Ismene Arguments In Antigone

Good Essays
In defending the gods’ laws, Antigone states “I must please those below a longer time than people here” (Line 74). Reinforcing her argument, Antigone attempts to reason with Ismene to join her cause and help in the burial of her disgraced brother. Antigone explains that if she follows Creon, she will suffer longer lasting consequences with the gods than she would following him. Antigone seems to contrast the severity of the consequences by showing how Creon’s execution will only hurt now, yet help her in the afterlife. Despite her pleading, Ismene refuses to help stating “I have no strength for it” (77). As a result, Antigone suffers as she has no one left to support her. She is forced to leave Ismene behind to fight what she believes is right. …show more content…
Antigone responds “Don’t worry for me; straighten out your own life” demonstrating how she believes Ismene is making a mistake. As the two continue to converse about how they should handle the burial of their brother, Ismene makes her final argument saying that Antigone is simply starting an impossible quest. Antigone however responds that even if she fails and suffers, she will at least not suffer a shameful death. In the end, Ismene finally agrees to disagree stating she will always love her despite how foolishness she becomes (83-97). Through her arguments, Antigone shows how she believes that Ismene, not her, is making the crucial mistake. Throughout their conversation, Antigone realizes that although she has always had support behind her, she will have to complete the hardest quest of her life alone as her sister is stepping away. Through their royal status she has always had someone there for her, but no more. Despite her loneliness, Antigone sticks to her morals by following the gods instead of Creon as she argues the consequences are far more severe by taking the other …show more content…
For example, Antigone criticizes Creon stating “I would never think your pronouncements had such strength that, being mortal, they could override the unwritten, everlasting prescriptions of the gods” (463). Antigone shows that despite what Creon says, he is nothing but another man in the world of the gods. She argues that since he is nothing but another mortal in this world, his commands have no power over those of the immortal gods. In result, Antigone is able to expose how weak Creon really is, angering him even further. While Creon is suffering from his exposed weakness, Antigone is affected by her becoming more emotionally stable and strong as she stands up to a man in Greek society. Despite her increased strength, Antigone also knows that through her protest, she will also die. Unlike others though, Antigone accepts her fore coming faith stating “Anyone who lives a life of sorrow as I do, how could they not count it a blessing to die” (474). Alluding to Esther in the Bible, Antigone is able to convey that she lives a life of piety and caution, but contains the faith and courage to stand up for what is right. Through the tyrannical leadership of Creon, Antigone is affected brutally as she suffers from loneliness and sadness, but also becomes sturdier in her faith in addition to becoming more emotionally

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Antigone feels that it is their duty as sisters of Polyneices, to bury him, and not leave his soul uncovered. Ismene denies Antigone’s offer because she thinks the circumstances are to grave. “We must obey his orders, these or worse. Therefore I plead compulsion or worse.” Ismene believes they cannot contend with Creon because they are weak women, and she does not want Antigone and her to perish, because they are the only ones left in their royal bloodline. Ismene tries to persuade Antigone to obey King Creon’s edict, because if she fails to comply, she will be stoned.…

    • 738 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Creon denies Polyneices, Antigone’s brother, burial rights and Antigone feels obligated to give him the proper burial because it is extremely important to her and for him. She is willing to go against Creon while her sister is not, due to the lack of her selfless qualities. Because her family is so important to her, she tells her sister that, “no man shall say that I betrayed my brother” (Sophocles 2). Antigone would rather honor her brother than obey Creon because she feels that his burial is imperative to Creon’s rules. She is willing to risk her life to empower the people around her to stand up for what they believe in.…

    • 1080 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    As she argues with Creon about burying Polyneices, he shames her and she retorts, “Not ashamed for a moment, not to honor my brother, my own flesh and blood” (Sophocles 670). Nothing earthly is more important to her than the bond between her family and herself, which is why she goes to such extreme measures to give her brother the burial she believes he deserves no matter what his crimes might have been. Her loyalty to her family—her mother and father, her two brothers, and her sister—is something that was so precious to her, she had no regret sacrificing herself for its…

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    His rejection of her during the beginning of the play symbolizes the beginning of the end for their relationship. Cordelia is a strong enough woman that she knows when it is time to back away and let things go. She accepts his faults, and does not let his faults define her. She goes on the marry a man, who’s “goodness” matches her own. He accepts her despite her lack of a dowry because of her father’s rejection.…

    • 1436 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Antigone Plot Analysis

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages

    She also asks for Ismene’s help, but she refuses. Even though her sister refuses to help her Antigone is determined to give her brother a proper burial. In this initial situation presented, Antigone’s failure is almost suggested. As she and Ismene discuss their brother’s situation, Antigone makes it clear that she is willing to die for her cause as she says that, “that death will be a glory” (Sophocles, Antigone 86). Now that the circumstances have been established, the plot is set in motion and moves onto the rising action.…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Two Sides of Antigone Antigone is a strong willed young woman that makes a difficult decision to disobey the king’s rule. Making the decision to disobey King Creon’s edict comes with a heavy consequence; for both herself and the people that love her the most. Throughout both plays Antigone tries to convince Creon why it is right to give her brother, Polyneices, a proper burial. He has been deemed a traitor by the King and shall receive no burial of his body while his brother Eteocles was honored properly. Antigone does not agree with this and will try any means necessary to make sure her brother is respected.…

    • 1555 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    As Antigone proclaims, “Him who is my brother, and yours-even if you would not wish it…I will not be caught betraying him”(44-46). In response to this, Ismene recounts all of the terrible things that have happened to their family. Their father’s incestuous marriage and involvement in patricide, their mother’s suicide, and their brother’s reciprocated slayings are not enough deterrents to prevent Antigone from going against established law for her sibling. It doesn’t matter to Antigone whether she alone defies a king. In fact, she resolves to her sister, “But you be whatever sort suit your opinion-while I Will bury him”(70-71).…

    • 1891 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Antigone asks her sister, Ismene, if she will join her in burying their brother, but Ismene is not quite as bold as Antigone. In response to Ismene’s concern, Antigone declares, “Creon is not strong enough to stand in my way” (Sophocles, Antigone 191). This is a very strong statement for a woman to be saying out loud, especially since it has to do with a man, at this time. While Creon may find her decision to oppose him as a weakness, now many find Antigone strong and brave for taking action. Also, Creon did not see this scene unfold; he thinks that her actions were impulsive, when in reality this is a deliberate plan to fix what Antigone believes is an unjust decision.…

    • 1147 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When Kreon attempts to cover up the fact that Antigone had attempted to bury her brother by telling her he would pretend it hadn’t happened and would just tell the people she was sick and needed time to rest, in Sophocles’ Antigone, Antigone says, “Dear god, shout it form the rooftops. I'll hate you all the more for silence -- tell the world!” (100-101) telling Kreon that she will not stand to be treated differently than anyone else would have been. If Kreon decided one of her brothers is to be buried and the other to be let sit and rot to prove a point and warn the people what will happen if you defy the law, why should she be held above the law? Sophocles writes, “I would not welcome such a fellowship. Go thine own way; myself will bury him.…

    • 1053 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Antigone had to be stronger because during this time women had no say or power, in the end she ended up dying for what she believed in while defying law. In The Dead Poet Society Neil Perry is very similar to Antigone because they both stood up for what they believed in. Neil was given instruct orders by his father to not do the play, but still choose to so. Neil could not stand up to his father, but is still persistent to do what he wants. How are the two conflicts similar and what makes them different?…

    • 795 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays