First And Second Estate Analysis

Improved Essays
In the 1700’s, France had a medieval styled, ridged class structure made up of the monarch and three groups, the first, second, and third estates. At the top of the social ladder as the highest-ranking person in the country was the king, followed by the members of the First Estate, the clergy. The Second Estate consisted of the nation’s nobility, and finally, at the lowest rank was the Third Estate made up of the bourgeoisie, urban workers, and peasants. While the First and Second Estates had little political power, they were granted many privileges such as how the First Estate was able to collect tithe as well as was exempt from taxes and only had to make an annual donation to the king, or the Second Estate had an exemption from military …show more content…
King Louie wanted the nobles and the church to give up some of their privileges and to pay taxes to help relieve the financial crisis that both Marie Antoinette and his lavish lifestyle had gotten the country into, but the clergy of the First Estate wanted to remain exempt from taxes and wished to keep their privileges. The First Estate was completely happy with the current system of government as not only were they not taxed, but also they could collect from the common people bringing in revenue. On the other hand, the nobles of the Second Estate told Louie that they would only accept being taxed if they gained political power in return. Giving the nobles political power would break apart the centralized administration brought about by King Louis XVI and would allow the noble’s input into all major decisions, something King Louie was opposed to. While all this was happening, the Third Estate, representing the majority of the French population, simply sought equality and representation along with a tax system reform that would free the peasants from the large tax burden imposed upon them as having the burden fall only on the poorest of the society was extremely difficult and unsustainable. Many members of the Third Estate lived in poverty and were even starving, as the taxes were too high. The Third Estate desired a reform of the …show more content…
Following this action was the Tennis Court Oath, where the National Assembly called for a new constitution of France, and when the king did not meet their needs, the common people stormed Bastille in the first act of the French Revolution. For years the French system of government had been dysfunctional and outdated and finally the people were fighting back against the unfair rule. Because King Louie XIV created a centralized administration that eliminated diversity in the governing of France, and Louis XV and Louis XVI both ignored the financial and social issues that arose as a result of the government structure, the common people of French were overlooked and their struggles ignored. King Louis XVI failed to cut down on spending, created an image problem for himself, and allowed the commoners to starve, and because of this the people revolted in hopes of political, social, and economic reforms that would ensure equality for the people of

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    The people of France rebelled because they were suffering from the monarchy. One factor that caused the people of France to join the French Revolution was that their rulers, King Louis XVI and Queen Marie Antoinette, lead them to bankruptcy and made them pay more taxes. In the document it states, “He lived…

    • 1114 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The 3rd estate thought it was unfair that even though they made the least amount of money, they had to pay the most taxes. With families spending most of their income on taxes, what little was left over was put toward food, which the price rose dramatically. Locke would argue that a government job of protecting life, liberty and property would cover the act of helping citizens buy food to stay alive and keep their families nourished. The French government was not attempting to help, effectively not protecting the right to life outlined as the main job of government by Locke. The enlightenment ideas of John Locke also created civil unrest with the idea of a king.…

    • 1271 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They started with solely good intent, but ended as a inquitous group of rebels, and broke away many citizens from the originality of their beliefs against the Monarchy. Life in France is greatly changed for the better because of the Revolution. Without the actions the Jacobins took, life would still be scarce,Governments wouldn’t have the peoples voices involved, and equality would not be as widely open as it is now. The Revolution was proof of how much power and control can be fought against, just to be exchanged from hand to hand. French citizens have built a new democracy around the events held throughout the years before, during, as well as after the Revolution of 1789-1799.…

    • 1011 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    2),” allowing the citizens of the New World to have a say in the political processes of their government. One of the main reasons for the American revolution against England revolved around the lack of representation for the colonists in England. The colonists, therefore, decided to create their own informal government in order to pass laws concerning urgent matters, especially considering the King typically put these laws off for quite a while or simply ignored them (“Declaration of Independence,” 2009, para. 4). The colonists informal governmental structure, involving a House of Representatives, then proceeded to be dissolved many times without re-election, leading to the danger of invasion or usurpation due to the distinct lack of any immediate authority (“Declaration of Independence,” 2009, para.…

    • 854 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Because of all the debt on the country, the people were heavily taxed, but only the commoners, or what made up the Third Estate. The main causes of the French Revolution was the taille, non-representation of the Third Estate, and the power of the church.…

    • 715 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    France was already in a very bad place at this time before they elected a new leader. Radicals were some of the main reasons France had revolts in 1848. In France, the demanded for a democratic government. in 1830, Frances King Charles X wanted to return to the absolute monarchy. by him trying to return to this, many riots started and forced King Charles to flee to Great Britain.…

    • 2436 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The people of France revolted against King Louis XVI because France had economic, political, international, and social problems as well as an ineffective ruler. The French government could have taken action to prevent the revolution from happening such as fixing financial issues, giving different social and economic classes equality and giving the majority what they wanted. The French government was spending a mass amount of money. Consequently, the country was slowly becoming bankrupt. Running the King’s personal court costed too much money.…

    • 2311 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He did not allow free speech or offer democracy and silenced anyone who spoke against him. Louis- Philippe only allowed the wealthy upper class to vote, which did not provide equality for everyone. He also became increasingly repressive as the lower middle class staged rebellions (biography). After he was exiled, French entered its second republic which only lasted a short period. Louis Napoleon declared himself dictator, and then emperor, which ended the republic and prevented democracy from developing any further after Philippe.…

    • 1017 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The funds used to help the poor were raised through taxation of the upper and middle class. This caused tension between the classes because the wealthy believed their money was being given to lazy people essentially rewarding them for not working. This parish-provided assistance money was also thought to be encouraging people to have many children that the Earth and the parents couldn't afford because the church would pay for them to be raised. This proves Malthus’s point that when income or resources are available people will continue reproducing until the resources are exhausted. Malthus’s ideas for the most part still apply to the present day.…

    • 1374 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Europe was petrified that their citizens would revolt against their government too, and so all of Europe got involved in the revolution. The situation got even worse when the new government of France made the Decree of Fraternity, which stated that France would help any country who chose to revolt against their government. Later, Europe’s fear occurred because the Dutch, Belgians, and Poles were inspired by this revolution (623). Each country fought the revolutionaries and some countries tried to rescue the royal family with no success. Austria tried saving the royal family but the king was recognized by a postmaster who knew him from “his portrait on the new French money” (605).…

    • 808 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays