Arguments Against Colonialism

Superior Essays
For almost four centuries, ever since Christopher Columbus crossed the Atlantic Ocean, the major European countries have been dominating the world by means of colonization. As Jerry Kloby defines it, “colonialism can be best described as the formal political domination of one country by another in which the relationship between the two nations is always one of economic exploitation, although the dominant nation may pretend otherwise” (pp. 100). Through violence and forced labor, countries such as England, France, and Spain have been able to colonize the countries they see to be weaker and exploit their natural resources. Even though the colonizing countries say that they are helping the colonized countries, there is much evidence to support …show more content…
Rothenberg argues that the “vast inequalities of wealth […], the unrelenting poverty that is the reality of life for the majority of the world’s people, […] cannot be understood unless we place them in the context of colonization and its consequences for development” (pp. 76). She is suggesting that the reason for some much of the world’s poverty and the vast gaps between the rich and the poor can be attributed to colonialism. During the time of colonialism, the natives that were being forced into labor were making very little profit, if they were making any profit at all. This can be credited to two main reasons—very low wages and high taxes. One example of this was seen in France’s West Africa—“In a sense, the peasant was exploited twice, first by selling his crop and then by handing over a part of the money made from the sale to the French government as tax payments” (Kloby, pp. 102). In order to make any money, the farmers needed to produce crops that the French wanted to buy. Then part of the money that they made needed to go back to the French government in order to pay their taxes. Even if the people did make some money from their produce, they would loose most of their profit anyway. This did not allow the natives of the colonized countries to grow economically, and it kept them perpetually below the economic standings of the colonizers. Even after the colonized countries have obtained their freedom, there is still evidence of the economic inequality of the past. Another major reason for this long lasting effect is during the time of colonization “whenever internal forces seemed to push in the direction of African industrialization, they were deliberately blocked by the colonial governments […]. European industrialists did not then welcome even the simple stage of processing groundnuts into oil on African

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Growth In Africa

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Given the high risks of agriculture in Africa, Collier states how households must use assets to smooth consumption over the long-run as opposed to invest, meaning they become trapped in a low-income and high-liquidity equilibrium. The third factor identified is Africa's very low population. The effect of this is high transportation costs, which have led to poor market integration and the…

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Although they educated a very few number of them, education opened the door to anti colonial and nationalistic activity. After World War Two and the democratic propaganda ceased influencing Africa they were determined to struggle for independence. The different colonial governments left behind roads, railroads, ports, new technology, and other benefits to the continent of Africa as a whole. Nevertheless, their impact on Africa was not all positive. Their foreign policies damaged the traditional economies and drastically changed the social ranks of land ownership and labor.…

    • 1325 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    It is fair to say that colonialism had a great impact on Africa’s current economical and social status. As the problems being identified, the original quote “the problem with the colonization of Africa was not that the colonizers exploited Africa, but they did not exploit the continent enough” could be interpreted as: because colonizers did not exploit Africa enough, Africa is underdeveloped. This also implies that if Africa is “well exploited,” African countries will develop good infrastructures, satisfactory education systems, and competent commercial environments. However, numerous pieces of evidence prove that Africa was not “well exploited” in terms of the development of the financial market and industrial progress. Was Africa being exploited for cheap raw materials?…

    • 1782 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The 3rd estate thought it was unfair that even though they made the least amount of money, they had to pay the most taxes. With families spending most of their income on taxes, what little was left over was put toward food, which the price rose dramatically. Locke would argue that a government job of protecting life, liberty and property would cover the act of helping citizens buy food to stay alive and keep their families nourished. The French government was not attempting to help, effectively not protecting the right to life outlined as the main job of government by Locke. The enlightenment ideas of John Locke also created civil unrest with the idea of a king.…

    • 1271 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Peasants paid half their income to the king in the form of taxes. These taxes helped pay for the kings ventures. They were the one who had to pay for everything from war to the debt that France had. France had many debts. One was because of war and another one was because France would borrow money from other places to pay off the debts they had.…

    • 887 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    European Imperialism in Africa had a negative effect on both Africa and the rest of the world by destroying African society, technology and culture. Europe, In the late 1800’s made its way into Africa. As Africa grew countries such as France, Britain, and Germany came in for personal benefits and started taking their resources. These European powers went into Africa destroying their society, materials, and culture because they only cared about their strength and resources. Africa was an easy target due to a large surplus in cash crops, not politically strong, and no modernization compared to the European countries with excelled technology.…

    • 1494 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He had fears because he knew it would harm his country Vice the Dark Continent). In some cases companies recklessly behavior lead to conflict, poverty and corruption through their activities (BBC How deep is corruption in Africa) The lower class receive insufficient wages that they too ended up supporting their income directly from corruption. In some instances if you don’t corrupt someone in a high position you can’t get a job. Countries in oil in West Africa generate a lot of money though at half of their people are in debt Most of that money is given to selected people. Governments, often in conspiracy with the, private ownership have used the revenue into their own pockets.…

    • 1393 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    One of the first economic issues that arose in the New World was a labor shortage in comparison to the abundance of land- the opposite of which had been the case in Europe. Contributing to the scarcity of labor was the fact that “few settlers wanted to work for others when they could get farms of their own.” One of the only practical solutions to this problem was to seek labor elsewhere, in other parts of the world. This led to the adoption of enslaved Africans as the primary labor source in the developing colonies, an event that would irrevocably entwine slavery and the Southern economy. Also, because there were so few workers available, the colonists that chose to work were able to demand high wages for their service (Goldfield et al. 73).…

    • 1673 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Just because European countries have the power to colonize the African countries does not mean they should. European countries have been involved in amassing overseas possessions and the colonization of foreign lands since the 1500s. Beginning in the second half of the 1800s, European powers began a mad rush to control as much of the world’s resources as possible. There are many contributing factors behind this spread of new imperialism. These factors include racism, ethnocentrism, economics, nationalism, and the missionary impulse of the people.…

    • 802 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As Andersen described “this exploitation in turn, keeps them from developing and perpetuates their poverty.” (208) Social inequality also involves race. Andersen argues in chapter nine that most of the poor nation involves the people of color and the wealthy nation involves white. This is also determined as social discrimination because the people of color are put away, and are not recognized for their potential. If the wealthy nation was helping equally the poor nations, many countries will leave any thought of hunger, lack of job, infant mortality, lack of education, and so on. But because they want to use the lower class nation they increase the cheap labor rate.…

    • 818 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics