Transcanada Case Study Summary

Improved Essays
TransCanada’s responses to its environment can be described by two actions: the drafting of the EIS and the Perryman Study and working with the Nebraska government to reroute the pipeline.
2.1 Environmental Impact Study and Perryman Study As to compile with the National Environmental Policy Act and the Department of State for a presidential permit that included a national interest determination, TransCanada had to prepare an EIS, which was a three-year study and examined “project design and safety, including the potential for oil spills, the potential impact on the Ogallala Aquifer and groundwater in the Sandhills regions, GHGs, wildlife, fisheries, cultural resources, visual resources, environmental justice, and an assessment of alternative
…show more content…
This can be addressed by integrating better technology into the pipeline that allows for efficient and effective detection of fractures or threats. My recommendation is for TransCanada to collaborate with new technology firms to stabilize the engineering of the pipeline, which would reassure the safety and maintenance of such a large-scale project. On the flip side, this initiative could be expensive and may yield inadequate results despite a lot of investment of money and time. Another risk is that they might not be able to find new companies who are researching and developing top-of-the-line oil transport …show more content…
The EIS was supposed to be an official document detailing how and why the TransCanada pipeline was “deemed desirable” (p. 7, 2014). Conversely, document created doubt and suspicion in the minds of the green stakeholders. It has even been stated that “one disgruntled senator – Bernie Sanders – initiated an investigation by the Inspector General of the State Department to see whether Cardno ENTRIX, the firm that did the [EIS], was somehow involved with TransCanada or biased in its work against various U.S. government agencies” (p. 12, 2014). The problem was that even the slightest hint of suspicion led to the undermining of the credibility of the EIS, which was an added factor to its failure. For environmental stakeholders, transparency of the research methods used is the key to gaining their acceptance of the project. The final EIS must list specific references and how they collected the data and came to the conclusions. TransCanada needs to back up their bold statements with hard facts and multiple sources of information. Furthermore, an open channel of communication or even a Q and A with green parties would demonstrate TransCanada’s earnest approach. The downside of developing transparency within the EIS is that it would slow down the process of its redrafting. Also, the environmentalists could be set in their ways and not want to participate in honest discussions of climate

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    “Tarmageddon”, an essay authored by Andrew Nikiforuk, demonstrates how the tar sands have negatively impacted Canada both economically and environmentally. The environmental factors are elaborated by explaining Canada’s contribution to green house emissions and acid rain when they were once a global leader against such pollutions. Nikiforuk compares Canada as being second worst for climate change next to Saudi Arabia since they started using bitumen. He highlights the politics surrounding the issues and includes the impact of the tar sands on public policy by stating that Canada no longer has a policy on climate change and have abandoned their targets. He goes on to include Prime Minister Stephen Harpers contribution to the corruption that branch out from the province of Alberta and his personal connection as “the son of an imperial oil executive” (AR.189).…

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Dakota Access Pipeline Controversy Introduction The Dakota Access Pipeline, or DAPL, is a proposed pipeline that would run one-thousand two-hundred miles from North Dakota to Illinois and carry more than four-hundred and seventy thousand barrels of crude oil. Ninety-nine percent of the land the pipeline covers is private land and does not need federal approval for construction. The Army Corps of Engineers reviewed the remaining one percent and concluded construction would have no serious impact on the environment. They decided to build the pipeline slightly north of the Standing Rock Reservation, directly through the tribe’s burial grounds, without their approval. The tribe believes that the pipeline would ruin the environment and their drinking water, despite the Corps’ claims.…

    • 587 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Americans have come together in support of the Tribe asking for a fair, balanced and lawful pipeline process. The environmental impact statement was wrongfully terminated. This pipeline was unfairly rerouted across our treaty lands. The Trump administration — yet again — is poised to set a precedent that defies the law and the will of Americans and our allies around the…

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Using Enbridge Northern gateway pipeline as a framework, explore how pipeline governance in Canada impacts the sovereignty of the Indigenous communities There is a growing concession of the need to consider the impact of large scale industrial development of resources extraction on indigenous communities in Canada, especially, projects which may have direct environmental impact on these communities, specifically, the tar sand industry. The aboriginal rights are protected by the Canadian constitution and the Canadian government is vested with the due responsibility of consulting the impacted aboriginal communities to amend and incorporate their interest where appropriate or as required, (D'Arcy, Black, Weis, & Russell, 2014). However, this…

    • 1246 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Keystone XL Pipeline is one of the most controversial policy issues in the last few years. Hundreds of millions of dollars have been spent on not only physical pipeline building but also on lobbyist movements to either approve or vote down the proposed pipeline. With potentially massive environmental effects looming, the battle between an environmentally conscious president and an opposing Congress has grown into an international dispute. Legislation for the pipeline was first introduced in 2008 when TransCanada “began construction the Keystone Pipeline after the United States issued a Presidential Permit authorizing the construction, maintenance, of the pipeline along the border of the United States and Canada” (O’Rourke) Despite Canadian…

    • 1025 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Perhaps one of the most widely debated topics, in recent years, is the construction of the Keystone XL Pipeline. The completion of the project has been done in multiple phases and one of the last phases scheduled to be completed is the phase 4 extension. This extension would create a pipeline that would trek, around 2000 miles, from Alberta Canada to the gulf coast of Texas (Friends of the Earth). Since the pipeline would cross international borders, approval from congress would be necessary in order to begin construction (NPR). The two main issue points on the topic are the economic gains that could incur from the development of the pipeline and the overall impression on the environment that would ensue from extraction, transportation, and refining of the oil.…

    • 1549 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Past Relationship The relationship between the government of Canada and Indigenous people has been a struggle to say the least. In 2012 bill C-45 was proposed, bill C-45 challenged Indigenous sovereignty and Indigenous philosophy involving mother earth. Indigenous people believe that knowledge is rooted in the land because it contains languages, stories and histories of the people (King, 218). The land also provides all the basic needs for survival, food water and shelter but most importantly the land is home (King, 218).…

    • 676 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Ken Winston, a member of the Nebraskan Sierra Club—an environmental group—boldly opposes the pipeline stating it will be one of the most, “environmentally destructive activities on the planet”(as cited in Sachs, 2014). This statement shows that environmentalists have no desire in seeing the pipeline built. They also have concern regarding the use of the pipeline—if it is built. A major concern is that “TransCanada forecasted the pipeline would leak no more than 1.4 times a decade. In reality, it spilled 14 times in its first year alone”(Wieners, 2014).…

    • 1623 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The United States’ has been using oil to fuel the needs of people and businesses for an extensive period of time. The country’s reliance on oil is a huge factor in maintaining the stability of the country. Though many advocate as to why the Keystone XL Pipeline will leave a positive impact on the country through economic prosperity and secured borders, many are consumed by the thoughts of potential damages and…

    • 1105 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Keystone Pipeline is a Legitimate Issue and Should Not Be Approved The controversy surrounding the Keystone XL Pipeline proposal steams from very legitimate concerns. While the issue has attracted support from some parties, it is apparent that many, including environmental activists, civilians and politician have strongly opposed the move, but the big question is, what are the specific reasons is in all this? According to Natural Resource Defense Council, NADR a New York based natural environment gives a comprehensive account why the move will be disastrous not only to natural environment but also to people (NADR). In addition, other non- partisan organizations like the Friends of Earth have also voiced their opposition to…

    • 876 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Exxon Valdez Oil Spills

    • 1980 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Around midnight on March 24, 1989, the Exxon Valdez oil tanker ran into Bligh Reef. The result was the release of about 11 million gallons of oil into the Prince William Sound in Alaska, loss of wildlife, and new environmental policies. The aim of this investigation is to identify the environmental policies that developed as a result of the oil spill, analyze why and if these policies were enacted, and search for evidence to either affirm or refute whether the oil spill made an impact on the development of environmental policies. Evidence and information will be pulled from various books, such as The Exxon Valdez Oil Spill by Tom Schouweiler, and from articles, such as “Update of Implementation of Recommendations from the NRT Following the…

    • 1980 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fracking In Canada

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Guidelines for Canadian Drinking Water Quality must be followed in all of the provinces where hydraulic fracturing takes place and the results shared with the property owners (Gagnon, 2016). Provinces In Canada, a handful of provinces have banned fracking; Quebec, Nova Scotia, and Newfoundland & Labrador, for the main concerns of water contamination, air quality, and the terms of clarification and operation licenses (Gagnon, 2016). While British Columbia, Alberta and Saskatchewan allow drilling of this natural resource with the proper permits and if regulations are followed. (Olive, 2016).…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The information released on climate change is often in complex scientific language, and is difficult to understand which correlates to why “only one in ten Americans (12%) correctly estimate scientific agreement at 90% or higher” (van der Linden et al. 1). These statistics indicate a grand disconnect as to how many Americans know of the severity of climate change. A considerable amount of denial is attributed to the lack of education on the issue and acceptance of false information. Skeptics consequently facilitate the idea that anthropogenic sources are not the root cause of climate change. The consequence of false information is a continuous cycle of confusion and denial.…

    • 1270 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    WCEAM Case Study

    • 1022 Words
    • 4 Pages

    This paper sought to determine the importance of institutional arrangements with regard to WCEAM (watershed cumulative effects assessment and management), because it plays a vital role in the field of CEA (cumulative effects assessment). The authors identifie that there is a gap in cumulative effects assessment procedure and development activity in watersheds and should be addressed what Schindler & Donahue (2006) refer to as ‘holistically’ and place emphasis on integrating and improving the concept and practice on WCEAM. The methods applied in the paper (i.e. document review, observational studies-interview, qualitative analysis) intent to answer the questions asked about the relevance of institutional authorities with WCEAM in the largest…

    • 1022 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    It is essential to discuss participation in EIA as a component and reflection of the general development of public engagement in environmental decision-making. Wood (2003), Glucker et al. (2013) claim that public participation is an essential part of the success of EIA. Public involvement in Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) The definition of public participation in EIA is often used interchangeably to involvement, engagement, consultation, and sometimes with little attention to their differing objectives and potential outcomes.…

    • 2006 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays