Peacekeeping Interventions: Do They Succeed Or Fail?

Improved Essays
The protection and human security of civilians is one of the primary purposes of the UN department of peacekeeping, yet evidence for whether or not they are actually effective in prevention of civilian deaths is a topic that has been controversially debated since the end of the cold war when peacekeeping interventions escalated. While the UN has been criticized for it’s failures, there is no doubt that some of their peacekeeping missions have been highly effective in the protection of citizen lives. There are diverging reasons behind why peacekeeping operations may either succeed or fail and there are several questions that should be addressed before the UN is to deploy any peacekeeping operations (PKO’s). Since the main goal is to improve the success of UN intervention missions, then it would be within the best interests of the international community to construct their operation strategies around specific questions that answer to both the size and …show more content…
If the correct number of troops, police, and military, were deployed to states involved in civil conflict, greater progress would be observed. Although third- party interventions have been accused of affecting and even escalating the severity of mass killings, many researchers have failed to look at PKO’s relationships in the long-term as opposed to simply looking at the “conflict year”. Each of the authors outlined in this essay have contended that, with time, foreign intervention through peacekeeping missions such as the UN Deployment of Peacekeeping offer the greatest opportunity for us to reduce violence in the long- term. The international community needs to become aware of this and make arrangements for PKO’s to become better outfitted in terms of skill, training, and equipment so that they are better fit to serve and protect civilians in civil war

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Un Peacekeeping

    • 2329 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Ngoma (2005), argues that Peacekeeping operations are a “mammoth task” because there are too many variables that go into peacekeeping operations like fact finding, humanitarian assistance and the usage of “good offices” which are hard to set up and implement. Ngoma goes as far as considering race factors in UN Peacekeeping missions by comparing the 1994 Rwandan genocide to the slaughter of the innocent in the former Yugoslavia. According to Ngoma, the latter received overwhelming international support whereas the former didn’t which lead to over 3 million casualties. She adds that the reason for the failure of UN Peacekeeping missions is not solely because of their intent but has to do in part by the nature of the host countries, non-state actors, individuals and society in general. She concludes that peace support and peacekeeping operations have thus far not brought about the peace and security the world has been searching for” (Ngoma 2005). Although most would, like Ngoma also consider race factors in UN Peacekeeping missions when we begin to compare host countries like the ones Ngoma mentions. Since such perceptions are often based on personal thought and not facts as the notion of race as a factor in such cases as far as where the UN Peacekeeping missions take place is hard to accept…

    • 2329 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    The UN Assistance Mission for Rwanda (UNAMIR) was established in October 1993 pursuant to Security Council Resolution (UNSCR) 872. Its mandate was to monitor the Arusha Agreement cease-fire and to assist in establishing new governance, however, this mandate represents the ineffectiveness of peacekeeping in resolving conflict as it did not permit the forcible removal of confirmed weapons caches or the use of firearms to protect civilians. Former UN War Crimes Investigator (“When Good Men Do Nothing” Four Corners), given the intelligence information received, the UN could have contained the killings, hence emphasises the failure of the SC in promptly responding to an impending crisis. Furthermore, the lack of funding and lack of political will, particularly the reluctance in using the term ‘genocide’ represents the absence and ineffectiveness of international cooperation in supplying adequate resources to UNAMIR, therefore significantly limiting the capacity of peacekeepers in resolving…

    • 1637 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The world’s reaction to the Rwandan genocide in 1994 is widely considered as one of the biggest failures of humanity and the UN, hundreds of thousands of innocent lives were lost over the course of the 100 day mass killing. The response has been described as” too little, too late” as an earlier intervention could have saved many more lives, which brings the question why did the world wait? Why did we fail all of these innocent people? The answer lies within the structure of our world’s political system and the different ideals and definitions of key concepts by different states. While no one state can be blamed completely for the lack of aid, the Rwandan genocide brought forward the need for a more comprehensive action plan for intervention…

    • 1831 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Catch: From 1956-1992 Canada was the the United Nations (UN) Peacekeeping Force largest and single contributor,but dramatically decreased after 1992. Canada in 2011, was 57th of the 193 UN member states.…

    • 1562 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    War often carries enormous human costs, but we recognize that the imperative of stopping or preventing genocide or other systematic slaughter can sometimes justify the use of military force. For that reason, Human Rights Watch has on rare occasion advocated humanitarian intervention—for example, to stop ongoing genocide in Rwanda and Bosnia.…

    • 980 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Following the Second World War, Canada has made various efforts to improve its peacekeeping reputation; beginning with them joining the United Nations (UN) after its creation in 1945 they were mostly successful (“Canada and the United Nations.”). However, not all of their efforts have been successful; they have also made some mistakes along the way. Canada’s efforts within the last 60 years include the Suez Crisis in 1956, the United Nations Mission for Rwanda from 1993 to 1996 and United Nations Operation in Somalia in 1992.…

    • 1190 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Peacekeeping Definition

    • 1215 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Canada has staged itself as being a peacekeeping country since the early 1940s. Peacekeeping, meaning an active conservation of a bond between nations, "the maintenance of international peace and security by the deployment of military forces in a particular area" (Dictionary.com, 2015). By definition, a united nations act of force. To breakdown those four words one has realise the true meaning of such; a truce is violently acted upon, but when one steps in, it is no longer keeping the peace. To make peace, is to suggest that two or more nations were/are already at war with one another. Peacekeeping itself is not a peaceful operation, it still involves killing people, and a fully equipped team of men and women to do so. The founding father…

    • 1215 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Michael Walzer makes a compelling argument in his article on global crisis, “the Argument about Humanitarian Intervention”. Walzer argues that humans have always been fighting each other and causing global problems. He claims that with today’s technology it has never been simpler to kill large numbers of people, if one has the resources of course. Walzer poses the question that in the event of a humanitarian crisis, such as cases of severe war crimes or ethnic cleansing, to what degree should the rest of the world respond?…

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    There are issues arising around proportionality, how much force should a state be willing to use to protect the rights of individuals in a foreign land? Should a state risk the lives of its soldiers for this cause? It is worth noting here that there is a contradictory nature in humanitarian intervention. By intervening to try to protect rights, rights are violated. Because of this, it is not plausible that intervening wars are a useful tool to promote rights in a foreign country (Norman 2013). However, Walzer suggests that such wars are beneficial given that “all states have an interest in global stability and global humanity” (2004, p. 74). For Caney (2005), the probability of success principle is a major underpinning for the case of humanitarian intervention. If intervention is unlikely to succeed, which is most often the case, there is no point for it despite Walzer’s claims of its worthiness. There are also issues surrounding the jus ad bellum principle of right intent. Many decisions to undertake interventionist wars are not…

    • 1550 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The world today is getting more peaceful and cooperative. Yet, there are places where wars are still happening. In a democratic way, it is believed that people of a nation are the ones who have the authority to control the government. Politicians believe that international actors, more specifically the international institutions such as the United Nations, hold the central authority. The arguments keep going; as such all actors wish to be involved in making the decisions of a governmental system. However when aiming for a successful peacekeeping worldwide, the intrastate governments are ideally the ones who have the absolute authority of taking control of conflicts within a state and/or amongst states. From there, the ideal peaceful world can be achieved.…

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It has aided citizens who are vulnerable and gave power to armed groups that represent for individuals that are harmed. The issue with using military force is that it also takes the lives of some innocent people. In Benjamin Valentino’s reading there were 18 soldiers in the US who passed away in 1993 in Somalia in the “Black Hawk” incident. The United states and United Nation troops killed about 500 Somalian’s and about 1500 during the mission. Half of those people were vulnerable woman and children. Military interventions make the costs of abuses from human rights higher for the ones that commit the act. If criminals wrongly accuse victims for difficulties and suffering caused by the intervention, retaliating against groups of victims and encouragement for the retaliation may increase. Interventions from the military can make persons getting harmed from being regarded as being trouble being looked as a traitor or backstabbing enemy. The enemy could have the ability to demand revenge, take hold of power and get away from the state. Most assignments in humanitarianism depend on air military strength to keep away from fatalities. The victims don’t have any protection from military attacks or revenge. In Valentino’s reading he talks about different cases and genocides. The issue with these cases is that nobody was sent or appointed to stop the violence. The forces that were moved around for military action didn’t have any resources or the authorization to end the violence around them. In some instances they couldn’t save themselves. Deployments that were strong and protective could have been more effective but it be…

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    They claim that "the UN commits more military and police forces to a peacekeeping mission" therefore decreasing the civil violence in foreign nations as for example they use the “armed conflicts in Africa”. (United Nations Peacekeeping 875) From a Consequential ethical point of view, one of the successful examples they provide is Sierra Leone’s civil war; they claim that before the UN intervened there was a lot of civil violence, but as more troops were deployed “the secretary-General delivered more positive evaluations of the situation” (875). They claim that there are two ways that peacekeeping can be done. Examples of what can be done: peacekeepers intervene in hostile attacks on civilians and they reduce problems by intervening and secondly physically guarding threatened civilians.(876) This is ethical from a deontological point of view because the motives are to preserve human rights, and on a consequential point of view they do end up keeping peace therefore the result is…

    • 1858 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Un Peacekeeping Failure

    • 1594 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The times that peacekeeping has been successful should overrule the failures because peacekeeping is necessary in our world in order to control universal safety. The crisis that sparked the movement of a different approach to peacekeeping was the Suez Canal crisis. The UN’s action to maintain peace in 1956 was a response to the destruction caused by WWII. The Suez Canal is a privately owned canal which links the Red and Mediterranean Sea which was built in the 19th century. During the time, it was owned by British and French company and was extremely beneficial because goods such as oil could move between Asia and Europe quickly and cheaply. The ships that passed through the canal paid fees for using the canal and the profits went to the company’s shareholders. However, later the Egyptian government seized the canal because the government believed that it was in national interest that the country would benefit from the canal rather than company 's shareholders. As a result, Israeli, British, and French forces invaded the Canal Zone while the Soviet Union supported Egypt and all of sudden the world was at risk of another war. Lester B. Pearson, Canada’s minister of external affairs, proposed that the UN send an emergency force to maintain peace. Therefore, the UN sent an emergency force to keep peace in the Canal Zone while diplomats negotiated a resolution. The force was made up of soldiers from various countries. Eventually the hostile countries withdrew and a peaceful solution was found. (5) At the time, the UN was the only one willing to step in and attempt to stop the conflict by resolving the crisis through negotiation and diplomacy. Without the UN’s interference in the Suez Canal crisis, another war could have sparked ultimately resulting in thousands of deaths. The war could have also continued for years…

    • 1594 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Original peacekeeping consisted of observer missions occurring after fighting had ended, to prevent further outbreaks of violence and assist in peaceful resolution. Post-Cold War saw a surge in peacekeeping, there was no longer the East (USSR)-West (USA) divide on the UNSC which often created stalemates during the Cold War, restricting the ability of the UN to act assertively. The removal of this divide post-cold war resulted in “a climate of optimism and expectations around the UN” and a hope the UN could play a more central role in containing and resolving conflicts.” However the increased demand for peacekeeping pushed the UN a great deal and the earlier successes “raised expectations for UN Peacekeeping beyond its capacity to deliver.” Conflict after the cold war was more complicated due to the increasing of democratisation and, increasing international security policy with more demands being made by citizens for rights as well as states having to be much more accountable to their citizens and the international system. States were still entirely sovereign however, due to the UN, they had a responsibility to be accountable in contributing to peace and…

    • 1734 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Over a decade ago the United Nations Security Council acknowledge through the creation of Resolution 1325 the changing nation of warfare in which civilians are increasingly targeted, and women continue to be excluded from participation in peace processes. Most people view women as simply victims of civil war in their countries. However, that is not always the case for majority women. Women are critical actors in peace building. The end of the Cold War era of international politics was detrimental within the Third World. Conflicts would arise where regional stability was threatened immensely and are accompanied by high rates of civil and human rights violations.…

    • 1589 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays