The Pros And Cons Of Dual Language Programs

Improved Essays
Conversations about dual-language programs often lead to a number of questions about how these programs can meet their goals of bilingual proficiency, academic achievement through two languages, and cultural pluralism for their language majority and minority students (Hadi-Tabassum, 2006). Given that Spanish is the minority language used most frequently in bilingual programs in the United States, this section will use Spanish to exemplify the minority language. A similar process would hold for other minority languages relative to English in the United States. Because Spanish-speaking and English-Speaking students’ needs are very different, this discussion addresses questions about goals for these populations separately.
Dual-language programs
…show more content…
The first dual-language program in the country was established in 1963 at the Coral Way School in Miami, Florida, as part of an organized state and federal effort to serve the large numbers of Cuban refugees that were resettling in South Florida (Kim et al., 2015). The Coral Way dual-language program has been described as an effective means of integrating Spanish-speaking Cuban students into the academic mainstream and of providing equitable educational opportunities to native English- speaking and native Spanish-speaking students that the schools serves (Kim et al., 2015). The Lillian Weber School (i.e., PS-84) in New York City is another example of an established dual-language program that encourages additive bilingualism for its language minority and language majority students as a means of promoting academic achievement for all of its students (Kim et al., 2015). Bilingual education advocates have argued that well-implemented dual-language programs like the ones at Coral Way and PS-84 can offer an equitable and effective means of educating language majority and language minority students. As a result, this type of bilingual program has been attracting mounting attention and funding in the United States since the late 1990s (Kim et al., 2015). In 1992 there were only 20 documented …show more content…
In some programs, students from the two language backgrounds are integrated for all of their instructional time. In other programs, students are integrated for the majority of their content-area instruction but segregated to receive additional language instruction in their second-language (Adelman-Reyes & Kleyn, 2010). Other programs segregate students from the two language backgrounds for the majority of their instructional time (which may be through one or two languages), and then integrate students for a small portion of each day and/or week for dual-language instruction. This third option is not likely to yield the full benefits of the dual-language approach because students from the two backgrounds spend limited time together (Adelman-Reyes & Kleyn,

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Richard Rodriguez in his is personal narrative “Aria” gives the reader his perspective of learning English while being a native Spanish speaker. As a child he attended a monolingual school. He was told that by not speaking Spanish at home he would be able to quickly develop his English. Rodriguez attributes much of his success in life to this event of learning English, which is why he is against bilingual education. “The Pros of Bilingual Education” by Stephen Krashen challenges Rodriguez’s stance by stating the positive impact that bilingual education has on students, and how bilingual education gives students an educational advantage compared to those without it.…

    • 1240 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many Americans ascribe to the belief that America represents a “melting pot” of cultures. With so many differing cultures in this country, America would be expected to have a high bilingual population and large support for bilinguals’ rights. However, America is only about 20% bilingual (source). This low bilingual percentage accounts for Americans’ general lack of empathy for bilingual people and their rights. Two bilingual authors, Martin Espada and Richard Rodriguez, portray contrasting perspectives about the issue of bilingualism in America by addressing the meaning of bilingualism, bilingual education, and discrimination against bilinguals.…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rodriguez has an alternative approach to the controversial topic of bilingualism. His opinion reflects a more practical, logical approach to bilingualism. When explaining his past experiences of English teachers in American classrooms, Rodriguez states “What they understood was that I needed to speak a public language” (20). He expresses gratitude towards his previous instructors because he believes that “Fortunately, my teachers were unsentimental about their responsibility” (20). Their responsibility being to teach Rodriguez the public language of…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He also mentioned the backlash by proponents of “English Only” in education who viewed bilingualism as a threat to American identity, but dressed it up as a concern for the Latino community educational disparities (pg. 140). This topic reminded me of the program “Spanish for Fluent Speakers” that I was part of for three years. The program was often undermined, as some saw it as means for Spanish speakers to evade the language requirement and take an easy class. I often received questions such as: “Why are you taking a Spanish class if you already speak it?” Despite those negative perceptions, this was a program that allowed me to reconnect with my Hispanic roots and recognize the social capital of bilingualism.…

    • 749 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Richard Rodriguez Aria

    • 1343 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In the reading Aria: Memoir of a Bilingual Education, by Richard Rodriguez, he challenges the idea of bilingual education, and takes us through his personal experience of a bilingual childhood. Rodriguez explains about what he encountered in America as he attempts to adjust to the American culture, and why he believes that learning the public language in school is more important than learning the private language. Throughout the essay he forfeits his happy and comfortable life in exchange for the opportunity to become an English-speaking student supported with the help of his parents and his teachers’ encouragements. And what he thinks of the private and public individual. Rodriguez doesn’t believe in the bilingual education system, he believes…

    • 1343 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Rodriguez grew up in a Spanish speaking family thriving and eager to expand his education and vocabulary in the “loud, booming with confidence” English language. According to Rodriguez, bilingual educationists have strong disbelief in the idea that schools should be assimilated with bilingual education because the students lack “a degree of ‘individuality’” This sense of individuality is absent in public society because often your heritage sets you apart from most others around you.…

    • 73 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    is so far behind in advancements academically and socially. Every other country encourages and supports bilingual education. In each claim and argument Rodriguez presents there are harmful consequences that the reader takes away from them. He believes that one’s native language and the public language are unable to coincide, not based on research or statistics, merely based on his own personal experience with not being able to handle the two. The takeaway from this belief is that there should only be one language in America, the public language.…

    • 1405 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Richard Rodriguez believes that the Americanization of a bilingual child will result in their public gain. “Aria” by Richard Rodriguez is a heart-wrenching piece of writing about the full Americanization of Rodriguez resulting in his native language of Spanish being forgotten and the full submersion into the English language. Many of the events Rodriguez faced in his life are present to many other bilingual students’ today. These events that bilingual students’ are facing will strongly influence their decision on struggling to learn two languages at a young age, stalling the development of one of their languages, or being forced to choose one language or the other in a full assimilation. Rodriguez’s viewpoint is that if you want to make a full…

    • 1373 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Seal Of Literacy Essay

    • 611 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “The Bilingual Education Act was in acted as an amendment to the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965. The goals of this program was to help educate Spanish speaking children in the late 1960’s. Activist argued for the use of bilingualism in schools pointing out the high dropout rates of Spanish speaking students. Slowly the atmosphere of English only, started to change as prominent politicians such as Lyndon b. Johnson advocated for the use of different languages, (Spanish in his case) in schools. Since then there have been ongoing struggles between the English only campaign and the campaign for bilingual education.…

    • 611 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rhetorical Analysis: Positivity of Bilingual Education Bilingual education has positively affected foreign children with their overall lives. Kenneth Jost’s, Harvard College and Georgetown University Law Center alumni, article, “Bilingual Education vs. English Immersion” is about the positive significance of bilingual education in public schools. Jeff Bale’s, a language education professor at Michigan State University, article, “Bilingual Education is the Best Approach for English Language Learners” also explains why this type of education is effective for foreign students. Together, both of these authors provide an effective argument with the use of reasoning, credibility, and emotion, but also include logical fallacies. Jost’s and Bale’s…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction Prior to the Bilingual Education Acts Prior to the Bilingual Education Act of 1968, the U.S. government had a change in attitude towards bilingualism and bilingual educations. At times, there was this permissive attitude that allowed teaching through the mother tongue acceptable. As long as it was within the jurisdiction of local towns and districts, schools were allowed to teach in the child’s native language. However, there were times in which higher authorities were strongly against languages other than the English. This hostile climate would culminate in the some of the nation’s most drastic changes in the public schools resulting in the reduction of any type of bilingual instruction offered by some states (Nieto, 2009).…

    • 1102 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Though the Bilingual Act has been amended and changed since 1968, it is undeniable that is has shaped the way that we deal with the needs of our immigrant students nationwide. It helped to bankroll the creation of bilingual education mechanisms in all 50 states. This, in turn, has led to the increased success for immigrant students who are now given the tools to both learn English and succeed in the US. Unfortunately, bilingual education today has transitioned from an emphasis on teaching both the student’s native language and English to a system which emphasizes assimilation and learning English as fast as possible. This is due to our state’s heightened focus on standardized tests rather than the student’s individual…

    • 624 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    What role does bilingual education policy have in the educational opportunity structure for English language learners (ELLs)? The study of X Public School District Bilingual program exposed all the deficiencies found in Bilingual education. The study was conducted in a district where the majority of ELLs were Hispanics who performed below the 50th percentile in the NJASK3 and NJASK4 Language Arts Literacy and Mathematics as well as below the 20th percentile in the GEPA and HSPA Language Arts Literacy scores for the 2001 through 2005 years. The study focused on five areas: District policy and Philosophy; Curriculum and Instruction; Language Assessment Tools; Staffing and Certification; and School Environment. A number of challenges were addressed…

    • 1649 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are many elements that effectively help the education program. There are programs such as the additive bilingual that helps the students learn the best way possible by two-way or one-way immersion. Even though there are programs that help the student become bilingual and biliterate, we must look at the translanguaging, comprehensible input, affective, cognitive, and meta-cognitive strategies from the student. We must also validate the student’s culture and support their language for a minimum of 5 years. “An additive bilingual situation is where the addition of a second language and culture is unlikely to replace or displace the first language and culture” (Baker, 2001, pg. 58).…

    • 958 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Bilingual education is a vehicle that facilitates the exposure of a fraction of the world’s collective cultures to a country’s younger generations. It serves as a bridge that connects students to different worlds and and enriches their understanding of not only their target language, but also the customs, traditions, and people of a country that is foreign to their own. And yet, there stands an argument that bilingual education is nothing more than a money-guzzling burden that imposes a seemingly menial and impractical task upon the American educational system. In reality, bilingual education is far more valuable than people regard it to be. Not only is it about merely learning a new language or getting immersed into a particular culture, but the process of learning a…

    • 1410 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays