The Pros And Cons Of False Confessions

Superior Essays
After spending nearly 24 hours searching for his missing daughter, Jerry Hobbs was arrested and interrogated for an additional 20 hours, while processing the grief associated with learning his daughter and her friend had been brutally raped and murdered. After hours of endless interrogation, coupled with harsh police interrogation tactics that are standard in American law enforcement, Hobbs confessed to the rapes and murder, crimes he didn’t commit, and then proceeded to the next two years in prison before DNA evidence surfaced. Prosecutors then cited the confession as a defense, and used bizarre alternative justifications for why the DNA test had cleared him. Subsequently, Hobbs spent an additional three years behind bars, all for crimes he didn’t commit. Unfortunately, Jerry Hobbs is among the thousands of people wrongly convicted because they confessed to a crime they didn’t commit. Even though the idea of falsely confessing is seemingly ludicrous, it happens way more than society would like to admit. The Innocence Project, a nonprofit legal team committed to exonerating the wrongly convicted, proclaims that “false confessions have played a role in at least 25% of DNA exoneration cases”, leading people to wonder and analyze exactly what brings an innocent person to …show more content…
According to Steven Drizen of the center of Wrongful Convictions at Northwestern University School of Law, “juveniles are particularly vulnerable, they tend to be impulsive, they tend to be more focused on short-term gratification like “If I confess, can I go home?” (False Confessions 1). Research is also showing that teens may be more vulnerable to producing internalized false confessions, a confession in which the suspect actually comes to believe they committed the crime, even if they don’t remember, as illustrated in the case of Michael

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Over years of cases and research, it has been found that a large proportion of false confessions are made by juveniles. To combat the rate of false confessions, there needs to be a reform of the legal practices used in juvenile court cases. The first significant step the court took in showing that adults and children are different was the case Roper v. Simmons – the ruling of this case forbid the use of execution on individuals under the age of 18. The court acknowledged that there are developmental differences between adults and children that make children at less fault for their crimes. These developmental differences include the “immaturity of judgement”, which highlights the differences of children and adults when it comes to risk taking, impulse control, and reasoning.…

    • 611 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Out of those who were innocent and falsely confessed, 88% admitted to doing so because they believed the bluff would prove their innocence (Perillo et. al, 2010). The combination of these three studies offer an insight as to how a bluff tactic can lead to a false confession from an innocent…

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I choose scenario two police interrogations and false confessions, as you see today on the news people who claim they were innocence at the time of the crime, but was made to say they were guilty were later set free. False confession is very much alive today, especially in the legal system in North America today , and there is a very long history of these type of wrongful declarations (Chapman, 2013). One of the first references to a false confession was recorded in 1660. a servant's name John Perry , he was sent to look for his master ,Williams Harrison when perry failed to return home for a prolonged period of a time, it was suspected that he robbed his master of rent money he had collected and he had killed Harrison in the…

    • 1179 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article the authors touch on the risk factors of police interrogation and false confessions among juveniles and young people. Prior research implicated juveniles and young people to be more susceptible of falsely confessing when compared to adults. The study presents ADHD and conduct disorder as major risks factors for false confessions. In a questionnaire, the juvenile participants were asked several questions of whether they ever had a diagnosis of ADHD and if yes are they receiving medication for it. The purpose of the study was to identify the risk factors of false confessions as well as the impact ADHD has on juveniles falsely confessing.…

    • 535 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For this portfolio assignment, I have chosen three articles that illustrate three different legal psychology concepts. In this first article, The Truth About False Confessions, the author talks about how two brothers are sentenced to death, after falsely confessing to the rape and murder of a child. However, they have recently been released from the North Carolina’s death row, as DNA evidence has finally established the guilt of another man. The reason why I chose this article is because the two brothers, who were convicted in this case, were vulnerable suspects as they were under the age of nineteen and had a mental disability. According to research, false confessions by minors have recently been increasing during the last couple of years, because minors tend to comply with authority figures, as they lack maturity and life experience (Schwartz, 2016).…

    • 553 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Background: False confessions are a major issue in our criminal justice system. Organizations like the Innocence Project have shown that 20% of the people they exonerate falsely confessed. Because of that, Russano, Meissner, Narchet and Kassin strived to identify what factors and circumstances increase the likelihood of a false confession. Through Kassin and McNall research, maximization and minimization were categorized as interrogation methods (1991). Russano, Meissner, Narchet and Kassin have decided to study both minimization and how deal making affects false confessions.…

    • 652 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    False Confessions

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages

    A confession is a written or oral formal statement where a suspect admits that they are guilty of a crime, a false confession is admitting to a criminal act that one did not commit. False confessions are usually brought on by coercion, contamination or misclassification. There are three types of false confession; voluntary, persuaded, or compliant. Voluntary confessions are given usually under little police pressure, these confessions are brought on by the persons desire to be noticed(fame), mental disorder, protecting the actual perpetrator, or they may be experiencing guilt from something else they might’ve done. Persuaded false confessions usually stem from this persons own self-doubt, where they feel as if their memory has failed them and they might’ve actually committed the crime, they…

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Internalized confessions can appear voluntary and in a traditional sense are not coerced (Chapman, 2013). Suspect’s beliefs are altered, and they come to believe that they have committed the crime, even if they have no memory of doing such (Chapman, 2013; Follete et al., 2007).…

    • 2131 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After eight years in prison- two of which was spent on death row- DNA analysis of the victim’s underwear showed that Boodsworth’s DNA did not match the samples believed to belong to the murderer. Years later, the real killer was identified through a match in the DNA database system.” this would be how the innocence project helps, if not for them he could’ve gotten the death penalty. Another example that Neufeld wrote about was Roy Brown “Roy Brown was convicted of a 1991 murder and spent 15 years in prison for a crime he did not commit... Although that mark had two more upper teeth than he had, Roy was sentenced to 25 years to life.”…

    • 1384 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the eyes of the jury and law enforcement, it seems like improbable if the person wasn’t being actively coerced. Unfortunately, false confession happens more than one would think. About 20-25% of DNA exonerations were convicted under a false confession…

    • 1621 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    While guilt has significant influences on confessions, the interrogation environment has been found to be connected with both true and false confessions. When tested on the accuracy of suspect judgement, researchers were surprised to find out that training might impair proper judgement of the subject. In Saul M. Kassin and Gisli H. Gudjonsson’s research, “The Psychology of Confessions”, Kassin and Gudjonsson claims, ”... the federal, state, and local investigators- compared with untrained college students- exhibited lower, chance-level accuracy and significantly higher confidence” (Kassin and Gudjonsson 38). While the accuracy of professional investigators fell, the investigators showed higher confidence in their judgements towards suspects.…

    • 1343 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    What I gathered from reading about this technique along with the false confession cases was that the detectives appear to be trained to enter an interrogation under the assumption that the person in question is guilty. The detective's job is to get a confession-- not actually question the subject and gather information. This technique is in absolute contrast to what directly follows in our court system: "everyone is innocent until proven guilty. " If you've already essentially been "proven" guilty by providing a confession, then the court trial really just becomes a formality. You know, to let your peers decide your fate, after you've already confessed.…

    • 397 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kumho Tire Case Study

    • 1290 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The most visible indicator of this lapse is the number of convictions that have been reversed many years later by the availability of DNA evidence, and other highly developed analyses that prove innocence. Many of these exonerations are publicly acknowledged through media reports; contributing significantly to the technical effects on the expectations of jurors. The highly publicized Innocence Project reports that, as of 2009, there have been 232 post-conviction exonerations by DNA testing in the United States. The availability of DNA testing has risen to numerous post-conviction appeals for DNA testing on the basis that it could produce crucial exculpatory evidence. Many states have responded with legislation addressing the standards for those requests.…

    • 1290 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Back then when I was in elementary school, I cheated on my weekly quiz for a few times. In the progress of searching an article, the word “partial confession” in the title caught my eye. Titled ““I Cheated, but Only a Little”: Partial Confessions to Unethical Behavior”, Shaul Shalvi, Eyal Peer and Alessandro Acquisti wrote this article on the February issue of Journal of Personality and Social Psychology in 2014. The article talks about how sometimes people make a partial confession instead a full confession.…

    • 107 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Like the example given in the article called DNA Testing and The Dead Penalty by The ACLU (American Civil Liberties Union) where in 1984, a man called Earl Washington falsely confess that he murdered a woman, but he suffered from mental retardation. After fourteen years, with new scientific innovations of the time, like DNA testing, Mr. Washington’s family could prove that he was not the perpetrator. After two more years and an additional DNA test, he was granted with an absolute pardon from the Virginia Governor Jim Gilmore. ACLU said that there are different ways to get the DNA “DNA testing on biological samples such as skin, saliva, semen, blood, or hair can help convict or exonerate with great accuracy” (ACLU 1). Current DNA identification used by police is highly…

    • 1728 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays