Disobedience As A Psychological And Moral Problem Analysis

Improved Essays
A central conflict in human society is a divide between obedience and autonomy. People are by nature, herd animals, with a need for the security of knowing their place in the world. In Erich Fromm’s essay, “Disobedience as a Psychological and Moral Problem,” states that by being obedient, we gain a measure of the power that we worship, be it the Church or the State or a charismatic leader, and we become strong. We become righteous. It frees us of thought and of the accusation of wrong-doing (Fromm 4). Following this, he argues that in order to disobey, a person must not be afraid to be alone, or to err, or to sin. A person must be able to say, “No!” (Fromm 4). The ability to say “no” must take place in a situation where the attempt at freedom …show more content…
He is not fleeing from the obligations of his life, but from the image of his father, Unoka. Unoka was a lay-about sort of man who, similar to Gregor Samsa’s father, was content to drift through life letting others shoulder his burden. Okonkwo’s effort for autonomy was to become the authority himself and demand the submission from those closest to him: his wives and children. In Okonkwo’s world, there was no ability to say “no.” He disparaged those who had the ability to be disobedient, calling them “women” and “weak.” (Achebe ?) In Igbo culture, the center of life was the clan. There is no independence and no autonomy in a communal society. The members of the clan had the ability to change their circumstances, but there was no real capacity to live outside the group. When the white men came, there came a change to Igbo society. Different paths became available and previously silent dissenters in the tribe became outspoken. Okonkwo was unable to handle the changing dynamics and started losing his fragile sense of power. As a result, he commits to the colonials, an unforgivable crime. He believes that the murder of the messenger will awaken the fire of independence in his kinsmen; however, it only tightens the yoke of submission. In his final act of independence, he commits suicide rather than face the consequences of his …show more content…
He goes on to say that when a man can only obey and not disobey, he is a slave. When a man can only disobey and not obey, he is a rebel (Fromm 2). For these two characters, the motivations for their deaths define them as people. While Gregor had been living as a slave, he used his death to spare others pain and in so doing, died a martyr. On the other hand, Okonkwo died out of anger and resentment, not due to a conviction or to spare his clan in any way. He lived his life as a man who would tolerate no weakness; and so when his own weaknesses were exposed, he chose death rather than face his inner darkness. He died a rebel, not a revolutionary (Fromm 3). Our lives have meaning and our deaths can serve a purpose. We can use them to save others or make a statement. Authority can tell us how to live our lives and can dictate our deaths, but it is up to us to give both of them meaning. That meaning is the truest definition of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    A Comparative Analysis of Ross and Nisbett’s “The Power of Situations” and Fromm’s “Disobedience as a Psychological and Moral Problem” Introduction Ross and Nisbett disagree with Fromm about the causes for obedience or disobedience to authority. It states in the introduction to “The Power of Situations”: “Erich Fromm conceives of obedience and disobedience as products of one’s character or of one’s moral choices” (627). This is suggesting that Fromm believes a person will obey or disobey based on their personality traits. He states: “All martyrs of religious faiths, of freedom, and of science have had to disobey those who wanted to muzzle them in order to obey their own consciences, the laws of humanity, and of reason” (623). People…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Okonkwo, grew up with a father that was seen as cowardly by the village and did everything to become the opposite of his father. His entire life he strived to be the best and became the extreme opposite of his father. Okonkwo found home in his success and constantly being above everyone else. After all of his successes, white men started coming into his village and changed how the society functioned. Okonkwo could not properly change with the times and became without a home.…

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Okonkwo became so discouraged from fighting and the way Umuofia was falling apart, because of the colonizers, that he had commit suicide which was seen as…

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Okonkwo does not want change. His view of masculinity and personal validation come from the traditions of his people. Okonkwo is also afraid of losing his social status that he has worked so hard to obtain. While talking to the rest of his children Okonkwo says, “You have all seen the great abomination of your brother. He is no longer my son...…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    There cannot be change without someone fighting to keep things the same. In 1890’s Nigeria some members of the Ibo clan embrace this new change, while others, like the protagonist Okonkwo, sternly believe in the old ways of the clan. This is the setting for Chinua Achebe’s greatest novel, Things Fall Apart. One theme of this book is violence.…

    • 1185 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “I became convinced that noncooperation with evil is as much a moral obligation as is cooperation with good.” -Martin Luther King Jr. Often regarded as one of the greatest threats to a structured society, rebellion is typically thought of to have no discernible purpose, with only the intent to dismantle the peaceful means by which citizens are expected to live by. However, can we truly decide the moral values of an action without considering the full spectrum of possibilities that could have prompted such a response? One of the basic expectations we set for ourselves and those among us is the discipline to follow the rules that are set by those in authority; from the time we were mere infants, being taught to respect our parents to our adulthood years when we must force ourselves to give the same respect to our bosses, law enforcement, and even our political leaders, it is considered a fundamental responsibility for us to follow the rules.…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Fancy Title In his 1963 essay, “Disobedience as a Psychological and Moral Problem,” philosopher Erich Fromm argues that disobedience to authority started human history and blind obedience may cause its destruction. Fromm’s view on obedience to authority is that when we obey authority, even when it goes against our own reasoning and morals, then that obedience is cowardly and destructive while any act affirming individual will and autonomy is an act of freedom. Humanity could easily destroy itself and people wouldn’t think to question the order that did it.…

    • 1245 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Disobedience has appeared at all times throughout the existence of mankind. It is a trait that all humans, no matter how submissive, own and utilize in their lifetime. Wilde’s claim that disobedience is a valuable human trait is valid because it has helped formed society today. Civil disobedience has been used many times in history and has resulted in social progress. Protests are a beneficial way for differential opinions to be expressed.…

    • 279 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He makes himself to be a great leader of the clan, but he is willing to sacrifice other clansmen just to maintain the high position. This is similar to when Okonkwo kills his own son, Nwoye, to save face with the other clan leaders. Okonkwo loses sight of what it means to be a leader as…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Are all those historical people we look up to actually role models? We can all agree with the fact that we, as a country, have made progress, but can we stand behind the idea that it was all done the right way? As stated by Wilde, disobedience is a valuable human trait because it is a necessity for things to get done. If it wasn't for extreme disobedience the United States would not have progressed once more in such a great manner. Moreover this country, this amazing, modern country, ratified the 19th amendment in the early 1920s after countless years of disgusting suffrage.…

    • 294 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One mistake Okonkwo makes is how in trying to be unlike his father, he becomes an angry, violent and aggressive man. This is one mistake that is definitely contributing to Okonkwo’s demise as it leads him to do irrational things and treat his family badly as well as treating himself badly even though he has achieved such wondrous things in his lifetime. Okonkwo’s also got many other failures of himself and one of those being how he has such excessive pride and is also such a traditional man that he is not able to accept what the missionaries have done to his village during his time away in “motherland” because he was banished from the village for 7 years. This was one of the big mistakes that Okonkwo made because he wasn 't able to accept how his village was being changed and he couldn 't do anything about it which was one of his past mistakes before he ended his life. One of Okonkwo’s first big mistakes in the book was how he partook in the killing of Ikemefuna after he was instructed to not by the higher ups in the spiritual respect of the tribe.…

    • 1160 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    How to Teach Children the Art of Obedience and Disobedience Since some social psychology professors proved a theory by several experiments, the theory has been accepted by the many social psychologists that human behavior can be markedly influenced and change by any situation, even though sometimes the changes of behaviors were not ethically right. Stanley Milgram, a professor of psychology at Yale University conducted a series of social psychology experiments to verify how ordinary German people could go along with and obey the cruel authority who perpetrated genocide at the World War II (McLeod 584-588). This experiment was composed of an experimenter and a teacher in the same room and a learner in the other separate room in Yale Interaction Laboratory. The teachers were the…

    • 1316 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Like in the feast he held, Okonkwo is scared. During the feast, Okonkwo overcompensates to cover up any sign of his unsuccessful father. This idea is not only seen in the feast, but in multiple scenes such as the murder of Ikemefuna. Ultimately, Okonkwo gets tired of covering up, and he just decides to run away from the problem altogether. This is not an act of courage because he is not persevering in the face of adversity.…

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Effects Of Disobedience

    • 278 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Has Disobedience really affected the way people live? According to Author Oscar Wilde, Disobedience helps promotes movements and social skills. Disobedience has evolved social movements and created trust on others. I think it is important to think on our own and to make our own choices in life, but disobey if it’s the right thing. One example of Disobedience had to deal with slavery.…

    • 278 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The man that had once been the most prideful in Umofia, was now dead. Okonkwo even knew himself how frowned upon it was to take his own life, and yet he still did it. The cultural conflict in this book shows us just how much of an impact a conflict can have on a man, especially one as prideful and strong as Okonkwo. The conflict in this book was so severe, that it drove Okonkwo to end his own life, because he had been driven so far away from his customs, that he felt as if there was no turning back to fix what he had done.…

    • 847 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays