Arguments Against The Electoral College

Improved Essays
Protects against the tyranny of the majority, encourages coalition building and discourages voter fraud

The American Dream has always been about promoting the well-sought after ideals of democracy and the will of the people . The ability of our constitution to enamor our citizens with the right to vote truly displays the principles of individualism and the rule of law. For no nation may thrive unless its people let their opinions be heard. The Electoral College, a mechanism designed by the founders to elect the President presides as a debated issue. When popular votes and the electoral votes choose different candidates is when the Electoral college 's authenticity and correctness is brought into question. Yet, the encompassing role is
…show more content…
The layman may argue that the majority 's voice is suppressed in favor of a diluted democracy. If a candidate running for president is able to win the electoral vote yet not win the popular vote, the validity of the Electoral system is questioned. When the majorities voice is suppressed in these situations, why not just trust the will of the majority? The over-encompassing issue is that in pure democracies, bare majorities undermine the principles of a nation by easily tyrannizing the minority. The media’s role in legitimizing the Electoral College is due to the polarizing effect of public opinion. People who identify with a particular party, may in fact be apart of various interest groups. Their ability to influence politics is tied fundamentally to the founder’s warning regarding factions. Madison in Federalist 10 mentioned that the creation of factions is “sewn in the nature of man”, insisting that it would be inevitable for special interests to arise and partition society. The influence of these groups would need to be controlled despite the fact that Madison had not predicted that they would not be powerful enough to dominate the government due to so many checks and balances implemented into the federal system. …show more content…
If every vote truly mattered in the sense that one vote could truly be the difference in obtaining a popular majority. Then, it would be easier for corrupt individuals to steal elections. One would simply just need to steal votes or change them anywhere in the country and therefore would be able to alter the result. However, because we have the electoral college and a vast number of swing states, it makes it more difficult to choose a state and try and change votes. With the current method of the Electoral College voter fraud in a strongly red state such as Texas would not have much of an effect as the state would remain a safely Republican state. However, in a pure democracy, stealing votes in a deep Red state would be able to alter the results. Stealing votes in any precinct in the nation would change the result of an election

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Heexplains how some states can be ignored andothers can be overemphasized. Brenner wants there to be a runoff for candidates to be sure he isthe most popular(Arrington, Brenner 239). For the other side of his argument for his topic hestates how the candidate with the most electoral votes could be the most popular. His second argument is regarding how third party voters could be discouraged. Hediscusses how they should be able to create their own organizations and report their presidency.…

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dbq Electoral College

    • 325 Words
    • 2 Pages

    This convention worked to set up government policies for running the newly independent country. The mid 1700’s was a time where many politicians were wary of the citizen’s knowledge. The Electoral College would allow the president to be chosen by the intelligent members of society due to the fear of an inexperienced person running the country. The original electors were voting with the intention of choosing the best candidate for presidency without any regards to their state of origin or political party. The number of electors was determined by the size of the state.…

    • 325 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Role of the Citizen in a Constitutional Democracy Despite major conflicts and social changes, the American Constitution has offered a framework of governance for over two hundred years. The Framers of the American constitution sought to create a government free of tyrannical rule—where power derives from the consent of the governed. The US constitution outlines a form of national government that aims to serve the American people by protecting their rights and liberties. The US constitution is succinct and difficult to amend; congress has only passed twenty-seven amendments since the ratification of the constitution. In this essay, I will analyze the arguments Robert Dahl’s presents in his book “How Democratic is the American Constitution”…

    • 1116 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Electoral College, founded during the Constitutional Convention of 1787, mediated the voting interests of both the states and the federal government. It was initially designed to promote the voice of small states and the American people, create a well-informed voting body, and establish the Presidency as an independent election free from Congressional bias. Although this strategy was an effective solution to political disputes of the aforementioned era, it has now become outdated in contemporary society. Consequently, the Electoral College should be abolished for the subsequent reasons: It is undemocratic in nature, guilty of inequitable representation of the population, and discourages third party candidates from campaigning for the Presidency.…

    • 833 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Electoral College Vs. National Popular Vote The recent 2016 presidential election, has caused the population to question the electoral college, more than it ever has before. Those who disagree with the electoral college have propelled the National Popular Vote (NPV), a movement that started in 1969.…

    • 1150 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the United States we believe all citizens should share an equal voice in electing who represents them. Every election year, citizens vote for our future president but the votes of the Electoral College ultimately decide the victor of the presidential elections, not the people. Using an Electoral College rather than a direct vote means that not everyone truly holds a voice. The Electoral College should be abolished because it violates the basic principles that our nation was founded upon.…

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 2010, for example, “an individual citizen in Wyoming has more than triple the weight in electoral votes as an individual in California” ( ). These major criticisms are the reason why the Electoral College is so highly disliked by the American…

    • 802 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Electoral College works and provides a stable form of federal government that cannot change and provides a plan that has little amounts of disorder. In Article 2, section 1 of the United States constitution it states, “Each State shall appoint, in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct, a Number of Electors,equal to the whole Number of Senators and Representatives to which the State may be entitled in the Congress:” (Document 2)…

    • 737 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Electoral College is a sure-fire way to guarantee the results of the election. Without the Electoral College, there is more room for error. Popular votes by people may exceed the time necessary to perform the election. Furthermore, some states in a campaign such as Florida, already take a significant amount of time to certify that the total number of votes are correct (Kimberling.)…

    • 1001 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Electoral College was designed so that the candidates running for President would need to campaign and appeal to all of the voters of our nation and not just a select few. It allows for even smaller states that a national candidate might never visit to require the candidate to show up and ask for votes. The every state has a right to hear and see the candidate allows the candidates to focus on issues that affect everyone around the country and not just one section of the nation. While the winner takes all fashion of issuing votes with the electoral college may be representative of the citizens of that state, it leaves out states that are not consider “swing” states for their issues being included. Candidates tend to campaign hard in states considered “swing” states and then ignore the states that they believe they have already won.…

    • 1111 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Electoral College Dbq

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages

    It became that a democratic election determines each state’s vote for president in the Electoral College. The incorporation of the Electoral College means that a candidate cannot focus all of their resources and time on the larger states (Reed 1). It forces the candidates to appeal to the entire population in order to secure each Electoral…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Duncan, the electoral college was created by the founding fathers were still fearful of democracy and “set up a system of election with more than a few fail-safe structures to prevent this from happening—to keep The People from running amok (Duncan 2016).” While this argument would have been valid at the time of the creation of the Electoral College, it is no longer valid today. The fear of democracy has long disappeared with the fear of witches and the plague, today democracy is what all Americans want to keep. Which proves the point that the Electoral College no longer serves its original purpose and when something no longer serves its purpose it must be rid of. Also at the time of the creation of the Electoral College, there was a strong belief that political parties are wrong and that the candidates should not campaign for the presidency, it was believed that “The office should seek the man, the man should not seek the office (Kimberling 2008).”…

    • 1146 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Electoral College which was brought about in 1787, has given more power to smaller states by requiring that all electoral votes go to the candidate who receives the plurality in that state. Although the electoral college was a compromise between election of the president by a popular vote of "qualified citizens", The termination of the electoral college has been the topic of discussion for quite a few decades. The citizens of American believe they should abolish the Electoral College and adopt popular vote to ensure that their vote is accounted for rather than appointed electors. The American people believe their country's president should be chosen for the people by the people.…

    • 699 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Electoral College, a topic hotly debated today, is a ridiculously unfair system for choosing the next president. As the Founding Fathers were drafting the Constitution, they had to reach questionable compromises; one of them being the Electoral College. The Electoral College is an unfair system used to decide the nation’s next president. The people at the Constitutional Convention wrongfully feared that the people of the nation would vote for a bad candidate, and decided to delegate the task of choosing the president to certain people chosen by each state. The Electoral College should be abolished because it does not provide the basic Constitutional right of political equality, and because it makes it encourages hyper-partisan.…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Electoral College was a system outlined in the United States’ constitution by the founding fathers, as the method in which they believe the president should be elected. But with the progression of time the views on the necessity of the Electoral College has become a controversy, as now two factions exist with one faction believing that the Electoral College is an illegitimate method for the election of a president. Though this faction exists and believes the Electoral College is an unfair system that gives a disproportionate voice to different United States’ citizens, but is it truly unfair and unjust. As the Electoral College is a part of the United States constitution where it can be found in Article II, Section I along with a few clarifications…

    • 1367 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays