The Telltale Hearts: The Vietnam War Movement

Improved Essays
The Vietnam War was a military conflict during the Cold War that started in November of 1955 and ended with the fall of Saigon on April 30th 1975. The war was fought between the United States along with Southern Vietnamese against the North Vietminh, in response to the French defeat in Indochina. At first the people in the United States supported the war and thought it would be patriotic to serve for their country, like the older generation that served in the World Wars’. However, as the Vietnam War progressed, the antiwar demonstrations started to spark because as military personal needed to support the war increased Americans saw no end to the war.
Telltale Hearts: the origins and impacts of the Vietnam antiwar movement explains the reasons
…show more content…
military operations in Southeast Asia” and “it did not help stop the war but rather helped prolong it.” Garfinkle’s thesis is that because the antiwar movement was not organized, they only aided in prolonging the war because they were a distraction for the government. Garfinkle criticized the antiwar movement’s belief that the movement “played a major role in constraining, de-escalating the ending the war” were wrong and that the antiwar movement “did not save lives but instead probably cost them” by “unwittingly abetting the paralysis of the Johnson administration.” A contributing factor in Garfinkle’s argument of prolonged war due to the antiwar movement is that the “civil rights movement-trained students did not take over the leadership of the antiwar movement” specifically speaking, the Students for Democratic Society (SDS). There were three elements that shifted the center of gravity of the movement the New Left, old Left, and the pacifist, which had many different groups associated with them like the “Americans for Democratic Action (ADA), SDS, the Socialist Workers Party (SWP) and the WRL, the CNVA, the FOR, WILPF, WSP, and the AFSC.” Students for Democratic Society believed firmly that “the antiwar movement could never stop the Vietnam War… they wanted to change and revolutionize American society and politics.”
Confronting the war machines: Draft resistance during the Vietnam War connects directly with the draft resistance
…show more content…
Garfinkle’s position is argued through 2 major arguments 1) “the sources of the era’s youthful radicalism” and 2) “the movement’s longer-term impact on American political culture” (Garfinkle 1). Garfinkle justifies the first argument by stating the many different interest groups affiliated with the antiwar movement; for example, the New Left, old Left, and the pacifist whom were in the same movement with different opinions. Garfinkle proves the first claim by showing that the three groups (New Left, old Left, and the pacifist) had other subgroups and different organizations forcing the government to focus on the people’s interest shown through Johnson’s “Great Society”, which in turn disallowed the focus on winning the Vietnam War; such as the Americans for Democratic Action (ADA), the WRL, the CNVA, the FOR, WILPF, WSP, and the AFSC (Garfinkle 67-68). Garfinkle criticizes that the movements showed antipatriotism toward the United States government because it was against the government. The more radical the antiwar movement got, the more disorganized the movement became. In turn the movement was less effective because they were no longer fighting for the same thing. Garfinkle’s argument differs from Foley’s because Foley states that because the government paid attention to the society, it was

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The United States' support of South Vietnam and involvement in the Vietnam War had divided the American public since 1965, as many disagreed with the government’s commitment to preventing the spread of communism in Asia. In particular, the focus of the protests was how brutally the war was being conducted by the US military. Across America, young people loudly protested conscription and many college campuses became hubs of anti-war…

    • 1417 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One such issue was Johnson’s strategy in the Vietnam War, which gained protest from both “hawks” and “doves.” James Burnham, a columnist from the National Review, thought the president was not committed enough to stopping the spread of communism in Vietnam; restrictions on weapons, tactics and strategy hampered the soldier’s ability to fight. He basically recommended that the president remove any restrictions and let the professional military leaders control the operations. On the other side of the argument, many college students in the New Left movement opposed the war completely. In 1965, Paul Potter, the president of SDS, gave a speech at an antiwar rally in Washington, D.C.…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Vietnam War provided the perfect outlet for these radicals. After experiencing the antiwar movement, which worked to free the oppressed from the United States, other groups of people, such as African-Americans and women began to work for their own freedom from the imperialism and oppression of the United States. In her book, Radicals on the Road Judy Tzu-Chun Wu looks at the actions of Bob Browne, the anti-imperialist delegation, and the…

    • 2224 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Vietnam War Dbq Analysis

    • 738 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Overall, the Vietnam war was a popular conflict that failed in terms of the defense of S, Vietnam against the communist N. Vietnam, and changed many American’s opinions about the nation’s role in the world and on their lives. The Vietnam War was yet another example of the escalation of the cold war, but his time, American intentions were completely misguided, and the damage done to society was huge. American involvement in Vietnam increased conflict and tension in the U.S. because of the overwhelming unpopularity of the government decisions causing great social unrest and unhappiness especially young people, political corruption in the Johnson and Nixon administrations, and economic mismanagement of the war effort vs. domestic programs. As…

    • 738 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Tinker V Moines Essay

    • 1544 Words
    • 7 Pages

    On Dec 11, 1965, the Eckhardt family hosted a meeting discussing ways to protest the war. Mr. and Mrs. Tinker attended this meeting (Ellis 5-6). The following night the Eckhardt family hosted another meeting with the same agenda, this time for high schoolers. The students were told that they could protest by wearing armbands from December 16 through New Year’s Eve (Farish 6). Meetings like these showed the effect the war had on everyone.…

    • 1544 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Muhammad Ali Dbq

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Though Muhammad Ali was not one to skirt with the concept of breaking the law and resorting to aggressive means to ensure his survival outside of the ring, but he was known to stir controversy when his opinions, often strong, were to clash with the established norms and issues of the time. One of the most notable examples was his eventual arrest and conviction upon refusing to serve in the armed forces during the Vietnam War. An institution that was one of the primary elements of the counter-culture of the 60s was the act of drafting soldiers to fight in the Vietnam War, a conflict that was waged with the objective of stopping the then-threat of communism throughout South East Asia. With the Johnson administration focusing on ending the war…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Dbq Vietnam War

    • 1700 Words
    • 7 Pages

    It is argued that American involvement in the Vietnam War is not justifiable; they were engaged in the wrong war, at the wrong time in the wrong place. I consider this assessment to be fair and the arguments of Carl N. Degler, Jon Roper and Nigel Cawthrone and others will be discussed in support of this argument. This essay will also elaborate on why I understand this assessment to be fair together with reasons why the involvement of the Americans in the Vietnam War was unjustifiable. America’s motive for involvement was to halt and prevent the spread of communism and a containment strategy and foreign policy called the National Security Council Report 68, NSC-68 for short, was implemented to do so. Roper explains the introduction to a book…

    • 1700 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Anti-war movement started during the 1960s and shaped America’s public opinion on conflicts for years to come. As in all its conflicts, the support of the people on the homefront influences America’s military commitment.. Without Homefront support, the American war machine dies. American pop culture during the 60s and 70s, sought to change public opinion against the Vietnam War. Through blatant anti-war lyrics to their actions, the popular artists and musicians of the era influenced the mindset of a generation to oppose the military actions in Vietnam.…

    • 2408 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    President Johnson “became more and more a prisoner in the White House” amongst protesters (Morgan 147). Johnson even audaciously argued that he would be more open “to negotiate troop withdrawals” if the protesters stopped their “aggression” (Morgan 147). With these statements, Johnson tactfully projects his own violence onto American citizens in an effort to absolve any blame for his own questionable foreign policies. For Johnson to assert that peace would come sooner “if the American people were united rather than divided” strategically equates the efforts of antiwar demonstrators to be as harmful as actual…

    • 1215 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When a country can produce more troops than its enemy, as well as support from citizens the chances of victory weigh more than defeat. It is apparent that America’s government understood this concept when the Vietnam War took root. The Vietnam War consisted of a draft concluding all men from the ages of 18-25are required to fight in war. Fanatically deprived young men, who could not avoid the draft by paying for college, predominantly made up the capacity of troops. Conversely the rise of civil rights movement and the hippie movement gave a voice to young men who refused to fight in the Vietnam War and resisted the draft.…

    • 1186 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many intellectuals and Americans saw the Vietnam War as damaging to American society and, unlike WWII, lead to people questioning America’s role in the world and whether the country had any right to intervene. Noam Chomsky in his 1969 book American Power and the New Mandarins directly negates the idea of American intervention. Chomsky links the Civil Rights struggle in America with the Vietnamese people in the statement “racism and exploitation at home can be linked with the struggle to remove the heavy Yankee boot from the necks of oppressed people throughout the world”. Whereas intellectuals during WWII encouraged United States to join a war, the vivid imagery of “heavy Yankee boot” and “necks of oppressed people” when concerning the Vietnam War shows how American influence in other parts of the world was now resented by not only people from these oppressed countries, but by Americans themselves. As well as this…

    • 1926 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Anti-Vietnam War movement eventually succeeded with U.S forces exiting Vietnam. Previous to that, achievements of the movement were in public opinion not policy. The United States interfered in Vietnam for the purpose of containing the geopolitical spread of communism. The Anti-Vietnam War movement was mainly made up of baby-boom college students, as they were the people threatened by the draft. The movement co-occurred with social change for American women, black people and non-straight people.…

    • 1389 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Vietnam War Themes

    • 492 Words
    • 2 Pages

    What are the main themes of this week's material? The main themes in this week’s material were the United States’ image, blame placed on returning veterans, and Vietnam Syndrome. As discussed in previous weeks, the United States’ image had been damaged following the Tut Offensive when the media aired and published footage of the war. In order to help save what was left of its image, it was decided to finally withdrawal from Vietnam.…

    • 492 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tragedies infected the overwhelming hatred for the United States war efforts. Sympathy for “Vietnam Veterans Against the War” and other adamant organizations protesting the Vietnam War. The United States heard the outcry from the citizens and found it in their best interest to cut their losses and admit defeat. Such an admission of defeat came in the form of a peace treaty with the North Vietnamese. This treaty, however, came with the condition of a full American retreat but a continued occupation of South Vietnam by North Vietnamese troops.…

    • 1026 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Containment In Vietnam

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages

    While trying to win the heart of Vietnamese people, the U.S failed to show its ethics as a well represented country when U.S decided to support the Southern Vietnamese by using African Americans as armed soldiers to send support in Vietnam. By spraying toxic and dropping the napalm of to the North known widely as Agent Orange, this created a devastated aftermath of diseases implanted in the soil of the living civilians around the Northern area. Furthermore, it broke the US’s promise to provide aid and arms for the South Vietnam during Vietnamization policy. Domestically, in the U.S around 1960s, the U.S create a Student for Democracy and Free Speech Movement that eventually spread across campus around the regions. With a lot of effort, thoughts and hard work, the students starts to oppose the U.S actions in Vietnam, unfortunately the U.S resist the action and brought the whole nation to division between the Hawks (Pro-war) and Doves (Anti-war).…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays