James Buchanan Analysis

Improved Essays
To President James Buchanan I am here to ask you “why fix something that’s not broken?” Understanding that you are coming up on your re-election; however, since you are a Northerner you might not know why slavery is deeply rooted within the south. There are many reasons for this, down south, slavery is a way of life for economic standards and has been a way of life for many generations. There are also other justifications as to why to keep slavery down in the south. The justifications to keep slavery in the south are for racial justifications, economical and religious justifications.

Within the deep south it is of the opinion of slaveholders that blacks are different compared to a white man those being; blacks are built different than
…show more content…
Historically speaking, slavery has been an outstanding source of free labor that has benefited many countries that had slaves in the past. Edmund Ruffin wrote that “The reasons for this universal early existence of slavery, and domestic or individual slavery, (except among the most ignorant and savage tribes,) can be readily deduced from the early conditions of society.” (p. 61). This exhibit that slavery can work and has proven to be effective within a society. Being no differently to the effects of slavery in the south. Lawyer James Henry Hammond said in his Mudsill Speech pointed out that there was double of the amount of exports of cotton, tobacco, lumber, rice and other minor articles between the years of 1856 and 1857. Reports of “There is no doubt that we sent to the North $40,000,000 in addition; but suppose the amount to be $35,000,000, it will give us a surplus production of $220,000,000. But the recorded exports of the South now are greater than the whole exports of the United States in any year before 1856.” (p. 84). This meant that the South could go without planting any cotton for a couple years and it still would be able to sustain itself economically (p. 85). So when a senator from New York insisted that slavery had to abolish slavery, Hammond spoke of the differences of the workers labor up North. Saying that unlike the white laborers that were hired for that day and wouldn’t be cared for and …show more content…
Buchanan you might be aware that the South have a deep connection with religion and the Bible. In which the South believes that God has given rights about slavery. Moreover, that De Bow reviewed the Bible and stated that in “the Bible teaches clearly and conclusively that the holding of slaves is right; and if so, no deduction from general principles can make it wrong, if that book is true.” (p. 109). Slavery wasn’t an issue for the people in the bible as an illustration, it is noted that Isaac while having flocks and herds also had servants that he owned (p. 109). In addition, Jacob’s sons sold Joseph to the Ishmaelites for silver, even then it was told that slavery was common and a way of life in Egypt (p. 109). It is true that God did send Moses to free the Israelites from slavery in Egypt; however, there are also other descendants of Moses that had slaves and it deemed acceptable. In addition, De Bow’s argued that, “Thus, we see that at a time when the Israelites had no slaves, but were themselves, in a manner, fugitive slaves, and when they had no use for slaves, being wanderers in a wilderness, and fed by God’s own hand he provided laws for bringing in, buying, inheriting and governing, slaves, in the land unto which they were to be brought at the end of forty years.” (p. 113). In this case, it is said that after the Israelites were freed from their slavery, they went on to owning slaves themselves. So despite the Moses argument, God has never claimed that

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    For much of the 21st century it was believed that slavery caused the economy of the Antebellum South to stagnate. Many historians took issue with the profitability of slavery and thought that its demise was inevitable, regardless of the Civil War. Some even consider the Antebellum South’s economy to be backwards in the sense that slave labour rates were so competitive that it resulted in the wages of other free workers to drop below the subsistence level (Conrad & Meyer 1971, 341). This created a deficit of skilled white labourers in the market and prevented a sustainable perfectly competitive labour market. In addition to this, slavery was criticized as being preventative to long-term economic growth.…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Free Soil Party Analysis

    • 1155 Words
    • 5 Pages

    He tells them that they have a responsibility when they return home to feel deeply for the slaves. He refers to slavery as a form of “evil” that all those who profess their love for God should shun (Mott 14). He notes that slavery is an “iniquity” that those with conviction should help purge from the country (Mott 15). In a way, Mott is using the scriptures to show his audience that slavery is forbidden. He is using them to convince them that since they believe in the Bible, then they should not be part of slavery.…

    • 1155 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The founding fathers of the United States are ones that are praised for their contribution to freeing the American people from British more than 200 years ago. In Thurgood Marshall’s “For Blacks, the U.S. Constitution is an Intimidating Document,” he argues that the founding father’s do not necessarily deserve the praise they receive for constructing the constitution and declaration of independence. It is said that the founding fathers created a “perfect union” that laid the foundation for what America is today. Marshall argues that in the contrary the reason the United States is the nation it is today is at the hands of the leaders following those before them. The need for the constitution to require multiple amendments and changes to fit…

    • 1317 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Sectional Compromise

    • 1335 Words
    • 6 Pages

    This compromise was made in order to keep the southern states happy in order to agree with the new Constitution. This compromise, lead to the protection of, “the Atlantic slave trade… for at least 20 years” (Shea 56). Which is written in the Constitution, “Article 1, Section 9, Clause 1..., prohibits Congress from stopping the importation of slaves from overseas until 1808” (Shea 56). With this, many Northerners pointed out the irony of celebrating the creation of a free country while still having slavery.…

    • 1335 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Bill of Rights to every American is the crown jewel center piece of our constitution and from which just about all legal proceedings are based from. Akhil Reed Amar's "The Bill of Rights as a constitution" pages 1131-1210 and 1193-1284, details and analyzes the strengths and weaknesses of the Bill of Rights. Amendments such as the fifth, ninth, and tenth are currently the sole topic of college courses such as Constitutional Law, the sixth, eighth, and a majority of the fifth are taught in Criminal Procedure and the seventh is taught in Criminal Procedure. Teaching these amendments to Americans is essential so that when issues arise we can have the knowledge we've learned right on hand. In the current day and age interpretations of the…

    • 1437 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Although Lincoln was personally against slavery, he never said he wanted to end slavery in the South because he knew that having southern states’ support would be more beneficial to his candidacy. With Lincoln being a republican, he couldn’t speak the whole truth about his thoughts on slavery. Lincoln felt that it would be impossible to get the southern states to agree with the abolishment of slavery. Lincoln did not want to interfere with the policies of slaveholding states because he would need their electoral votes to win the presidential election. His platform was trusted by the voters of the Northeast and…

    • 1586 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Slavery had always been an issue in the United States after their independence from Great Britain. Although both north and south had slaves, it was a bigger issue in the south. The reason for this is because the south was very agricultural. The issue of slavery brought many problems like making southerners believe that their institution of slavery was under attack by the republicans and Lincoln, debates before the civil war, and southerners believe they had to succeed. Southerners believed their institution of slavery was under attack by Lincoln and the republicans because the republicans did not believe in slavery.…

    • 508 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Slavery had remained prevalent in the Southern state up to 1860. When slaves were first brought to America, they were primary used to work on plantations in both the Upper and Lower South harvesting crops like cotton and tobacco. As time passed, other forms of labor became favored in the Upper South and slavery began to slowly diminish in some southern states. However, plantation owners still heavily relied on slaved to grow and harvest their crops. The main changes in slavery that occurred between 1815 and 1860 were that the Upper South became more diversified and no longer relied on slaves as a labor source, while the Lower South tried desperately to maintain their slave population by changing their ideologies and attitudes towards them.…

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Constitution never said that having slaves was acceptable but abolitionists thought that slavery was a sin. It was said that “the abolitionists movement not only caused conflict over whether slavery should be abolished but was a major factor in bringing about the Civil War” (Bolotin 1). Slavery divided the North and the South but so did sectionalism. Sectionalism is defined as “loyalty to a state or section, rather than to the country as a whole” (Prentice…

    • 1801 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tom Buchanan is labelled as a hulking, hyper-masculine, and aggressive. The way Nick describes him, he seems to be “one of those men who reach such an acute limited excellence at twenty-one that everything afterwards savours of anti-climax” (Fitzgerald 10). Tom is born into old money, and because of that, he is able to have many opportunities in life that benefited him such as his ability to go to Yale and receive such a high education. Also due to the fact that Tom had virtually no financial worries, he is able to live more of a carefree lifestyle that eventually led to his somewhat uncaring personality. While living nearly his entire life surrounded by those of similar upbringing, Tom has learned to be racist and proves it by even telling…

    • 1040 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Northern South Slavery

    • 439 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In the Northern States slavery was allowed but it wasn’t as vital to the North’s economy as it was to the South’s. Slaves that lived in the North were often domestic servants to small farmers and rural ironworks. The populations of the slaves themselves were very small, because Northern farms were not large-scale enterprises that focused on producing one cash crop; they had required fewer slaves to do the work and were generally smaller. The Northeastern and Mid-Atlantic states had legally permitted slavery in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries; but a few decades before the Civil war, many of the slaves were emancipated through a series of state legislature statutes; that ended up creating the Northern Free States and the Southern slave…

    • 439 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After getting overly oppressed, the idea of freedom, equality and human rights was growing inside of every black slave. Not only slavery brought great success to the South’s economy before the civil war, but it also stabbed the South’s back by pushing them inflated to a critical point and inevitably…

    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The success or failure of Reconstruction may have been one of the most controversial questions in all of history because the answer cannot be justified. The solution to the success or failure of Reconstruction depended on the intent of the matter. Based on the fact of the reunification of the Union, Reconstruction may be considered a success for accomplishing this goal. On the other hand, Reconstruction may also be recognized as a failure if the main idea revolved around the equality of the blacks. The situation regarded both aspects of Reconstruction.…

    • 1781 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the 1800’s, the constitution was suppose to establish America as one nation, but instead the constitution created sectional discord and tension and contributed to the failure of the Union. Slavery in the 1800’s was exceedingly cruel, African Americans were thought of as property, were not allowed to have rights,were kept in horrendous living conditions and were treated unfairly. Sectionalism, when one’s views are based on where they are from, divided America into two sections, the north who opposed slavery and the south who supported slavery. Citizens were typically proud of where they were from and stayed loyal to their region. The American Government questioned if slavery should have been deemed unconstitutional in the Constitution,…

    • 1118 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The South was as secure in their conviction that slavery was a proper institution as the Minutemen who turned the British back at the Old North Bridge were in theirs. The insulation of the South allowed these convictions to thrive without serious opposition in local communities. With everyone thinking and therefore voting the same way it was easy to keep slavery alive for decades. Insomuch as they believed the proslavery position was unfounded in reality putting forward idealized and sometimes fantastical ideas of Southern society and slave holding. The slave’s perspective was very much real where even in the best position slaves still felt the fear of sale and control by whites.…

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics