Argument Analysis: DACA Immigrants In The United States

Good Essays
Argument analysis After jeff’s sessions speech about rescinding DACA and his words about how DACA “Denied jobs to hundreds of thousands of Americans”, DACA became a trending, hot, and divisive topic that social media and people talk about. In this argument, I will analyze two of the op-eds written about DACA and how it affected the current situation of immigrants in the united states. The first op-ed is “NO, DACA immigrants aren’t stealing American jobs” written by Bryce Covert published in the New Republic. The other op-ed is “How DACA pits ‘good immigrants’ against millions of others” written by Joel Sati published in the Washington Post. While both of them did a great job in supporting their points of views, I will argue in this essay that …show more content…
“DACA allowed them to get over the table employment, and the extra money they made led to financial stability and a big increase in car and home purchases…. Six percent even started businesses on their own, thus creating more jobs for others” (No-DACA, 3). This supports that DACA was very beneficial for dreamers by allowing them job permits that gave them an opportunity to have a job and earn a salary like US citizens which opposes session’s speech about how DACA recipients stole jobs from Americans. In this op-ed, Bryce tended to use ethos and logos as she used her authority and supported her argument with statistics and her point of view about the situation which makes sense to the readers, but she failed to give more evidence to support her claim. In the second op-ed “How DACA pits ‘good immigrants’ against millions of others” the author argues that DACA wasn’t the best solution for immigrants. “And while some continue to debate the fine points of DACA, the policy was never an adequate solution to our nation’s immigration situation.” (Sati, 2). Sati thinks that DACA only favored a small group of immigrants and wasn’t in favor for others who aren’t looking for higher education or good jobs and that they also don't get full rights in the US and still undocumented immigrants without papers that make them legal. In this op-ed, the …show more content…
Six percent even started businesses on their own, thus creating more jobs for others.” (No-DACA, 3). In this quote, Bryce used logos as it makes sense that more jobs give more money which means economic growth. Bryce used statistics to support her main claim that DACA didn’t steal jobs from Americans. The evidence that the author uses to support her main claim is misleading as it makes the person convinced that DACA was the best reliable source for dreamers, but by doing further research DACA actually didn’t give people legal status and immigrants were still undocumented and it only came in favor of those seeking high education but it wasn’t beneficial for immigrants who had old criminal records or not seeking higher job positions.
The other op-ed written by Joel Sati, a DACA recipient, supports that DACA wasn’t the best solution for immigrants and there is a distinction made by favoring the good deserving immigrants “dreamers” over others. The author used ethos in writing his argument as he is a DACA recipient which makes him a credible source to relay on. He also used pathos in his argument when he wrote: “we deserve this not because we are good, but because we are human beings”. This appeals to the emotional part of the reader. Sati knew how to successfully affect the reader and

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    The U.S. has its fair share of low educated, low income, high welfare use individuals but the U.S. would not benefit from adding to the problem by allowing less educated illegal immigrants to stay. Advocates of Amnesty claim doing analysis by household is not accurate because the children were American born. They argue that the costs for education, welfare, and other programs that benefit children should not be counted because these children are not immigrants. The number of illegal immigrant children add up being that 80 percent were born in the United States. Skeptics completely ignore the fact that they would not be here if it were not for our broken immigration system.…

    • 1437 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The thesis statement discussed the volume and impact of unauthorized immigrants have on the United States economy. They state that at the state level, they are forced to take care of their own immigration problems because the federal government has continuously failed at enhancing border control and interior enforcement. Furthermore, at the state level, although the states have passed over 1600+ bills and resolutions, the states are not achieving their intended goals and are likely to result in harmful, unintended consequences which won’t alleviate natives’ concerns about immigration’s labor and fiscal impacts because they need the federal government’s help. After the thesis, the author’s, once again, split the subtopic into two smaller subtopics, Federal Level and State Level, to further discuss each point in detail and support their thesis statement. By doing this, they are able to provide their audience with an abundance of information showcasing their knowledge and increasing their credibility.…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In America there is hate crimes towards innocent foreigners just for being from a certain country. Unfortunately America is not the country that immigrants think it is, they come to find that migrating to America means facing many hardships. Not being able to have the life they envisioned for them and their families all because they are “inferior”. Even if you are a legal immigrant the hardships don’t seem to stop. Some will never consider you a full-fledged citizen if you are an immigrant.…

    • 1020 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    50 Years Ago Immigration

    • 1521 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The national government only answers how many immigrants and from where so instead of explaining whether immigration is encouraged or not. Most Americans think that immigration is undesirable and is not even necessary and thus Americans are not for the idea (Williamson & Chilton, 23). Most of the immigrants allowed during the past years included people from Europe who provided cheap and skilled labor in America. Therefore immigration was of beneficial to America before immigrants from other continents came up and increased the population instead of actually helping the American economy. The progressive movement however advocated for restrictions on immigration since many immigrants came to America and caused strain on the environmental resources.…

    • 1521 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This belief stems from the idea that an American educated native could be easily overlooked by an employer for an immigrant. Places with higher immigration, if this were a true fact, would show more unemployment in hard times (“The Economic Blame Game” 1). This simply is not evident in the United States. Many immigrants and American-born people do not even compete for the same types of jobs. This could be due to language or education barriers, but immigrant jobs usually compliment native-born jobs rather than take them (1).…

    • 2318 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Americans view themselves as competitors with immigrants. Contrary to popular belief, this isn’t something that the working class needs to fear. An increase in immigration will, in turn, raise the earnings of Hispanic women by 1.1 percent and for men, 2.25 percent. Immigrants are viewed as job stealing-low lives that migrate to America and put native-born American’s out of jobs when the truth is they are taking the jobs that nobody would want. Immigrants are taking labor-intensive jobs because these are the ones that are available, and these spots are vacant because they are not necessarily desirable jobs.…

    • 1237 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Donald Trump Pros And Cons

    • 1204 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Typically the work of undocumented people in the United States is more dangerous and difficult, often times the jobs immigrants take on are the jobs that American citizens would never want to do. This shows how important immigrants are to the United States work force because they contribute so work and get paid very little. Donald Trump’s immigration plan will not work because of his plan to…

    • 1204 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    But Working Hard is a Skill” by Jeff Flake, both use impactful diction to express why immigrants are important in society but differ in the way they use the tones to express this idea. The articles both use impactful words like “desperate hope” (Flake, 1) and “to seek a better life” (Nutting, 1) to express that America is the best possible place for them. Using this powerful diction makes the views very impactful because using words like desperate shows that living in America and working the bad jobs is their only option of getting a better life which can really make people feel sympathy for immigrants. However, “We Need Immigrants with Skills. But Working Hard is a Skill” has hardworking and driven tone by using phrases like, “sole credential in life” (Flake, 1), that says that this was the person's only hope and their only focus is getting to a better life.…

    • 1084 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Yes, “immigration fuels our economy. Many Americans wrongly believe that immigration hurts the economy. There is consensus among many leading economists that immigration actually gives economies a net boost… contrary to popular belief, immigrants do not reduce native employment rates overall” (Kelly). Immigrants do help the economy to grow bigger by spending money on appliances that are needed daily: food, drinks, and clothes. Also, Immigrants are helping small businesses to grow bigger day by day, by consuming their products available for the costumers.…

    • 1111 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Immigrants Human Capital

    • 1357 Words
    • 6 Pages

    It is not that immigrants steal jobs, it is that Americans often think that immigrants should get jobs that match their human capital. In Wheelan’s book it says “individuals do things that make themselves better off”(Wheelan, 285). This applies to immigrants because they are willing to take on any occupation, even manual labor-intensive occupations. This is because they lack the human capital necessary for better jobs. Most Americans don't want or consider these intensive occupations because they believe they can do better.…

    • 1357 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays