Louisiana Purchase Analysis

Great Essays
The Louisiana Purchase Negotiations and the Constitutionality of the Purchase The negotiations pertaining to the acquisition of the Louisiana Territory from France began prior to Robert Livingston departing for formal dialogues in France with Bonaparte. The earliest stage was when Livingston went to France to engage in an intake process to determine Frances plan for the Louisiana Territory. Prior to the final negotiations, Livingston made intense efforts to tap into what the French were hiding as a means to figure out their weakness. The United States was always a step ahead of France because they were already aware of the Spain transferring power over the territory back to France. These points are verifiable with an excerpt from “An Immense …show more content…
When an individual or a group holds a constitutionalist perspective, it means the principles they stand by are influenced by the United States Constitutions and its contents. The Federalist Party did not view the Louisiana Purchase as being in harmony with the values expressed in the Constitution. His article “Party Politics during the Louisiana Purchase”, Sean Theriault explores how the various parties of the era had the tendency to flip-flop with regards to their views on certain issues. Additionally, he explores voting patterns amongst members of the various parties, and the arguments for and against the Louisiana Purchase that were held members of each part. In his essay, Theriault cites Congressmen Roger Griswold as …show more content…
On the one hand, Jefferson recognized Frances point of vulnerability and the necessity of the United States to maintain access to the ports at New Orleans and acted in his best judgment. On the other hand, President Jefferson prided himself for his strict adherence to the ideologies expressed in the United States Constitution and was struggling with whether or not the transfer of power from the France to the United State over the region of Louisiana in its entirety violated the U.S. Constitution. The attribute the distinguishes President Jefferson and Jeffersonian Republicans from the Federalist Party and its leaders like Alexander Hamilton and Roger Griswold, is Jefferson’s willingness to contemplate the matter and figure things out. The article “Louisiana Purchase” from “Shaping of America”, 1783-1815 Reference Library, 2006 illustrates the conflict of conscience that was plaguing President Jefferson when it says: When news of the agreement reached Jefferson in mid-May 1803, he was thrilled but conflicted. Congress had only authorized a little over $9 million to be spent, not $15 million. More important, he did not think the Constitution gave the U.S. government the power to buy a huge expanse of land. Throughout his public career, Jefferson had always insisted that the Constitution

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The Revolution of 1803 In the Revolution of 1803 by Peter S. Onuf the thesis was the events related to the Louisiana Purchase, The territories before the Louisiana Purchase, Jefferson’s Inaugurals speech, and the views of Jefferson on the revolution. The Louisiana Purchase was the purchasing of land from the French. This expanded the United States west ward. “United States acquired 82800 square miles for 15 million dollars,” (91).…

    • 325 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Louisiana Purchase was controversial for Jefferson because he wanted to control an empire of liberty and expand across all of America, however he wanted to avoid foreign entanglements as much as possible. Therefore it would be very difficult to expand when Spain had control of Louisiana which was thought to be soon taken over by France, proving to be a rather large obstacle and making avoiding foreign entanglements impossible. The other possibility was that Britain might take Louisiana before France, which would still prove to be a large obstacle. Pluses : Drawbacks - Ability to deposit American produce in New Orleans : - Possible Entanglement with France - Purchase a vast amount of land for very little money : - Possible Entanglement with Britain : : 5. Aaron Burr plotted to have high federalist form a Northern Confederacy which would be pro-Britain and in this way get federalist nomination for the governorship of New York.…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As all great presidents, many encounter some of the toughest decisions for our nation. Thomas Jefferson has proven this statement true, The Lousiana Purchase seemed to be an obvious dilemma that could potentially make the United States great. Although our nation would succeed, Jefferson had to exam the situation and realize the importance of the circumstances we were in concluding with the Mississippi River. For Thomas Jefferson, many pros and cons were on the line but he had to make his decision based on what benefited our nation’s economic growth, expansion, and Constitution. The Mississippi River played a large role to this negotiation.…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many saw the Louisiana purchase as a huge waste of money. As stated in document 6, “Jefferson’s political opponents in the Federalist Party argued that the Louisiana purchase was a worthless desert” (Document 6). The Federalist party argued that the purchase was a waste of money because there was nothing there to…

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In March 1808, Jefferson tried to conciliate his Federalist adversaries by persuading them that both parties had the same ideas and morals, even if they do not agree with each others opinions. Jefferson promised to lessen government, free trade, make certain that freedom of religion and the press is obtainable and staying away from getting mixed up into crazy alliances with other nations. Jefferson wanted to get rid of Federalist beliefs and keep the centralized state that they encouraged from happening. He also minimized the navy and army and the amount of government workers, did away with all taxes except for the tariff, and paid off some of the nation’s debt. In Jefferson’s eyes, the Louisiana Purchase was his greatest achievement.…

    • 221 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the long term, the Louisiana Purchase expanded the fortunes of the United States and the power of the federal government immensely, but in the short term, the expanse of territory and the feeble reach of the government obliged to control it raised fears of secession and foreign interest. Although the Louisiana purchase contradicted Jefferson's constitutional view, the purchase initially benefited the United States as Jefferson fulfilled is vision of an agrarian…

    • 830 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Though America was allied with France, it is dangerous to have another country controlling trade just a river’s width away. There could be surprise attacks or even a trade monopoly put on by France. According to James Madison (Document C) “It will be of great importance also to take the regulation and settlement of that Territory out of other hands, into those of the U.S who will be able to manage both for general interest and conveniency.” This excerpt, along with the whole document, serves the purpose of convincing Robert Livingston to agree to purchase the land. This letter was written right as America was deciding to say yes or no to France.…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is highly recommended that any American reads this book. For something that at most gets a page worth's' mention, the Louisiana Purchase was actually quite a long, complicated conflict. After reading the book, a sense of respect and gratitude forms for the entire western part of America. It is noteworthy that America had very little control over its destiny. The Louisiana Territory was made for Americans.…

    • 1237 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A man named Monroe was sent to Paris to buy New Orleans and land to its east in 1803. He was advised to spend no more than $10 million but Napoleon offered him a compromise he could not refuse. Napoleon would give the entire territory to America for only $15 million. Jefferson understood that spending more than $10 was against the Congress but he continued with Napoleon's deal.…

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    First he had to deal with France and the Louisiana Purchase. After the Haitian Revolution and the loss of its sugar colonies, France led by Napoleon Bonaparte decided that it no longer wanted a North American empire. This led to the Louisiana Purchase where the United States bought the Louisiana territory. Jefferson created this deal, but there was no explicit power in the constitution for the president to purchase foreign lands. Document C details a letter from Jefferson to John Breckinridge where he admits to reaching beyond the constitution in order to make the deal happen.…

    • 884 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Louisiana Purchase Dbq

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Some historians may analyze the Louisiana Purchase and argue that when Thomas Jefferson purchased the Louisiana Territory from France, he altered the shape of a nation and the course of history. However, there is considerable evidence that shows that the Louisiana Purchase influenced the United States Ideas and policies of citizenship by challenging the social hierarchy, bringing groups together, and establishing a democracy over all of the United States. The addition of the Louisiana territory led to conflicts in the United States. The government was forced to find ways to keep the whole country intact.…

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Therefore, Thomas Jefferson set up negotiations with the French and sent James Monroe and Robert Livingston to negotiate the sole purchase of the Port of New Orleans and west of Florida for $10 million. When they showed up to the meeting on negotiating plans of purchasing the port and land, France was at war and was running low on funds for the war, so when Monroe and Livingston proposed the offer, the French representative instead offered the whole Louisiana territory which was 825,000 square miles of land for $15 million. Even though they were only sent to purchase The Port, they knew that this was an offer that they couldn’t refuse. So they went beyond the instructions that Jefferson has given them and purchased the whole territory and signed the treaty on the second day of May which came to be known as: the Louisiana Purchase.…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The American people were enthusiastic about the new state but Jefferson “worried that the purchase might be unconstitutional. The president pointed out that the Constitution did not specifically authorize the acquisition of vast new territories and the incorporation of thousands of foreign citizens.” (PG. 185) Although he felt his act was unconstitutional he still sent Lewis and Clark to explore the vast territory. Also once he became president he realized we needed a stronger government to take on unexpected challenges, leading him to put money back into the army, which goes against his low spending…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In 1787, the Continental Congress was brought together in the Philadelphia Convention to revise the Articles of Confederation. The Constitution was written and since people had different views on how to interpret it, two political parties were eventually formed: The federalists and the Democratic-Republicans. The main reason for the rise of political parties during the 1790s was because each of the parties favored different political and economical reforms needed as a new, developing country. Alexander Hamilton led the Federalists and they favored a loose interpretation of the Constitution, while Thomas Jefferson and the Democratic-Republican Party favored strict interpretation. The Federalists wanted to create a national economy by creating…

    • 1488 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The United States expanded across North America to the west at a rapid rate most notably in the 1840’s through the 1850s. Many social, econonomic, and political factors lead to the nations growth and acquisition of land. Social interests included families’ desire to seek more land out west along with economic opportunities for interstate commerce and political agendas concerning territorial expansion. The Louisiana Purchase of 1803 from the French government, by President Thomas Jefferson, cost $15 million, and included territory from Canada to New Orleans, and the Mississippi to the Rocky Mountains (Westward Expansion, 2009). The purchase of these territories doubled United States’ size and according to Jefferson it was crucial to the nation’s…

    • 740 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays