Ford/Taylor's Economic Analysis

Improved Essays
During the debate on Thursday I found several key issues with the Ford/Taylor

arguments. First, the relegation of workers to menial jobs for relatively low pay and allowing no opportunities to broaden their knowledge of their job nor other opportunities to leave said job is continuing to create the “dumbing-down” of the worker. And second, how do we address the false sense of security corporations provide their employees?
` There is no doubt in the current capitalist economy that people tend to be split into two categories: managerial and laborer. In Taylor’s economics, the laborer is truly satisfied with his lowly work, as he doesn’t know any better. In fact, Taylor insists that the manger must actually talk to the employees in a condescending,
…show more content…
Eventually, as we have seen in the past, workers come to find a sense that they, and their work, are worth more than their pay. It also surmises that money is inherently intertwined with how happy one will be. In this way, a populist could argue, the scientific management cannot work because it is inherently divisive and offers no real substance, because once the person has provided for themselves and their family, and has managed to accumulate a decent amount of luxuries, happiness does not increase. Happiness comes from money because it allows a sense of security, but happiness in Taylor’s capitalism comes from acquisition of wealth beyond what provides comfort, but with what provides …show more content…
The populists wanted to attack this because they saw the flaws in their rhetoric, and knew ultimately the workers were not most important, but profit and gains were paramount. It’s exploitative and manipulative on account of the corporations. They’ve also managed to perpetuate the negatives of an economic system in which it is nearly impossible to leave, because reverting to a way of life that is based on being totally self-sustaining is unrealistic. And while at this point there is obviously no return, constricting the size and control these corporations have, not just over the government or the market, but also over their employees, is critical in maintaining capitalism that is in the best interests of the

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Typically, in modern capitalist corporation’s democracy is ignored. The ban of democracy in the workplace causes workers to resent their task which leads to less productivity and profits. This may be the result from employees feeling disrespected from corporations’ commanding heights, and feeling undervalued and unrecognized for their achievements. To cope with this, corporations hire many costly workplace supervisors. Thus, with the accumulation of profit the corporate expenses are some of the many factors leading to wasteful costs of capitalism.…

    • 1701 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The lack of employees has produced an initial increase in monetary savings but the prolonged effects of not having adequate employees will yield a large decrease in the revenues over an extended period Fd gqert q4tq gqert notice a lack of employees manning the store. If you have a question about a product good luck trying to hunt someone down to assist you with your inqucdtrt;qwerkqwe’r233343240234l’iry. Often times you will feel as if you are the only one in the store. This is due to the fact that TheStore has trimmed the company employees down below an acceptable level for conducting normal business operations. The lack of employees has produced an initial increase in monetary savings but the prolonged effects of not having adequate employees will yield a large decrease in the revenues over an extended period Fd gqert q4tq gqert notice a lack of employees manning the store.…

    • 52230 Words
    • 209 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The lack of regulations let the owners of the companies force the workers to work beyond what was fair for little pay, and this caused them to not live fulfilling lives as they lived paycheck to paycheck. The stress this created linked them together in a common struggle, and this is what Marx was trying to monopolize on. If he could get the lower classes to realize they all had one common enemy they could join forces to rise against the rich and powerful. Many of the things Marx argued for in his time are now simple realities today that people would be aghast if the government did not provide them, such as public high school and progressive income tax. While many of his ideas were a bit farfetched or unachievable in the current society today with how far into capitalism America sinks its…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Benefits Of Outsourcing

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The outsourcing of the jobs put the boss out of business because while it saved money in the short term it forced his own people into destitution. While this was an extrmem example, I think it goes to show that there is a downside to outsourcing. It causes economic harm to the home country, and with a large enough firm or group of firms it could cause an economic…

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This term is applied to the exploited social class who has no idea that they are being exploited. They fail to see the unfairness of the capitalistic system, and their unequal treatment. They believe they have the same interests as the owners and are a part of a fair transaction of labor and wages. Because of this held false consciousness, they do not see their true strength and power in society and will not rise to overthrow the system that is perpetuated. This unrealized strength continues the pattern of growth among capitalists and the widening of the wealth gap between…

    • 946 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cohen concludes that the socialist economy was clearly better on the camping trip, because it became toxic once they started to act like capitalists (Cohen). To his point, in a Capitalist economy people are forced to provide for themselves and their families, because there is no guarantee of resources, and while that might encourage people to work harder, it also encourages corrupt business practices. Everything is based around profit, not quality, equality, honesty, or generosity. Products are being made not for the good of society but for the profit they will produce. Leading to companies aiming for quantity and marketability rather than quality, resulting in the consumers suffer.…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    By engaging in misleading CSR practices, companies can obviate the need for government regulation. Several corporations tend to engage in unethical behavior such as child labor, polluting the environment, or exploiting third world countries. Because of the increasing amount of socially aware consumers, companies can no longer partake in such nefarious activity. A variety of corporations would rather continue the dirty work they are doing because it is cheaper and more beneficial for their self-interest. In order to keep doing whatever they already do, companies use corporate social responsibility as a marketing strategy to fool the government.…

    • 1503 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Productive forces often add pressure and customers become tired of inadequate wages, this is caused because capitalists have arranged poorly to cover costs of production to stay combative in the markets. To further support and prove that productive forces are detrimental if not handled well and not evenly balanced with the mode of production, Engels states “in each crisis society is smothered under the weight of its own productive forces and products of which it can make no use”(Engels, p 308) this leads to society standing “helpless in the face of the absurd contradiction that the producer have nothing to consume because there are no consumers” which sadly leads to the “seize of the means of production by society”(Engels, p.309). Undoubtedly this “puts an end to commodity production” (Engels, p.309). Engels now believes this is where hope begins this is now time for new assembled system which should be beneficial to everyone; spiritually, physically and…

    • 748 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, there are some shortcomings of "scientific communism," just like there are shortcomings of economic communism. In economic communism, de-incentivizing competition can lead to several negative effects. First, the quality of the products produced will decrease, since manufacturers no longer need to compete for customer attention. Second, extra/overtime productivity can be lost - in a communist system, once you hit your quota you're done, extra productivity beyond your quota does not necessarily lead to extra income like in capitalism. Third, truly remarkable performances don't get the recognition they deserve, since everyone's paychecks are the same, an outstanding businessman or inventor won't get the tremendous cash influx that they deserve under a capitalist system.…

    • 1485 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In other countries, workers have the advantage to easily get a job but the disadvantage is that they do not get paid enough and receive benefits. The offshoring of professional jobs by US companies is done to save money, but it has raised concerns. As the US struggles to recover from recession, the rate of job…

    • 1313 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics