1984 And Fahrenheit 451 Comparison

Superior Essays
Nineteen Eighty-Four by George Orwell and Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury are two well acclaimed novels (Goodreads) displaying the theme of censorship in literature. Both are dystopian novels written in the postmodern era (Oxford), thus portray many themes from World War II such as nuclear war, war poverty,, and totalitarianism. They follow the journeys of the protagonists as they realize the corruption of the society they live in, and attempt to resolve it. Although both protagonists arrive at different conclusions, it is clear the plots contain many parallels. This will be shown through comparisons between the plots, the societies they live in. the ideologies of the governments, and the themes of blindness and isolation. In Fahrenheit 451, …show more content…
The television, a primary source of entertainment, depicts gruesome, meaningless scenes conveying an erroneous notion of death and promoting violence. In a scene from White Clown, a show Mildred and her friends enjoy, “Three White Cartoon Clowns chopped off each other 's limbs to the accompaniment of immense incoming tides of laughter” (Bradbury 102). Clarisse mentions to Montag “[She is] afraid of children [her] own age. They kill each other” (Bradbury 32). This corrupt ideology on death also makes suicide commonplace; Gloria, a friend of Mildred’s lost her husband to suicide, and Mildred herself had attempted suicide before. In addition to death being taken lightly, a lack of love is evident in this society. As explained by Mildred’s friends, children are “ruinous” (Bradbury 105), born so “the [human] race must go on” (Bradbury 104), home from school three months a day, and are not shown affection by their parents. Furthermore, love is almost non-existent between couples; Montag sleeps on an “open, separate” (Bradbury 13) bed from his wife, and Mildred’s friends are apathetic about their husbands at war. The mindless nature of this society engenders it …show more content…
Unlike Bradbury’s depiction of passive control, the government, in this society has a constant public presence, and extends its control physically, psychologically, through technology, and over language, information, and history. (Sparknotes 1). Rather than an absence of information, citizens are required to “doublethink” and simultaneously accept contradictory facts in accordance with the government; thus history, information, and language are constantly reworked in consonance with “Big Brother.” Telescreens, televisions with cameras, are also used as a manipulative tool by the government to constantly broadcast propaganda and monitor its subjects. In addition, perpetual war, another method used by the government, kept citizens of the large lower class deprived of necessities, thus mitigating any desire to revolt. Although Big Brother maintained a greater appearance in the public, the governments in both novels utilized similar methods to attain control over its

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Although people believe our government and the Party in 1984 share no similarities, the two governments frighteningly resemble too closely to one another because they both publically and privately watch over their citizens through the use of technology and people, and they also change or restrict information given to the public in order to make the nation look more appealing. Big Brother spys on its people through the use of strategically placed telescreens as to interfere with any conversation being given, and also trains the children to become loyal enough to turn in any suspicious people they encounter no matter who they may be. Our government parallels their behavior in that they hack into citizens’ personal emails, texts, and voice recordings as to intercept anything they deem as suspicious. With propaganda, although our government does not intend to make the population remain in an amnesia-like state, it to copies they ways of Big Brother when altering information in history books as to make the nation appear more heroic than brutish and aggressive. Orwell highlights these points throughout the novel in order to persuade the reader to look at those they trust in a new light in hopes that they open their minds and not follow anything with a blind pair of…

    • 1599 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Society has become desensitized to things like death and violence. Mildred is always blissfully ignorant of the violence and crime around her. This is evident in that it took Mildred four days to even mention to Montag that Clarisse had died. When she did finally say something, her tone was uncaring. It was as if life means nothing to her.…

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    People in this society are miserable. They don't care about one another or have anything to talk about. Mrs. Phelps, a friend of Montag's wfie Mildred, has had 3 husbands that either killed themselves or went of to war. Mildred's other friend, Mrs. Bowles sends her children away to school to get away from them. She even had given birth by Caesarian sections because there is "no use of going through all that agony for a baby".…

    • 955 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Differences: 1. Clarisse and Montag meet for the first time in the street late at night in the book but they meet on the train in the movie. Clarisse is a school teacher and twenty in the movie but a student and seventeen in the book. Clarisse also dies in the book but stays alive in the movie.…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fahrenheit 451 Comparison

    • 1562 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Fahrenheit 451 And Saudi Arabia Comparison Essay “Of all dictatorships, a dictatorship sincerely exercised for the good of its people may be the most oppressive.” This quote talks about how the more tyrannical a dictatorship gets, the more strict rules and harsh consequences will be implemented to the people of their country. In Saudi Arabia, the people are living in a dystopian society as rules have harsh consequences, censorship of the internet, and the fear of ISIS. In Fahrenheit 451, people are living in a utopia which turns out to be a dystopia as technology takes care of people problem’s but in return take their humanity away from them, with the censorship of knowledge, and the fear of the hound.…

    • 1562 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Fahrenheit 451, a dystopian novel by Ray Bradbury, the government controls its citizens by eliminating books and other forms of mental stimulation, which are replaced by mind-numbing television shows and school programs. The control exerted on citizens by the government and media reflects Karl Marx’s theory of social classes, which can be seen in the novel's characters, as well as it’s description of government control. Fahrenheit was written in the 1950’s, during the Red Scare. This was a time when Americans feared communism and it’s possible infiltration of the government and society. Jonathan Eller points out that “the book was conceived while Josef Stalin was still in power in Russia and published before Sen. Joseph McCarthy was censured…

    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What if in our world, knowledge was limited and nobody could truly connect with anybody on a personal level? Well, in the society of the book Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury, both of these things are happening. The society created in the book and our society today may look and sound very different, yet that’s not all there is to it. In many ways, this supposed “utopian” society of Fahrenheit 451 and our society that we live in today are very different, nonetheless, the two also have their similarities and are alike in many different ways.…

    • 1035 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fahrenheit 451 and 1984 After reading the dystopian novels of 1984 by George Orwell and Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury, one can see numerous similarities and differences between the two novels. In 1984 the protagonist, Winston, has a strong desire to withdraw himself and challenge the dystopian society, but is lost without a helping hand. In Fahrenheit 451, the main protagonist, Guy Montag (referred to as Montag), has the same urges as Winston, but is substantially more proactive about it. This raises the important question of, how are 1984 and Fahrenheit, so similar, but so different?…

    • 849 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For starters, the way people deal with their emotions. In Fahrenheit 451, people have ways to control how they feel. Everyone in the society does these things. For example, there are destruction places when people are angry. Clarisse McClellan states that she often goes to these places to solve her anger problems.…

    • 463 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    After Mildred remembers to tell Montag about Clarisse’s disappearance, Montag pays closer attention to Mildred which shows her bland life style, “her hair burnt by chemicals to a brittle straw, her eyes with a kind of cataract unseen but suspect far behind the pupils, the reddened pouting lips, the body as thin as a praying mantis from dieting, and her flesh like white bacon” (45). The words used paints an unpleasant image as Mildred is described as a corpse with her “flesh like white bacon”. Montag’s description of Mildred shows society’s demand for artificially beautiful women which can be achieved through dying one’s hair with “chemicals” and “dieting”. With Mildred following society’s orders it highlights her adherence to rules even though it is molding her into the ideology of their society … Clarisse and Mildred’s differences are highlighted through the way they spend their time alone which influences Montag. While Clarisse refuses to comply with the ideologies forced upon her, contrastingly, Mildred lives a monotonous lifestyle, adhering to the standard of society.…

    • 1561 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The government, called the Brotherhood, in 1984 reminds everyone in the story that “Big Brother is always watching.” (Orwell 5) whether it’s by posting the phrase everywhere on billboards and billboards or repeating it at the end of every broadcast they have on their city-wide telescreens. The Brotherhood also uses corporate propaganda by placing the word “Victory” in all goods and products (i.e. victory gin and victory cigarettes) to insist to the people they’re winning the war against Eurasia when actually the fighting is only making things worse. The government in “Harrison Bergeron” let’s its society know they’re in control by transmitting their thoughts “into short bursts” (Vonnegut 1) of about 20 seconds. The government in this story uses technological control as an advantage to control peoples’ thoughts anywhere at anytime.…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For example, there are not parlor walls that people treat as family as shown in the book when Mildred states “‘The uncles, the aunts, the cousins, the nieces, the nephews, that lived in those walls.”’ (41). Also, people today do not play roles in programs on the television. Mildred spends her time being in programs. For example, when the novel states, “‘Now, don’t get angry!’’…

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The burning of books, the murdering of lives, and the destruction of knowledge. All of these subjects intertwine in Ray Bradbury’s novel Fahrenheit 451 to create a censored world where knowledge is viewed as a crime. As books represent knowledge in Bradbury’s novel, it is clear that the act of burning books as well as the individuals who refuse to give them up represents censorship and the oppression of knowledge and freedom of speech/expression. The three major points that will be discussed in this essay are: the burning of books mirror the real world’s book burnings as well as their purpose to censor and destroy knowledge, the burning of the old women and all of those before her represent the oppression of freedom of speech/expression, and…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fahrenheit 451 is a dystopian novel written by Ray Bradbury in 1953. The book describes what Ray Bradbury anticipates the world would be like in the future. He depicted a society in which values like appreciation of nature, independent thinking and meaningful conversations are not practiced but discouraged and replaced with excessive amounts of television viewing and listening to the radio. He envisioned a society where firmen do not put out fires but start them, particularly when it comes to the burning of books. Censorship is the altering or suppression of speech, public communication and other information that may be considered harmful determined by the government.…

    • 1207 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When a person first thinks of an overpowering government, what comes to mind? None other than the ruler who uses their iron fist to smash his opposition into submission and acceptance of the rulers demands. The rulers of this novel are called “The Party” which uses the name Big Brother. It is clear that the iconical figure of Big Brother has their eyes set to the people because “BIG BROTHER IS WATCHING YOU (Orwell 3)” and there is no comfort when a person’s every move is being watched by a collective person who is both larger and stronger than that person. This symbol of oppression uses stiffening fears and lack of privacy to allow The Party to ensure that none disagree with their demands.…

    • 1262 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays