired Betty Nelson over social media postings (Holley, Jennings, & Wolters, 2012). A recent Idaho Supreme Court decision supports First Alert’s actions. By comparing and contrasting these two cases, the issues of technology and job protection in the contemporary workplace can be prudently considered and a legal case made for reasonable workplace social media policies.…

    • 1334 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Social media has a huge impact on society. Society relies on social media for so many things like the news, entertainment, and information. The concept of integrity can be applied through social media in many ways, such as positive and negative. The negative often out ways the positive when it comes to social media, social media is often displayed in a negative way. People have become so depended on social media for everything. Society has this idea that they have to live up to social media. “Most fundamentally perhaps, it is because communications has a very ambiguous character in respect of the claims of “society” or, those made on behalf of the “public interest” (McQuil2). Society often feels they need to meet the requirement of “public interest” and with doing that they often lack integrity. Integrity is the quality of being proven to be trustworthy and having morals. In the world today, society lack morals. Social media lacks morals. The internet, such as social media websites, often causes ones to become more close minded to reality. Integrity is not shown through social media. “Social networking can make people more media literate, but ultimately the real challenge is the need for someone to vent the information” (O’Connor172). If one is not careful about what they post they often bring harm to themselves. Reveling personal information on social networks can often make a user vulnerable to crimes such as identity theft, stalking, and etc. Many employers perform a background check through the internet before hiring an employee. If a future employee has posted anything that might be embarrassing or negative on social media it can affect their chances of getting a…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The next type of posts to avoid is anything that could be seemed as discriminatory. In today’s day and age, anything that could have even a slight connotation of being racist could have a disastrous consequence for any affiliated company. As a result, companies have zero tolerance for any discrimination on social media, whether by employee prospects or current employees. According to an article on Forbes.com, a PR worker tweeted a racist tweet before boarding a flight to Africa, and before her plane had even landed she was publically fired by her…

    • 1069 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Employers have been taking advantage of the public nature of the internet and using it to spy on their employees, and using their posts as a reason to fire them. While bigotry is in awful in every way, shape, or form, people are entitled to their nasty opinions, whether it be outloud or online. And now that is it a new and notorious method of not only prospective employers, but also college admissions offices, and schools in general, the general public has conformed to the expected standards of those groups, instead of standing up for their right to privacy online. Many parents now closely monitor their children’s social media accounts, or don’t let them have an account at all, to ensure they won’t tarnish their reputation and endanger their chances of getting a job or being accepted into a college. Most people now censor themselves on their accounts, only post formal photos and statuses on websites like Facebook and Twitter, instead of challenging the social media companies themselves, to force them to make their private accounts truly private. Now if someone is doing something illegal online, that should have consequences and law enforcement officers should get involved in that kind of situation, but that kind of information would find its way to prospective employers, since breaking a law goes on someone’s permanent record. But people shouldn’t be getting…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although this could happen, employers have the right by law to look for personal information and use it (Jolly). With the information people given, they can spread rumors (Parks 39). Peoples perspectives on social media or reality, they can make lies about a person; subsequently, the threats, embarrassing pictures, and sharing private information without the person's consent have increased within online websites and working environments (Parks 40). Meanwhile, multiple times in a workplace sometimes employers afflicted their employees. Through these vile actions, the victim may commit suicide (Paris 41). An oppressed person will try and get help, or they can even take their own life. In each environment, bullying affects many people, and others hack information from websites to torment a…

    • 609 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Potential employers use social media to find out information about a new hire including your lifestyle, relationships and positions on social and political topics before they ever actually meet you face to face. This information could suggest you aren’t right for the job therefore they discriminate against you because they made a judgment only based on your online profile. Jury consultants use social media analytics to find out a wide range of information to determine if you would be a problematic juror completely based on your online presence and this has completely change the effectiveness of juror selection. While new found power in social media has increased the effectiveness of an individual to be heard it has also increased the potential of discrimination as some will seek out your information for their own benefit and make judgments about you that may not be…

    • 657 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Ethical Issues Of Social Media

    • 992 Words
    • 4 Pages
    • 2 Works Cited

    Legal challenges begin when employers attempt to control the how, when and why current employees use social media sites. A leading concern for employers is when employees choose to use social media websites. Employee’s use of social media websites can lead to a decrease in production and distracted personnel. For an employer the distraction an employee can be problematic. Not only are distracted employees more likely to get into costly accidents the quality of the product they are producing can be affected and may present a safety issue to product users. The two areas that are the most difficult to construct rules around are how and why such sites are used. Employers need to be careful not to construct social media polices that are not overly broad. While a clear business need exists to protect proprietary information, employers should also be careful not to exceed their bounds and attempt to prevent employees from organizing and voicing their opinions on work conditions. If an employer attempts to prevent employees from organizing to voice opinions on current working conditions the company’s social media policy would violate of Section 7 of the National Labor Relations Act. While employers have been successful at winning lawsuits pertaining to termination of employees based on a single disparaging remark made by an employee as soon as other employees begin to become involved the courts tend to rule in favor of the employees. (Hidy…

    • 992 Words
    • 4 Pages
    • 2 Works Cited
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Social media has its online dangers that the individual must be aware of. Social media used negativity can cause a decline in productivity. For example, “Studies show that British companies have lost billions of dollars per year in productivity because of social media addiction among employees.” (Ta). Social media in a workplace can be dangerous to productivity levels. To prevent this, Jenny says, “Many companies have blocked social networks on their office Internet as addicted employees can distract themselves on such sites, instead of focusing on work.” (Ta). This shows that companies are aware of these dangers and are doing everything they can to prevent them. While this is only one downside to social media, it shows the traumatic loss a business can take by allowing employees to use social media while on the…

    • 1091 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Hiring Process

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the eyes of the employer, the most positive benefit of using social media as a hiring method is attaining the best possible employees and creating a more efficient hiring process. Social media allows employers to eliminate potential employees with bad online reputations. The article states the top three reasons a candidate is rejected are “concerns about the candidate’s lifestyle, inappropriate comments and text written by the…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Social Media Ethics Essay

    • 1535 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Employers will either use it to find people to work or to check an applicant’s credibility. According to Jonathan A. Segal, “There can be valuable information on a candidate’s social media pages that an employer lawfully can consider.” Meaning that they can legally obtain personal information from a profile, whether it be a picture or something that was said. This can make a major impact on who they interview and hire, because they want someone who will fit the job perfectly. It lets the hirers see what an applicant is like outside of their application. Although most do not look for the negatives, they may find something inappropriate without trying. Checking someone’s social media pages has become a growing trend in the work force and will only continue to grow with the new generation of…

    • 1535 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays

Related Topics