Plato And Carr Analysis

Improved Essays
Although Plato and Carr lived in drastically different time periods, they have very similar thoughts on the traditional ways information should travel. Both of them are attached to their respective conventional ways of communicating. At the same time, however, they express a certain level of openness to the changes, Carr even claiming that the internet had been a “godsend to [him] as a writer” (2). Plato felt negatively about writing in general, yet explained that “the parent or inventor of an art is not always the best judge of [its] utility” (1), admitting that he may just simply not understand how useful writing may prove itself to be in later generations. Overall, Carr and Plato felt very negatively about the changes they were witnessing,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Yemisrach Reta ENG 121-340 Professor Ashley Waterman 2 May 2017 Rhetorical Analysis of the Essay “Is Google Making Us Stupid” In “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” Nicholas Carr uses some evidences in his argument in order to convince the idea of the other people . I believe Carr’s argument is effective because he starts explaining how he feels when he is reading a book and immersing himself in a book.…

    • 1510 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Failing to address these benefits to the internet would open Carr immediately to criticism from other writers, such as Clive Thompson, a writer mentioned early in Carr’s text who wrote his own book detailing the benefits of the internet. While Carr does provide many good examples of Prolepsis, this is not to say that Carr creates an absolute defense, as even in the quote above, he fails to mention other aspects of the internet’s effects such as the internet’s effect on writing, something Thompson goes into great detail over, leaving a weakness open in his argument. Additionally, Carr could use more evidence for some of his uses of Prolepsis, as even in his section rebutting a very short section from Thompson, “Thompson has written,”[The Internet] can be an enormous boon to thinking.” But that boon comes at a price”(Carr, 2), he relies on a personal view, rather than evidence. However, despite the deficiencies of parts of his defense, Prolepsis is key to Carr’s main argument, in that if he cannot defend the weak parts of his article and at the same time force his audience to face the possibility of side effects in the commonly believed “benefits” of the internet.…

    • 1649 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the beginning, Carr tells us about how we have benefitted from the internets unlimited information. Shortly after, Carr switches sides on his opinion about the internet and how it has reformed our brains thinking capabilities. He talks about how the internet has affected our attention span, which has also started to affect our reading and writing abilities. He says that it is affecting us this way because of the way the internet provides us information.…

    • 508 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Abstract: In “Into the Electronic Millennium”, Sven Birkerts lays down his central arguments that the introduction of electronic communications are fundamentally changing-and will continue to change-the way that the world works. He focuses on explaining how the assumptions behind reading printed text and electronic text are different, and the visible symptoms in our society. By looking at 3 examples of literary figures as they interact with and utilize the electronic word, he provides acute analysis of different effects that electronic communications are different than print. Birkerts only explains what he sees to be the changes and looks towards the future to hypothesize about other possible effects, without specifically suggesting any changes to be made.…

    • 1049 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rhetoric Analysis: Is Google Making Us Stupid? Indents? The article by Nicholas Carr Is Google Making Us Stupid, formatting? Carr’s main argument is as the Internet has become an integral part of our society is changing the way we process information an simple way of processing information. My interpretation of Carr’s main argument is that the Internet has made it harder to process complex information and now rendering the way information is processed in a simply manner. The reason he accomplished expressing his argument in a effective manor manner (a “manor” is a large home) was his use appeal to Karos, Ethos & Logos; also, with the aid of rhetorical devices.…

    • 1048 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Plato's Closet Analysis

    • 243 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Plato's Closet I have always been a bit of a penny pincher, but I don't necessarily want to look like one. So I'm always on the lookout for quality second-hand clothing, shoes and accessories stores. One of my like-minded, very fashionable friends told me about Plato's Closet in Myrtle Beach she recently discovered and we rode there together one Saturday morning. As we walked through the doors, my first impression -- and something I always look for when scoping out good second-hand shops -- was the near-perfect orderliness.…

    • 243 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When referring to the net Carr states that “They supply the stuff of thought, but they also shape the process of thought . . . my mind now expects to take in information the way the Net distributes it.” From this excerpt, the author is stating that although our minds are gaining information from the internet, this medium is also causing a change in our minds. The author believes the internet has caused his mind to be manipulated into changing the way it obtains or analyzes information to be in sequence with the internet’s behavior. Whether it be a journal entry, a blog, an article, or an argument found on the internet, it will be likely that it will share the same writing style that Macdonald had described.…

    • 1319 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the two texts that we read in class, Plato, Phaedo, and Lucretius, Nature of Things, both Socrates and Lucretius try to reassure us that we should not be afraid of death. In Plato, Phaedo, Phaedo is telling the story of Socrates’s final hours from being their first hand. In Lucretius, Nature of Things, Lucretius’s telling his view on religious issues and how he got to his view, poetic skills, and study on scientific phenomena. Both Socrates and Lucretius have different arguments on why we should not be afraid of death. Socrates and Lucretius would have their own responses to each other 's argument if they were to reply to each other.…

    • 1540 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Argumentative Strategies of Plato vs. Aristophanes In Aristophanes’ “Clouds” and Plato’s “Apology” Socrates is satirically attacked and rationally defended respectively. The two argumentative styles of Aristophanes and Plato are on opposite sides of the spectrum. Aristophanes utilizes satire and humorous exaggerations of sophist teachings to denounce Socrates. Alternatively, Plato’s “Apology” uses logic and reason in order to defend himself against the charges brought against him.…

    • 2212 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Technology is advancing to where everyday tasks become simpler with a click of a button. Search engines like Bing, Yahoo, or even Google allow people to instantly find answers that we are looking for on any topic. In Nicholas Carr’s article “ Is Google Making Us Stupid,” he appeals to readers’ emotions to describe personal experiences, uses logic, facts, and analysis backed by research to lure the audience in, and persuades them that the internet causes our brain to be easily distracted and shortens our attention span. Carr starts off the article by explaining how he feels the internet is affecting how he focuses on tasks, and how “he can no longer be completely immersed in a book.’’ But as a writer, he also finds the internet to be a “godsend.’’…

    • 1090 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The author believes that personal relationships in oral cultures are created through stories. Also, non- literate cultures use numbers in addition to challengers to remember and process the information while literate cultures analyze stories. As the article continues, Ong argues the views of Plato to be similar to the arguments that are made against technology in today’s society. Plato argues that literacy is artificial, manufactured, and inhuman. His opposition about writing is similar to Ong’s opinion against computers.…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout the piece Carr utilizes two quotes from the famous author ‘Wolfgang Schivelbusch’ which act as a means to validate his own opinions by attempting to relate them to someone who is seen as trustworthy and credible by the reader. Also his use of the quote from the unnamed ‘German diarist’ which was written during a time of war acts as a way to persuade the readers emotions, in order to further grip and reel them in; connecting them in a more personal manor. Furthermore the authors mentioning of passing generations and the advancement of technology acts in a way to connect with what may be the target audience of people over the age of twenty-five which grew up without the existence of computers even though it is unrelated to the main argument…

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Plato’s Republic In the Republic, Plato presents an ostensible utopian society, in which a rigid caste system is maintained through deceit. Plato uses this “utopian society” as an analogy for the soul and thorough it demonstrates how an individual can become just. Despite adopting many positions in the Republic antithetical to many of his beliefs in presented in Plato’s other dialogues, some continue to misinterpret the Republic as a serious political treatise. Plato’s preposterous construct of a “just” society has led some, such as German political philosopher Leo Strauss to view the Republic as an ironic work.…

    • 1673 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Evaluation Essay “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” is a widespread essay written by Nicholas Carr. The essay is about how desired technology is making people think differently and how maybe google is being a little too helpful when someone is in need of an answer. Carr takes writing to a whole new level when he goes in depth to explain what the internet is doing to a human brain. He uses his own experiences and feelings to evaluate how he feels and what he believes on the effects of modern technology. Based on superior evidence, a strong view on the subject, and showing the changes Google is doing to a person’s way of thinking, the essay “Is Google Making Us Stupid?”…

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the text “the Cave Allegory” by Plato is about people who are confined Plato states, “ their legs and neck chained” in a cave facing one direction of a wall, with a fire as the only light and a roadway behind them. The confined people are only able to see the shadows of the objects which people are holding as they pass by on the roadway. Plato talks about the tiresome and challenging journey of how one achieves real truth not second hand truth, which the prisoners perceive is real. In this text the most significant ideas of Plato’s allegory is the idea of self- actualization and real truth.…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays