20th Century Homosexuals: Article Analysis

Superior Essays
A perspective on 20th century homosexuality
Males have a fear of being perceived as being gay because of the stigmatization that society has towards people who are homosexual and because of how poorly they are treated. Before the time of the 20th century, the author and historian of “The Queer Frontier” (winter 2014 article) Dick Lyle explains that there was not enough existing literature about homosexuality for people to be educated enough to comprehend the consequences that homosexuals experienced (Lyle 20). This essay argues that the punishing and criminalization of homosexuality causes a fear in straight males to be viewed as gay.
Firstly, the fear of straight males can be understood with following example. As mentioned in the article
…show more content…
In Winnipeg there was an incarceration of two men for three weeks because of wearing female attire (Lyle 20). This denotes that homosexuality was looked upon negatively and treated severely. In the case of Duchesne the police report did not even hold the true information of his arrest. As mentioned that it was because he dressed in a feminine matter, the police report stated that it was because of “buggery” as they put it (Lyle 20). This shows the bias of the legal enforcers (police) towards …show more content…
This demonstrates how much pressure is put on those who are homosexual. A quote from Spencer himself to illustrate his view on the matter “I do believe it was a mistake to have legalized it.” Spencer was previously a Baptist pastor which due to being religious may help explain his opinion but certainly does not justify it. He strongly believes that being homosexual is wrong and that not only should Trudeau have never legalized it in 1969 but that society ought to be courageous and make changes to what he believes to be quite a mistake. No male would want to open up about being homosexual if someone such as a politician would go as far as marginalizing

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The author states, “Men may feel particular pressure to disassociate themselves from such a label because homophobia, and the more general fear of being seen as unmanly, remains deeply fundamental to the construction of manhood” (Felmlee, D., Sweet, E., & Sinclair, H.). At a young age men are taught to be strong and not show any signs of weakness. When you are taught this strict view on life you start to distance your self from the emotional viewpoint on life. Therefore, when the time comes to be vulnerable and sensitive to another person’s emotion they will not know how to cope and handle the situation. Men are used to being that dominant figure in a relationship in which they start to lose a sense of what the other aspects of what a relation is…

    • 1707 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gay men are perceived also a threat to male dominance and control. Men need to be superior at all times and being gay makes you less superior in the eyes of your peers. Heterosexual men fear to be out-ranked by homosexuals in the work force. Gay men are seen as betrayers and should be killed of their crime. Wait, so why are gay men being killed, but lesbians are being saved? You would think males who like being superior would be happy to see a gay man being in charge and superior than get mad about…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Laramie Project, written by Moises Kaufman and the members of the Tectonic Theater Project, offers a commentary on homosexuality and living as a minority in the United States. As a gay man, Matthew Shepard represents a small minority in the overwhelmingly conservative town of Laramie, Wyoming. In Laramie, the population is largely straight and 89.39% Caucasian. These demographics represent one of the most reserved political views of rural republicanism. Rural republicans are largely homophobic, pro-life, and share a fear of the unknown. Through examination of The Laramie Project and current events, it is clear that American opinions on homophobia have changed slightly, yet remain similar to how they were in 1998.…

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sexual Identity In Canada

    • 869 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Robert Frank Wake who conducted the tests would conclude that they were indeed homosexuals (Grewal, et al., 2012). To continue, the timeline, in the late 1960’s Canadian Justice Minister Pierre Trudeau passes an amendment that decriminalized homosexuality. Trudeau explained that “what’s done in private between adults doesn’t concern the criminal code” (CBC News, 2012). I agree with this statement, the only people that should be concerned about what you are doing in your sexual life is those that are engaging in it with you. Otherwise, it does not concern them. Furthermore, almost ten years prior to this amendment, Quebec became the first province in Canada to include sexual orientation in the Human Rights Code. Thus, making it illegal to discriminate against someone based on their sexual orientation (CBC News, 2012). Skipping ahead another ten years to 1980, MP Svend Robinson attempts for the next decade to improve gay and lesbian rights. After a long battle in 1992 the federal courts lifted the ban on homosexuality in the military. A few years later in 1996 sexual orientation was added to the Canadian Human Rights Act (CBC News, 2012). Since 1996 same-sex couples are able to receive…

    • 869 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    1963: The RCMP tried passing a law to taking away all the homosexuality from the police…

    • 192 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Throughout the 1900’s there was a lot of things built up against the United States, from WWII to the civil rights movements there was plenty for the citizens and the government to deal with. One important part of this time that people forget is the attacks and discrimination of different homosexual groups within this time. Thus it is believed that the U.S. should have gotten involved in stopping any persecution of homosexual individuals or groups in the 1900’s because, if they had done something then there might not be any of the difficulties and misunderstanding that there is today.…

    • 1796 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Homophobia is a dislike of or prejudice against homosexual people. People who claim to be gay, lesbian or bisexual are still human, they have the same rights as we do, even if they do not follow the “social norms” of liking the opposite sex. Dude, You’re a Fag by C.J. Pascoe presents a variety of examples that show that our society has a problem with people being anything other than straight. Homophobia is more than hate speech in high school but the central concept around which adolescent culture is organized.…

    • 1316 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout the years, laws have been created to build a more positive view on homosexuality. Dr. Phil Hickey, PH.D., wrote “In 1973 the APA’s…

    • 1179 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The usage of the words “gay” or “homo” in a negative way can further normalize heterosexism. Within chapter four, “Sentimental Education” of The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao, Yunior describes the dorm Oscar lives in as “Homo Hall” because it was full of “weirdos and losers and freaks and fembots”(Diaz, 170) (Fembots is a term often used to describe a feminist who is very adamant that women are oppressed in every situation they encounter.) Yunior’s use of the word Homo doesn’t refer to the sexual identities of the occupants but that they are stupid and do not fit properly into society. The use of the word homo as a way to refer to something as stupid or abnormal can lead people to think that queer people are stupid and abnormal. The word gay used as a substitute for stupid comes about again when Yunior and Melvin are talking to Oscar about the sign on his door. Melvin says the sign written in Sindarin is “gay-hay-hay,”(Diaz, 172) meaning that the sign is silly and lame. The usage of the words homo and gay in this way can also further intensify homosexual panic. If a person who associates the words gay and homo with words like stupid, lame or abnormal, they will have a bigger reaction to being called gay or thinking that they might be gay(Parker, 210). By associating “homo” with “abnormal” then we are also associating “hetero” with “normal” and further…

    • 1700 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Homosexuality In Canada

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages

    To begin, before 1969, being homosexual was illegal. The gays were affected by this due to the severe punishments some of them received such as, being arrested, and the death penalty (Rau, 2015). An act that benefitted this group was first brought to light in 1996 when Canada added sexual orientation to section 15 of the Canadian charter of rights and freedom (Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, 1982). With this new addition to the law, homosexuals in Canada were then able to live in equality with everyone else in the country. This allowed Canadians to under-go several years of adapting to the new era where the public began to understand more and more that homosexuals are just like anyone else. As a matter of fact, study shows eighty percent of Canadians polled think that homosexuality should be accepted (Huffington, 2013). Finally, in 2005 Canada made it legal for gay and lesbian couples to get married (Timeline, 2012). Although this caused a lot of controversy with some of the religious folk in Canada, many of the homosexual supporters were extremely satisfied with this decision by the Canadian government. (Landolt, 2015) Also, a new program called “It Gets Better Project” has made movement in Canada with their campaign to let the LGBTQ youth community know that life does get better as it goes (IGB, 2014). This company was brought to life in…

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Holden affiliates with two other men who display homosexual tendencies or are described as displaying them, Carl Luce and Mr. Antolini. Salinger purposefully connects the three males through their attraction to older women, which is possibly a means for the men and boy to conceal their true sexual desires. Carl Luce is dating a Chinese woman who is "in her late thirties" (Salinger, 145) while Antolini is married to a woman who was "about sixty years older" (Salinger, 181) than him. Holden himself is attracted to Mrs. Morrow, as seen through his personal observations of the woman. He said, "she was very good looking" (Salinger, 54) and "had quite a lot of sex appeal" (Salinger, 56). This affinity for older woman is not a coincidence but rather a conscious effort by Salinger to connect the three.…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Homosexuality in the 1960’s wasn’t as open and fortunate as it is today. The same time period where Alison Bechdel and her two brothers being raised in west Pennsylvania in her graphic novel Fun Home, Her father Bruce and self were going through sexuality identification problems at the same time. Although it is not forwardly said but with evidence from the text, Bruce may have committed suicide in result of holding his true identity from the public, his wife Helen and family and covering up his sexual desire for younger men. All a mist of this, Homosexuality was still considered a mental illness and you could be jailed if you’re caught doing homosexual acts. Also the way homosexuals were portrayed made it look like to the rest of the world…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the last century, sexual, gender, and relational practices and norms have changed tremendously. With the sexual and gender revolution, people are no longer bound to lasting relationships with one another in order to have sex. Instead many individuals have shifted to short term hook-ups, at least for the early parts of their adulthood. While it may seem like people are foregoing marriage in favor for these short term relationships, young adults are still looking forward to getting married someday. Many teens and young adults believe that “they should explore different relationships [and] it may be foolish and wrong not to” (Regnerus 2011: 110). Dating and long term relationships are not in danger of becoming a thing of the past; rather people are pushing them off to later parts of their lives.…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article, the authors bring up the question of why the Matthew Shepard case became a national news story, opposed to other hate crimes that had occirred against the LGBTQ+ community. The authors point out that there were nearly 27 LGBTQ+ related hate crimes which resulted in death, however, none broke into the national news sphere in the manner that the Matthew Shepard case did (Ott & Aoki 489). The authors accredit this circumstance to the fact that Matthew Shepard was able to be ‘normalized’ into the everyday boy next door type of character, white, young, and middle-class. Matthew Shepard’s persona was an easier sell to the American people, and due to his adherence to what appeared to be ‘normal,’ the public was able to excuse what made him different, his…

    • 1150 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Lamble argues “that legal forms of limited knowledge and limited thinking regulate borders of (in) visibility, and play an active part in shaping identities, governing conduct and producing subjectivity” (Lamble, 82). Subsequently, the rulings post bathhouse raid dismissed the charges and declared the evidence that the policemen gathered inadmissible (Lamble, 82). However, the ruling that was made was in reality not a progressive movement towards social and legal inclusion and acceptance of queer women’s sexuality. In actuality, the cornerstone of the defense’s case was argued on the basis that a search of semi-naked females was conducted by men instead of women (Lamble, 83). Interestingly, neither the concern with regards to queer sexuality nor the abuse of liquor laws held any relevance within this case for both the judge and the defense (Lamble, 83). Therefore the ignorance and tip toeing around queers is highly problematic within our present society. Such that majority of queers and transgendered people are often associated to be a highly controversial and sensitive subject. The invisibility of non-conformists women in Canada can be attributed to the few public…

    • 1431 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays