Compare And Contrast Ralph And Jack

Improved Essays
The Lord of the Flies, by William Golding, stresses Thomas Hobbes’s theory that all civilization eventually corrupts due to human nature. Although the two main characters, Ralph and Jack, share a few similarities in the beginning, they later divide completely due to their different values, beliefs, and views on society. Ralph hopes for an organized society, maintaining order as chief while they wait for a rescue ship. On the other hand, Jack lets savagery overcome him, prioritizing his lust for power and using violence to threaten all things that get in his way. The similarities and differences between the two emphasize Golding’s theme that if not controlled in a proper manner, one’s mind can easily corrupt from the thirst for power. In the …show more content…
Ralph initially assembles the boys by blowing the conch, which symbolizes order in society. Shortly after Ralph blows “a series of short blasts” an entire group stands before him (17). From the start, Ralph possesses leadership skills by assembling a group and controlling his administrative abilities for everyone’s best profit, as they come together, united as one clan instead of living on the island divided and only having themselves to depend on. In addition to, Jack also possesses leadership abilities as he introduces himself confidently and talks with pride, suggesting that he contains no self doubt. Jack demands that he should claim the chief role “with simple arrogance” (22). From the beginning, Jack has full confidence in himself to rule the island, an important leadership skill that all quality authority figures must acquire. However, in Jack’s case, too much confidence can result in excessive conceitedness, where the authority figure ignores all other suggestions on improving their policies because of pride. “Jack shook his head,” to indicate that although the littluns have trouble sleeping, he still believes he should not change his actions to please them, refusing to give them more care and attention than anyone else, despite their age …show more content…
Ralph’s principal focus revolves around the signal fire and constantly making sure that the smoke remains strong and visible, just in case a rescue ship stumbles upon them. Whenever Ralph notices the smoke had been missing, Ralph becomes furious with the group, claiming that he holds the chief role and asks, “can’t you see the mountain? There’s no signal showing. There may be a ship out there” (108). Ralph’s main priority orbits around the fire, just in case a ship comes across the island, as this will benefit the entire group. In order to prioritize his ideal among the others, Ralph tries to make sure that he maintains that power and stability among the group, remaining their role model figure. He sees the need for the boys to stay civilized and attempts to create authority by building shelters for the boys to sleep in. Believing that they are to everyone’s advantage, he works hard and finally “two shelters were in position” (50). Ralph symbolizes how sometimes one can overcome vicious tendencies by persistently trying to keep the peace, clearly seeing that the island needs civilization to function, not savagery. Therefore, the fire and huts become useful as they create order, a civilized conduct. On the other hand, Jack continues to represent corrupt leadership skills, consistently favoring savage tendencies. He rubs paint on his face and states that it symbolizes, “hunting. Like in the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Other than a necessity to their rescue from the island, the flames are also a symbol of hope. The signal fire gives expectations of leaving the island and being saved to the boys. Furthermore, Ralph expands on the optimism by convincing everyone a ship will come through soon and save them. He does this through reasoning that “the Queen’s got a picture of [the] island… [and] sooner or later, [they] will be rescued” (37). As a leader, he provides the boys optimism during the direness of their situation.…

    • 1195 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    True leadership is represented by standing up for the greater good of a group without selfishness and ignorance towards others. The story The Lord of The Flies by William Golding demonstrates a constant struggle for power and leadership between Jack, Piggy, and Ralph. The malicious actions that result draw out specific aspects of leadership from each boy. Apart from Jack and his aggressive attitude toward others or Piggy with the lack of respect he receives from the others, Ralph 's rational thinking is the trait, that as a leader, trumps the others and clearly shows how his endless efforts for the greater good of the boys make him the distinct leader. From the arrival of the boys onto this island, Jack’s devotion to power by anger has…

    • 1659 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Human nature will create some infractions in life just as it did in the book Lord of the Flies. Jack and Ralph both had the human nature of wanting full control and running things the way they thought was better, while not taking the others ideas into consideration. “which is better- to have rules and agree, or to hunt and kill?” “which is better law and rescue, or hunting and breaking things up?”(180) As Jack and Ralph are arguing right before jack sets the island on fire to try and kill Ralph. This created conflicts and it forced sacrifices to be made and in the end the brightest figure survived. Afterall without human nature Ralph may have never survived, but he did survive because his human nature allowed him to outsmart Jack and his fellow…

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At the start of the novel, Ralph is focused on the fire, as it serves a purpose for the boys to be rescued. He repeatedly tells the boys to keep the fire lit on the top of the mountain, for the smoke will signal their presence to passing ships. “‘The fire is the most important thing on the island. How can we ever be rescued except by luck, if we don’t keep a fire going?... I tell you smoke is more important than the pig, however often you kill one…’” (Golding 86-87).…

    • 1429 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a leader, they have to think about others and behave properly by following the rules, but behaving civilized doesn’t necessary mean that it can lead to victory. What defines a good leader is the quality they have and also the experience they had. Hatred started because of jealousy, which can lead to revenge. Just like the situation between Jack and Ralph, and Jack has a purpose to become the leader, to be able to show the boys, that he can protect them, make them feel safe and give them food. All leader, have to think about what his group wants, and this characteristic best suits Jack.…

    • 912 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This shows the different set of priorities that Jack has. He excludes himself from some of the more tedious jobs such as this and does only what he wants. In meetings, he is very dismissive of the ideas of the other boys. He never lets anything get in his way of having the total power over the people that he wants without anyone else’s opinion. “We don’t need the conch anymore” he says, “We know who ought to say things.” Even though Jack has no organization, he has complete control over those who follow him.…

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At the beginning of the book the boy’s first goal for fire is to try and alert a passing ship but they get to carried away and a piece of the island gets burned down. It starts out as a symbol for hope and rescue but we also see the destructive side of fire. The hope that fire brings can be shown when Ralph says “If a ship comes near the island they may not notice us. So we must make smoke on top of the mountain. We must make a fire.” (pg.…

    • 1064 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He tries to get the boys to think as if there was an adult on the island as well. Ralph decides to remain rules unlike Jack and his boys. Ralph states what needs to be done in order to be the great leader he needs for the boys to become more civilized. Dropped “ I’m chief… because you chose me. And we are going to keep the fire going.…

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “You voted me for chief. Now you do as I say” states page 81. This quote influences the fact that Ralph is aware that he has power and even if it meant disciplining the boys, he would make sure the boys complete their tasks. Unlike Jack, Ralph realizes that the boys need to feel secure and they need someone in control in order to stay civil and alive. “They talk and scream.…

    • 640 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Hobbes believes that humans are born with a natural evil and will grow corrupt. Through the character Jack, that Golding creates, readers can understand that it is human nature to have an urge for something, which is Jack’s case is a hunger for superior power. Jack starts off losing the election to be leader and is secretly resenting…

    • 1567 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays

Related Topics