Hayek Vs Laissez Faire Model

Improved Essays
The British economist John Maynard Keynes (1883-1946) and the Austrian economist and philosopher Friedrich August von Hayek (1899-1992) are two of the most prominent figures in history of the economic science. Their economic thoughts not only had huge impact in the past, but, along with their debate, will continue to shape the future. Their ideas contributed to the vicissitudes of the world economy by influencing generations of policy-makers. During the Great Depression, US President Franklin Roosevelt’s New Deal popularized Keynesianism, and Keynesian economics was embraced by many economies thereafter till the 1970s. When the world was engulfed by Stagflation due to the oil crisis, a trend of neo-liberalism based on the Washington Consensus …show more content…
In classical economics, it was stated that aggregate production and supply entails an equal level of aggregate demand. Say (1834, p.121) contended that a widespread excess of supply cannot occur in the market; if it does, and then there must be an unmatched demand for other goods that are produced, so the economy would naturally tend toward full employment and prosperity. Frequently, it has been a proponent of the laissez-faire approach. According to Hayek (1978, p.180), Say’s Law is a principle of market organization: it explains the logic of how demand is determined and competition in the market would stimulate demand by informing individuals of various existent resources. Therefore, in Hayek’s view, Say’s Law is correct in its basic form and productivity entails demand and thus output, so job creation is also attained. Keynes (1936, p.27) summarized the Law of Say as “Supply creates its own demand”. He stressed the role of money in refuting Say’s Law: a portion of the money is not spent on consumption because of hoarding, thus this increase in net savings requires extra earnings in excess of supply. Thereupon, Keynes pointed out the invalidity of Say’s Law and acknowledged that it was spending that drives the economy. Moreover, the Keynesian School insisted that saving was undesirable at times of recessions because it reduced stimulus when it was imperative (Keynes, 1936,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Modern macroeconomics emerged in the climate of a decade (1929-1939) of high unemployment and stagnant production throughout the world economy known as the Great Depression. These were years of human misery on a scale that is hard to imagine today (Parkin, 2010).…

    • 983 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When one is infected by a disease, one will not be infected by the same disease. The Great Depression served as a “Great Awakening” for the American government. It made the economic flaws transparent. Hoover, Roosevelt, and the government understood that if economic reform failed to occur, the country would be susceptible to another Great Depression. The greatest effect of the Great Depression was the start of the adoption of Keynesian economics. With this new paradigm shift, the government assisted the people in times of crisis to continue to encourage them to participate in the economy. American society forever changed. Most of the flaws of the American economy was resolved by this adoption of Keynesian economy. Keynesian economy proved to be a sustainable form of capitalism. Since this transition of American capitalism, the United States avoided a situation as deplorable and as hopeless as the Great…

    • 1535 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Reagan spent one trillion dollars on military. The largest peace-time military spending in history. By the end of Ronald Reagan’s presidency, most of the victories made in the 1960s were overturned (Barrett). Reagan and "The New Right" supported neoliberalism. In the 1970s, western governments, academia, and media understood relationship between state and market according to the same liberal consensus in WWII. The "Golden Age of Capitalism" government, capital, and labor had reached uneasy agreement that markets produced social ruin when left to their own devices. The state needed to mitigate inequality to provide basic services and to even out capitalism's boom-bust cycle. "Neoliberalism" was first used by interwar continental, economists, and philosophers. "Neoliberalism" was used to describe an economic doctrine that favors privatization, deregulation, and unfettered free markets over public institutions and government. Some people saw that "neo" signals a liberalism shorn of many of the features that made classical liberalism plausible and effective. There were two popular accounts of how this philosophy of free markets and minimal government came to determine the economic policies of the…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In The American Economic Review (1948), The Role of the Monetary Policy by Milton Friedman debates about how monetary policy can affect an economy. In the earlier days the responsibles of the monetary authorites were to stifle any rise in the interest rate, price and output stability and to maintain the gold standard. The monetary authories did not pay much attention to the monetary policies which lead to the The Great Contraction which destroyed the economy. This prove to show that Keynesian was impotent to suggested that the depression was caused by collapsing of investment, shortage of investment opportunities and stubborn thriftiness. The author ridicules other economists about their point of view of The Great Contraction and the solution…

    • 1049 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The acceptance of “conservatism” as the description of the growing movement of opposition to the rule of liberalism was not automatic nor without strenuous opposition. Both Frank S. Meyer, who eventually became one of the acknowledged leaders of the conservative movement, and F. A. Hayek, who did as much as any other single person to give direction and a sound footing to the movement in opposition to the planned economy, wrote vigorously against conservatism as a description of their position. Although recognized as one of the founding fathers of the conservative movement, Hayek has never been willing to describe himself as a conservative; he prefers to be known as an “Old…

    • 2141 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the Great Depression. Keynes economic ideologies include the theory of “Effective Demand”. “The economy can also be Demand-Constrained by the strength of aggregate purchasing power. If purchasing power is weak for some reason, then unemployment will exist”. (Stanford p.57) Keynes is saying that if “spending” is low then unemployment will continue to be low. And just like Marx, Keynes economic beliefs coincide with his political beliefs, which are that policies need to be in place to restore full employment (Stanford Table 4.1 pg.60). As a liberal, Keynes believes the government should intervene to encourage people to increase spending, as well as hiring people directly to dampen unemployment (Kramer, Three types of economists chart). To gain full employment, Keynes political views included having the government do massive spending to decrease unemployment which in the proved to be successful after World War II. It is nearly impossible to separate ones economic and political beliefs and in the case of Karl Marx and John Maynard Keynes it is clearly…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lizabeth Cohen’s book A Consumers’ Republic discusses how politicians, labor, and others supported the Keynesian approach to stimulate the economy after the war. Throughout her narrative she mentions the term “Keynesian”, but fails to fully explain the true meaning of the term. Instead, she describes how politicians, economists, labor, and other supported “full employment at high wages; big markets for high-volume, low unit-cost production of goods, and whatever government intervention was needed to sustain mass purchasing power.” Cohen initially describes how, in the 1950s, consumer spending increased with the purchases of homes, automobiles, household furnishings and appliances. These increases encourage Americans to save less,…

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Great Depression Dbq

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages

    He begins by explaining the role that Keynesian economics played in the policies of Franklin Roosevelt. Keynesian economics center around the principle that the private market’s negative decisions make it necessary for government to intervene and raise the gross domestic product. Politically, an application of this philosophy was to “prime the pump” of the economy by pouring government money into it. The narrator argues that many of Roosevelt’s early policy follows these principles, such as the 250,000 men enlisted on government dollar to work in the west. However, Keynes accuses Roosevelt of being selective as to where he applied the philosophy, and blamed the recession of 1937 on this incomplete devotion to priming the pump. According to the narrator, the end of the Great Depression only comes after the implementation of more intervening policy in the economy of World War…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    A government directly interfering with the economy of its nation is contrary to the ideals of basic capitalism. When the New Deal was introduced by Franklin Delano Roosevelt in response to the Great Depression, it was viewed with skepticism due to its perceived anti-capitalistic policies and seemingly communist-esque ideas, which struck fear in the eyes of Americans. However, Roosevelt proved that government involvement in the economy is not only stable, but also is a fair equalizer amongst a nation’s citizens. Paul Krugman’s, The Conscience of a Liberal, discusses the major political situations between the Great Depression and the twenty- first century. This includes the moral and statistical benefits of what are considered…

    • 1481 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    The economy, a social phenomena created by the greed that embodies human nature, is a never-ending loop full of extravagant ups, and tragic downs. Inflation, recession and depression are all factors of a growing economy, and though countries have been destroyed by this powerful force, America survived due to government intervention spurred on by John Maynard Keynes. Through public works projects, the encouragement of budget deficits, Roosevelt’s New Deal and his writing of “The General Theory”, Keynes pushed for state spending and promoted economic ideals during the Great Depression which are still seen in many modern governments today.…

    • 978 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Similarity In Generations

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Isaac Newton, an English scientist once said, “What goes up must come down”. In our daily lives we rely on a paper money to be able to pay for any goods and services. In order to understand macroeconomics, it 's crucial to have a clear definition of what money is. Money is an asset, property, and resources owned by someone or something. Money is an important feature practically in every economy. It plays an important role in the daily life of a person whether it is a consumer, a producer, a businessman, a broker, a politician or an administrator. In the early 1920’s, the Roaring Twenties, was the period of sustained economic success with a distinctive cultural edge. This was an era before the Great Depression and…

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During The Great Depression unemployment decreased from three to 25 percent, nationally the income of household were nearly cut in half, and and residential construction nearly diminished (Adler, 2016). It was during this time period of despair that John Maynard Keynes (June 5, 1883 - April 21, 1946) wrote a book called General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money (1936) to provide his own general theory of how the public government would be able to gain full employment. Keynes lived by the model of “in the long run we are all dead”, and he also believed that saving would ruin the economy in the long run. Since unemployment was so high, as well as no flow of income, businesses were hesitant…

    • 289 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This essay will outline key differences in economic policy between Keynesian and Neoliberal theory, examined by their effect on social policies in Australia. The scope of the essay is comparison between Keynesian Australia, particularly in years following the Great Depression, and Neoliberal Australia post 1975. In the years after the Second World War, successive governments adopted the Keynesian theory that the economy will not natural stabilise but requires government intervention to maintain sufficient prosperity. Similarly, government social policy considered unemployment and individual welfare as the responsibility of the government. In contrast, Neoliberal governments took the approach that the economy will naturally maintain its peak over time, adopting social policies which prioritised privatisation and individual responsibility in the form of ‘mutual obligation’.…

    • 1014 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The allies turned into enemies and international conflict led to mass economic distress. Central and eastern Europe suffered the most. Wealthy class protected themselves by taking their fortune abroad and investing in real assets, but the middle-class suffered a great deal, they lost their savings in a very short time. One of results of WW1 was the rise of America as the world’s biggest economic power. American manufactured products tripled during wars and by 1925, when British and German returned to their pre-war state, American economy was 50% bigger as compared to 1914 (pg.132). In order to finance the war France and Britain borrowed from America and afterwards America insisted on returning the debt considering that it was a business deal. Hyperinflation was the worst outcome of the war which ended in 1923. John Marinard Keynes was the main personality of the world’s economical thought. His ideology was that 1923 crises should be dealt with New Deal and state intervention. The technological progress continued as radio, television, refrigerator and airplane emerged changing lifestyle. Automobile industry became most popular and brought drastic change in economy. Europe tried to catch up with America but the cars were not affordable for working class. USA, 1913:0.5 million vehicles; 1921:10 million vehicles.1939: USA 29 million, Europe 8 million vehicles (pg.159). Due to WW1 new techniques…

    • 1271 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Keynesian economists believe that wages can not be reduced because workers would resist to such a proposal. Plus, workers with lower wages would be discouraged to spend or invest, that would cause deeper economic recession and unemployment. The government should spend and invest more in order to increase aggregate demand.…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays