Compare And Contrast Ravitch And Gatto

Improved Essays
Diane Ravitch and John Gatto both set up their arguments to have a message mirroring each other, in that the current system that schools have in order to teach kids is failing and needs to be refined. Diane Ravitch approaches this view in contrast to Gatto. She builds her argument around the solution that children should be educated in such a way that sets them up for citizenhood during and after high school. Gatto’s approach takes a different view in which children are responsible for their own education and it should be left up to the individual students on whether or not they wish to “take away an education rather than merely receive a schooling,” (Gatto, page 115). Both build up to this belief through their separate experiences within the schooling system. Gatto had received more of a negative side from attempting to reform the education system on his own terms when …show more content…
Gatto states more of fixing individual students by making them responsible for their own education. Any boredom that occurs is with the fault of that student. He gives the statement, “Let them manage themselves,” but doesn’t offer any insight to how this could be accomplished or even the effects of such a proposal. This creates a hole within his argument and causes wonder of why this would be a better solution than the current implemented system. Ravitch gives a more developed solution, saying that standardize testing should not be removed, but reduced so that programs such as art, music, and historical literature can balance the constant persecution of only math and reading. She gives more of an option to change the curriculum and have these children possess a more necessary education, that not only sets them up for college, but allows them to become more well versed within the political side of the nation. This will in turn create a more educated nation able to make critical thinking decisions within our civic

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In the United States, the school serves as a primary institution in regards to the education and socialization of any given community’s children. Over the course of the nearly two-hundred-year history of public education in America, the school has come to replace other significant institutions, such as the church and family, in the daily lives of most students. Children between the ages of 7 and 18 spend a majority of their time in school learning content in addition to being socialized to fit within societal norms. Joel Spring’s Goals of Public Schooling, the introductory text to the course, provides historical insight into the development of the school’s role in society. From the era of Thomas Jefferson’s meritocracy ideology where school’s sole purpose was to enable children with basic skills to Edward Ross’ declaration of school being “a form of social control” a sense of societal liability has been bestowed upon schools.…

    • 898 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She explains that the No Child Left Behind law was made to narrow the achievement gaps. She provides evidence about how important this has been to many people. Ravitch also speaks about lawmakers, legislators, and policy makers and how they thought that testing and accountability would help close the gaps. She shows other people’s views on what they think will solve this achievement gap problem including President George W. Bush. He claimed that if teachers were required by law to have high expectations for all students then all students would learn and meet high standards.…

    • 1238 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the book, “The Death and Life of the Great American School System”, Diane Ravitch, the former assistant secretary of education examines her career in education reform. Ravitch’s book will be used to answer the following questions. According to the author what can we do to improve schools and education? The author stresses that there is no silver bullet that will magically fix the United States schools and the education system.…

    • 1719 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “We cannot provide equal educational opportunity if some children get access to a full and balanced curriculum while others get a heavy dose of basic skills (Ravitch 108).” Using logos, Ravitch makes the audience realize that it is simply unacceptable for a country as advanced as the United States to have such a huge discrepancy in education depending on whether or not you go to a private school. Private schools have the necessary funding in order to offer a wide variety of classes to their students. Public schools get funding from the government and hard economic times have caused their budgets to shrink. With a decreased budget…

    • 1041 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Children in society struggle daily with meeting the educational expectation. Compared to other countries around the world, the United States’ high school mathematics program stands in 31st place, and 24th in science. (Desilver, 2015) The American educational system remains below the expectation, and unfortunately, relays no signs of improving. In his essay, America Skips School, Benjamin Barber argues that the reason for the education crisis falls on the hands of the adults, because of their lack of initiative in supporting the youth of America.…

    • 979 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Both reviews are mainly positive but both reviewers focus on different aspects of the book. Johnson’s review praises Alston for providing translations and interpretations of sources that were previously inaccessible to students. Johnson also praises Alston for his writing style and ability to select and organize a large amount of material well. Johnson recognizes that Alston draws numerous interesting conclusions including those about the quick pace of educational reform compared to the slower pace of the government becoming constitutional. Douglass also praises the organization of the book and the choice to divide the information into three parts.…

    • 384 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Barber 's “America Skips School”, he addresses the increasing dropout rate for high school students. Not only are the flaws in the education system prevalent amongst students, but also amongst adults. It is an unfortunate reality that over 90 million adult Americans lack basic literacy, and in turn, the children of these adults obtain a lower level of education because of their parents ' limitations. As a result, education becomes insufficient all around, affecting the overall quality of education around the nation. The inadequacy of American schooling is especially put in perspective when compared to the schooling that students in foreign nations receive.…

    • 1372 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In John Taylor Gatto’s essay, “Against School,” Gatto writes about his perspective on the American public school system that he believes is not as beneficial as it is expected to be. He begins by explaining that teachers and students are bored inside classrooms simply because students are not taught better qualities such as critical thinking or curiosity. Instead, they are “schooled” rather than “educated” so students only learn how to conform. Gatto goes on to describe the goals of school as, “making good people, making good citizens, and making each person their personal best” (117). He later comments on Inglis’ interpretation of the functions of modern schooling.…

    • 1581 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “Against School,” John Gatto argues that the main purpose of public schools and the educational system in general is to produce a “manageable” populace. Gatto argues that the current educational system does this by slowly acclimating students into certain habits, confirming students to certain rules, and implementing a certain mindset into students that makes them respond well to authority. All of these things that Gatto argues adds up to make a system for training a complaint workforce. Firstly, schools achieve what Gatto states their purpose is by acclimating students to how factories are organized and what working in a factory is like. Secondary, schools also accomplish Gattos argument by restricting the class choices of students and…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In America, an education is no longer considered to be an option but in fact, a necessity. Many are raised to believe in order to ensure a successful future, education is a key component. In fact, there are others who believe that the educations systems we have in place today, actually does more bad than good. There have been many movements that had an idea to insure that students are properly educated and all receive the same form of education but, the institution of these movements may have caused more damage and simply relied on the forcing of educators to produce a group of workers who are unable to consciously think for themselves. Although there is no way of making sure that the potential of a student is fully developed, possible solutions…

    • 1720 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Public Education Failure

    • 1158 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Tom DeWeese, in his article “Public Education is Failing,” from Opposing Viewpoints in Context, suggests our education system is failing to teach our children the basic subjects of reading, writing, and mathematics. DeWeese is the president of a public-policy organization that promotes less government involvement and more free enterprise. According to DeWeese, the “root problem” with our education system is, “. . . the federal programs and the education bureaucracy that run them.” He also suggests that the education system no longer concentrates on teaching the basics, but is training our children to perform “menial jobs.”…

    • 1158 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The education system in the United States, since 2001 when the “no child left behind” act was passed, has moved to much less wholistic version of education. This issue is presented in “The Essentials of a Good Education,” by Diane Ravitch. In this article Ravitch presents many thought provoking points about the importance of looking at students as people rather than numbers. The author argues that since 2001, schools have been focusing more on the scores their students receive on standardized tests and less on how much students are actually learning. The author establishes credibility very early, and maintains it by presenting facts and using a professional tone.…

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A Critique of Diane Ravitch’s “Education in the Post Sputnik Era” On October 4th 1957 the Soviet’s launch the world’s first satellite called “Sputnik 1” ending the debate that the quality of education in America’s school system has been a concern. This event that the Russians beat the Americans sparked crisis in America’s education system. This crisis lead to restructuring the education system in English, History, Science, Mathematics, and foreign languages. While many programs were developed and government funding was allocated to enhance school systems and colleges, the racial revolution presented a forceful challenge to the political, social, and economic basis of American schools (Ravitch 324).…

    • 1031 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The New York City Teacher of the Year, John Gatto, argues in “Against School- How public education cripples our kids today, and why” that the school system is taking advantage of the students mind. Gatto states that not everyone has to go to school in order to be successful, but the school system is enforcing that everyone must go to school. Education can be accomplished anywhere, according to Gatto, but schooling is tearing down peoples ability to think, also “dumbing down” society. John Gatto argues in “Against School-…

    • 1277 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Gatto gives his feedback from when he was a school teacher. Gatto has seen what the public school system are doing to your children, and what it has done to you in the past years. Gatto makes a clear argument not against learning, but schooling and how public education cripples out children. Gatto begins by talking about how schools farm for boredom. Gatto also talks about how this culture of boredom fosters indifferent followers.…

    • 1464 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays