The Diploma Disease

Decent Essays
In 1976 Ronald Dorepublished a study called “The Diploma Disease” in which he argued “the ‘bureaucratization of economic life’ in all modern societies is making selection for jobs/careers by education attainment more and more universal.” From this he argued that one could predict the flow of “credentialization” throughout an economy, for which the primary indicator was the university degree. At the time he was most concerned about Associate and Bachelor degrees. In this volume in various ways we seek to extend aspects of his analyses to graduate education, arguing in some instances that for many purposes the MA is the new BA leading to most of the consequences Dore foresaw: credentialism, a lack of alignment,the privileging of the symbolic

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    According to Yeager, Nelson, Potter, Weidman & Zullo (2001) in many ways higher education should be seen as a business as it “produces and sells educational services to customer” (as cited by Winston, 1999, p.13). However, at the same time, while education is indeed a business in some retrospect, it should not be regarded as only a business either. Over the last several decades, many economists have attempted to solve the array of issues surrounding the idea that education should be seen as a way to strengthen society and its ability to maintain a stabilized economy that is ever growing. However, throughout history, an idea that originated by Adam Smith, the founding father of economics, is that education should be used counter the negative side-effects of economic development (Gilead, 2015, p. 625).…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Going to college and obtaining a degree for an individual's chosen career is just as questionable as to the worth of being in debt and wasting years on useless courses. Some would agree that a liberal degree could be the solution to all of this, and some will oppose the wasted time and money spent on education that should have already been obtained from grade school. In the following articles, Charles Murray ‘Are Too Many People Going to College’ and Sanford J. Ungar’s ‘The New Liberal Arts,’ explain the hardships about the collegiate standards and what it should consist of in order to have an individual’s future successful. Using these rhetorical devices greatly show how the education system in college has been immeasurably depreciated in value and in return caused an escalation of student debt and an insufficient, useless degree.…

    • 1358 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Finally, his last reasoning is “the sharp distinction made between academic and vocational study” (Rose 102). Rose goes in depth to explain how it is incorporated in peoples’ minds that vocational study means working class or “blue collars” (Rose 102). While on the other hand, the academic curriculum emphasizes on studies for arts and sciences. Even with school reforms to change this mentality of “compartmentalizing of knowledge, the suppressing of the rich…

    • 935 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The intimacy of knowledge and higher education is vital, from the birth of civilization, men have valued the potency of academic literacy. There are very few topics that have an outstanding agreement from scholars concerning academia moreover the exposure from the media, as the influence between economics and educational environments. Lynda Barry and Brent Staple discourse in their works the prevalence of this influence and the development of expectations concerning education over time. Economics have had an exacerbating effect on the nation's educational atmosphere, especially concerning “lost” students and inflated grades.…

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    William Deresiewicz claims that in the neoliberal world we live in, the market mentality drives students to attend universities purely to obtain higher paying careers, rather than to expand knowledge. This article describes how students are most interested in practicing majors corresponding with the highest salary jobs: “the most popular majors are the practical, or … the commercial ones: economics, biology, engineering, and computer science.” Today, parents invest in college with hopes to make larger investments back, due to that fact that an individual’s worth in society is based on their wealth. Students no longer attend college to question and reflect on the world, but rather to rise on the social ladder. Deresiewicz believes “college is…

    • 1394 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Liberal Arts

    • 1812 Words
    • 8 Pages

    To Be or Not to Be Educated Colleges and universities, or more importantly an educational degree in the liberal arts, in today’s society is an important necessity that can help determine students’ goals and future in life. Maybe even calling these institutions or the educational system life itself can be called an understatement. However, there is no doubt that for some people in any part of the world they would risk everything they have in order to receive high-level education and use it to perform better for their future and live a comfortable lifestyle at the same time. But for some people even though they would like to receive a formal educational degree they cannot afford it thus possibly failing in earning a livelihood. There are however,…

    • 1812 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Can degree attainment provide a clear path towards upward social mobility? Andrew Braaksma, in his essay “Some Lessons from the Assembly Line,” would argue that education can and does provide such opportunities. In the essay, Braaksma details his life as a college student that moonlights on summer vacations as an assemblyman at a factory plant. He highlights the disparity between the two worlds – detailing the grueling days at the plant with that of an easy life at school – while underscoring the importance and advantages of a formal education by inferring that without a degree, he could become an assemblyman indefinitely. The essay draws a socioeconomic line in the sand between those with and without a degree.…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Today's Market Only College Grads Need To Apply, In the Article “In Today's Market Only College Grads Need To Apply”. The author Explores the significance of possessing college degrees and how only people that possess the college Degrees greater chance of surviving and succeed in the free market economy. Jobs are only looking for the best and in order to be even considered for a job, one must have a Bachelors degree. ”The most bevelvent explanation is that technology has changed the nature and responsiblities of many job” (Rampell). jobs are looking for people that Qualify and a Degree signifies that you are educated enough to work in the Today’s Market.…

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    College’s perceived worth varies between person, with many discouraging students to attend because college graduates are often left unprepared and debt-ridden. Hrabowski in “Colleges Prepare People for Life” disagrees with the notion that college is worthless. H, as well as Glassner and Schapiro, points out that the possession of a college degree is a sort of job security; college graduates are more likely to be employed than those with simply a high school diploma. This concept is one that Murray also recognized when he noted that employers value only that an applicant has a degree, not really what they learned to receive their credentials, which Murray also equates with “first-class citizenship.” The purpose of college is at the core of this debate; Hrabowski touches on it briefly, warns that so…

    • 425 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Is College the Right Choice? For so long, there has been a controversial discussion over the need to attend college to make one successful. In the article, “On ‘Real Education’,” a man named Robert T. Perry is involved in this dispute. According to his article, Perry seems to be discussing his beliefs in which more people should attend college. He begins his writing with a variation of claims made by Charles Murray, the author of “Bell Curve.”…

    • 1273 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The author 's ethos demonstrates a disrespect towards elitism and irrational, perhaps cynicism, concern about employment prospects following college graduation. To counter this, Leonhardt states statistical data that supports and reinforces the working reality detailed in his…

    • 1057 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In her article, “A New Course”, Magdalena Kay, an associate professor of English, questions the ideal of education, innovation, openness,and self-fulfillment, then points out the problems of higher education. In her lifetime, Magdalena Kay acquired her Bachelor of Arts at Harvard and PhD at UC Berkeley. Dr. Kay now teaches British and Irish literature at the University of Victoria. Kay claims that a change must be done to problems within higher education such as, the increase of tuition, the decline of college ideals, college’s true purpose, etc., in order to save the future of higher education. College education is a “work factory”, an on the job training facility, to prepare students and acquire the ideal jobs of each individual to survive in our innovative world rather than experiencing personal and intellectual growth and becoming like minded individuals throughout one’s time in college.…

    • 1266 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As Carneville states in his essay, “College is Still Worth It”, “the unemployment rate for all workers with college degrees is a quarter the rate for high school graduates.” Carneville fights the belief that in today’s economic state, college degrees are pointless. A college degree and higher education is exactly the opposite of pointless. Research has shown that educating our workers to a higher degree can improve our nation’s productivity and innovation skills. By not allowing more students to receive a higher education, it hurts state economies growth and development because businesses will turn away from the less qualified areas in search of the level of skill that they…

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    They Say I Say Analysis

    • 2196 Words
    • 9 Pages

    In the book, “They Say, I Say” chapter fourteen discusses the necessity for tertiary education. The fundamental focus of chapter fourteen is to determine whether or not higher education offers the bang for your buck. The chapter initiates disputes beginning with the article, “Are Colleges Worth The Price of Admission?” by Andrew Hacker and Claudia Dreifus. This article conveys a controversial issue of the rising cost of admissions and the descending quality of college education.…

    • 2196 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The value of a college degree is a dispute that is commonly contemplated, yet rarely answered. I will attempt to express my attitude towards college education, personally defined as an Associate’s Degree for returning adult students. In an effort to explain the greater benefits of a college degree despite the common rhetoric that it is not financially worthwhile, I have considered the positive and negative effects of doing so. I have examined the following articles, “Learning by Degrees and Live Chat With the Author,” “The Major and the Job Market, the dream and the reality,” and “In the Basement of the Ivory Tower,” to support my stance. When one maintains a desire to progress academically and an open-mindedness to educational demands in the…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays