The Pros And Cons Of Genetic Modification

Improved Essays
Genetic modification is a growing possibility. With genetic modification, parents could choose anything they want their child to have, the possibilities ranging from hair color to intellect. There are several reasons that genetic modification is wrong, however; for example, parents should love their children no matter what. The only reasons genetic modification should be accepted is to rid of diseases and disorders in a child’s genes. Genetic modification may seem like a swell process for parents that want a perfect child, but it is wrong and unfair to the child unless it is to possibly save his or her life.
Some people may argue that the genetic modification of human beings should be allowed for a variety of reasons. Genetically modifying
…show more content…
In “Building Baby from the Genes Up,” author Ronald Green discusses several fears that people have about genetic modification. He says that after seeing Gattaca (1997), a movie in which parents are able to choose their children’s traits, many people were “horrified” with the thought of genetic modification for reasons such as designing a child to fit the parents’ wishes (178-79). Green also suggests that a child may not be able to feel proud of himself or herself when he or she accomplishes something that the parents chose the gene for, such as succeeding in athletics. He states that some people who had seen Gattaca might question whether or not the parents’ choosing of genes would cause them to love a child any less, fearing that they may become obsessed with perfection …show more content…
In a discussion with Luhan Yang (a “young postdoctoral scientist”), Antonio Regalado learns that altering the DNA in the “germ line” (egg and sperm) or in the actual embryo can help to possibly “correct disease genes and pass those genetic fixes on to future generations.” These diseases could include those like cystic fibrosis and Alzheimer’s. “Such history-making medical advances could be as important to this century as vaccines were to the last” (Regalado 27). Jason Pontin, editor of MIT Technology Review, also believes that these medical advances should be used to correct mutations and disorders that could affect a child’s life. If medical advances have been made that can help eliminate diseases such as Huntington’s or mutations that cause breast or ovarian cancer from a child’s DNA structure, why wouldn’t we take advantage of them? Pontin also suggests that if possible, “extraordinary characteristics” such as unbreakable bones could be inserted into an embryo’s genes to make him or her less susceptible to harm (Pontin 2). When done correctly and for the right reasons, genetic modification in human embryos can be a very helpful and possibly life-saving

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Parents want the best for their children, so it is understandable that they want them to have the best set of DNA, but modifying the child to their liking, is it really what is best for the child? Their decision is based on their preferences and not on the child’s. It is the child that will live with the genetically modified characteristics for the rest of their lives and not the parents. If the child finds out that he/she has been genetically modified to suit his/her parents’ preferences, this might change the way the child feels about their parents. It will cause the child to question themselves and their identity, thus creating a strained relationship with their parents.…

    • 1394 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Ethics of Prenatal Genetic Modification Genetic engineering is a method of altering the genetic makeup of an organism with the intention of improving the organism. The technology that is used for this modification is still in its early stages, but was intended to be used in the manufacturing of insulin, various hormones, and antibodies, as well as disease research and gene therapy. This technology is beginning to encroach into reproduction, where it has the potential to be used to prevent certain sex-linked diseases and screen for embryos that are predisposed to certain genetic conditions. Once this technology is integrated into reproductive processes, a door will be opened for parents to have “designer babies,” which is a term that describes…

    • 1939 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    3 Types Of Cloning

    • 1278 Words
    • 6 Pages

    There are also those people who would like to have children but do not have mates, and would like the option of not having to use surrogates or prefer to have their offspring genetically identical to them. On a more scientific perspective it is very possible for these cloned offspring could face severe side effects, developmental problems such as nonfunctioning or premature…

    • 1278 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    If the parents have their children modified to be gifted in a certain area, such as athletics, and the child grows up to hate sports, then there may be problems between the parents and the child. If only the very wealthy had access to this technology, a genetic aristocracy would be installed, where the genetically modified humans are on top (Simmons). The gene editing technologies that we use now can be compared to breeding, except that the technologies used now are precise and deliberate. "The newest gene-editing tools are different from breeding in one fundamental and, many would say, positive way. "We 're [now changing traits] in a more targeted way — we actually know what we 're doing" says Alison Van…

    • 1077 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Parents already control kids - Prenatal supplements, education, and religion. (The Pros and Cons of Designer Babies) If not done right the embryo would accidentally be terminated. Parents could use it for superficial purposes. Could create Classes between societies. May affect the baby 's gene pool.…

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    With improving technology and The Human Genome Project’s comprehensive list, designing babies has become a legitimate possibility. Though it will come at a hefty price, at least in the beginning, the manipulation of genetic sequences will allow parents to create healthier, stronger, and more beautiful babies. Just because it can be done does that mean it should? Despite the major benefit of designing babies across the world, there are many problems that this new technology allows. Nicholas Agar attempts to tackle this crisis in his article Designing Babies: Morally Permissible Ways to Modify the Human Genome However, his idea to focus on the aspect of life goals causes more problems with designing babies to pop up It is possible that despite…

    • 1693 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is true that parents do have the ability to shape their child into the person they hope they will become, however, this ability is not the same as genetically shaping them. For instance, a parent can try and raise a hardworking, polite, honest, and generous child into an adult. Yet, as the child grows up these qualities are something that the autonomous adult must choose to continue to practice in order to be that person. Therefore, a child’s parents influence them only to the point that the child chooses to allow them too. This is far different then genetically enhancing the characteristics and personalities that a parent “wants” for the child because it would result in good consequences.…

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It might seem reasonable for Henry and Molly’s parents to manipulate their reproduction to save their kids life. On the contrary, it might seem irresponsible in other’s eyes. However, under life or death circumstances, technology can be used to satisfy people’s desire. In order to create a boundary preventing people from abusing technology at their benefit such as altering baby’s eye color, or hair color, federal agencies need to create laws that outline the limits of what technology can do. Regulations prevent technology from unethical actions, and also contain people’s desires.…

    • 1468 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    To begin with, there are medical advantages to genetically modifying embryos. This process would allow the eradication of the genetic diseases that haunt humanity. As such, the manipulation of embryonic DNA would help screen potential diseases that might affect the individual that will grow out of the embryo. The “Blueprint of life”, as Tarantola (2015) names the human genome, contains the details of every aspect of our future health, screening for…

    • 1747 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some are created with inherent flaws and others break down before their time. However, manipulating with traits should not be allowed because it allows for parents to go to the extremes of changing their child’s traits and in many cases it cannot be reversed once children get older, but how do we truly know if parents will be satisfied with the results. It also brings up the question of: Where do we draw the line when it comes to selective breeding? What I will say is that science has the potential to do good with problems such as diseases and should be utilized to do good for everyone. It should not be taken advantage by inflicting harm upon others, especially with…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays