Arguments Against Criminal Reform

Improved Essays
Inside Injustice
Every political figure faces the struggle of law violation and hence, criminal regulation. In the ongoing election of 2016, contenders debate the subject of criminal reform that assists non-violent offenders of the law. Two out of five primary presidential candidates voice their view on criminal reform support the REDEEM and Justice Safety Valve Acts. These acts remove records of non-violent offences on the federal level of juveniles under 15 and allow judges to regulate the minimum mandatory sentence of non-violent offenders to their best interest. Anti-reformists contend that laws exist to maintain order in society, with punishment being the main—if not only – factor that preserves the effectivity of the legal system. Pro-reformists
…show more content…
Although it is true that all citizens should be guaranteed the rights to life, liberty, and happiness, criminals that take away those rights from others violate Constitutional values. Therefore, they do not apply for constitutional rights. Criminals that deprive others of the rights to life, liberty, and happiness should no more be entitled to those rights than law abiders. In any terms of deprivation, depriving criminals of federal punishment decreases their chances of changing their ways, which discredits the authority of the judicial system. If an estimated 95% of nonviolent releases had an arrest history preceding the arrest which resulted in their imprisonment (Victoria Police Department), then evidently release without punishment must have little to no effect on their behavior. If anything, rehabilitation tactics should be reformed by the judicial system as opposed to reformation of the punishment itself. Punishment and -documentation on non-violent crimes allows juveniles to recover from mistakes and learn from them, the entire purpose of the legal system. The idea that non-violent criminals do not diminish public safety due to their “docile” nature is entirely false. 58% of released prisoners become arrested for a public order offense within five years of release (Slifer). Coincidentally, more than 80% of those nonviolent offenders released from prison have a prior conviction (Bureau of …show more content…
Children have the potential to take after their parents not only physically, not only genetically, but morally as well. 70% children whose parents are criminals are “doomed to follow in the same footsteps as their parents becoming imprisoned at some point in their lives.” In fact, children of incarcerated parents are five times more likely than their peers to commit crimes (Mosely). Should criminals be released to have their children stagger in the shadow of crime? Shockingly, this shadow looms over innocent families as well. Police, judges, officers, and wardens: where does their money come from? Occupations in the judiciary system typically receive pay from government—or do they? Ultimately, taxes fund government jobs. Citizens pay taxes. Citizens pay wardens, police, and correction officers. Why should that money go to waste on an insufficient system? Conviction of more criminals lessens the need for active law enforcement and “government” expenses on police. Although crime pays, it doesn’t pay

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Vance Gosselin Prof. Norling PHIL A120 MW 15 Nov. 2016 Response Paper “As a sheriff, I know that jail is not always the answer” written by Al Cannon Jr. for The Washington Post is an opinion piece that challenges the idea that all law-breaking offenders including those that commit nonviolent offences are deserving of jail time. The piece begins with the example of a young mother reported shoplifting groceries by store officials at a Walmart store in Charleston, South Carolina. This example of a nonviolent offence is a moral issue that our author, who is also a sheriff of Charleston County has encountered several times before.…

    • 634 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    INDIANA SENTENCING REFORM: TWO YEARS AND STILL NOT WORKING In an article I published this past January (“State Sentencing Reform: Reducing Recidivism OR Costing Indiana Counties More Money?”), I argued that the new sentencing reform bill, which radically changes the way criminal courts sentence offenders, could actually cost local communities more money without doing much to prevent recidivism. Under the new guidelines, offenders sentenced to a year or less in criminal court would not see a state prison. Instead, they would carry out their sentences in the communities in which they were convicted. If offenders had to serve jail time, county lock-ups would serve as their prisons.…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    By the time people enter into jail or prison, they have normally been a part of the system numerous times. Trying to rehabilitate or give consequences for people’s actions that late in the game does no good in regard to enabling them to change their life style. People have to be reached much earlier than when they enter into the criminal justice system. That is why there should be more programs for youth and programs that encourage education. If youth remain in school and are also given vital resources like safe places to live, food, and positive environments then they may be less likely to commit crime.…

    • 1735 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The New Jim Crow Summary

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “During the past few decades, millions more have cycled in and out of the system; indeed, nearly 70 percent of people released from prison are re-arrested within three years.” The current system of incarceration does not help those who came out of prison stay out. Rather it draws them back in due to all of the negative legal repercussion. Ex-felons do not have the same freedoms. They are barred from certain jobs, housing, and voting.…

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mandatory Minimums

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages

    With a total prison population of 2,217,000 people as of 2013, the United States continues to have the highest prison rate in the world (Institute for Criminal Policy Research). In light of these numbers, it is clear to many that the United States is in need of some kind of reform in the way it responds to crime and carries out justice, however, there is much disagreement on what aspects of our criminal policies need to be reformed and in what way. Many factors play a role in the enormous prison rates in the United States, however, some of these factors raise concerns not only about the prison populations, but also bring up questions regarding economics, ethics, and the overall effectiveness of the United State’s current criminal justice policies.…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Did you know the United States is home to five percent of the world’s population, with twenty-five percent of the world’s prisoners and ninety percent of those prisoners being non-violent offenders? According to Us News & World Report the prison population has grown by eight hundred percent since the 1980’s while the country’s population only increased by a third. With this cancerous growth of the incarceration rate in America, the question is how far will this problem go, and how much will the American citizen have to pay before they realize the current justice system is obsolete. With an outdated system of justice and a spiraling incarceration rate, the question on most people’s mind is should the justice system be reformed? The main question on a lot of people’s mind is how the justice system get so jacked up.…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Punishment in contemporary society is concerned with managing crime at an acceptable level rather than correction (Disagree) The Australian criminal justice system today focuses on rehabilitating offenders to reduce recidivism rates. Rehabilitating offenders is not only beneficial, it is a cost-effective means of reducing society’s incarceration expenses and lessens further harm to that society. This essay briefly discusses these programs and demonstrates through studies the effectiveness of offender programs in reducing recidivism rates and how these programs help offenders reintegrate back into society as law-abiding citizens. If Australian society stopped caring about rehabilitation, offender programs would cease and imprisonment certainly becomes a punishment without any redeeming features.…

    • 600 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As crime rates have continued to decline, especially in the recent years, criminal justice policy continues increase, therefore, leading to new social problems, such as a growth in the prison population, increased expenditures, and lengthier prison sentences. Over these decades, however, there clearly has been a cause for concern about the lack of accountability and evidence based practice in criminal justice policy in which is needed in order to justify these new social problems and the significant increases in the criminal justice system. Despite these calls for greater accountability and evidence based policy, a large gap continues to remain between these ideals and the realization of them (Mears, 2010). Evidently, these issues are in…

    • 919 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Having a parent in prison can have an impact on a child’s mental health, social behavior, and educational prospects. Mass incarceration has had significant and long-lasting impacts on American society, and particularly on the children of the incarcerated. This paper will provide an outlook on why having a parent who is incarcerated has a negative effect on the child. I will begin by providing an estimate on exactly how many of those incarcerated are parents. Secondly the effects the incarceration has on the children and finally what the government is doing to help these children to not follow into their parent’s footsteps.…

    • 1200 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The United States must reform its laws when it comes to crime, as of now people are only being hurt, with juveniles taking the brunt of that harm. One major law in need of reform is the law pertaining to felony murder. This charge is responsible for putting thousands of youths into prison for decades or even for their entire lives. Those youths charged with felony murder include those “who did no harm, possessed no weapon and did not intend to hurt anyone.” (New York Daily News).…

    • 1273 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Many people think that incarceration is like a vacation at a country club until they see what really happens behind the bars. Offenders do not get the help that they need when they are in prison. When offenders go to prison and when they are let out nothing has changed and they usually end up back in prison. The rates of population have gone up and prisons are becoming over populated. Craig Jones and Don Weatherburn proves, “The sentenced adult prison population has increased by about 20 per cent since the mid 1990s” (10).…

    • 1725 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Pressing for Prison Reform The prison system is just as corrupt as the prisoners inside them. We live in a world where it is deemed acceptable to punish a criminal by taking away their humanity, and only release them when they find it themselves. We must reform the flawed prison system; only then can we correct the criminal way of life. Today, it is not uncommon to hear intrusive and abhorrent events that happen behind bars, including excessive violence, sexual harassment, health violations, and misconduct of legal power.…

    • 1793 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Does Parole Work Essay

    • 1026 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Does Parole Work? Parole is a prime example of the reintegration program used by the criminal justice system. It releases the offenders back into society many of them are placed on parole as a proper form of punishment instead of having them crowding the prisons. Parolees, The Bureau of Justice Statistics tracking of parolees that found that 62% of parolees were rearrested within three years of their release (Worrall 210).With so many forms of parole from diversion programs, boot camps, house arrest, electric monitoring, and rehab programs. Alexander Maconochie ran a prison in England he believed that inmates could have to be rehabilitated, so he made a program in which inmates had to earn their release.…

    • 1026 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “Why Prisons Don’t Work,” Wilbert Rideau claims state prisons will never improve the lives of criminals and lower crime rates in other states. There are four reasons to consider for dramatic shift to make prisons legitimately functional: 1) Resulting with a “silver bullet” instead of turning a criminal’s life around, 2) Keeping a prisoner long enough can make a man embrace inmate life, 3) Not focusing on the main threat of the young potential criminals, 4) Not giving enough opportunity of giving a convict a second chance at rehabilitation. People who come into a prison may never come out of the rest of his unchanged life. Putting a “silver bullet” through criminals does not keep society safe.…

    • 916 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the last 40 years, incarceration in the United States has reached epidemic proportions. We have the highest incarceration rate in the world; we hold 5% of the world’s population, but house 25% of the world’s prisoners (Kelly 2015). The use of incarceration has gradually become a more acceptable and more used form of punishment. As a result, our prison population is overflowing with offenders ranging from petty theft criminals to violent offenders. As cited in the textbook, purposes of our justice system should be retribution, deterrence, incapacitation, and rehabilitation, (Clear, Reisig, & Cole 2016, p.72-73) but we focus far too much on punishment first and rehabilitation second, if ever.…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays