When young Chinese-American girl Jing-mei’s mother first arrived to the United States in Amy Tan’s novel The Joy Luck Club, she still retained some of her Chinese beliefs. Jing-mei wrote, “My mother believed you could be anything you wanted to be in America,” (Tan 18), citing her mother as one of the few who still believed in America as a land of opportunity for all. Her mother’s belief in American opportunity forced Jing-mei to undergo various tests her mother made up in attempts of becoming a prodigy–a Chinese Shirley Temple, a child geographical genius, a balance-oriented girl, and then a Bible-commanding lady–but failed until her mother watched a Chinese girl mastering piano on the Ed Sullivan Show like how her mother expected Jing-mei to be. But alas, when she took piano lessons from a deaf teacher who could not distinguish anything from another, she sabotaged her own performance by playing badly, which her teacher praised, and destroyed her own performance at a church talent show. Jing-mei’s deliberate misplaying at practice shot her performance down, where she changed her mind and wanted to perform extremely well, and showed a contrast between the Western attitude of individualism and the Asian expectations of obedience–a clash of ideologies that molded into one volatile mass, where all it takes is one small jolt to set it
When young Chinese-American girl Jing-mei’s mother first arrived to the United States in Amy Tan’s novel The Joy Luck Club, she still retained some of her Chinese beliefs. Jing-mei wrote, “My mother believed you could be anything you wanted to be in America,” (Tan 18), citing her mother as one of the few who still believed in America as a land of opportunity for all. Her mother’s belief in American opportunity forced Jing-mei to undergo various tests her mother made up in attempts of becoming a prodigy–a Chinese Shirley Temple, a child geographical genius, a balance-oriented girl, and then a Bible-commanding lady–but failed until her mother watched a Chinese girl mastering piano on the Ed Sullivan Show like how her mother expected Jing-mei to be. But alas, when she took piano lessons from a deaf teacher who could not distinguish anything from another, she sabotaged her own performance by playing badly, which her teacher praised, and destroyed her own performance at a church talent show. Jing-mei’s deliberate misplaying at practice shot her performance down, where she changed her mind and wanted to perform extremely well, and showed a contrast between the Western attitude of individualism and the Asian expectations of obedience–a clash of ideologies that molded into one volatile mass, where all it takes is one small jolt to set it