Stagecoach Film Analysis

Superior Essays
Throughout the films I have watched this semester, American Indians have been constructed and represented in many different ways. Different films in different eras have led to stereotyping American Indians and poorly portraying the construction of American Indian life. At the beginning of this semester, films portrayed American Indians as savages who could not kill a Cowboy, but at the end of the semester, that stereotype changed into American Indians represented as helpless people who cannot be rescued from the alcoholism and distress found on reservations. The ways the American Indians are portrayed in these films create an image that Americans see in today's society. In the first films viewed in class, Americans were entertained through …show more content…
Stagecoach represents American Indians as noble savages, a typical Hollywood Indian in western movies. A noble savage is a racist term used to describe a character as a wild person who symbolizes the goodness of humanity. American Indians are outsiders who have not been civilized, which is a representation completely stereotyped and inaccurate. The stereotypes were created for the entertainment purposes, yet they were highly fictionalized. For example, people cannot shoot an arrow at a long distance moving target and hit one hundred percent of their shots, yet in Western films, American Indians are prodigies at riding horses with an arrow in their hand. One film that depicts many stereotypes found in Western films is Stagecoach. The film is a Western-style film with scenes of Cowboys versus Indians, in which the American Indians are helpless, and the Cowboys seem to come out of the middle of the desert (Ford, 1939). Western films portray the American Indians through basic stereotypes such as riding horses with bows and arrows, they are always outnumbered, and they are portrayed in a dehumanizing style. American Indians are portrayed as wild animals due to the lack of civilization and are incapable of surviving battles against Cowboys. America now sees American Indians as the image of the Hollywood Indians in today's society. The image is problematic because American Indians are citizens just as every other American, and Americans still treat them as if they are inhumane. American Indians are viewed differently through the Hollywood image as if they are objects rather than people who live right in the same neighborhood and the audiences watching these films. American Indians are not given the same opportunities as everyone else, creating racism throughout the country. The representation of American Indians in Stagecoach creates a visual that American Indians are impotent and

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In today’s society Indians are not recognized or given enough respect towards them and their culture and lifestyle. However, this is nothing new, it has been going on ever since Christopher Columbus stepped foot in America. In the film industries, Native Americans have mostly always been depicted in negative ways. However, there have been movies that have tried to portray the reality of Native American lifestyle and culture in America. They still have some, but less, Native American stereotypes or myths than other movies .Two…

    • 917 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The West is romanticized in a manner that creates a stereotype that exemplifies the idea of cowboys and Indians. In addition, these images deliver the story of changing roles and adaptation to new circumstances while seamlessly integrating the relationship between diverse cultures. Beginning with the earliest piece (Lost in a Snowstorm-We Are Friends, Charles Russell, 1888) an encounter between cowboys and Indians lost in a snowstorm illustrates the…

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stagecoach Movie Analysis

    • 1324 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The “Good” vs. “Bad” Girl in Stagecoach In John Ford’s film, Stagecoach, he shows his audience the drastic difference between a lady from the East and a prostitute from the West. When the film opens, the audience meets a proper and well-behaved woman, introduced to us as Lucy Mallory, searching for her husband, “I’ve traveled all the way here from Virginia. I’m determined to get to my husband. I won’t be separated any longer” (Ford, 1939). She quickly shows that she is quite the opposite of Dallas, with the men asking her opinion and putting the drink in a separate cup from the other people in the car for her.…

    • 1324 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    These examples show how the films are trying to upset the belief that Native Americans were savages that were still in the stone age. Instead, they wore the same clothes, the same weapons, ate the same food, and endured the same conditions as the whites. Not only this, but the films also accurately depict the critically important role Native Americans played in the war, one that if they did not participate, the success of the American army would have been decreased significantly. They do not seem to belittle or devalue the efforts of the Native Americans as many have done in the past, which contributes to eliminating the stereotype of the vanishing Indian. The films also expose American society for it’s discrimination and hostility towards Americans, despite how important they were to the war effort and…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The history between these two cultures is strong, for American Indians were once enslaved by Europeans that immigrated to America. This book is a perfect example of sociological terms related to culture and race. Throughout the book, the reader learns about the prejudices associated with American Indians and cultural appropriation. The treatment of American Indians in this country can be related to the actions and thoughts centered on this culture.…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As teenagers, everyone calls who they are into questioning. Is one punk rock? Is another the classic prep? What about the jocks? These characteristics are typically pulled into play because high school gives teens the chance to throw themselves into the unknown to find who one is, who they want to be, and how they ended up there?…

    • 906 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Blazing Saddles is a comical film directed by Mel Brooks in 1974. Mel Brooks was a well known and loved actor, comedian, and filmmaker. Brooks, in the process of making this film was faced with many obstacles that he had to overcome in order to make this film a success. In the process of making this film Warner Bros executives had many dislikes about the film. According to The Daily Beast, Bart explained that they wanted him to “Lose the fart scene, cut out any racial and ethnic jokes, edit scenes where a horse and an old lady get punched.”…

    • 1325 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Being of Native American descent; my grandmother (Bessie) a proud Cherokee woman, it was almost natural for me to be drawn to the work of the artist Neil Diamond. “Retrospect: Reel Native Americans” (pp. 428-434) provides us with a glimpse into the transformations made, in the depiction of Native Americans spanning a fifty plus year period. Once, depicted as nothing more than a war mongering savage, through time we bear witness to the softening of the imagery used in the portrayal of the Native American culture. Although, I am not fully aware of the forces used to perpetuate the changes, with research, I hope to gain more knowledge about my own heritage as well as the Native American culture. What was the turning point, when did our society…

    • 257 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This may be evident by "Touring Indian Country" which demonstrates the rural agriculture scene in Native American Tribes near Wyoming and Montana, similar to that of the small American farming towns. The similarity allows contemporary citizens to have believed in the safety of traveling west through the depiction of a scene similar to that of home. The authors of this article as advertisers for the Northern Pacific Railroad were likely biased in creating this serene image because in hopes to increase customers and ultimately their own salaries they would have to depict a safe and alluring environment that welcomed the families that were on the fence about traveling westward. This article also develops a sense of progress within tribes which counteracts the popular "vanishing" ideals and instead reveals improvement from nomadic days, which now rendered an unstable food supply to the development of agriculture and immersion of modern tools and commodities (source 3) . In addition, although Lewis Henry Morgan ranks a few Native American tribes in rather lower rankings he in his study features the undeniable fact that each tribe was increasing whether from outside sources or their own evolution and notes tribes that have significantly risen to a upper and middle status and have adopted major…

    • 1459 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Reel Injun Analysis

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages

    It is a very good accurate portrayal of what it promises, which is that Native Americans were harmed by the initial and continual portrayal of themselves in Hollywood. The movie does end on a positive note that more and more Native Americans are becoming involved in movies. It is not a movie that goes far back into the history of the Native American peoples, but rather it waits to do that at the end. This movie is made instead to show the entanglements of White culture in Native American society and how Native Americans are beginning to see themselves finally with pride rather than with the shame that they have had directed at them from White culture (Diamond, "Reel Injun"). It shows a lot of events and tells the viewer about many different perspectives and how the White perspective “prevailed” at times to help “mystify” the Native peoples of America.…

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    One of the popular representations of native americans in old western movies is that the indians were always savage warriors, uncaring, and brutal. Is that the kind of message that the owners want to communicate to fans and native americans themselves? Also the way that they are depicted in the pictures is very stereotypical, their hair braided with feathers in it and a high bridged nose. You can see this the Cleveland Indians and the chicago…

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nationwide Misrepresentation of Native Americans: Politically and Historically Explained As a nationwide problem in the United States, Native Americans are widely misrepresented and misidentified as a group and race of people. Both in the past and in the present, Native Americans have been looked upon as people as well as an ethnical group. Native Americans often have a lower social status in the United States, they are often looked at as people who are exceedingly poor, have many health problems, and are people struggling to make a living for themselves and their families. However, this is not the case.…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stagecoach Film Analysis

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages

    There is nothing more classical in film then the Western, and no one tackled the Western better than John Ford. Shawn Dwyer a classic movie expert states, “if there was ever a director-actor tandem that defined the Western genre, it was John Ford and John Wayne” (Dwyer 1). His film Stagecoach was the first of it’s kind in the film industry as being the first talking picture in the Western genre. The film included everything known to the classic Western, however, Ford wanted to question some aspects of the genre. What John Ford did to the plot and the character portrayals diverged from the classic Western and subverted some of the themes that were typical in Western books and earlier silent films.…

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Indians throughout the years have been indicated as savages and sadly enough the first they are portrayed as hunters with feathers on their head. However, that is a very broad and stereotyped identification, a person can not under no circumstances able to judge based on appearance. Indians were belittled from their culture, their land and most importantly their self-integrity. Rothenberg, in the book Race, Class, and Gender in the United States explains in an article Indians Tribes : A Continuing Quest for Survival that Indians were a problematic issue for the expansion and growth of the United States. Although Indians were viewed as different entities, they “have been viewed as an inferior race” (Rothenberg, 2014: 502).…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    For generations thousands of North Americans have grown up watching old classic western films of the “Indian and cowboy”. Such films portray the wise elder from the film Little Big Man, the drunk in Tom Sawyer’s films, the breath taking Indian princess from Pocahontas, and who can’t forget about the loyal sidekick Tonto from the Lone Ranger. It is these iconic films that have shaped the public’s perspective of Aboriginals and has even affected the Aboriginals perspective of themselves. These films have reinforced the notion that Aboriginal only exist in the past forever chasing Buffalo or forever being chased and killed by the cavalry. These films have created false and romanticized stereotypes of the Aboriginals.…

    • 2238 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays