Analysis Of Hirsch's Critique Of A Thoughtworld

1211 Words 5 Pages
Critique of a Thoughtworld
1.) In Hirsch’s “critique of a thoughtworld”, from The Schools We Need and Why We Don’t Have Them, he begins by talking about what he believes to be is the “one true belief” among mainstream educationists. He believes that the “one true belief” is characterized as a “constantly repeated catechism” that has “currently no thinkable alternative”(Hirsch, p.69). What he means by this is that for quite some time now educationists have been using the same old out dated logic in our education system, and they will not look at any different options, because they will not accept that their “one true belief” could be wrong. If they could just put their beliefs and pride beside then we would be able to reform our schools and
…show more content…
Since we are so “different from other countries we have little to nothing to learn from them.” This is important because it is one of the examples of how Americas education system how American educationists are only focused on what they think that we should be learning and will not take into consideration the other alternatives that are out there. In Hirsch’s “critique of a thoughtworld” he talks about how by 1987 the most of the Britons had converted over to their new education curriculum and after only a small time period were doing better then the British school …show more content…
By having these separatism educators will be able to easily teach their students without biases. Hirsch also talks about William Heard Kilpatrick and his connection with professional separatism. Hirsch talks about how Kilpatrick when he was the new institutional dispensation he implemented a militant separatism. With this militant separatism Kilpatrick was able to separate the “subject matter from pedagogy, and the separation of forward-thinking social thinkers.” As a result of this separatism the army’s strengths increased because its “principles were the best ones socially, scientifically, and philosophically” (Hirsch,

Related Documents