Land Rights Argumentative Analysis

Improved Essays
Land rights are still bitterly contested, passionately fought over and, irrefutably, close to the hearts of thousands of Aboriginal people all over Australia. Land rights and the Land Councils, never far from controversy, are, once again in the political spotlight. While the critics change, their arguments have basically remained unchanged for nearly two decades. Land rights, one of the few positive outcomes to emerge for Aboriginal people in the Northern Territory in the past 40 years, has slowly been turned into an unfulfilled obligation for the Australian government.
Individual home ownership by Aboriginal people living remotely is almost non-existent. There are some homes bought on Tiwi Island and four families nearly bought houses at
…show more content…
He must also comment on any detriment to others that may occur should the land be granted and the effect a grant may have on existing or proposed patterns of land usage in the region.
The Minister for Aboriginal Affairs decides whether or not to recommend to the Governor General to grant all or part of the land under claim.
As a result of an amendment to the Aboriginal Land Rights Act by the Hawke Government, no more land claims could be lodged after June 30 1997. However some claims before then are still outstanding, with over 1000 yet to be determined in NSW alone. Recent 2014 studies indicate that less that 1% of land in NSW that is available to be returned, has been returned.
Clearly, this long, arduous process of lodging and receiving acknowledgement of a successful land claim needs to be completed more speedily and in a more comprehensive manner than is currently occurring.

The oldest aboriginal land rights claim in Australia as of the 14th January 2014, as recorded by the ABC website, is that of the Kenbi tribe, traditional owners Tibby and Sherana Quail. The claim was lodged in 1979 and 36 years later it is still not

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Haudenosaunee In Canada

    • 2486 Words
    • 10 Pages

    However the most recent and most publicized of these land claim disputes came in 2006 during the Douglas Creek Estates Dispute in Caledonia. The dispute began when The Six Nations of the Grand River sought to reclaim and halt the development of the Douglas Creek Estates subdivision in Caledonia, which was to be built on land known to some Haudenosaunee as Kanonhstaton, “the Protected Place.” This dispute led to blockades by Native protestors…

    • 2486 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Calder Case Summary

    • 1417 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Recognised treaty right of first nations to fish, hunt or gather can be moderated by the Province and cannot be exercised in abeyance of the authority of the Canadian State or the Province authority. Delgamuukw V British Columbia [1997] 3SCR 1010 This case was instituted as a representative action for and on behalf of the Gitksen or Wet’suwaten hereditary chiefs and on behalf of their houses claiming aboriginal rights, ownership and jurisdiction over approximately 58,000 square kilometers of land in BC. The plaintiffs relied on among others in proving their claims by oral evidence detailing their connection to the land, historical use of the land in question from time immemorial, and ownership over the large tracts of land in question.…

    • 1417 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Mabo Decision

    • 884 Words
    • 4 Pages

    This is because all aspects of Aboriginal spirituality and life such as their belief systems, rituals, totemic responsibilities, traditions and laws are rooted in the stories of the Dreaming which are intimately connected with the land. Therefore, the religious and political Land Rights movement that aimed to regain access and ownership to sacred sites and traditional lands was paramount in attempting to re-establish ceremonial life, reconnect the Dreaming and preserve Aboriginal spirituality which was lost as a result of European settlement. Regaining access to sacred sites was especially important so balance rites and rituals could be fulfilled. Aboriginal people believe they are custodians of the land, which is the resting place of ancestral beings and totems which form the foundation of beliefs and traditions, so land rights promoted conservation of their culture and fulfilment of their role. Connection to the Dreaming was, therefore, an inextricable driving force for the Land Rights…

    • 884 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Greg McIntyre and Eddie both applied successfully to conduct research for the case. ("Eddie Koiki Mabo", 2015) 20th of May 1982, Eddie Mabo and other Mer Islander civil rights activists Sam Passi, Celuia Mapoo Salee, Reverend David Passi and James Ricebegan their legal claim for their land rights with the High Court of Australia. The case was know as the 'Mabo Case' as Eddie Mabo was the first named claimant. The legal doctrine of native title was inserted into the Australian law: 'In recognizing the traditional rights of the Meriam people to the islands in the Torres Strait, the Court also held that native title existed for all Indigenous peoples in Australia who held rights in their lands under their own laws and customs prior to the assertion of British sovereignty and establishment Colonies across the continent from 1788.' As the new doctrine replaced the terra nullius which the British claims were justified as a wrongful legal presumption of how the indigenous people were not settled by law to use the land.…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hotel Bone Poem Analysis

    • 1029 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Q. 1 Write about 3 lines for each of the following about the significance for Indigenous Land Rights in Australia: (a) “Terra nullius” Terra Nullius means that land without. When Captain Cook and his crew was in Australia , they decided the land was Terra Nullius. They acknowledge Indigenous people because of their primitive life. The High Court's Mabo judgement overturned the Terra Nullius fiction in 1982. (b) Protective legislation…

    • 1029 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Mabo Case Study

    • 1337 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The Mabo case refers to the legal action taken upon the commonwealth of Australia outlining Native title, Indigenous Land Rights by activist Eddie Mabo to which was concluded in 1993. The case was stimulated due to the Australian Civil Rights Movement of 1957 - 1973, it refers to the leading fight that was put forward in an attempt to gain rights and recognition of land connection to that of the Indigenous and Torres Strait Islanders. The Mabo Case is a famous story and that of which is extremely important to the history and future of Australia. Eddie Koiki Mabo was born on the 29th June, 1936, Mabo lived on ‘Murray Island’ in the Torres Straits, he was educated about his land and culture to a great extent. Eddie Mabo at age of 17 left the…

    • 1337 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1967, after ten years of campaigning, a referendum was held to change the Australian Constitution. Two negative references to Aboriginal Australians were removed, giving the Commonwealth the power to legislate for them as a group. This change was seen by many as a recognition of Aboriginal people as full Australian citizens. The referendum campaign effectively focused public attention on the fact that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians were second class citizens with all sorts of limitations - legislative and social - on their lives.…

    • 131 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “ who do you reckon this land belongs to? Not to you mate” (P.158). Aboriginals were thought to not be capable of owning property or making any decisions for themselves. White Australians attitudes shown towards Aboriginals were very different. They were thought to be incapable of doing anything useful, inferior to everyone else and there opinions were never…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Tsilhqot Case Analysis

    • 1517 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Provincial and federal governments take advantage of and use unclaimed Aboriginal land, often ignoring legal standards. In 2014, the Supreme Court has enforced constitutional procedures the Canadian government must take relating to Aboriginal land claims in the Tsilhqot’ in Decision. This Precedent setting case will strengthen Aboriginal rights for protecting their traditional territories and bring about change within their communities. By analyzing the legal policies our government must abide by, as well as the implications of the precedent its self, we can see how it will benefit and create more rights to Aboriginals. The case through its decision will also indirectly bring about positive change within Aboriginal communities.…

    • 1517 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “A Republic is the last step in our journey of departure from our colonial origins. And it cannot be achieved as a truly significant step ─ a moment of re-funding ─ unless it also represents the end of the colonial experience for Aboriginal people.” (2004, p.20-21) This argument is at the heart of Mark McKenna’s book “This Country a Reconciled republic? “, that was published in 2004, only a few years after the failure of both the 1999 republic referendum and the reconciliation movement.…

    • 1252 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tully's Argument Analysis

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Rights and interest of equal legitimacy” (Tully 230). Aboriginal peoples and settlers would coexist as self governing entities who are equal. (Tully 234) In doing so would reverse the assumptions of unilateral authority vested in the Canadian state and allow Aboriginal peoples to be recognized as self-governing entities with sui generis rights that are not subjects to the Canadian government or minorities with persisting or extinguishable rights. The legitimization of Indigenous legislative power would include the right to hunt, fish, educate their children, speak their language, and express their culture without the suppression of the Canadian state (Tully…

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Aboriginal Struggles

    • 1283 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The United Aboriginal Struggle “Get over it!” A statement that has been repeated time and time again, with regards to Indigenous land. It’s a surprise that Aboriginals want their land back after centuries of not owning it. Is it not? Well, no, it is not.…

    • 1283 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Aboriginal people still do not feel that the recognition process which began after WW2 in 1967, is reasonable and just. Megan David argues that Australian needs a more in-depth acknowledgement of the injustices which occurred such as the Frontier war, the Killing times, the Protection era the stolen wage and the stolen generation . There are many contemporary issues which are not creating Indigenous recognition. As written about by Peter Seidel the Indigenous Yorta Yorta people lodged a native title claim in 1994 for what is rightfully theirs and, in their claim, they sought recognition of basic truth; that they had always been an intimate part of Yorta Yorta country. For many years they fought for their native title but in 2002 the High Court dismissed their appeal because there was an ‘interruption’ in the Yorta Yorta observance of traditional law and custom in 1881.…

    • 1432 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Aboriginal Dreaming

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages

    However, Aboriginal’s persist to encapsulate the authentic Ancestral Dreaming, as a medium to succeed the indigenous ‘fight’ for land rights and native title. Here, their inextricable connection with the land is being restored through the land rights movement where they are able to foster their lost connection with the fabric of life- their inextricable connection with the land; through which the marks of dispossession are slowly fading. The notion of ‘Terra Nullius’ under the European settlers’ jurisdiction acted as a detriment to the Aboriginals, as it preached their mass genocide- genocide of their being and identity. Judith Wright accentuates that “the all-embracing net of life and spirit which had held land, and people, and all things together was in tatters. The sustaining ceremonies could not be held, men and women could not visit their own birthplaces or carry out their duties to the spirits”.…

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The policies and practices associated with the Aboriginal Protection Act 1915 (Cth) supported and administered by numerous welfare organisations and social institutions, effectively separated tens of thousands of children from their families. In conclusion, despite the attempts by CAR to advance reconciliation in Australia, the Indigenous people continue to suffer long lasting effects resulting from European colonisation. However, the persistent colonialist philosophy continues to influence government attitudes and practices into the twenty-first century, demonstrated by the refusal of the Howard Governments to accept the findings of the National Inquiry into the separation of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children from their families, and the recommendations in the Bringing Them Home report (HEROC 1997). Essentially, the child removal policy has left a trail of suffering and grief which is a journey experienced by generations of Indigenous people and maintained by governments and social institutions who block their path to…

    • 1586 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays