Gary Dotson Case Study

Improved Essays
Despite all of the good that using science in criminal investigation has done. Like all things there have been some hiccups. DNA testing has both enhanced and eroded the status of forensic science in criminal cases. Conventional forensic disciplines were unable to identify a perpetrator with any true discrimination. For instance, conventional serology (the study antigen or antibodies) field analysis of blood group substances was largely used in sexual assault cases during the 1980s (Mosby's Medical Dictionary 8th edition, 2009). The basic method was sound and frequencies of the A, B, and O blood types were derived from scientifically sound databases. While serology could exclude or place an individual within a percentage of the population …show more content…
Dotson was convicted in 1979 of rape, and he was sentenced to 25-50 years in prison. (Garrett & Neufel, 2009)In 1988, DNA testing was ran after the Governor of Illinois had denied Dotson a pardon, despite the victim's recantation in which she stated that she had falsely accused Dotson of rape to conceal consensual intercourse with her boyfriend. Edward Blake, who led the forensic application of the polymerase chain reaction ("PCR") technology, conducted the testing. He study found that the DNA results excluded Dotson as the source for the genetic profile, but was able to include the victim's boyfriend as matching the genetic profile found. Based on those findings, Dotson's conviction was overturned. Blake also found that the State's forensic analyst's testimony at Dotson's trial was misleading. The analyst had testified that both Dotson and the semen donor possessed the B blood type, a type shared by only eleven percent of Caucasians (Garrett & Neufel, 2009). The problem was the testimony in the courtroom. While on the witness stand, the analyst did not tell the jury that the victim was also Type B and that her fluids were mixed in the sample. The Type B substances found in the sample could have solely come from the victim. Her genetic markers might have overwhelmed those from the semen; as Blake put it, "no genetic information was obtained about the semen donor." Consequently, due to the testing methods available at the time, any man could have been the donor. It was misleading to suggest to the jury that a subset (11%) of the population including Dotson could have been the donor thereby excluding the remaining 89% (Garrett & Neufel, 2009). So even though the advances in forensics did grant Dotson's exoneration, the invalid forensic science testimony is what granted his

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Farmer also argues that the evidence was insufficient to support the conviction. P.F did identify Williams as her rapist in 1988, but Williams DNA was eliminated after the Analysis came back with Farmer being a match. The court believed that with the trauma of having two offenders commit sexually assault, it not uncommon for a victim to mistakenly identify a person. Farmer’s confession along with the DNA analysis was enough to prove beyond a reasonable doubt Farmer was the rapist and that he participated in the Burglary and murder of…

    • 838 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The only evidence in Jones’s conviction was a strand of hair. A forensic expert testified that the hair came from Jones. In early 2000, Jones’s attorneys filed petitions that requested the hair be submitted for DNA testing that was now…

    • 172 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Eric Lander Case Summary

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “Neysmith was finally exonerated after blood and semen samples were sent to Cellmark diagnostics which confirmed the original exclusion.” (Lander, 1989, p. 505) Assistant district attorney Karen Yaremko questioned Lifecodes about their differences in DNA results from Cellmark, Lifecodes commented a mistake had occurred and refused further comment. This case is an example of human error or laboratory mistake which almost cost Neysmith his…

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hey, Pedro, have you ever heard of a famously female named Amanda Knox who was convicted of, and then acquitted of, the same murder twice in 2007? Well, Ms. Knox spent four years in prison before being freed in 2011, for the murder of 21-year-old Meredith Kercher, Ms. Knox’s roommate. (Brayson, 2016) However, Ms. Knox’s case was re-tried in 2013 for the same murder because of biological evidence for DNA analysis. Ms. Knox and her then-boyfriend Raffaele Sollecito were tied to Kercher's murder were a kitchen knife, and a bra clasp was tested for DNA evidence.…

    • 613 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Later, during his jury trial, Thurman was identified by the victim and another witness as the attacker. Additionally, a Virginia state crime lab analyst, Mary Jane Burton, used the DNA found in the victim’s underwear to determine that the attacker’s blood type was Type B – the same blood type as Thurman and also 20% of all African-American men. Without the technology we have today, this was enough to convict Phillip Leon Thurman of rape, abduction, and assault and he was sentenced to thirty-one years in prison.…

    • 404 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The court convicted Perrot as the one who did it although they had no evidence against him. They only had a strand of hair and automatically said it belonged to him. They had no evidence such as blood, semen and could not trace DNA. Perrot spent 30 years in jail before they realized it wasn't him. Name of the case- Tiny fibers helped FBI nab serial killer Victims-…

    • 384 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Without the innovation of DNA there would not have been an association in the DNA test that was taken to discover Lonnie David Franklin Jr liable of his…

    • 412 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Donte Booker's Rape Case

    • 695 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Test results excluded Booker as the contributor of DNA on the victim's clothing and the rape kit, and his convictions were overturned on February 9,…

    • 695 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We now can interpret biological evidence that has been left at the crime, by comparing the suspect’s DNA to that left at the scene (Lawyers). Therefore, the court no longer has false accusations when it comes to accusing someone of…

    • 952 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Forensic Science Duality

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The duality of Forensics Forensic science is the application of natural science to matters involving the law. Forensic science consists of many branches, and though they all differ, they relate in the aspect of their attempts to find out the truth in a criminal investigation, But just how effective and reliable is forensic science? And if effective, is it for better or worse? Of course, opinions on this vary greatly. Here’s mine.…

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    DNA Sampling Controversy

    • 1456 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Technology has made a major impact on the world we live in today keeping it both current and informative. It serves a great purpose providing various benefits. However, the use of technology can also raise some controversy. The advancement of DNA technology is imperative and it has significantly changed the legal system in the way cases are questioned, investigated and solved. On the other hand, DNA sampling raises issues involving privacy and the violation of human rights due to its personal, unique makeup and the fact that it is stored in a database.…

    • 1456 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The past decade has seen great advances in a powerful investigation tool: DNA. Being DNA is found in every human being, every person's DNA pattern is one of a kind and except for identical twins, no two people can share the same DNA pattern. During a criminal investigation when biological evidence exists, DNA evidence can be used to identify criminals with incredible accuracy. Likewise, DNA can also be used to dismiss suspects or exonerate individuals mistakenly convicted of a crime. Ultimately, DNA evidence is increasingly vital to ensuring accuracy and fairness in the criminal justice system.…

    • 612 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. What is your thesis statement? Innocent individuals have been wrongfully convicted for crimes that they did not commit. This has happened in the past, before DNA technology was available, however, it continues to happen today. Some people have spent several months behind bars, while others have spent decades behind bars, all while being innocent.…

    • 1773 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Frye Case Study

    • 612 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The use of the Frye standard made the results of the DNA sample which the prosecution needed to use in this case to determine the guilt of the defendant inadmissible which could result in the defendant getting out of these charges. The conclusions to this case included that the DNA forensic identification methods were generally acceptable,…

    • 612 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Chimera Essay

    • 1662 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Karen and Lydia both presented as much evidence as possible, proving their maternity, including birth certificates and testimony from an obstetrician, but the courts persistently relied on the DNA evidence and found their stories unbelievable” (Granzen, 2014). With DNA testing being infallible in court cases the legal system is potentially being shaken with the possibilities of chimeras rattling the judicial system. Although these two cases where only affecting government assistance and pre-operation testing, the possibilities that chimeras can have in any case relying on DNA can be thrown out of court. With the word getting out on the possibilities of chimeras and the difficulty confirming it has opened the eyes of many criminals. For instance, a man named Hamilton on a cyclist team was accused of blood doping.…

    • 1662 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays