Story Of An Hour Comparative Essay

Better Essays
Comparative Essay

The Yellow Wallpaper and The Story of an Hour both focus on themes of women in marriages feeling trapped and suffocated, while showing the effects of illnesses that become more pronounced through the relations to their respective spouses. Through personal observations and narratives the two wives in both stories express similar relations to both of their husbands, which is internal toleration. “And yet she had loved him-Sometimes. Often she had not” (SH). In this state of mind Louise shows minimal feeling regarding her relationship with her husband, a mental and intimate detachment. The wife in the Yellow Wallpaper shows similar themes where she respects and trusts her husband but grows to become detached as the story
…show more content…
“Effort it is,- to dress and entertain.” Louise reacts differently but overall similar in reason to the affects of her husband's ‘death’, “dull stare in her eyes”, shows her lack of meaning now that her role of wife is terminated. The two stories try to convince us that personal ambitions are shied upon over the favour of their constricting roles. Originally Louise fights feelings of happiness knowing it to be wrong and monstrous to consider, like how the wife in the Yellow Wallpaper refused to help herself in favour of satisfying her husband. “Recognize this thing- beat it back” (SH). The wife’s growing hysteria and depression in the yellow wallpaper worsens in favour of keeping a seemingly normal exterior. Rather than acknowledging the problem the characters would rather bury it under superficial remedies in order to look ‘okay’ instead of being ‘okay’. “Gaining color, appetite is better, I feel easier about you.". The irony within this statement is that on the surface and physically she is considered improving but the real problem lies internally.“It does weigh on me- not to do my duty!”.This internal suffering of Louise and the women in the yellow wallpaper is an iterative development that shows the lack of care in well being in accordance to being problematic and a burden to her …show more content…
The duration of the Yellow Wallpaper’s conclusion compared to the Story of an Hour’s is tied within its severity in which the woman Is periodically getting worse mentally while Louise envisions her future. “Beyond bitter moment- years belong to her absolutely” (SH) Her grief is shattered because what she wants, but never realizes until the death of her husband, was a life of her own. For the yellow wallpaper, the woman restricts her actions of freedom.“Less opposition and more society - but John says”. The consequence of having Louise think of herself is death, by the appearance of the oppression that follows her in the figure of her husband. The future Louise envisioned is abruptly ceased off, the writers purposeful conclusion of irony through short lived liberation. “Free , Free, free mind” (SH) Showing how Louise accepts the joy of freedom that overtakes her with the absence of her husband in order to feel genuine happiness. The parallel between Louise and The Yellow Wallpaper shows how one is trapped and progressively worsens to a breaking point, while the other rises to hopeful ambitions and immediately cut

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Independence, openness, and powerless all play key roles in how the theme is developed throughout the story. In the beginning of this story Louise is devastated, as any person who lost a loved one would be. She confined herself to a room and just took in her husband’s death. While locked in the room, she comes to notice that she allowed herself to be control by her husband because she did not assert her own will. As Louise thinks, she says, “There would be no one to live for during those coming years; she would live for herself.…

    • 924 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    She also uses verbal irony to describe her feelings toward her husband. For example, she “gets unreasonably angry at John sometimes” (Gilman 487), she makes it feels like it wrong for a woman to develop anger and frustrations toward her husband. The society does not allow that kind of behavior. Verbal irony denotes the loss of self-expression. Moreover, Gilman uses dramatic irony to show that the perception of woman in the society do not always fit with the conventions for example, she says that she feels better because she has discovered the secret of the yellow wallpaper, but the reader can see that something is wrong with her finding an abstract object (wallpaper) alive.…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Some would say she is an extremely fragile and ill woman who learns of her husband’s sudden tragic death. She locks herself in her bedroom to mourn alone and dream about how life would be without her husband. But, in that same hour she would learn that her husband is not dead, which then lead to her own demise. The story about Louise Mallard tells of her life through her eyes,…

    • 1196 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “The Yellow Wall-Paper” talks about a woman going mad and “Eros Turranos” seems to talk about a wife complaining about her husband and committing suicide at the end. Both stories seem different from one another, but they share one thing in common, an unhappy marriage. Even though the narrator in “The Yellow Wall-Paper” seems to love her husband and the wife in “Eros Turranos” never left her husband, neither marriage seemed to be a happy marriage, however, for different reasons. John, the husband in “The Yellow Wall-Paper”, seemed to talk down to the narrator, like she was a child. He never actually listened to her concerns either.…

    • 722 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    During that era, many people have stereotypes of men’s and women’s characteristics. Men were considered powerful, active, brave, logical, rational, and independent. Women, on the contrary, were considered weak, passive, timid, illogical, emotional, and dependent. In “The Story of an Hour” Louis is unhappy with her marriage and feels subordinated by him; however, she recognizes her temporary freedom after she thinks her husband is death. Louise’s husband is “kind” and he loves her, but she feels that she is trapped in his marriage.…

    • 1615 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    If she loved her husband truly she would have died of sadness because he was no longer with her, not at the thought of him being alive. This one-sided love caused her to feel trapped in her marriage and in the end killed her. In The Necklace Madame Loisel hated her husband. She had no ounce of love or respect for him. “She looked at him out of furious eyes, and said impatiently: And what do you suppose I am to wear at such an affair?…

    • 1231 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It was natural that she would be upset with the death of her husband, but the story made her seem weak, and had both her sister and her husband’s friend be there to break the news to her. Mrs. Mallard also has heart problems in the story, which can make the reader see her as a weak person from the very beginning. In “The Story of an Hour”, Kate Chopin reveals that women in her stories are longing for independence, and wavering between the duties of being married and the freedom associated with self reliance.…

    • 1222 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The sight of such a young couple who also suffer from the malady of marriage has only greater impact on Mr. Kapasi‘s grasp of his own miserable and ill relationship and his inability to cure it. Also, reader can see Mr. and Mrs. Das‘s marriage is their different expectations of life, which result in Mrs. Das‘s repression of desire. The symbols of repressed desire accompanies Mrs. Das through her marriage and has its roots in the born of her children, when she had to abandon her former friends and life. Mrs. Das‘s dissatisfaction with her life and her feelings of constant distaste are the main symptoms in already spreading malady of her marriage. Wife‘s repression of desire is visible throughout her behavior, such as treatment of the children, ignorance and indifference to her husband, but the main repression of her needs is revealed by her confession to Mr. Kapasi.…

    • 1243 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Despite writing that her husband “loves [her] very dearly and hates to have [her] sick,” she states how she “get[s] positively angry with the impertinence of [the wallpaper] and the everlasting of it” (Gilman). She inadvertently reveals that while she wants to love her husband, she feels upset instead that he does not consider her opinion in the matter of her own health. As time passes, Gilman uses the wallpaper to illustrate her character’s gradual realization of her own entrapment. Her character describes how the outside pattern of the wallpaper “becomes bars” (Gilman). She later includes a woman who “is all the time trying to climb through” and how it “strangles” them (Gilman).…

    • 1247 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The delay in revealing Mrs. Mallard’s first name is another indication of the oppression that marriage brings. Mrs. Mallard’s first name, Louise, is not revealed until the news of her husband’s death is announced: “Louise, open the door! I beg; open the door-you will make yourself ill” (Chopin, “The Story”). This indicates that Mrs. Mallard only experiences independence as an unmarried woman. Furthermore, Mrs. Mallard’s bleak outlook on her life suggests that marriage is oppressive.…

    • 2097 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays