Inequity In Plato's The Republic

Improved Essays
Aristotle analyses politics as a whole. Relation between law and ruler, many rulers and one ruler, individual and state, state and house hold management, etc. Aristotle’s work seems to promote a community-centered approach to society in order to sustain the state, which aims at the good life for the its citizens—the good life is the aim of the state, and of minor institutions such as the household. From several types of community found in nature, the state is the most natural and best one. Aristotle utilizes nature to prove which form of government, and relation between subjection and mastership, is more natural. His work is more of a sum of arguments than of a systematic treatise on politics.
In his first book Aristotle analyses household
…show more content…
They arise from the misunderstood permeated in the very foundations of ordinary states. Inequality is the result of bad and over-simplistic ideas about justice. These ideas have consequences, and many times lead to revolutions. Nor democracy nor Oligarchy are excluded from the possibility and reality of revolutions. Democracy, however, being by definition formed by the idea of making everyone equals, is considered by Aristotle to be more stable than Oligarchy, which is lead by extreme views of equality that result in the opposite: numerical and proportional inequality. This is how some Constitutions are formed, they are the “correction” of past errors. Constitutions carry the marks of past …show more content…
In order for a government to continue, it must restrain itself and his people from acting impulsively and/or selfishly. For a tyrant to remain in power he must act hypocritically. They must not act in front of the people in the same way they act in front of other tyrants. He must reserve power to himself while appearing honesty and transparent in public life. He should mirror the head of the household, and portray himself as a king. From all governments, tyranny is the one with the shortest life. After explaining this, Aristotle then attacks Plato, mainly in his understanding of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Wilson Vs Aristotle

    • 2256 Words
    • 10 Pages

    The Founders of the United States, in their lists of dependable and confident political philosophers, frequently included Aristotle. Some of the Founders, especially, John Adams and James Wilson, often refer to Aristotle and show an admiration for his Politics. By the “rule of law”, Adams and the Founders did not comprehend the simple consistency or predictability of law and procedure (Pakaluk, Michael). He was recognized as the original source for many policies, mostly declared by the Founders. Some of which include: “1.…

    • 2256 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Instead, he believes that international relations lacked regulation and justice, which allows the stronger nation to do as they please, and force the weak to suffer as they must. Having too much power inevitably corrupts all governments that rule only in their own self-interest, such as tyrannical governments, oligarchies, and even Athens’, the world’s first democracy. Corruption originates from individuals who run the governments, which is evident with characters like Cleon and Alcibiades, mentioned later on. However, not all governments are subject to corruption. According to Aristotle, governments that rule for the common good, such as monarchy, aristocracy and constitutional polity would not be subject to corruption because their verdicts and laws are made for the majority of citizens and not the few (Aristotle, Politics class…

    • 1792 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Apology In the Apology, Socrates intent at his trial was not to prove his innocence, but to unveil philosophical truths to the citizens of Athens, as well as exposing the true motives of his confronters. Socrates is known as one of the most influential philosophers of all time, but he never actually wrote any of his thoughts down on paper. Most of what we know about him comes from the writings of Plato, who was one of his students/followers. And attended the trail. Plato s Apology is the principal text on which Kierke-gaard relies in arguing for the idea that Socrates is fundamentally an ironist.…

    • 2079 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Aristotle Diction

    • 406 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Aristotle oligarchy and democracy are the mixed principles of the Polieta creating the Polity It avoids dominance through…

    • 406 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    Athenian Attitudes Toward the Authority of State Through the Eyes of Plato and Sophocles The first evidence of democracy, a government in which the citizens have say in the rulings, was discovered in Ancient Athens. However, when we study Athenian history, we focus on the democratic system of government and tend to overlook the Athenian citizen’s points of view. Through close examination of the writings of Sophocles and Plato, one can discover that the Athenian’s respect towards the governing power, changed during the Classical Athens period. Although the Ancient Athenian government seemed to have control over its people, Antigone of Sophocles and Crito of Plato reveal that from 441 BCE to 360 BCE, the citizens began to lose respect for the…

    • 1528 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Aristotle’s “Types of States” and Aristophanes’ “The Birds” seem completely unrelated initially however when “Types of States” and “The Birds” read closely both share the common theme of government and how government can greatly influence the way society works. Aristotle and Aristophanes contributed their ideas of government through their works each explaining in their own way how government affected society; Aristotle explaining directly in “Types of States” and Aristophanes showing what he believed would happen through means of entertainment in “The Birds”. The purpose of both writings was to be used as an attempt to convince the audience of their views on government persuading the audience to adopt their ideas. Aristotle and Aristophanes,…

    • 1444 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    For a ruler to maintain in power, the most important action he should take is to let the counter-elite circulate and get some power for them not to rebel against his government. When this does not happen, the counter-elite is not happy and this can lead them to organize the non-elite and start a revolution. A revolution is a radical change lead by violence. The Mexican Revolution ended with a the 30 year dictatorship of Porfirio Díaz and since then there has not been a dictator.…

    • 880 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    There are three classes of citizens in the state: the craftspeople, the auxiliaries, and the rulers. According to Aristotle, justice in the state is these three classes doing what the are naturally inclined to do and not meddling in the others natural craft*(434d). The craftspeople build and create, the auxiliaries defend the city, and the rulers rule. Similarly, there are three parts in the soul: the rational part, which rules the whole of the soul; the spirited part, which dictates our passions and carries through what the rational part declares; and the appetitive part, which desires. Justice in the soul is each part of the soul doing what it is supposed to be doing.…

    • 1869 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There is the tyrant, who is abusive of his or her given power and uses it to their own benefit and carries out their priorities through force and depends on the obedience of their subjects. The tyrant’s style of governing is authoritarian. They usually end up benefiting only themselves and using their subjects to carry out their plans. This is because the tyrant is usually arrogant and refuses to change their methods of thinking. On the other hand, the mature leader who possesses humility and the willingness to work not just with the rest of the government, but their people as well.…

    • 843 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Healthy Democracy In book six of Aristotle’s, the Politics, Aristotle lays out two major tenets of a true, healthy, democratic regime. The first is that members of a healthy polity must understand being ruled and then ruling in turn. Within this overarching assumption there is the idea that each citizen should have an equal share, as well as the belief that the poor have more authority as they are a larger population in the polity. The second is that each member of a healthy democracy, polity, should have the ability to live as one wants.…

    • 1421 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Furthermore the two conclude that this peace in the completes man, and this occurs inside of the polis. According to Aristotle mans is a “political animal”. This means that man is naturally found in a polis. Aristotle holds that the polis is created organically starting from the family, which grows need and eventually allies itself with other families to form a village, which in turn allies itself with other villages to form a polis. This happens because the polis is best able to supply individuals with a good life as no…

    • 950 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Introduction: Over the course of human history there have been a number of highly influential philosophers who have helped shape modern political science. Yet, few can claim to have made as large of an impact on political theory as Plato and his seminal work The Republic. The book takes the form of a dialogue between Socrates and a variety of different individuals, and touches upon a number of subjects, such as the nature of justice, and debating whether the just or unjust man is happier. Despite having put forward a wide collection of arguments, The Republic, and in many ways Plato himself, has had their philosophical legacy defined by the Allegory of the Cave in Book VII.…

    • 1904 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In The Republic of Plato, Plato considers the nature and value of justice and the other virtues as they appear in both the structure of society as a whole and in the personality of an individual human being. This city-soul analogy supplies Plato with a metaphoric language that enables him to describe aspects of the structure and dynamics of the human soul. He began with a detailed analysis of the formation, structure, and organization of an ideal state before applying its results to a description of personal life. This paper will explore how the Republic uses the description of an ideal city-state as a vehicle for explaining the harmonious operation of the human psyche, which can be likened to a city. This “psychopolis” can be well or poorly…

    • 1482 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Education and Democracy are entangled in American history and thought. Each one shapes the other. Plato mentions the cycle of cities and soul. The best city is the aristocracy, followed by a timocracy, oligarchy, democracy, and tyranny. The type of souls to be found in the city are a philosopher, timocract, oligarchy, democrat, and a tyrant, respectively.…

    • 1276 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As we have seen, Plato believes that justice is in the interest of those who are just. We have also seen, however, that Plato does not think that justice is good solely for its consequences; it is also good in itself, an intrinsic good. He shows this by arguing that justice is a component of the happy life. If the virtues were only an instrumental means to happiness, then they might fail to lead to happiness in other circumstances, and one might be able to achieve happiness with simply the appearance of virtue. But if virtue is the supreme constituent of happiness, then one could not be happy without being (genuinely) virtuous, and one could not be virtuous without being happy.…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays