Abstinence Of Comprehensive Sex Education In Schools

Improved Essays
Introduction
Sex Ed., just the mention of it brings flashbacks to a room filled with giggling preteens. Despite that image, sex education should be taken seriously. What is taught to young people early on about sex, impacts their lives as adults. Abstinence only sex education teaches students to wait until marriage for sex, often leaving out details about STDs and pregnancy. Comprehensive sex education gives students medically accurate and evidence based information about sex, providing them with the knowledge they need to have safe sex and healthy lives. Despite comprehensive education being the most informative method, in 2014, abstinence only programs received $55 million dollars in federal funding, as indicated by the State Profile from
…show more content…
A study of abstinence only education in relation to pregnancy rates in 48 states across the U.S. was performed in 2005. A positive correlation was found in the level of abstinence taught and pregnancy rates, from an article by David W. Hall, Department of Genetics, University of Georgia, Athens, published by PLOS One on October 14, 2011.
2. Second, students aren’t informed about STDs, HIV/AIDS, and other possible sex related health complications.
a. A quote from Emily Bridges, MLS, in an article published by the Future of Sex Education (FoSE) in 2014, stresses the need for a reformation in sex education curriculum in schools with this alarming statistic, “Young people ages 15-24 account for 25% of all new HIV infections in the U.S. and make up almost one-half of the over 19 million newly diagnosed STD infections Americans acquire each year.”
b. Virginity pledges ( /// ) are a key problem in the lack of STD education because students don’t know the risks of other sexual interactions. A quote from Peter Bearman, Ph.D., in an article published by Science Direct in April 2005 reports, “Because virginity is often culturally linked only to vaginal sex, to preserve virginity, adolescents and young adults may engage in other sexual behaviors that involve exchange of fluid and are thus salient for STD acquisition.”
…show more content…
This Act would also promote inclusion for all students as highlighted by the Real Education for Healthy Youth Act of 2013, published on the website Congress.gov in 2013, it “Prohibits programs funded under this Act from discriminating on the basis of actual or perceived sex, race, color, ethnicity, national origin, disability, sexual orientation, gender identity, or religion.” 3. Some might argue that abstinence only sex education is the most effective way to teach.
a. The concern about comprehensive sex education is that when students learn about growth and development, they will be influenced to have sex at an earlier age.
b. In a study by Science & Success, previously cited, 14 of the 26 comprehensive programs analyzed, did infact delay the the first time students had sex, and when students did engage in sex, they used contraception and STD prevention methods. On the other hand, abstinence programs method of preventing sex, virginity pledges, were found to be ineffective for prevention by Science Direct, previously cited.
III. Conclusion
(Summary) On a final note, abstinence only programs are giving excluding and misleading information to young people about sex. As a result of this, they 're putting student 's health at risk, so these programs need to be eliminated from school curriculum for that

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    As defined by the Sexuality Information and Education Council of the United States (SIECUS), comprehensive sex education programs start in kindergarten and continue through 12th grade. While abstinence-only supporters believe that sex education programs expose the children to sex too early, which in turn leads to more sexually active youths, this is not true. These programs provide the youth with “complete, accurate, age-appropriate sex education that helps them reduce their risk of HIV/AIDs, other sexually transmitted diseases, and unintended pregnancy.” Though it is true that abstinence is the safest sex measure, people will have to face reality and remember that sex is a natural part of life. There are too many people living in “denial” about their children being sexually active; and even if their children are abstaining from sex, eventually there will be a point in life where they will be. Teaching comprehensive sex education in the school system is essential to youth’s development as the information learned on the subject could help them avoid potential problems in the future.…

    • 847 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sex is going to happen among public school students no matter what. According to “Teen Sexuality and Pregnancy,” 62 percent of high school seniors in the United States have had sex. The argument over whether to teach Abstinence-only or Comprehensive Sex education is ongoing and yet unnecessary. There is absolutely no possible way to insure that every single public school student refrains from having sex until marriage. Asking students to commit to remaining abstinent-only until marriage is unrealistic. It also adds additional pressure in an already stressful environment. Comprehensive Sex Education allows students to make educated decisions. Comprehensive Sex Education covers more information than its outdated rival; Abstinence-only Sex Education. Should public schools teach Abstinent-only? Comprehensive Sex Education should be the only sex education program taught in the public school system because; Comprehensive Sex Education is more informative, removing Abstinence-only programs from public schools will save money in government funding, and teaching Abstinence-only goes against the First Amendment.…

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The abstinence-only sex education in schools leads to many societal repercussions in areas where this education is taught. Abstinence-only education is the only sex education to teach children in schools is to abstain from sex. The issue of teaching abstinence is an important issue to address because the area in which abstinence-only education faces societal repercussions. Some of these societal repercussions are increased teen pregnancy, increased STD rates, and belief in sex myths. Abstinence-only education relates to the other themes in class such as sex education, government regulated sexuality, and religious views impacting sexuality. Abstinence-only education relates to the social construction of sexuality because it is forming how society…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In turn, abstinence based sexual education does not teach about things such as contraception or safer practices. Not to mention that abstinence-only education has stopped being funded federally since 2009 after evidence that abstinence based sexual education is ineffective was accumulated (Stranger-Hall & Hall, 2011). For example, teens that reside in states that prescribe abstinence education are more likely to become pregnant. Abstinence education in the U. S does not actually cause abstinence abiding behavior (Stanger-Hall & Hall, 2011). Thus, showing that abstinence based sexual education is not only, not effective, but it could also be…

    • 2166 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Criticizers of abstinence-only curriculums think that abstinence-only programs are ineffective at reducing the initiation of adolescents participating in sexual activities. Rather than research showing that abstinence programs are not effective, there are simply few studies that have examined the impact of abstinence-only education on student sexual behavior (Denny & Young, 2006). The studies that are available show that abstinence-only curriculums are effective in increasing knowledge and decreasing sexual behavior. The following section will present studies that examine abstinence-only sexual education.…

    • 1395 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Leslie Kantor’s 2008 article on abstinence education, she discusses several studies on programs that include information on both abstinence as well as contraception and sexually transmitted disease protection. These studies have reported that the students in these wait longer before having sex, use condoms and birth control, and have less sexual partners. This shows students who are given more information on sex practice abstinence longer than their abstinence-only counterparts. Overall, comprehensive education that includes information on abstinence is more impacting than abstinence-only education. Another example of abstinence education not giving accurate information is in a study by representative Henry A. Waxman, which found that over 80% of federally funded abstinence programs distort information. Overall, Abstinence programs do not have strict curriculum guidelines that prevent the distortion of information. This leaves room for educators to put in their own ideas on sexuallity into classes and does not mandate for an informational learning environment. In summary, abstinence education is not more effective than comprehensive education, nor does it have intact guidelines on how truthful the information it is teaching must be, making abstinence only programs an unsuitable form of…

    • 1524 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Abstinence-only sexual education has been around for a while now and is focused, generally, on one of two types of messages regarding sexual activity: abstinence only or comprehensive sex education. Abstinence-only messages relay that sex should be delayed until marriage for a multitude of reasons including religion, teen pregnancy, and the spreading of sexually transmitted infections. However, there are many false claims in these programs in order to further push teenagers into accepting abstinence as a life choice. The effects of not only the programs but societies opinions on this personal choice range in various negative ways.…

    • 1151 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, research shows that abstinence-only programs have been proven to be ineffective at delaying sexual activity and reducing teenage pregnancy rates. A review of ten cities in 2002 of abstinence-only sex education programs revealed that nine cities could not provide credible evidence that the programs reduced the frequency of sex, or delayed the initiation of sex (Hauser, 2004). While this is not representative of all abstinence-only programs, it is enough to realize that abstinence-only programs are not as effective as some would like to think. In 2004, a review of a 11 state-based evaluation showed that not only were there little evidence of long term impacts on the attitudes and intentions of those enrolled in the programs, but it was also shown that when these youths did engage in sexual activity they were unwilling to use contraceptives, or partake in any other activity to prevent negative sexual health outcomes (Advocates for Youth, 2004). If preventing teens from engaging in sex is failing then these programs should at least prevent negative sexual health…

    • 658 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Abstinence-Only Education

    • 1496 Words
    • 6 Pages

    For many reasons, including both moral and financial, “Abstinence-Only-Until-Marriage” sexual education programs are taught all across America. These are programs that emphasize abstaining from sex until marriage, and generally tell students that this is the most effective way to avoid pregnancy and diseases. These programs often do not teach about other forms of contraception, with the belief that abstinence should be enough. Unfortunately, these programs are still taught despite the mounting evidence showing that not only are they ineffective, but actively harmful to the student’s health. This evidence includes high rates of teen pregnancy and STDs across America, cases of misinformation…

