Summary Of Racial Discrimination In The Criminal Justice System

Great Essays
The topic I chose to study for my report is racial discrimination in the criminal justice system. The first article I read was Skin Color and the Criminal Justice System: Beyond Black-White Disparities in Sentencing by Traci Burch which was published in the Journal of Empirical Legal Studies. The second article I read was and Justice for Some: Race, Crime, and Punishment in the US Criminal Justice System by Jon Hurwitz and Mark Peffley which was published in the Canadian Journal of Political Science. This first article analyzed sentencing outcomes for first-time offenders black and white, not solely based on race but also by their skin colors. The author was trying to understand why blacks in the United States make up more than 36 percent …show more content…
The average of black first time offenders are prone to receiving higher incarceration sentences than whites regardless of crime type. Dark-skinned blacks receive longer sentences than both whites and light-skinned blacks after taking into account crime and demographics. Through this data the criminal justice system revealed that they differentiated between light-skinned blacks from their darker counterparts by assigning them different rights, privileges, and status within the system. The upper class continues to use this racial hierarchy in the criminal justice system to maintain the U.S. racial order, by putting the dark-skinned blacks in jail longer and less for the whites or lighter-skinned blacks. Burch believes that if the United States keeps discriminating based on the darkness of skin tone, the racial hierarchy in which whites are privileged relative to blacks can be considered alive and well in the United States. The second article sought out to determine the perceptions of the fairness of the Criminal Justice System (CJS), as well as the political consequences of these perceptions, by black and white individuals. The authors were trying to see if either of the groups saw discrimination in the CJS and if they were handled fairly when talking about white and black offenders. The main focus of this paper argued by the authors …show more content…
Inequality of race has always played a significant role in the convictions and sentencings of blacks, having harsher punishments for crimes. The method of using the inmate research file in the first article about sentencing was the best possible method that could have been used. On the other hand, if Burch surveyed civilians instead of using the inmate file about how the different skin tones of blacks were related to sentencing; I believe that there would be different outcomes in data and less realistic. In the second article the method of surveying “free” individuals for obtaining data, was a very smart choice. This is because they were trying to see the race of an individual would influence their opinions about the fairness of the criminal justice system. However, if the authors surveyed respondents that were in prison or have been to prison then I believe that they white respondents would have had a different opinion about the criminal justice system and the actors involved. In the first article Burch’s hypothesis was strongly exemplified by facts and in depth analysis of differences in skin tones and what they mean to sentencing. Both of the articles leave me with the same question, why are females excluded from all of the data? Also, if women were to be included in these analyses would that change

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    But it does not happen very often. Today you can find blacks, women, hispanics, and other minorities in the criminal justice system. Where this was white, male dominated it is not anymore. People are hired to work in the system because they are the best for the job, not because of skin color or if they are male or female. That has changed for the better in last 40 years.…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The criminal justice system in the United States has increasingly targeted people of color, more specifically African Americans, for crimes that they may have not committed. A huge number of incarcerated African Americans have been wrongfully convicted within the past 20 years. Through the creation of the national police force in 1893, African Americans have had a target on their back. Ever since the establishment of Jim Crows Laws in the 1890s through “separate but equal,” racism has been prominent in society. Through systematic racism, many Americans assume that Africans Americans are more likely to be engaging in criminal activity.…

    • 1996 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This paper examines the controversial issue regarding racism in the law enforcement system. Statistics in regards to minorities and white people are included to show in numbers how people are actually being affected by the treatment of those in law enforcement. Two college campus rape cases are discussed in order to display the difference in sentencings given to two athletes of different races. Lastly, the ideas of institutional racism as well as the Implicit Bias theory are explored.…

    • 914 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In a study, it was indicated that African Americans are more likely to be arrested than whites, and often are over represented when it comes to crimes that involve violence, for which they are even more likely to be arrested. “African Americans are five times as likely to be arrested in cases of robbery or murder (Walker et al., 39)”. Though many people have argued over the fact of whether police data is accurate and valid. Most of the dat that can be found on the inequality that has to do with race and crime comes from the Uniform Crime Reports (UCR) system. “Crime in the United States, the annual UCR report, compiles data from 16,000 local, state and federal law enforcement agencies representing more than 95% of the U.S. population (Walker et al.,…

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Once arrested, blacks are likely to remain in the prison. They are harshly treated, sometimes even for crimes not properly investigated and crimes they did not commit. The biggest crimes in the United States criminal Justice system is that it is a race-based, institution where African American are directly targeted and punished in a much more aggressive way than white people. Without question racism is still extremely present, fixed in a society that fails to understand it and buried in a badly damaged judicial system. An analysis of black history reveals that blacks often serve higher sentences than whites for the same crime because of inequalities such as racial profiling, bias in police department across the country and unfair criminal justice…

    • 902 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mass incarceration has created racial discrepancies among those being incarcerated. Many studies have been conducted to study the causes of these discrepancies and almost all of these studies have found that African Americans and other minority groups accounts for the vast majority of the prison population. In 1991 Albonetti found on her study that African Americans are more likely to be convicted and received longer sentences than their Caucasian counterparts (Kamalu, 2010, p. 2). Another study by Spohn found that when African Americans are male, unemployed, young, and the offense is not serious, then they are more likely to be convicted than Caucasians that fit the same characteristics of those African Americans (Kamalu, 2010, p. 3).…

    • 1056 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Racial disparities are very common in the United States criminal justice system for a long time. African-Americans are imprisoned in proportions six times higher than whites, and three percent of all African-American males are currently incarcerated in a state or federal prison. There are many causes that explain racial disparities in prison, including practices to combat drug trafficking. For example, whites and African-Americans commit drug offenses at comparable levels, but the rates of arrest, prosecution and imprisonment for these crimes are vastly different.…

    • 241 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Considering the achievements, and advancements African Americans and Hispanics conveyed, they are still dubbed as second class citizens and through the eyes of the White superiors should receive longer prison sentences, and punishment due to the findings of data which puts their minority group at a high rate of incarceration. In addition, as noted in the above-mentioned subject matter, one can reason that racial disparity in the U.S criminal justice system is considerable, a social issue confronting our public. Most minority groups such as African Americans, and Hispanics encounter the erroneous outcomes of this issue. Accordingly, should greater attempts be made to stop this ongoing issue within minority communities by all race groups, and those working within the system could support the Black and Hispanic populace from encountering disparity in…

    • 1297 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    According to Frazier and Bishop (1996), this research is different from prior research “because it focuses on differences between the processing of the delinquency and status offense (dependency) cases, rather than simply the juvenile justice system in general” (p. 393). The results demonstrate that among those referred for delinquent behavior, a greater percentage of nonwhites than whites receive the more severe dispositions; this can be observed at each successive stage in processing. In contrast, for status offenses, it appears as though whites are treated more harshly than nonwhites. During the intake screening, more white status offenders are referred to court and that proportions of white repeat offenders that are incarcerated is slightly higher than nonwhites. This information is significant because it illuminates the potential for discrimination at the “bivariate level of analysis” (Frazier and Bishop 1996).…

    • 1353 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    One of every three black males born today will go to prison in their lifetime. According to Alfred Blumstein, “80 percent of racial disparity is explained by the greater involvement in crime”(51). According to Michael Tunry, “Only 61 percent of the black incarceration…

    • 1575 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Racial Disparity In Criminal Justice Essay

    • 1737 Words
    • 7 Pages
    • 5 Works Cited

    These are acknowledgement of the cumulative nature of racial disparities, encouragement of communication across the key players in all steps of the system, knowing what works at one step of the system may not always work in another, and working together towards a systemic change. The issue of racial disparity builds at each stage of the criminal justice system from arrest through prosecution and sentencing rather than the actions of one particular level of the system. In order to tackle the unwarranted disparity there are strategies that are needed in order to tackle the problem at each individual level of the system and this will need to be done in a coordinated and strategic way. Without a systemic approach to the problem gains in one level may be offset by reversals of another level. Each decision point and area of the system requires their own unique strategies depending upon the degrees of disparity and the specific population in which is affected by the actions of that level.…

    • 1737 Words
    • 7 Pages
    • 5 Works Cited
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the United States the juvenile justice system is very harsh and can be unruly on children, even though it claims to rehabilitate and not make children feel like criminals. As young as twelve children are being charged as adults with homicide, murder and other high degrees of crimes. Some would say the system would be a bit of a joke and others find this to be equal justice. This body of written work will go over why juveniles are treated the way they are in the justice system and how race has even taken effect on the outcome of these individuals.…

    • 2175 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, in the article What it’s like to be Black in the Criminal Justice System, it states that “black male federal defendants were given longer sentences than comparable whites”. This suggests that black men still obtain longer sentences than a white man who has a similar criminal background because, like the article says, those men were comparable. In addition, it states that black men’s sentences were, on average, “10 percent longer than those of their white peers”. Another way the criminal justice system is racially biased is that black Americans, when pulled over, are far more likely to have their cars searched. More than that, blacks are more likely…

    • 507 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    African Americans have a long and difficult history in the United States. They were once property that could be bought and sold. They once had separate water fountains, bathrooms, and schools than whites. They had to fight for their rights in America and even though they have as many rights as every other American under the letter of the law, there are areas in which they still have to deal with undo ridicule, harassment, and injustices in our society.…

    • 1501 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As you can see white people really don’t serve their full sentences, while black people are more likely to serve prison time. This shows that African-Americans are less valued by society because they are more likely to serve their full sentence compared to whites. But for some people they think white people serve longer sentences. Which isn’t true because “Black and Hispanic men are more likely to receive longer prison sentences than their white counterparts since the Supreme Court loosened federal sentencing rule “(Taylor). We can see that there was a rule that is loosened for white people.…

    • 1811 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays