Stereotypes In Nursing

Superior Essays
Stereotypes have always been prevalent in the profession of nursing, most of which are negative and degrading. Many of these stereotypes have derived from how nursing is portrayed to the public through media sources such as television shows, movies, and commercials. The purpose of this essay is to identify and expand on the image of the professional nurse and how the media perceives it to be in comparison to three scholarly articles, which accurately reflect the nursing profession. The media source of which the three scholarly articles will be compared to is a film named Meet The Parents, more specifically a clip where Greg Focker is explaining his career choice of a nurse to his fiancées condescending parents. This essay will discuss how …show more content…
Greg is wearing half-buttoned pajamas with his hair a mess, while Pam and her family are dressed classy and well groomed. Greg presents himself as a passive, average male who is more sensitive and not as intelligent unlike his fiance’s family who mock him. Greg has to explain as to why he is a nurse since they cannot grasp the concept that someone would choose to be a nurse when they have the option to pursue a career like a doctor, and the fact that Greg wrote his MCAT yet still decided to be a nurse astonished both of them. When he finally builds the confidence to defend himself and his nursing career, Pam’s mother interrupts him to diffuse the situation and to prevent hurting the men’s egos. In this clip Greg is chastised because he is a male nurse, which makes him a minority and is not respected because males aren’t seen as efficient nurses, one has an image of a male nurse in their head as very feminen and simple-minded. The audience of this specific clip is geared to an older audience and to nurses in general to show that male nurses, aren’t shown respect by all professions, like in this clip for …show more content…
Even though the image of the male and female nurses have been improving over time there are still many misconceptions and misunderstandings of what nurses do and how complex their career really is. How Greg Focker explains his career choice of a nurse to his fiancées condescending parents was analyzed. It was discussed how this affects the views of nurses, how this media resource specifically affects the public views of nursing and finally I compared my findings with scholarly articles on the image of nursing (hkeener,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The public has different perceptions of the nursing profession which creates stereotypes. Throughout history, the nursing profession has had different reputations viewed by the public. Through the use of articles and media, the public forms beliefs in nursing stereotypes. These stereotypes lead to the shortage of nursing in the United States.…

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    These visions become a constant mirror of what that career consists, leaving the real life struggles hidden. Nursing is one of those careers that many people intend to pursue, and most people would say that they want to become a nurse because they want to help others. However, along with this answer, an individual could realize that nursing is not a career they wish to follow. Therefore, it’s essential that an individual digs deep into their real intentions when pursuing a career. The film, The American Nurse, projects the reality in nursing.…

    • 2026 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Image of the Professional Nurse As we view the media daily, we tend to see that there are many different aspects of our daily lives being portrayed either negatively or positively. The image of nursing is a very important factor because it may change people’s image on the professional nurse. The media portrays various misconceptions about nurses. However, the positive portrayals of nurses in some concepts are being revealed. This paper further explores how the image of the professional nurse is portrayed positively in the media.…

    • 1252 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Professional Nursing Role Term Paper All through this paper, I will be clarifying what nursing means to me, the image, roles, and responsibilities, along with a historical overview of nursing. This paper will likewise contain data about educational pathways for nurses, requirements, and opportunities for professional nursing employment. In conclusion this paper will incorporate points explaining the Code of Ethics for Nurses, identify nursing organizations, and an explanation over a current issue related to professional nursing. Personal Definition of Nursing…

    • 1301 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    These negative images and stereotypes exist because nurses allow them to. The Nursing Profession: Discussion Paper states, “Nurse should work harder to communicate both their professionalism and their contribution to the health care system.” By communicating to both the staff and the patients, they are clearing up the misconceptions about themselves. Another way nurses can promote their positive image is by keeping up with how society obtains information. The article states, “To be given due recognition, nurses could profit from using social media such as the internet and YouTube.”…

    • 166 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The most important day in your nursing career is the day you graduate. As new nurses, we look to the words of Florence Nightingale for guidance as we are called to respect all persons regardless of their background (Egeus, Leinung, 2013). Regardless of these significant words, nurses have failed to observe and carry them out, resulting in hostile work environments. When you ask others how a nurse should act, you expect to hear the words compassionate and caring, not cold, abrasive, disrespectful and violent. So why has a profession built on giving and caring acts, become one in which nurses treat each other with such negativity and abuse?…

    • 1680 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stethoscopes In Nursing

    • 1410 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In the application of social stereotypes and gender roles within the healthcare field, it is typical to presume that when waiting for a nurse to give care to a patient one expects a woman to walk into the room to set up the equipment for the presumably male doctor. However, this does not necessarily exemplify prejudice of nurses due to gender stereotypes, but it is a reflection of the knowledge that the profession itself is predominately female. Sexism toward women may lead to the idealization of the mothering role of female nurses, such that benevolent sexism toward women would predict more positive attitudes and stereotypes of female nurses (Clow, Rosemary, Wally). This concept supports the assumption that a professional role which revolves around ensuring the wellbeing of others, and providing the utmost care for patients during a traumatic period in their lives should be provided by a person who embodies the stereotypical caretaking qualities. One might even argue that a woman would be more competent than a man in this role, because of the fact that men stereotypically think in an analytical manner in contrast to one of compassion and…

    • 1410 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Great job articulating the message on such a hot topic. As we have discussed in previous years, stereotypes and social media are both issues when it comes to the nursing profession. Men face stereotypes in the workplace and can be interrogated by the media on their choice for nursing as a career, their sexuality, their masculinity and can be seen as unreliable and unable to follow “nursing characteristics” (Weaver, Ferguson, Wilbourn, & Salamonson, 2014). The media highlights these stereotypes making it difficult to recruit and retain male nurses despite the need for nurses as the baby boomers enter an age of increased chronic diseases and comorbidities.…

    • 245 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    To see residents in a nursing home enjoying life was quite eye opening. I have to admit I believed the stereotypes that a nursing home was institutional, almost hospital like. However, observing the quality of life the residents were displaying squashed my perceptions of nursing homes. The residents were full of life and very willing to speak with me and reflect on their life changes. Before this experience, I felt a nursing home was a place where the elderly did not have a voice, could not make their own decisions, lost their identity and went to die.…

    • 781 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Media’s Negative Impact on the Nursing Image Nurses are skilled and educated professionals. As caregivers they also provide education to their patients on improving their quality of life. Unfortunately, the image depicted in the media has not always been accurate or flattering (ONA, 2013). According to McNally (2009), “Whether nurses like it or not, modern media, and especially popular television drama, has shaped society’s perception of nursing”…

    • 1164 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The major concerns in relation to the nursing shortage are the lack of available nurses, nurse burn-out/job dissatisfaction, and decreased patient quality of care. Some proposed solutions for the nursing shortage are: 1) “retainment of experienced nurses”, 2) “recruitment of new graduates”, 3) encouragement to obtain double (or dual) degrees, and 4) positive depiction of the nursing field (Hickey Sumison & Harrison, 2010). Keeping a hold of experienced nurses in the health care setting is an effective solution to correcting the nursing shortage. To begin, experienced nurses offer knowledge and familiarity to both patients and new staff that keep the facility running smoothly (Gillen, 2013). This decreases the risk for codes and adverse events.…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stereotypes Of Nursing

    • 1050 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The social perception of nursing has changed substantially over the last few decades due to various factors which include sexism, NHS failings and media coverage. “One big problem is the unhealthy media portrayal of the profession, which plays a key role in forming and reinforcing popular attitudes. Even television dramas affect the public's views and decisions about health care” (Summers and Summers, 2010). The media is an enormous force influencing peoples’ beliefs globally in the same way that a politician will influence their political party, and with the ease of social media in the current day, news is travelling faster than ever. There are many aspects with relation to this topic that could be discussed, but the stereotyping of nurses…

    • 1050 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Stereotypes In Nursing

    • 433 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In nursing journals and in media men are rarely portrayed as nurses. Men are often assumed to be doctors (Genua, 2005, p.6). In the first scene of Meet The Parents, Focker is caring for a patient when the patient calls him doctor. Focker corrects the patient explaining to him that he is a nurse (Niro, Roach, Rosenthal, Tenenbaum & Roach, 2000). When the public is used to the idea that nurses are females it creates a barrier for men to provide care.…

    • 433 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Anyway one puts it, women have had a hard road in equality, something that was still occurring during the Vietnam War. Women, at the time, were regarded as “second class soldiers” (Carlson, “Women, the Unknown Soldiers”). The nurses had a rough time, especially in training. Apparently, orientation for nurses was a “bloody hell” (Carlson, “Women, the Unknown Soldiers”). “The surgeon threw a pair of scissors at me and said, "Don't just stand there.…

    • 1287 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This demonstrates social perceptions of nurses completely vary; although some individuals do not trust nurses frequently, there are individuals who still do. Ferns and Chojnacka, (2005) stated that a perception of a nurse will be formed in different ways, for example by personal acquaintance, contact during own or some else’s illness and throughout the media. Therefore, those who experienced a lack of care, relatives who witnessed it happen and those who have followed the reports which print the truth of the Midstaff’s Crisis are more likely to have a negative perception of a…

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays