Charles Murray On Real Education Analysis

Superior Essays
Is College the Right Choice?
For so long, there has been a controversial discussion over the need to attend college to make one successful. In the article, “On ‘Real Education’,” a man named Robert T. Perry is involved in this dispute. According to his article, Perry seems to be discussing his beliefs in which more people should attend college. He begins his writing with a variation of claims made by Charles Murray, the author of “Bell Curve.” Perry points out how Murray believes society tries to educate too many people nowadays, and most of them do not even deserve it; however, since Perry disagrees, he starts to list his own views for the reader to remember. For example, how a college education could lead to a higher paying job. The main
…show more content…
This can be explained by his statement that says, “Those left out of higher education would have fewer employment options than they do today” (Perry 671). The reason behind this is because soon all the low-wage jobs would fade away leaving the people who do not have the right education jobless. Because we can not depend on them to work the jobs that they are unfit for. This starts to show a little bit of Pathos. I started to feel with the readers who did lack an education and could not find themselves a job, even individuals who did have a job, because they have the chance of losing it. Looking more into pathos, Perry states, “We cannot survive in an international economy by simply working cheaper, as there will always be companies overseas who are willing and able to use unskilled work at a lower cost” (671). This starts to play with the reader’s emotions in an unhappy manner. Because the part of the audience who do have low-income jobs are basically shown that they have an easy replacement that is able to get them jobless at any time. They are basically being told “Hey! In the end, you are …show more content…
Perry admits that, “Not everyone who completes a four-year degree will be able to write like William Faulkner” (672). This quote is significant for two reasons. First, it seems that Perry explains that he views education as learning to learn. Some may not be able to write the best, but they are experiencing a new way to write a new scenario. Second, with the famous writer who won a Nobel Prize, William Faulkner, being mentioned, gives the ethos part of the article. Ethos is the part of an essay that shows authority and can also be appealed by a famous

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Instead, they are forced to work overtime to just make over $2 by a week. Offshoring of U.S businesses may seem an advantage to them because they can easily get a job, but the working conditions are inhumane. The conditions are inhumane because they work for cheap wages, work over 65 hours a week, do not receive health benefits or insurance, neglected by supervisors, and the work environment is unsafe. If a company preferred to relocate to other countries, the employees should at least to earn more or at least be provided health benefits. To pay employees cheaply is unethical, because they are unable to provide for themselves.…

    • 1313 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Murray believes that it may also be a waste of their money if they are just going for the LIB art major which may lead them nowhere and leave them with nothing but loans. Although Murray does make a good argument that four-year college may not be for everyone, I disagree with him, saying that vocational school would be a better option and that not everyone is qualified, therefore I do think that everyone that whoever chooses to attend college is able to and should attend. For instance, a four-year college may be for someone who has a clear vision of what they want to be in life. However, like Murray said, “some large proportion of students on today’s campuses -- probably a majority of them -- are looking for something that the four-year college may not provide” ( Murray 2). He believes that four-year colleges try to do too much, a more practical option would be vocational schools.…

    • 1402 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The lack of employees has produced an initial increase in monetary savings but the prolonged effects of not having adequate employees will yield a large decrease in the revenues over an extended period Fd gqert q4tq gqert notice a lack of employees manning the store. If you have a question about a product good luck trying to hunt someone down to assist you with your inqucdtrt;qwerkqwe’r233343240234l’iry. Often times you will feel as if you are the only one in the store. This is due to the fact that TheStore has trimmed the company employees down below an acceptable level for conducting normal business operations. The lack of employees has produced an initial increase in monetary savings but the prolonged effects of not having adequate employees will yield a large decrease in the revenues over an extended period Fd gqert q4tq gqert notice a lack of employees manning the store.…

    • 52230 Words
    • 209 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “College is a waste of time” and “Hidden Intellectualism” both share the concept that the educational curriculum should be changed to interest people’s minds more and that it’s too expensive to waste money on. These two essays make the reader understand that both authors are wanting to change the curriculum to fit people’s interests rather than the curriculum that is being taught today, which fail to teach a variety of subjects. In “College is a waste of time,” Dale Stephens acknowledges that college isn’t right for everyone, he uses his own opinions to back up his evidence. Dale clarifies that college is expensive. He refers to the College Board Policy Center because tuition is about 3.6 times higher today than it was 30 years ago.…

    • 825 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The countries people are highly educated but a lot of them cannot find jobs in their fields, and are underemployed. If a young graduated could find a job in the field that they are working in, then they may be fired first. This reason is due to lay-offs and the new graduates are the lowest person on the staff, and they have the least experience and the least skills. This leads them to be let go of first if there are lay-offs in the workplace. Also, a lot of graduates cannot find jobs so they have to become servers until they find something better.…

    • 1407 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is also harder to get the benefits of the job. Such as health insurance, dental insurance and eye care. Many companies look for people they can count on and hard workers. When they drop out, that shows that they just gave up and can not be counted on to keep showing up to a job. When most students that dropout, if they find a job, it is usually underpaid with an unstable income.…

    • 1385 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Trade does, from time to time, create losers and, unfortunately, there is no way of protecting them. When a company relocates its plants to another country, as mentioned above, it costs many people their livelihoods. Protecting these jobs, however important and morally correct it may be, will stunt economic growth in the long run. If a factory is not relocated for the sake of saving jobs, it no longer has the ability to produce more at a cheaper rate. The economy is no longer growing, it is stuck in the same place it was when the company started.…

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Inequality In America

    • 1383 Words
    • 6 Pages

    They note that 's a good time to reevaluate career choices” (300). Those new graduated feel that jobs requiring less professional qualifications are less likely to feel the effects of economic cycles. But the truth is the economic may never recovery, which means taking up jobs that seem more susceptible to poor economic cycles because when they start work in a particularly low level job or unsexy career, it 's easy for other employers to dismiss them as having low potential. Moving up, or moving on to something different and better, becomes more difficult. (301) It results in stagnation in economic status much worse, as there is little chance for professional betterment.…

    • 1383 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Raise Minimum Wage Essay

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages

    As a result, companies are the reason why people cannot afford a place to stay or to buy food to eat. Nowadays, as long they will find people who will work for low wages they will keep their business running. When people get paid lower, it is bad for the economy because they don’t have money to expand on demands. They are selfish and self-centered. Hopefully, companies start paying workers a better pay…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In an interview, William Cooper stated that he didn’t have time to go to school, and that he can read but not right. If all children were like William Cooper, then it would have been harder for the working class to work in any better places than a horrible factory. While Friedrich Engel did get some of the middle class people to see the abhorrent situation of the working class, enough of the middle class didn’t care enough to help. In fact, some of the middle class were part of the problem! Another reason why the working class could not better their lives was because they spent most of their days working, they could not go to school.…

    • 464 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays