School Is Bad For Children John Holt Analysis

Improved Essays
Education has grown to become a mandatory requirement in not only our culture, but in societies across the globe as well. In John Holt’s essay, “School is Bad for Children” he shares his thoughts on the relationship that children build with the school. Obviously, as one can infer from the title, Holt does not view education as the blessing it is. Not only are his views irrational, they are also completely biased. The manner in which Holt presents his ideas are refutable. John Holt 's essay is erroneous due to his utilization of pronouns, his misuse of the allness fallacy, his inadequate research, and the overall content of the essay. Although his essay has a “cold, rigid” view of the education system, Holt does make a few solid points. Like …show more content…
For instance, Holt uses the allness logical fallacy when he says, “Every teacher knows that any kid in class who, for whatever reason, would rather not be there not only doesn’t learn anything himself but makes it a great deal tougher for anyone else” (74). John Holt gives himself the authority to speak on behalf of all teachers. It is hard to believe that teachers choose this inspiring occupation if they feel like they do not have control or are not making a difference in their own classroom. Another example of Holt utilizing the allness fallacy is when he says, “People remember only what is interesting and useful to them, what helps them make sense of the world, or helps them get along in it. All else they quickly forget, if they ever learn it at all” (76). Again, Holt finds authority to speak on behalf of all “people”. According to Daniel T. Willingham, a psychologist at the University of Virginia, students do retain information after completing their education. He says, “Nevertheless, the contention that we forget most of our education is wrong. Naturally, lessons learned in school are subject to forgetting, like any other experience, but some of what we learn stays with us” (Willingham, 2015). John Holt seem to give himself the power to speak fallaciously on behalf of certain individuals and …show more content…
Holt puts his beliefs higher than everyone else 's. He tells the audience that, “The child soon learns not to ask questions-the teacher isn’t there to satisfy his curiosity” (Holt 73). However, the purpose of an educator is to educate, and a main portion of the traditional learning process is for students to ask questions and for teachers to provide answers when possible. “Instilling students with a strong desire to know or learn something is what every teacher lives for, and research has even shown that curiosity is just as important as intelligence in determining how well students do in school” (Stenger, 2014). Almost every teacher who wants to pursue teaching as a career and who puts forth the effort, is a teacher who honestly cares for their students. Being a teacher is not an easy job. There is so much time and effort put into each lesson plan, each grade, and each project. John Holt criticizes education and teachers, when in reality, it is education and teachers that builds the foundation of our society.
John Holt’s perspective on education is undoubtedly biased. He portrays school as a prison where children’s curiosity and innovation is consequently lost. Holt also brands teachers as incapable, unloving beings. However, due to his inadequate research, Holt fails to validate his opinions. Holt also gives himself the prideful authority to speak on behalf of certain groups and

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    To define true education, one must start by looking at the careers and likely livelihoods of the students being educated. Students need to be prepared for the events in life that would benefit them as a whole, not just core curriculum. Not to say core curriculum isn’t important, because it’s very crucial that the basics of math, literature, and science are taught to everyone. On average a student is individually different than his/her peers, and are expected to learn the exact same way. Although some may believe that America is doing good graduating students with knowledge that should help them succeed, in reality students are unprepared in almost every way since they are taught under the same guidelines and standards.…

    • 1146 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Schools are restricting the future successors. If schools were less restricting and strived to educate students while allowing them to learn from their downfalls, the education system would be ideal. The majority of schools do an excellent job in teaching students the information they will need to succeed in the future, but their only downfall in the education system is they need to be less restricting on the students. Allow them to make mistakes and learn from them. Nothing in life is perfect and even if the education system changes, there will still be problems.…

    • 898 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I was amazed at how many teachers don’t take the time to do this. As a future administrator I think developing a strong relationship with the EC department and fostering a strong relationship with them the rest of the staff is critical to serve the needs of these students.…

    • 1133 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Personal Factors

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages

    However, there are factors that they cannot control such as the number and kinds of learners they may have in the classroom, the class size, time spent with each child, and the availability of equipment. With all of these factors weighing on the teachers mind it is no wonder that when looking at the survey discussed in class, it was found that these issues do not leave the teacher’s mind. We always want the best for our student so we will continually worry as to whether or not they are receiving the best education possible. Our personalities alone are not enough to carry the weight of a poor school. We must combine it with our knowledge of the content and our experience level to create a favorable outcome for the…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These programs by allowing for our teachers to help our students in more than one way. Those students in the twilight program need a little more support, and the educators that are helping them are not following a standard curriculum, these educators are moving on the flow and helping every student they can. The apex program is the same, it allows for students to find another way to be successful. Our principal wants every student to be successful, if that means more of an unconventional curriculum or setting than that might be what is needed. Each of these programs is teaching students how to be successful after high school which is the main purpose to my principal’s philosophy.…

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    School Reform System

    • 736 Words
    • 3 Pages

    That is only partially true, more now with the new reform system. Teachers are given set of instructions on how to teach, and who to each (Rose). Many teachers despise the ‘No Child Left Behind” act because it still enables what it wrong with the education system; focusing only on a fraction of students, and leaving other students behind (Rose). They also dislike the amount of state testing is included in the reform system. Rose states that the reform, “concentrates on standardized tests, students might improve their scores but receive an inadequate education”.…

    • 736 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Everyone knows the importance of getting good grades, but what if it isn’t as important as we all thought it was? What if the idea that grades should be valued above all else is actually hurting students more than it is helping them? We are taught from a young age that we need to try as hard as we can to get A’s in school because if we can, any college will open its doors to us. We learned that good things will happen to us if we can excel in all of our classes. These ideas have worked their way so deeply into our minds, that few people see anything wrong with them.…

    • 1071 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    But, both have an ideal argument that would have an impact on the broadest audience possible. And that would be the fact that even though schooling hasn't been doing a good job, it is still a two-sided commitment, from teachers and students, to the challenges and responsibilities of education. Gatto takes a position where most students could completely relate to him in order for the audience to connect with him. Gatto expresses to us how he doesnt like the schooling system because of the same routines they put students through, as well as himself. He provides us with context on why students are dropping out and what schooling and education really is.…

    • 1571 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dorothy Roberts Reflection

    • 1067 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Over this semester I think one of the most eye opening things we talked about was how women were uneducated but were the primary educators. This is crazy for me to think about, because they were expected to teach the children about everything that was going on. This also shows how much education has evolved since then. I think that it is our responsibility as teachers to the students to teach them about the issues, this can mean using other sources besides the textbook to teach the students. There are certain chunks of our history as a country that is left out in many textbooks, they try to make it seem like they are less terrible that how they really are.…

    • 1067 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Issues in Education: John Holt’s “School Is Bad for Children” They say everyone’s opinions matter, but in an academic school setting, opinions are irrelevant. In John Holt’s “School Is Bad for Children”, the author addresses the problem of the public education system. Holt portrays the schools by saying that they kill children’s curiosity about life, and goes to show his personal reaction since he himself is a teacher and educational theorist. An analysis of “School Is Bad for Children” reveals that not only his personal characteristics and his underlying message about education, but that the rhetorical strategies engage the reader and that the reader can grasp the author’s message about the flaws of education. Holt’s personal characteristics…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics