The libretto was developed from archival material such as declassified government documents and first-hand personal narratives. Critics of the opera attack this form of story writing by stating that the words were “pedestrian, speechifying, and painfully simplistic,” and that, " ‘singing’ relentlessly dull prose does not raise it to the level of art.” Adams answered these critics in an interview explaining “I suspect that opera purists and critics looking for something to hate about this will probably first latch onto the libretto, (but) the way that Peter put it together has enormous theatrical tension…in this opera the scientists really are arguing.” Being it the first opera I have ever watched, and being an avid listener of popular music, this was a brand new experience for me. I didn’t realize how unusual the libretto was until researching about it, but this was because the libretto was put together well. Sure, the beginning threw me off a little with laws of physics as the opening scene, but I felt like the quotes from Oppenheimer and Teller were intertwined beautifully with their own real passions for poetry. There was a bit of scientific jargon but it was blended into the prose in a subtle way that lets the story flow
The libretto was developed from archival material such as declassified government documents and first-hand personal narratives. Critics of the opera attack this form of story writing by stating that the words were “pedestrian, speechifying, and painfully simplistic,” and that, " ‘singing’ relentlessly dull prose does not raise it to the level of art.” Adams answered these critics in an interview explaining “I suspect that opera purists and critics looking for something to hate about this will probably first latch onto the libretto, (but) the way that Peter put it together has enormous theatrical tension…in this opera the scientists really are arguing.” Being it the first opera I have ever watched, and being an avid listener of popular music, this was a brand new experience for me. I didn’t realize how unusual the libretto was until researching about it, but this was because the libretto was put together well. Sure, the beginning threw me off a little with laws of physics as the opening scene, but I felt like the quotes from Oppenheimer and Teller were intertwined beautifully with their own real passions for poetry. There was a bit of scientific jargon but it was blended into the prose in a subtle way that lets the story flow