    • 1496 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Abstinence-Only Education

    • 1512 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Former sex education programs in American led to misinformation about the fundamentals of sex. For example, a sex-education video from the 80s insinuated that a young girl performed better in bowling due to the starting of her menstrual period (Oliver), It is important that the basics of sexual education are accurately and efficiently delivered to the students of America. If a student is provided with a book but is never taught how to read, what use does the book serve? Who will teach the student that it is not okay to throw his or her book at another student, unless the student asks to read the book? This same analogy can be applied to abstinence-only education. This gap in sexual education knowledge can be attributed to the fact that many school districts either circumvent the topic of sex or avoid it all together with an abstinence-only based curriculum. Every child deserves the same comprehensive education about his or her sexuality, and failure to equally educate all students about their sexuality leads to great disadvantages (Oliver). These disadvantages derived from an abstinence-only education include unfamiliarity with contraceptive methods, consent, and the effects of sexual intercourse on both the body and the mind. Although abstinence-only programs tend to leave students uninformed about their sexuality, it has been proven that abstinence as a rule leads to more satisfactory and healthier relationships for students (McCarthy). According to a University of Austin Texas study conducted in 2007, non-romantic sexual relationships are more likely to lead to cohabitation rather than marriage (McCarthy). Despite this fact, it is still important to teach abstinence as an option instead of a rule, for teaching abstinence as the only option may lead to both misinformation…

    • 1512 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Sex education has been a notorious failure in the education system. Such programs fail because they teach teenagers to be judges of their own sexual behavior—not society, not their authoritarian parents, and certainly not the church. Sex education programs approach sex from a “neutral” viewpoint by teaching students to postpone sex until they are more mature, but encourages them to use proper protection if they are unable or unwilling to wait. From this “neutral” viewpoint, there is no good explanation for why students should not have sex when the technology to prevent or terminate diseases and pregnancies is readily available. Sex appears to be just another sport activity where only the proper gear is needed to stay safe.…

    • 1510 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many experts in the healthcare field have stated numerous times that sexual education is extremely crucial in the school systems. Sexual education in schools needs to be addressed because it could deter HIV/AIDS; it will decrease teen pregnancy, and it can also help young people make wise decisions. Without the input of sexual curriculum the world would slowly deteriorate with one preventable incident at a time.…

    • 706 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Sexual Education has been encouraged to be a part of public school education since the late 1800’s. It is a program that is supposed to help young adolescents understand their body, promote abstinence, types of contraception, the risks of engaging in sexual activities, and how to prevent diseases or pregnancy. However, many parents fight this program because of their beliefs that teens should stay abstinent till marriage, and learning about sex will increase their urge to have sex. Depending on what the state requires to be taught and what a school district wants, a student will either receive one of the two styles of sexual education. The two styles are comprehensive and abstinence only. While they both stress the importance of abstinences,…

    • 1798 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “According to the U. S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), an average of 40,000 to 80,000 new cases of HIV are reported each year in the U.S. It is estimated that half of all new infections are among people younger than 25” (quoted in Statistics). There have been many debates over this topic. When is the right time to talk about sex and would it make them more curious? Children are already curious about their bodies; the goal is to make sure they are safe overall. To prevent young adolescents from contracting diseases or experiencing teen pregnancy, sex education should be mandated in public schools. When comprehensive sex education is taught throughout the school, teens are more aware of the consequences of sex. The basic science of sex should not only be discussed but also how to protect yourself. More importantly, sex…

    • 1800 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Adolescent sexual activity and little knowledge on how to protect themselves against STI/STD’s may be answered through more advanced sex education classes in school. Comprehensive knowledge to these subjects will be provided in the classroom including: birth controls, the use of condoms to prevent STI/STD’s, sexual behavior, meanwhile also encouraging abstinence and delayed sexual activity. Few parents disagree with school’s providing the information to their children; although, the parents who do contradict may not be willing to provide information about this subject and the knowledge the adolescents need to know. A child has the ability to have sexual interactions whether or not they are taught safe sex; so why not provide the information they need to know to keep themselves…

    • 1124 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays