Examples Of Tragic Tragedy Of Brutus

Improved Essays
The archetype of a tragic hero has appeared in scores of great works; they are principled figures marred by major flaws that inexorably cause their downfall, in such a way that arouses pathos in the audience. In William Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar, Brutus is a classic tragic hero - presented as a virtuous man, his weaknesses lead him into the calamitous act of betraying a friend. It is the fatal flaws in Brutus’ own character that cause his fall from power and eventual death: his honour, which he will do anything to protect; his idealism, which contributes to a fatal naivety on his part; and his trusting nature, easily exploited by many.
As a Roman senator whose ancestor once quelled tyranny in Rome, Brutus had honour. He was highly regarded
…show more content…
Before the assassination of Caesar, Brutus strives to justify what he and the other conspirators are about to do. While the other conspirators have selfish intentions such as desire for power or jealousy, noble Brutus is driven entirely by the well-being of his nation. He reminds the others that noble Romans do not betray “... the smallest particle / Of any promise that hath passed from him” (2.1 145-146); thus casting their plot to commit a brutal murder as a righteous undertaking and the conspirators as courageous and irreproachable men. Brutus strikes Caesar down in the name of emancipation, fearing that Caesar 's absolute power will make him view himself too highly, enslaving Rome to the will of a single man: “... not that I loved Caesar / less, but that I loved Rome more.” (3.2 22-23). After Caesar has been stabbed to death on the floor of the Senate, Brutus continues to glorify the murder as a blow for freedom and his credulousness misleads him into believing that he can convince everybody to see it in the same way. Idealistic and naive, he is unable to recognize Antony’s deceit and unaware of the power of raw emotion over intellect. The events following spiral completely out of his control as Rome is plunged into a civil war, causing he and Cassius’ to take their own lives. The idealistic vision Brutus has for Rome is completely shattered, and ultimately, assassinating …show more content…
Deceived and misguided by Cassius, who cleverly exploits Brutus’s overly trusting character, Brutus joins the conspiracy to assassinate Caesar. Cassius mainly uses flattery, convincing Brutus that he is genuine and has good intentions: “Your hidden worthiness into your eye, / That you might see your shadow...” (1.2 57-58). As someone who has been friends with Brutus for a while, Cassius knows him well and simply brings to the surface the tensions that already exist within him. Trusting Cassius is the catalyst to the events that eventually lead to Brutus’ downfall. Another character who takes advantage of Brutus’ trust is Antony - before the funeral oration, Brutus trusts that Antony will only speak good of the conspirators and their intentions. Even though Cassius warns him, “You know not what you do: / do not consent / That Antony speak in his funeral” (3.1 33-35), Brutus is confident that Antony will be able to gather the support of the Roman people. However, moments later, with Caesar’s will in his hand and tears on his cheeks, Antony is able to engage in a masterful rhetoric to stir the crowd to rebel against the conspirators. He persuades the audience to rescind their support, instead condemning Brutus and the others as traitors - turning against Brutus and breaching his trust. While trust is often a

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Brutus: A Tragic Hero

    • 1287 Words
    • 6 Pages

    One tragic recognition Brutus has is that he acts rashly about killing Caesar. Brutus thinks the conspirators act rashly when they kill Caesar because they do not know how Caesar would act if he would become king because he never because king. They just act out of pure impulsive and do not think through their actions and this is the part that troubles Brutus no taking a step back and instead just going for it. A second tragic recognition Brutus has is he realizes that his great friendship with Cassius is gone. Brutus realizes this because when Cassius comes into his tent they start to fight about stuff because Cassius is taking bribes. With the fighting and disagreements it cause Brutus to realizes that his friendship with Cassius is dissolving. When the ghost of Caesar comes to Brutus and tells him that he will see him at Philippi Brutus realizes that this is an omen. This omen is representing that Brutus is going to die at Philippi and this will avenge…

    • 1287 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For example, he was not easily convinced to join the conspiracy. As a senator, his goal was to make Rome the best it could be. For him to take such trouble in deciding whether to kill Caesar or not, it shows that Brutus only wanted the best for his country and his people. Brutus says, “It must be by his death: and for my part/ I know no personal cause to spurn at him/ But for the general good.” (II.i.10-12). His goal was not to receive any personal gain from Caesar’s death; he would rather be at fault for murder than have his people live under tyranny. Brutus was also the last of the conspirators to stab Caesar. Even though he felt guilt for killing his friend, he would not let the means of reaching of his goals override his desire to help…

    • 1130 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    His love for Rome is greater than his love for Caesar so after hearing this, Brutus agrees to help Cassius kill Caesar because he believes Caesar is ambitious although “[he knows] no personal cause to spurn at him But for the general.” (II.i.10-11) His easily manipulative mind is twisted by Cassius’ lies which displays the hamartia Brutus possesses proving that he is the tragic hero. Brutus is persuaded enough to side with the conspirators and aid them in their plot to kill Caesar. He thinks that what he is doing is right; because it is for the people of Rome but in reality his motives were influenced by Cassius whose motive is out of…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Brutus As A Villain Essay

    • 779 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Alike John Wilkes Booth, who killed Abraham Lincoln, Brutus was also under the assumption that he was doing good on behalf of the people. Brutus, while under the influence of others opinions, thought that Caesar would not be a good leader and his rule would not benefit Rome or it’s people. One way he was under the influence of others is the quote where Cassius states, “I will this night, In several hands in at his windows throw, As if they came from several citizens, Writings, all tending to the great opinion That Rome holds of his name”(Shakespeare 1. 2.). Cassius plants fake letters from the “citizens” because he knows he can not change Brutus’s mind about joining the conspiracy but he knows the citizens can. In John Wilkes Booth diary entry it states, “I struck for my country and that alone. A country that groaned beneath this tyranny.”(Booth). The quote explains how his own view and opinion of his leader corrupt him and lead him to make a foolish decision. This is a perfect example of why Brutus made one wrong choice and his character turned from a hero to a villain, even though he believed he was not a villain and that he was doing the right…

    • 779 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Citizens of Rome, do not lend me your ears, but instead lend me your heart. I stand before you on this tragic day to acknowledge the death of Marcus Brutus. Brutus, who was once the most respected, noble, and honorable man in all of Rome, now lies before us dead, more worthless than dust. Brutus was a stoic judge and the best friend of Julius Caesar, further demonstrating his high status and his nobility. His grievous death was caused by his dire desire for honor and his extraordinary view of idealism. Cassius, one of Brutus’ dearest friends, was aware of Brutus’ tragic flaw, his weakness for honor and his idealistic view of people. With his venomous and manipulative tongue, Cassius convinced Brutus to join the conspiracy and kill Julius Caesar. Unlike the envious Cassius, Brutus believed Caesar’s death was necessary for the prosperity of Rome. Brutus was blindsided by his desire…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    First, Brutus possesses the fatal flaw of being easily manipulated/tricked. This ultimately is Brutus’s downfall as he is easily controlled by his peers. In the beginning of play, Brutus is seen upset and “at war” with himself. Cassius attempts to boost his mood, by telling him how well-respected he is. At this time, Cassius is also trying to persuade Brutus to join the conspirators in killing Caesar. Aware that Brutus would never kill Caesar, Cassius convinces him that he would be a better ruler for Rome than Caesar. Cassius says “ ‘Tis just/And it is very much lamented, Brutus/ That you have no such mirrors as will…

    • 1105 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Brutus’ speech creates an understanding from the plebeians of the moral obligation of Caesar’s death. After hearing Antony’s speech the romans experiences a lot of anger and decide to burn down the houses of all the conspirators and kill them. “We will be revenged” (III.3.198). The anger inside of the plebeians proves to create irrational thoughts which results in them killing an innocent man who just happens to have the same name as one of the conspirators. In addition to that they also go to destroy the conspirators’ houses. Antony’s speech ultimately leads to a battle between him and the conspirators. Brutus has good intentions, but nevertheless he makes a lot of bad decisions which eventually leads to his…

    • 877 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    During the beginning of the play, the only reason Brutus joins the conspiracy is because Cassius sends him letters begging for Caesar to be removed from power, which Brutus believes are from the citizens of Rome. Before receiving the letters, Brutus teeters between whether or not he wants to get involved, but after reading them he feels that he is “entreated / to speak and strike” (II.i.56-7). Probably any other person would be suspicious whether or not Roman citizens actually wrote the letters or if they were forged, but Brutus’ naivety and dedication to Rome allow him to make a final decision once and for all: that he will join the conspirators to assassinate Caesar. Another event that exemplifies Brutus 's naiviety is the trust that he places in Antony. Not only does Brutus tell Cassius that they will “be sacrificers, not butchers,” refusing to assassinate Antony, he also allows Antony to speak at Caesar’s funeral after Brutus speaks (II.i.166). Although Brutus gives Antony rules about what he can and cannot say, Brutus trusts Antony to adhere to those rules, which Antony does not. In this speech Antony persuades the Romans to mutiny and turn against the conspirators, which Brutus finds himself unable to stop because he blindly trusted Antony and left. At…

    • 1700 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As seen throughout the play, Brutus ends up agreeing to the plot of killing Caesar deciding that it was for the benefit of Rome entirely. This step is further influenced by Cassius slyly changing Brutus’s mind about Caesar, because Cassius sees Caesar as no more than a man (Taylor). However, this plot makes him dishonorable to the Roman society. Attempting to keep Rome safe, Brutus and the other…

    • 1125 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “For let the gods so speed me as I love the name of honor more than I fear death” (Iii 94-95). He ends up killing his best friend over his love for Rome and to keep his honor, but he ends up losing Rome and brings it further into a civil war. Cassius’ quote in Act I Scene II is so important, “Thy honorable mettle may be wrought from that is disposed” Brutus believes Cassius’ plot and kills Caesar. Then, because he didn’t want sole power of Rome, he leaves, giving Antony the opportunity to take over. While explaining to Rome how Caesar is not ambitious, this leaves the Roman people to have a grudge against Brutus. Brutus loses all of his power and most of all he lost his wife Portia. “Have made themselves so strong- for with her death that tidings came- with this she fell distract, and swallow’d fire.” When Brutus heard the death of his wife he sounded very sad, and this caused him to want to die on the battlefield rather than be put in chains and taken back to Rome. Since Brutus did die on that battlefield it shows how he lost it all, everything he loves and cares about, even his own…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Without Caesar’s sudden popularity, he would not be in power. Because he manipulates and captures the attention of all Romans, they are attracted to him. Cassius explains this to Brutus as he tries to convince Brutus to join the conspiracy, telling him, “I was born free as Caesar. So were you. / We both have fed as well, and we can both / Endure the winter’s cold as well as he” (I.ii.99-101). What Cassius implies by saying this is that Caesar does not have any special attributes and should not be protected. He is not someone sent from the gods to better Rome, and should not be treated so. The Romans, however, do not believe this, and think Caesar could do no harm, because of what they hear of him. They do not hear of the bad he does, and are left in the dark. To bring them out of this, it is important that Brutus joins the conspiracy to guide Rome away from the type of rule Caesar used and serve as a better leader. At the time after Caesar’s death, the Romans are confused, and can be easily manipulated. They will believe whatever they may hear. When Brutus speaks at Caesar’s funeral, he immediately turns the crowd from rambunctious and hassled to content with Caesar’s death. Minutes later, Antony convinces the same crowd to avenge Caesar’s death. This displays the Romans’ vulnerability at the time, and how simple it was to change their viewpoint. Because of this, they need to have a truthful leader who will not take advantage of them, as Caesar would have. Brutus exhibits this by saying “If it be aught toward the general good, / Set honor in one eye and death i ' th ' other, / And I will look on both indifferently” (I.ii.87-89). Here, Brutus expresses that he is willing to die to protect the general good, showing he is deeply concerned with the safety of Rome, whereas other leaders may be concerned with themselves and how much power they hold. He…

    • 1403 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Even after pleasing other people with his actions, after Caesar’s death he believed in the fact that Brutus was genuinely looking out for the good of his people and was loyal towards…

    • 706 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Brutus’s loyalty to Rome makes him vulnerable to the manipulation of Cassius, who uses Brutus’s fatal flaw against him for his own agenda. Cassius knows that Brutus will do anything for Rome, no matter…

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Brutus and Mark Antony 's motivation for their speech was almost the opposite of one another to a certain extent. Brutus felt a great amount of sorrow and remorse, and tried to appeal to the ethos and Logos of the public to gain there trust and respect. He also reminisced upon his and Caesars friendship, and very clearly stated he only followed through for the good of Rome. Brutus only desired to stop the tyranny that Julius Caesar was provoking, and protect the health and success of his country. Brutus uses logical and rational ideas and therefore appeals to Logos when he speaks that he killed Caesar because he “loved Rome more.” Brutus tries to justify his and other conspirators actions, to relieve any intense emotions or potent tension. Brutus also connects with the citizens of Rome as referring to them in his greeting: “Romans, countrymen, lovers.” This engaged some of the audience specifically, as well as making them feel as though Brutus sought of them as friends and equal to him. As well as this, it made the audience feel like he values and respects them for all the work they have done for the success of…

    • 1074 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Caesar professes his trust in Brutus, and exits the stage, leaving Cassius alone with Brutus. This is where we see the true Brutus. Cassius starts to pull Brutus to the other side, telling him that Caesar is no good for Rome, and that he needs to be... Cut from the picture. Brutus, whi was once one of Caesars most loyal followers, starts to see the light. By the next act, Brutus has his own soliloquy to discuss with himself why he wants to kill Caesar. It seems that he doesn 't think that Caesar has done anything wrong... And it even seems that he doesn 't think that Caesar may even do anything wrong in the future. Really, it seems that he 's going to kill Caesar on the off-chance that he might go power hungry in the future. Just a little strange. His wife thinks that he is acting strange also, and confronts him about it. So he lies to her as well. Anything for the good of the people, I guess. The next day, he and the other conspirators gather at the senate to prepare for the murder. Soon however, Lucius comes with the news that Caesar is not coming. So they decide to send Decius Brutus with the message that a sacrifice was slaughtered, and after it was mangled and had its guts removed, that could not find the heart. Caesar took this to be a sign that the gods were telling him that if he didn 't go to the senate, he would be a heartless beast. Of course. When Caesar arrives, Brutus…

    • 1483 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays