Napoleon: A Nationalistic Symbol Or Hero?

Improved Essays
Napoleon is undeniably a powerful nationalistic symbol and hero in the eyes of the French, due to multiple reasons. Some would argue that Napoleon was a tyrannical individual who was selfish, greedy, and used propaganda to secure his position as emperor for life. However, such individuals fail to recognize how Napoleon’s accomplishments lead to the modification and immense improvement of French society. The multiple domestic policy reforms and expansion of French influence over Europe developed a sense of pride and belonging to the nation, which is still deeply enrooted in each French citizen today. Where previous leaders had failed, Napoleon stabilized the French economy by creating the Bank of France. As well, he established equality and religious tolerance, …show more content…
Several argue that the forceful coup d’état conjectures Napoleon as a tyrant as the people did not vote him in. On the contrary, the people did not need to vote him in, as Napoleon saved them from the Directory, a government steadily trying to re-establish the Old Regime. Napoleon saved the French from reverting back to the very system they desperately worked to abandon, rather than dooming them, making him a hero. Furthermore, others will argue that such reforms and accomplishments were due to Napoleon’s self-seeking nature; his intentions were to create gain for himself, rather than all of France. However, this is not a matter of intentions, but outcomes, where Napoleon’s actions may only deem him a hero to the French for improving France in such an imperative manner. Admittedly, Napoleon did make some harmful decisions, such as reverting back to slavery in French colonies. As well, the Russian campaign was a disaster for the French. Nonetheless, Napoleon’s contributions to France, as well as her nationalism, greatly outweigh his harmful decisions; thus, French people consider him a powerful nationalistic symbol and

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Napoleon’s atrophy and subsequent defeat resulted from his inability to understand the limits of his power. Miscalculations of economic warfare, mismanagement of Spain’s government and his botched attack on Russia were all deciding factors to end his sovereignty. “The downfall of the Continental System was inseparable from the fall of the Napoleonic regime.” This economic strategy was a risky gamble by Napoleon which adversely became a critical variable in his defeat.…

    • 574 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Napoleon was therefore seen as a progressive and thusly favored by a sizable portion of the British public. Even though the two nations were at war, ideologies were able to travel across the English Channel in both directions, fueling a progressivist fervor in the British Radical party which was most definitely vocal and thusly heard. The Loyalist party, however, attacked Napoleon’s character on the basis of illegitimacy. He was certainly an emperor in terms of power and influence, but Loyalists, whose rhetoric has since become hegemonic and embedded in Western prisms, claimed that his rule was undeserved—that he was not born into his position as was expected of a king. The common argument against Napoleon’s character in my anecdotal environment has been that of a monster who took his emperorship by bloody force during the 18 Brumaire coup.…

    • 1575 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It’s thanks to him that French citizens were able to enjoy fair leadership, equality before the law, and a stable economy. The first important fact about Napoleon is that he rose the ranks of government entirely fairly. He began as a military general and “ rose... to the astonishing height of power [he] possessed (being emperor) without having committed a single crime to obtain it” (Doc 6)…

    • 605 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In January 1793, King Louis was executed, but the war was still going bad for France. The period following Louis’ death was known as ‘The Terror’ in France. It spread all over the country. This was a cruel period when France was killing its people by hundreds in a frightening way of rage and decadence. The people were arrested and executed without trial if they were accused of being enemies of the revolution.…

    • 224 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Napoleon had caused and supported nationalist movement, which encouraged many countries, such as Ireland and South Africa, to become independent countries. In addition, because of his conquering, he had created unity of Europe. He had also sparked further revolutions, such as a chain of revolts in 1848, after he had died, his nephew had restored the French Empire. Ten of thousands of books were written on his political brilliance and military tactics. These books helped inspire many of the greatest commanders.…

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a result of these actions, Napoléon succeeded in deceiving his people, also preventing a united French society. In short, Napoléon acted out of self interest, defying integral ideas of the French Revolution and gaining the support of his people through deceit rather than virtue, causing French society to be deeply divided. To begin, Napoléon’s actions could have been meant…

    • 1317 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Napoleon provided the French a monarchy that was more efficient and more powerful than any other. He did this because he believed that they needed some type of form of monarchy. When he was emperor he recreated a French “upper class.” While the emperor he continued to reward his commanders of the army with noble titles and estates.…

    • 58 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Napoleon: A Political Life by Steven Englund crafts for the reader a detailed and comprehensive timeline of Napoleon Bonaparte’s origins and the events that led to rise to power through military success, political knowledge, and personal ambition. In order to accurately present this subject, Englund utilized a large amount of primary sources ranging from letters from Napoleon and others that are mentioned throughout the reading, publications from newspapers during the time, as well as many other reliable sources. Englund himself is an American Historian from California who currently lives in Paris and teaches History at the American University in Paris. It is fairly possible that this move to Paris and his occupation there served as inspiration for Napoleon: A Political Life.…

    • 1232 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The opinions on whether Napoleon Bonaparte was a hero or a villain constantly changed during his life, through both the French, as well as internationally. The English had seen Napoleon as a tyrant, especially during his reign, while the French considered him a hero due to his accomplishments toward France. However, according to Dwyer, when he was overthrown and exiled, Napoleon was not very well liked, as it had seemed like he was not a hero anymore because he was finally defeated. Yet, when Napoleon returned from exile, the French did not like the new ruling, and Napoleon’s return was a blessing for the French, and became an instant hero once again. Yet, tensions that led to the loss at Waterloo created Napoleon into a failed hero, almost as a villain.…

    • 1547 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He as gotten many new opportunities to retreat battles, but because of his over confidence he seemed to try to push forward which ultimately led to many downfalls of the French military. Napoleon had gotten thousands of troops killed and important French territories captured by enemy countries. This all shows that Napoleon had ultimately failed to accomplish his dream of a European-wide…

    • 527 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    With so much chaos, politicians turned to Napoleon Bonaparte, a brilliant and ambitious captain and emperor, for help and to try advance their own goals. Napoleon was a popular military hero, had very much military success, who won a series of brilliant victories against the Austrians in Italy. Napoleon decided to outwit them all and become the ruler of France. He controlled prices, encouraged new industry, and built roads and canals. He set up a system of public schools under strict government control to ensure well trained officials and military officers.…

    • 141 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is observed through his abuse of power to force the people of France to obey and worship him. Napoleon claimed to have absolute power and that those who resisted his rule “would render themselves worthy of eternal damnation” (Document 10). This conveys how Napoleon would persuade the French to follow him by instilling fear, which is injustice to the freedom that he initially wanted the French to have. This contradicts what he had wrote in the Napoleonic Code, which stated that “every Frenchman shall enjoy civil rights” (Document 8). Since the French were unable to form their own beliefs and act as individuals, Napoleon contradicted his original goal of wanting the French to have political and social justice.…

    • 676 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Adrianna Morina Although, Napoleon Bonaparte has made major military mistakes throughout his reign, such as invading Russia in the middle of winter, it does not however qualify him as a power hungry dictator nor should he be accused of crimes against Humanity. Reason being is that Napoleon Bonaparte has proven time and time again that his best interest was for the people of France. This is shown by his many reforms which helped abolished inequality amongst social classes in France, spreading enlightenment ideas throughout Europe, and his military genius, losing only two battles during his unification of Europe. These are all qualities of a good leader and only further prove that Napoleon is not guilty of crimes against humanity when he put…

    • 1722 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Maxwell James 9/29/16 Mr. Puzzo World History (H) John Locke and the French Revolution John Locke was a French philosopher and was interested in how a citizen and a government interact together, in times of peace and in times of tension. John Locke studied government and came to many conclusions; the role of government is to protect citizen’s natural rights: Life, Liberty and property. If a government wasn’t adequately protecting citizen’s natural rights, the citizens had a responsibility to overthrow that government and establish a new government that does better to protect those rights.…

    • 1271 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction: When Napoleon III ruled France from 1848 to 1870, France underwent rapid economic growth because of the Industrial Revolution and Napoleon III’s involvement in this revolution. Napoleon III modernized France by building railroads, canals, and banking institutions. This helped centralized France’s capital and created a strong unified state, which made France one of the big powers of Europe. Napoleon III, like Napoleon I, wanted to make France the best country in Europe, and so because of this, he stepped up to the throne and bean reforming France immediately. Also like Napoleon I, his downfall came after he involved France in many wars like the Crimean War.…

    • 454 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays