Paternalism And Respect For Patient Autonomy Summary

Decent Essays
While reading about " Paternalism and Respect for Patient Autonomy", what stuck out the most to me was example about a Jehovah's Witness who was in need of a blood transfusion or else they would not survive (pg 59,60). With that issue still standing out in my thoughts, I continued to read. Then I came across another proposal in this section about making dissions for a patient who does not have the ability to make the same chooses he or she would normally choose. Continuing on to the other sections, this scenario came about: A young 16 year old girl is rushed into the emergency room by her parents. She complains of cramps in her mid sections. The doctors run test and find that she has a ectopic pregnancy. The family is a good Christian family

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Dr. Katz Ethical Theory

    • 411 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In this case, Katie’s right to autonomy conflicts with the moral principles of Dr. Katz. Similarly, autonomous decisions can be affected by the mental capacity, mental status, and maturity of the decision maker. Dr. Katz approached the hospital ethics committee and asked them to get involved to help be a resource for the patient, family, and staff. In summation, the ethics committee promoted the baby’s rights and was there to assist Katie in making an ethical informed…

    • 411 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The conversation often returns to the fact that no human can 100% of the time predict the outcome of the patient - because there are the scenarios where a patient in a coma miraculously returns to leading an independent life. While this situation can occur, it is very unlikely. The thought of having someone else make medical decisions on my behalf because I am incapable makes me uneasy. While I have seen situations where medical paternalism seems necessary, specifically with mental health patients, I have seen scenarios where medical paternalism…

    • 1410 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The presentation of group 9 was on the case of Henry Rayhon, 78, who was charged with third degree felony sexual abuse for having sex with his wife who is in a nursing home with alzheimer's. He faced a 10 year sentence if found guilty. The relationship Henry shared with his wife was described as a loving relationship, and she was always happy to see him. There was no physical or emotional signs of abuse/rape. The doctors that evaluated Mrs.Rayhon advised Henry in writing prior to the act that she did not have capacity to consent to sex.…

    • 875 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pillow Angel Case Study

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Although Beauchamp and Childress claim that the best standard through which a decision should be made is the pure autonomy standard because it takes under consideration the patient’s preferences prior to being incompetent (Beauchamp & Childress, 65), it simply just doesn’t apply in the case of Ashley because due to her condition, she has never been a competent individual. For that reason, Ashley’s parents’ decision to administer her with a high-dose of estrogen to remove her breast buds and uterus is based on the best interest standard because their sole purpose was to maintain their daughter in the least amount of “discomfort and boredom” possible. According to Beauchamp and Childress, a decision based on best interest is an inescapably criterion of quality of life for which judgments are meant to focus attention entirely on the value of the life for the person who must live it (Beauchamp & Childress,…

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Paternalism- Paternalism is a form of beneficence and it occurs when individuals and/or institutions believe they know what is best for others, thus making decisions for others. Pozgar, G. D. (02/2012). Jamilah Shah, a 90 year old Turkish women who has lived in the United States for 40 years with her family. Ms. Shah presented to the emergency department after collapsing at her bed side and after several test, it was determined that she had suffered a heart attack ahd treatment with anticoagulants was started immediately.…

    • 161 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Being able to refuse treatment for your child is your own choice you can base your choice off many things like risks, if the treatment is truly needed, and religion. Some parents believe that if a child gets a blood transfusion they will go to Hell because it says in The Bible, these people are Jehovah’s Witnesses; this is considered an ethical dilemma because there are two morally right choices based on which side you take. An ethical dilemma is essentially to choose between two or more morally correct or morally wrong choices. With ethical dilemmas come problems, religion plays a large role in our community about 0.8% of the United States population is a Jehovah’s Witness, that may seem like a tiny amount but that’s actually about 2.5 million…

    • 235 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    The story of how Madeline Kara Neumann passed away is a tragic situation in which there is a debate regarding religious beliefs and necessary legal medical treatment that plays a crucial role. Neumann was eleven years old when she became seriously ill from diabetic ketoacidosis. Her diabetes was undiagnosed and instead of getting medical attention, her parents decided to respond to her sickness with prayer instead (Johnson, 2013). The purpose of this paper is to further explore Neumann’s background story, the ethical principles related to this case, the difference between the right to religious freedom and the duty to protect children, the impact on laws and regulations, similar cases to Neumann’s story, and also an opinion regarding what stand…

    • 1707 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Strong Paternalism

    • 1126 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Dandan Zhang PHI 3633 Case A Response Paper In the case of the 19-year-old patient X seeks to get a vasectomy, strong paternalism is evident in the urologist’s refusal to perform the surgery. Paternalism is defined as overriding someone’s actions and decision-making for his own benefit (71). In patient X’s case, his autonomy and ability to make his own rational decision were undermined by the urologist, who stated he was too young to make such a decision.…

    • 1126 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Prohibitionist’s surrounding the debate of saviour siblings argue that being a continuous donor without giving any consent is greatly dishonourable on a child’s autonomy. Which, should not be seen as compatible with certain strained life experiences. Denying a child the right to make medical decisions regarding their own body, when they are capable of doing so, is neither fair or ethical (Anderson & Christman 2005). Despite the success of the cases stated above, the birth of these saviour siblings highlights the controversy and raised ethical concerns about the welfare of these children. However, upon review, the HFEA claimed that provided there are strict conditions regulating the practice, the welfare of both the children would be equally…

    • 117 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Online resources and forums enhance and support patients knowledge on their medical conditions. The Internet has become a valuable tool for health care. Patients become more educated and treat their chronic diseases with the support of others who experience the same symptoms. Online support groups offer solutions and patients can share their experiences in hope that they will find effective treatment.…

    • 318 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the short story “The use of force,” the two characters collide and both show power, the doctor has the knowledge and the experience and the girl uses manipulation and physical force. When different kinds of power are utilized, one person has the edge over the other person and wields in more power. Being a doctor can be hard most of the time. Patients think that they know better than the doctors. That’s completely understandable being a worried patient.…

    • 1283 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The ethical right of patients’ ability to refuse treatment is a considerable right that respects an individuals’ autonomy. This right is enforced in all patients’ cases, except if the patient requires immediate intervention from a health threatening state. In mental health nursing, individuals are commonly involuntarily hospitalized for treatment if they are at risk for harming themselves or others (Townsend & Morgan, 2017). Many states support a mentally ill clients’ right to refuse medication and treatment, but many considerations are made by health care providers in which exceptions to a patients’ autonomy are made. This involuntary hospitalization is commonly driven by a petition for court ordered treatment and challenges the ethics and…

    • 379 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Firstly, due to the magnitude of these disputes, there are often dire consequences for those involved. Consequences include parent’s having their children taken away by the state as a result of not making medical care decisions that align with the practitioners involved. Moreover, the outcomes of these types of cases set a significant precedence for the larger medical community and society in which they occur. For these reasons, I would like to strive to find ways in which the ethical reasoning and actions of healthcare providers could be enhanced or improved in order to be more effectively constructed for dealing with cases that are particularly influenced by a patient’s religious…

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The evolution of health care in the United States have evolved since the 1800 's until the present, going through an atmosphere of home care, remedies and itinerant physicians to complex system, technological, scientific, and lucrative called industrial medical complex. Coupled with this development the relationships between physicians, health personnel and patients suffered a marked change in the last years and is looked at 40 from different edges or points of view, one of them is the dilemma paternalism versus autonomy in health care. It is well known by all the notion that we live in a society where hundreds of patrialcal values have supremacy on others that they are often imposed in order to maintain a social order. The paternalism has exercised significant influence in a significant number of legislatures and countries around the world of there the importance of discussing and analysing the impact it has on the health care structures in the population.…

    • 1113 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Case Study: Healing and Autonomy, the current case reviews how the delay in making medical decisions affected the health of their eight years old boy James. Mike and Joanne are the parents of James and his twin brother Samuel both born eight years ago. James was initially treated for A Streptococcus infection, and the complication of this infection led to acute renal failure. James doctor suggested temporary immediate dialysis to relieve James of the buildup fluids in his Lungs, and body and also to bring down the elevated blood pressure; Mike and Joanne decided to put off the dialysis treatment for faith healing clinic as they have seen their close friend being healed through prayer and spiritual healing. They informed the Doctor…

    • 281 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays