Human Cargo: A Journey Among Refugees: An Analysis

Improved Essays
Although the "Universal Declaration of Human Rights" sets a baseline for human rights, Caroline Moorehead's "Human Cargo: A Journey Among Refugees" shows an example of a nation violating ideas within the Declaration, while Vaclav Havel New Year's Day Speech show an example of a nation that has somewhat started following the principles set forth in it. Moorehead mainly draws attention to articles 3, 14, and to a lesser extent, 7. Article 3 states that "everyone has the right to life, liberty, and the security of person," while article 14 declares the right for people to seek asylum from persecution in other nations (TM 434, 435). In the early 1920s, the League of Nations persuaded Fridtjof Nansen to oversee the repatriation of hundreds of thousands …show more content…
Haraway defines cyborgs in four different ways: a cybernetic organism, a hybrid of machine and organism, a creature of social reality, and a creature of fiction. While the second and third definition might seem to match Blade Runner's replicants, they have no machine parts and thus cannot be put under the second definition. It can be inferred that Haraway's cyborg is a female, because of the rapid growth of technology. By leaving their traditional roles, the "oppositional" female crosses a gender line and moves toward the cyborg state to become postgender (Haraway 481). A male character that moves towards technology is nothing new, and doesn't help him step past the idea of gender. An interesting thing to take note of is that all the main female characters in Blade Runner are replicants. Zhora and Pris's jobs are completely sexualized, such as "taking pleasures from the snake" or a description of a "basic pleasure model." Rachel's role is also one of a sexual object, because throughout the movie she seems to be Deckard's lover reluctantly, or face violence otherwise. Although they are all placed in an oppressive environment, their actions show how they attempt to become cyborgs of Haraway's third definition. When Deckard and Rachel return to the apartment after killing Zhora and Leon, Deckard seemingly tries to …show more content…
She describes how a group of people from North America built a place called Mill Reef Club for them to vacation in without having to interact with the local Antiguans. Although they gave some money to scholars and charities, many of the people still felt as if they were rude "strangers in someone else's home" who didn't interact with their host (Kincaid 468). There was even a doctor from Czechoslovakia who would send his wife to examine the patients and make sure they were not dirty in any way, before admitting them. This is very clearly racist, which is ironic because he was running from Hitler. Even the teacher sent to run the school would tell them not to behave like monkeys, likening the Antiguans to animals. The people were described as "ill-mannered," "crazy," and "puzzling," but all of them were "not racist" (Kincaid 470). What this most likely signifies is that the people of Antigua at some point in time did not consider the people from England as racist. It may even be a form of escape, and trying to trick themselves into thinking that the people weren't even from England. To the Antiguans, the colonials were considered tyrants who took everything without asking, killed and imprisoned people, and finally left after being driven out. However, they continued watching from afar as the Antiguans continued doing to themselves what the invaders had done. As she

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    It is through the consequences and experiences of a discovery where an individual makes an attempt to conceal or forget the events of the past, but find it impossible to suppress it completely, as the discovery made is confronting and provocative. Through the dramatic text Away by Michael Gow and the poem Refugee Blues by W.H. Auden, the notions of loss, time, and nature are explored. These ideas consequently lead to transformed perceptions of life and human experiences as a whole and thus a rediscovery. These ideas are further explored through various language forms utilising both dramatic and literary techniques that amplify the concept of discovery and its effect on groups and individuals.…

    • 1123 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jacobs claims that freedom does not include dehumanization and racial prejudice, both of which she experienced in the South and does not necessarily correlate with emancipation. Antigua suffers from the same flaws, and thus much like the United States lacks freedom. This understanding of Antigua, however, is not made entirely clear by Kincaid herself. While her language definitely indicates both dehumanization and evidence of racial prejudice, it leaves the reader without a complete understanding of Antigua’s freedom. Thus, reading the two narratives together allows the reader to bridge this gap and fully understand…

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As Mahatma Gandhi stated, “Without action, you aren’t going anywhere.” “Be the change you want to see in the world.” Both these quotes can accurately be witnessed in the actions and messages through the hard work and dedication of John Peters Humphreys. Human Rights all around the world have been a cause thousands have been fighting to protect for decades. From sexism to abuse, our world has seen and participated in all kinds of prejudice.…

    • 1434 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Abstract Human rights are rights that each single one of us has fair by the truth that we are people but it wasn't like that continuously. We didn't always have those rights. A part of time, battle and numerous battles had to pass for these rights to begin being recognized and regarded. In her speech, “The Struggle for Human Rights”, Eleanor Roosevelt uses many rhetorical devices to show how the United Nations is trying to enforce a Declaration to different countries to make sure people’s rights are not affected or lost.…

    • 1133 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This report examines the seriousness of the issue on refugees and asylum seekers that Australia is facing, and also shows that there is a need of change in Australia's policy on this matter. Although in recent times, there have been a several changes made. However, with a country that has such strict immigration law and policy for refugees like Australia, this report reveals the contradictions between Australian's legal system with the UN policy of human rights; and research also shows that the attempt made has not been enough on gaining remarkable progress. In recent years, countries that are suffering war and poverty like Afghanistan, Iran, and Iraq occupy a significant number of asylum seekers coming to Australia by boats (p5).…

    • 523 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For years people and countries have ignored a very important right, it is the right to free movement in and out of the country. This human right has either been forgotten or ignored, yet it’s very important. For example refugees that left Saudi a Arabia were sent to Australia but the Australian government refused to let them in because of actions made by others. The right to free movement in and out of the country should be enforced in countries all around the world because innocent people want a better life, people in history fought for these rights, and biased people can or could change governments’ minds to not allow immigrants in their country. This right should be enforced in other countries; they deny immigrants the entrance to their country.…

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Turning away refugees goes against the 1951 United Nations refugee convention. “The journey refugees make is dangerous and controlled by criminal gangs, and we have a right to stop it,” says both Labour and coalition parties, who support tough refugee policies (source 6). Australia’s leading coalition government made refugee and asylum seeker policies strict when it took government in 2013, which first introduced the military in control of intercepting refugees on Australian waters, turning them away (source 6). The liberal government responded to this by saying “its policies have restored the integrity of its borders and helped prevent deaths at sea” (source 6). The government is causing deaths at sea because they are sending back refugees…

    • 270 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jamaica Kincaid, the author of the short story “Girl,” was raised on the island of Antigua. During the time in which she was raised, Antigua was influenced by the British government. Because of the British control, Kincaid was raised in a culture immersed in the ideals of oppression and slavery. Being an African American woman in Antigua during the rule of the British government influenced how she wrote later in life. She eventually moved to America and landed a job as a writer for The New Yorker.…

    • 1434 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The ward’s goal is to gather the misfits and in turn, produce homogenous and productive members of society. Gender is a human trait that makes people different. Since gender is not a trait that can be applied to a machine, Ms. Ratched tries to emasculate the…

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Hortense Powdermaker’s book, Stranger and Friend, chronicles her experiences doing fieldwork throughout her career. In it, she discusses culture as shared meaning, where context and history give different components of a society social value. Through this process, essential qualities of a culture develop. The theory with which Powdermaker views culture, cultural essentialism, is one which uses these essential qualities as means of identification to form groups of people. This differs from Malinowski’s functionalist view, which claims that culture serves the needs of individuals rather than of larger communities.…

    • 967 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Early on in Annie John, the mid-twentieth century Antigua narrative, there arrive a conflict between the main character Annie and her manners teacher, “someone who knew all about manners and how to meet and greet important people of the world” (AJ 27-28). This incident prefigures many other complications and troubles that she has in dealing with gender and sexual inequalities of the African-Caribbean females under British colonial rule. The Autobiography of My Mother also signals that Xuela too, in early twentieth century Dominica, will have multiple struggles with her deep resentment and rebellion against gender and sexual inequality under British patriarchal colonial rule. The reason for Annie’s and Xuela’s rejection of British colonial rule seems to be inspired by their discernment…

    • 2245 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Living life under oppression with no freedom under the influence of others is not living life in joy. In "On Seeing England for the First Time" by Jamaica Kincaid she uses metaphor and repetition in order to convey her oppressed and bitter attitude toward England. Kincaid uses metaphors throughout the passage to show her oppressed attitude towards England. Since Kincaid was a child she has been introduced to the map of England, the European country that took control of their small Caribbean island of Antigua.…

    • 830 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Bahamas is recognized as a popular tourist destination. Each year hundreds of foreigners from America, and other parts of the world flock to its shores and Bahamians are notorious for treating their guest like royalty. Haitians are another group of foreigners also flock to the shores of the Bahamas. However, only a few of these people receive open arms of love and affection like the Americans or other nationalities that visit the Bahamas. In Fredrick Smith’s article “Discrimination is the Bahamian Political Crack!”…

    • 1155 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    INTRO: Imagine living in the time when the Taliban was at large and you are living right in the middle of warfare. in the book under the persimmon tree it shows part of what it is like to be a refugee and how bad the conditions and how crowded they are but in actual refugee camps in real life they are worse Susan fisher staples shows how the Taliban impacts the life of a refugee body paragraph 1: in the book it tells you about refugee camps and there conditions let me enlighten you on the situation. Susan fisher staples says that the refugee camps are filled with many refugees at most ten people to a tent with little to no food and dirty gross water but only a cup or less. Susan fisher staples also says that the refugees are injured with cuts and large wounds along with bruises because of them trying to get Away from their home.…

    • 527 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Countries have a moral obligation to protect the human rights of refugees. Refugees are people who have been forced from their countries within reasons varying from political unrest, persecution, and war; refugees are people who have been stripped of their human rights. To live in such dreadful environments is a direct violation of Article Three from The Universal Declaration of Human Rights: “the right to life, liberty and security” as well as Article Twenty-two, which is “the right to social security and is entitled to realization, through national effort and international co-operation” (The United Nations 1948). Take for example the story of Yusra Mardini, a refugee: somewhere along the coast of Greece and Turkey, twenty people are crowded on a tattered boat, trying to reach asylum across the Mediterranean Sea. All the sudden, the motor begins to quiet.…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays