Self Driving Pros And Cons

Improved Essays
Conger Wraase
Professor Diehl
ENGR 107-003
8 December 2016 The automobile industry is one of the fields that humans relies on the most. Cars get people to and from their jobs, family events, vacations, entertainment, and more; without them the world would not be able to run as smoothly as it currently does. There is a bad side to automobiles though, per the Association for Safe International Road Travel “nearly 1.3 million people die in road crashes each year, on average 3,287 deaths a day.” To try and prevent such a staggering amount of death the automobile industry is trying to create self-driving vehicles. Cars that will no longer require human operation and can therefore prevent human error. This advancement in technology is great and
…show more content…
This is evident in the advancement of self-driving vehicles. While there is a positive side to the idea of a car operating without human intervention there is a negative side to it as well. The issue stems from a similar ultimatum often given to people in ethics class. The question is this, if there was a train the could either split one way and kill five workers or split off the track another and kill one person and you were required to pull a switch and decide who died, would you kill one person or five? The issue with a self-driving car is not the exact same problem but it is a similar one. If a crash between a self-driving vehicle and another truck was unavoidable unless the self-driving car either swerved into an SUV or a motorcycle, how would the car choose? Would the car take a chance and hit the SUV which is ultimately safer for the passengers in the SUV but could still destroy the self-driving car, or would the car hit the less safe motorcycle which would keep the passenger in the self-driving car safe but put the motorcyclist at a higher risk? How could a code make this decision when it’s difficult even for a human to make it? On top of this what if a person died because of the choice the self-driving car made? The car was coded, by a human person, so would it be considered man slaughter by the coder, murder, or neither? These are the major issues behind a self-driving …show more content…
By hitting the motorcyclist, the car might kill the person on the motorcycle but save the car’s passenger, and by hitting the SUV the passengers in the other vehicle might be safer but it puts the passenger in the self-driving car more at risk. In regards to the train dilemma per “The Messy Ethics of Self-Driving Cars” by Wendover Productions it is often seen that people are more likely to move the train to the path that only kills one person. That is the majority choice made by people who can process such ethical decisions. It was not an easy one though, and if they were asked a similar question about stopping a trolley from killing five by pushing one that would stop its movement in front of the trolley many said no. People did not want to play such an active role in the death. People struggle with these complicated decisions even though they have the mental ability to process them. A car that is programed though, will not be able to make the same kind of judgement calls, the car will make the same decision every time. That is regardless of if that decision is the right one, mostly because there is no true right decision when it comes to deciding who lives and who dies. If a car starts to make the decisions about who lives and dies in a car accident it is possible that many people will feel this is wrong and that the car has too much power. They quite possibly

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The left leg is the real one and the other one is the prosthetic leg. It uses pathos because it makes the reader to feel sorry for the person with the missing leg. The viewer might also become aware and seriously think about the negative consequences of getting into an accident, especially when it is being under the influence of alcohol. Many outcomes can occur when people are out of control on the road, they will drift the road, and will crash into an accident. BMW Company wants to show that human parts are not as appealing as the car parts, yet human-flesh is barely possible to be made.…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    But when people argue that they are simply not looking out for the better of others. There are many ways to keep the speed limits from being an ¨ Inconvenience¨. Have a schedule and stick by it so that you don't have the urge to speed. Laws are made not to bother people but to keep everyone as safe as possible. Think of how awful it would be for a driver that was speeding to make a mistake and hit someone because they couldn't stop in time and think of how much worse it would be for the victims family.…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Trolley Problem Analysis

    • 863 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The trolley problem is a made-up scenario that could happen in many instances where a person must make an intuition decision to save either five lives or one. The trolley problem at hand is about engineering self-driving cars. The scenario is whether the self-driving car will crash into a building and kill the passenger and owner or the car which would only be one person, or to swerve and hit and kill five other random bystanders. Views on what to do vary between various types of people’s beliefs; utilitarian, Kaintains, and myself all have different views on what to do when designing the car on what to do in a trolley problem situation. According to Merriam-Webster dictionary, utilitarian are types of people that believe a theory that aims…

    • 863 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Would you like to get in a bad car crash, or have it be worse than drunk driving and or risk the people around you. As you can see texting and driving is illegal but I don't understand why people don't follow the rules. If you're someone that texts and drive it's not doing anything good to your life it's just risking your life to be shorter, so think again when you're on the road and looking down at your…

    • 1060 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    So that 24% could cause deaths, crashes and injuries. All those updates and advances in aren’t in everyone’s budget and not everyone can get them or has them so using your phone isn’t worth taking all those risks. As you now know, distracted driving is a very big risk to take. Distracted driving is dangerous and leads to many deaths and all those laws are there to protect you, but people just don’t follow them also all those types of distraction are equally just as dangerous as texting while driving. This topic is very controversial because not everyone agrees, but all those risks you take while driving can be avoided and not using your phone while driving can save lives.…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Ford Kga Case Study

    • 1058 Words
    • 5 Pages

    However when I found out about the problems and difficulties Ford was facing with the particular car I have, I would rather be safe than sorry and trade my car in before any serious damage occurs and having the risk of myself losing a lot of money, but when I went to the dealership they said I would get nothing for my car and that if there was a problem they would not fix it. I was extremely dissatisfied and so I could not do anything so I carried on using my car to get around with the possible risk of it catching alight and unlucky for me it did exactly that. I now have burns on my body, no car to use and I am sitting with huge financial losses due to this…

    • 1058 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For example if your headlights are turned to high it can cause to other driver to be blinded and lose control of their car. Making sure your headlights are in proper working order can save your life and others life’s around you. Other people or animals in the car can also be a distracting while driving. You are focused on what they are doing, and not paying attention to the road or the other drivers. The radio is a great example you and your passengers get into a fight about what station you should listen to and end up causing to wreck.…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Mothers Against Drunk Driving website also states that, "Americans take 233 billion trips in cars each year. Of those, about one out of every two thousand trips are taken by those who are driving under the influence of alcohol" (MADD). Most injuries or fatalities occur by a drunk driver hitting another car. But for most people, going through their everyday routine they do not realize that just by walking across the street, they could be hit a by a drunk driver. These drunk drivers that are getting their licenses returned only after a short suspension are not learning their lessons and will most likely drink and drive again.…

    • 1088 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Chip-integrated ignition switches, engine cut off devices, and stolen vehicle locators are now more common in cars. Unfortunately for us, poorly motivated and unskilled car thieves have adapted by becoming more violent to get the cars they need and don't think twice about using force against us. Sometimes criminals will carjack a vehicle for use in another crime like armed robbery or for a drive-by shooting. These carjackers prefer to have a set of car keys and not have a visibly smashed window or damaged ignition switch that can be easily spotted by the police. This class of car thief is the most dangerous because they are usually heavily armed and are not concerned with your…

    • 1103 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Blah blah states that the first cars to come into the market will have a steering wheel for safety reasons. The ceo of Volvo the car company and google has stated that they will all liability issues that will come. "So the question becomes who is responsible and we think it 's unrealistic to put that responsibility on our customers… if the customer used the technology in an inappropriate way then the user is still liable," said Mr. Coelingh. Some car companies are uneasy of the thought of being held liable for driverless car accidents and therefore reject the idea for now. The big problem with this is that these stories of car manufactures rejecting the ideas make customers wary of the whole idea of autonomous cars.…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics