American Football Australia V Ashley Case

Superior Essays
Introduction
Does the correspondence between Ashley and Ben give rise to a concluded agreement? American Football Australia (AFA) will be liable for the bill that Ben sent to Ashley on behalf of Gridiron Association (GA), if there is a binding contract between the two parties. There are essential elements which must be satisfied for a binding contract to exist including agreement, consideration and intention to create legal relations.
Agreement
Offer and acceptance analysis may be used to show agreement. An offer is a statement of intention by one party to be bound by certain terms of the contract without further negotiation. Whether a statement is an offer is dependence on how a reasonable person in the position of the offeree would interpret
…show more content…
In the battle of the forms, the last form that was dispatched and received without objection govern the contract. If that is the case, the standard terms proposed by Ben would be the terms of the contract. Nonetheless, it might be evident that they reached agreement during the phone call.

Consideration
A promise is legally binding only if consideration that is an act or promise is provided in return by the promisee. Ben promise to secure a US team which is sufficient consideration for the promise of payment by Ashley and vice versa. As illustrated by Chappell & Co Pty Ltd v Nestlé Co Ltd consideration have to be sufficient but not adequate.
It could be argued that no consideration is provided for the promise to recompense BA if contract does not eventuate. The promise to secure a team would be past consideration which is not a valid consideration.
Intention to create legal relations
To form a contract two parties must give mutual consent that the agreement is legally enforceable. There is a strong presumption that commercial agreement are intended to have legal consequences. The presumption cannot be rebutted as there is no express or implied repudiation of the
…show more content…
Firstly, there must be expressed or implied unequivocal promise leading to an assumption that legal relationship exists or would eventuates. Fedos claim that they are ready to sign on and expressed great interest which clearly might imply the promise to sign the contract to play in the game leading to the assumption of future legal relationship. Secondly, promisor could reasonably expect promisee would be encouraged or induced due to action or inaction of promisor, to act on the assumption. When Ashley contacted Fedos, they might reasonably expect the words ‘ready to sign on’ and expression of interest would induce Ashley to adopt the assumption. Thirdly, there must be actual and reasonable reliance causing detriment and promisor fail to avoid detriment. Ashley relying on the assumption suffered detriment by endeavour to secure a US team and option to football stadium which lapsed and selling broadcasting right. The correspondence between Ashley and Fedos must be assessed in full and detail. It might be proven that Fedos did not attempt to avoid the detriment that might result. For instance, early notice of the availability to play and notice of reserving the right to bail out. Lastly, it would be unjust and unconscionable if the promise is not enforced. Unconscionable departure is dependence upon all the circumstances of the case including the reasonableness of the conduct of promisee in adopting the assumption and extent

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    • The contract also contains ‘considerations’ which are services, goods or any actions of legal value that accepting party is bound to provide in replace of money. • Both parties should aim for the contract to be legal and the objective of contract should also be legal. • Contract should also state the conditions, obligations and rights of both parties. These conditions are based upon those which are specified by parties or those which are bound to be fulfilled because of their presence in country’s constitution. • Some clauses are also included in contract that determines that if unintended events are faced, one party or both parties will not be responsible.…

    • 904 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Hyder V Wrench Case Study

    • 1795 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Consideration need to require the contract whether binding. Both of these parties need to reach an agreement under the law binding. If the parties are not accept the offer in the agreement, however the offeror can quit the contract with no any problem. (Williams v Raffrey Brothers). (iv)Intentions: Intention to create legal relations (I.T.C.L.R) is defined as a purpose to enter a lawfully authoritative understanding or contract.…

    • 1795 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Two-Sided Contract

    • 1555 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Thought is the value that is approached by the promisor in return for their guarantee – the cost for a guarantee. In numerous wards thought is not a vital component of an agreement – it is adequate that gatherings have achieved an official understanding. In any case, the custom-based law requires that, for a consent to tie, the guarantee (or guarantees)…

    • 1555 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The facts are similar: the claimant (C) had communicated to the defendant (E), the importance of the land being suitable. The C then relied on that information and entered a contract. However, would not have if the land was not suitable. Suitability for marquee installation is a fundamental term of the contract, and without it, there is no motive to contract. In this case, it was held that because the claimant had communicated to the defendant the importance of the term; hops must have been treated without sulphur, and because the claimant relied on the statement, the hops had not been treated with sulphur, the claimant’s action for breach of a fundamental term was successful.…

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This is in regards to that state in which the party resides, or that state in which that concerned property is located. Thus, with all these aspects, it can be well stated that such agreements are of extreme importance while limiting legal agreements. Hence, with help of a hold harmless agreement form, you can surely get an idea as to how to write a hold harmless agreement. How to write a hold harmless agreement? Have you decided on framing your own agreement letter?…

    • 1974 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    In which the scenario expresses the term that “would” is a precatory word. But one can argue that the level of precatory which deals with the trustee’s willingness to hold the property for the benefit of Sian rather than settlors intention to create a trust. Presuming that Andy was certain about making a trust that it would fulfill the certainty of intention. This was illustrated in the case of Lambe v Eames (1871) . Next we have to consider whether this has the certainty of subject matter.…

    • 1894 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Consideration is another essential element which makes the agreement binding. Only in special contract like deeds do not need any consideration. In this element, the offeror will give something in exchange for the promise which also part of the bargain and it must be real and tangible with actual value: White v Bluett (1853) and need not to be adequate: Thomas v Thomas (1842) (Fried 2015; Turner 2014). In most cases, consideration in return for a promise will constitute both benefit and detriment to both parties. There are certain scenarios where the promise does not constitute a valid consideration.…

    • 705 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A consideration is supposed to be legal and normally supports a simple contract. Consideration can only be present or future and not past (Roscorla v Thomas (1842) 3 QB…

    • 926 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Liquidated Damages Essay

    • 891 Words
    • 4 Pages

    • Section 74 read with Section 73 and, therefore, in each case of default, and the aggrieved person to prove that he suffered before he can apply for a decree does not require a breach of contract, the actual loss or damage. Under the circumstances the Court has the ability, even without proof of actual loss suffered the consequences of breach of a violation of a reasonable award of compensation. • In some contracts, it would be impossible to court, in order to assess the breach, if we consider the compensation will not be punished or unreasonable manner, the court may grant the same, if it is a genuine pre-estimate of the parties arising compensation As a reasonable compensation…

    • 891 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Question 1: Issue: Is the exclusion clause enforceable? Rule: A disclaimer is a statement that one of the parties will not be in breach despite failing to perform one or more of their contractual obligations. Whether a disclaimer is enforceable depends on; 1. Is the disclaimer part of the contract: (1) is it expressly set out in a written contract that has been signed by the parties? (2) It is expressly brought to the attention of the party by reasonable notice given before the contract was formed.…

    • 2390 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays

Related Topics