Howard Zinn's The Politics Of History

Improved Essays
When reviewing the evolution of my worldview, Howard Zinn’s The Politics of History comes to mind. His book is a collection of case studies and essays that argue for a radical approach to the past. Zinn’s work changed the way I saw my purpose in life. I had originally planned to enter a field in science, despite my passion for history and the Humanities. In an age where the college degree had lost its traditional value, STEM fields seemed to me like the only practical route to success. However, Zinn inspired me to pursue a career driven by passion. He challenged me to question how the study of the past can impact change in the future. He made me realize that, “We need to dig beneath the abstractions so that our fellow citizens can make judgements on the particular realities beneath political rhetoric.” Zinn’s work allowed my worldview to evolve from accepting a passive view of the past to developing my own theory on history. As I first read The Politics of History, I began to realize that there was something fundamentally flawed in the way public schools taught history. It is often portrayed as the simple regurgitation of facts, names, and dates. Or it is indoctrinated into …show more content…
It’s the traditional responsibility of the historian to separate themselves from the public. Their role is to provide the masses with facts and theories. After all, there is the sanctity of neutrality we must uphold. I understood and embraced this position prior to reading Zinn. But my view was changed by his book. “[T]he real choice is not between shaping the world or not, but between doing it willingly or unconsciously” he writes. As a historian, we can either maintain the status quo by relaying forms of lullaby history or we can influence our students by promoting a radical approach to history that shapes the world anew. Or to quote the historian Eric Foner, “In order to create a new future, we must first create a new

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    It is a study focusing on the questions that enshroud the pursuit of history and a Historians job. The heart of this book is the analysis of studying history, the approaches taken upon that task, and how they have changed throughout the centuries. It asks important questions, what is cause and effect? Do the victors really write history and ultimately asks and tries to answer the whopping revelation of what is truth in historical terms? I believe Carr, at least with what I have taken away from this book, wanted to instill an existential…

    • 1225 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To make his point of the human enhancement debate not just suddenly springing up as a radical movement in the 21st century, Hughes relies on historical evidence to show how “the intertwined aspirations to transcend human limitations and enter a radically new social order are found in the earliest recorded human cultures” (The Politics of Transhumanism, 759). This indirectly directs his argument towards conservatives who are lamenting over the current “greed” of humanity to ascend what God has granted to society. In “The Human Condition Hurts: We’d Be Fools Not to Better It”, Hughes shapes a very similar argument quite differently: he uses events, but these are events that readers could relate more with -- not just intellectual movements of the distant past, but rather discoveries and inventions that have directly impacted modern humanity. In this way, Hughes caters to his audience by promoting recent inventions such as penicillin and kidney dialysis in order to concretely…

    • 1413 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Additionally, note what specifically about Kuhn’s perspective helps you understand how we come to know? If I imagine a conversation between Kuhn and Descartes, upon closely looking at their publications, I believe Kuhn would disagree on several of his discourses with Descartes. Using his idea of paradigm, Kuhn helped bring the philosophy of science closer to the history of science. On the other hand, Descartes’ way of knowing is based on experience and influenced by deductive reasoning to lead to the development of ideas. In this connection, Kuhn believed that Descartes caused a paradigm shift in a broad, and historical sense.…

    • 700 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The history of education is used to consider a passive recording for the history, but it can be interesting subject to learn because of his high discuss value to encourage critical thinking and broaden the horizon of knowledge. Also, the study of the history of education can possibly lead to significant reformation on the education system even if sometimes it can reproduce some unexpected consequences to people create the study. The learning of the history of education can encourage critical thinking and expand the scope of knowledge of learners. First, there is no clear answer to many historical issues, so history learners can start an open-ended discussion for improving their ability of critical thinking. According to “Recovering Our Histories:…

    • 1230 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Interdependence Theory

    • 1968 Words
    • 8 Pages

    It was written, to guide readers through learning theoretical tools that will guide individuals to understand the world more accurately. The theoretical tool they used to base their argument was the Liberalist theory, however, the focused one of the theories major points, which is interdependence. Even though, the authors tried to explain interdependence as a theory on its own, one cannot deny this theory has deep seeded origins from the Liberalist theory. They clearly state that neither the traditionalist vision nor the modernist vision is nowadays adequate to interpret our world, due to the fact that there is an “ever- growing and multidimensional interdependence”. Another interesting feature of this book is that the authors compare two ideal types: realism and one that they constructed, complex interdependence.…

    • 1968 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    William Stubbs had transformed the study of history to a continuous and research driven university discipline. It is important to note that the study of history was not created by Stubbs as it was present for centuries. However through Stubbs’s work the subject of history began to have an impact for academic studies and future historians. The legacy of Stubbs can be seen through the introduction of the Constitution History of England. Stubbs’s articulates a warning to his audience before reading the history of the Constitution of England as it lists what history was and what it is now to become.…

    • 1826 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Footnote Analysis

    • 1926 Words
    • 8 Pages

    As a result of this combination, histories that were both supported by cited facts and that had an overarching narrative began to become more common. It was this tradition that Ranke drew from as he was creating his own works. Ranke’s own approach to history is characterized through his condemnation of Francesco Guicciardini who he believed lacked both a cohesive narrative and first-hand facts regarding the events he described. The fact that Ranke finds fault in Guicciardini’s information and narrative show that he felt that both were intrinsic to the study of…

    • 1926 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Misperceptions Of History

    • 1171 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Both conflicting and controversial, yet also one-sided and universal, history is a game of perspectives, opinions, and thoughts with facts used to support any of the former. However, this should not leave unstudied and abandoned, left to old books and tomes of knowledge. History is a living subject, that should be taught and passed down to future generations like traditions taught by our forefathers. In this, I would like to pursue a future in governmental history as noted before. In this role, I hope to influence the future by teaching or telling the stories of the…

    • 1171 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What has become common sense or second nature to scientists now is the action to develop a new theory from a failed attempt with an older theory. When working with science one is to expect such failure to occur quite often. These crises offer the opportunity to the scientists to rethink and reorganize. Following its emergence, Kuhn gives us a response to crises. He wants us to assume that a crises is a precondition, as he puts it, for the emergence of novel theories and ask how scientists react to these theories.…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    My Teacher Told Me

    • 2271 Words
    • 10 Pages

    One of those questions inquires as for why educators perpetuate myth rather than offer the student a more accurate account of American history. Newcomers teachers usually have the illusion of changing the educational system; however, the system has been proved to be…

    • 2271 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays