Who Is Responsible For Gatsby's Death

Improved Essays
George Wilson pulled the trigger that ended Gatsby’s life, but all of the blame should not be placed on George. Gatsby’s death resulted from a chain of many events that all contributed to his demise. The death could be traced back to Daisy Buchanan, Myrtle Wilson, Tom Buchanan, or Gatsby himself. The main events that contributed to Gatsby’s death were Myrtle and Tom’s affair, Gatsby’s obsession and affair with Daisy, Myrtle's death, and George Wilson eventually shooting Gatsby. These events all have different causes and effects, but I believe only one person should take the responsibility for Gatsby’s death.

The first event that contributed to Gatsby’s death was Myrtle and Tom’s affair. Tom decided to cheat on Daisy and have an affair with
…show more content…
This death was very odd because Myrtle was the one who ran into the street, yet everyone put the blame on the driver for killing Myrtle. No one knew who the driver of the car was that struck her, but Myrtle thought that Tom was driving the car and she was hoping that he would stop to visit her. It was actually Gatsby’s car that killed her, but Daisy was driving. Most of the characters in this book could take responsibility for this accident, Tom caused Myrtle to run into the road, but Myrtle should have known better, also Gatsby should not have had the heated argument with Tom which caused Daisy to drive home erratically and to show no remorse after killing a woman. Daisy did not even stop after hitting Myrtle which infuriated George and caused George to seek revenge on whoever murdered his wife. Daisy allowed Tom to continue his affair with Myrtle which caused her to run into the street where Daisy hit her and drove off. These actions directly triggered George to hunt down the murder of his wife, so if Daisy would have driven more carefully and stopped after hitting Myrtle then maybe that would have saved Gatsby’s …show more content…
Unfortunately no one interferes so Gatsby was killed and only one person should take the blame for his death. Based upon research and analyzing the situation Gatsby is the one at fault for his own death. It was his life that was taken and he had the most opportunities to prevent his death. Initially this entire situation could have been avoided had it not been for Gatsby’s obsession with Daisy. Although her marriage was not the happiest she had not seen or interacted with Gatsby for five years, and she had probably lost most of her emotions for Gatsby. Five years is too long to suddenly try and re-enter someone’s life, especially if they are married, so Gatsby should have moved on and avoided the whole situation. Whenever Daisy murdered Myrtle he should have taken some initiative and cleared his name instead of waiting for his unknown punishment. Gatsby probably did not expect to be shot, but he had to have assumed someone would figure out it was his car that killed Myrtle. If Gatsby went to George and told him the truth then he definitely would have survived. Tom’s affair with Myrtle, Gatsby’s affair with Daisy, and Myrtle's death all contributed to George Wilson shooting Gatsby, but Gatsby is the one who had the most control over the situation so he is the one at fault for his own

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The novel The Great Gatsby, by F Scott Fitzgerald, tells the story of a man (Gatsby) who owes his life to Daisy, the love of his life who had been separated from him due to financial difficulties. Gatsby later finds enormous wealth through his involvement with Meyer Wolfshiem, and eventually finds Daisy through Nick again after throwing numerous parties in favor of once reuniting back with her. Once rejoined, numerous disputes occur within the main characters (Daisy, Tom, Gatsby, Nick, Myrtle, Wilson) which eventually leads to the death of Mr. Gatsby, but there are two characters in particular who caused this. Gatsby’s obsessive behavior and lack of sensitivity, combined with Tom’s decisions and desire for revenge against Gatsby for taking…

    • 358 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He becomes wealthy in order to show off for a woman that he knows is married. "Buchanan serves as Gatsby 's executioner; he allows George Wilson to believe that Gatsby had killed Myrtle" (Trask 3). This passage is about Tom Buchanan having suspicions about what may have been going on between his wife and Gatsby. Though he is not being faithful either, Tom decides to let Myrtle’s husband George believe that Gatsby was driving the car and that he deliberately killed Myrtle. In reality, Daisy was driving the car. Tom cannot believe that Daisy is not being faithful. He never thought that their marriage would get to that point, though he is already cheating with his secret love, Myrtle. “Some time toward midnight Tom Buchanan and Mrs. Wilson stood face to face, discussing in impassioned voices whether Mrs. Wilson had any right to mention Daisy‘s name” (Fitzgerald 37). This part of The Great Gatsby is ironic because he is not okay with Daisy doing something that he has been doing for a while. He expects her to be completely okay with knowing that he does it, but when she does it, he makes her out to be a bad person. In a sense, George and Gatsby are similar. They both love women who do not love them, but instead love Tom. Tom is the only character that is aware of this because he knows that Myrtle loves him more than she loves her own husband and that his wife, Daisy, loves him more than Gatsby as well. George and Gatsby are both searching for something that they are unaware is probably not going to…

    • 1459 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When introduces Gatsby to the reader, Nick describes his desire to reach his goal as something that," it is what preyed on Gatsby"(2). Daisy is quite reckless in nature due to the privilege of being a member of the upper class. Nick describes how," they were careless people, Tom and Daisy-- they smashed up things and creatures and then retreated back into their money or their vast carelessness, or whatever it was that kept them together, and let other people clean up the mess they made"(179). Gatsby takes the blame for killing Myrtle while it was actually Daisy who was at the wheel of the speeding car that knocked down Myrtle. Gatsby does this as a final attempt to rekindle his relationship with Daisy, but when she never calls on him after the incident, Gatsby knew it was over. Not only does Gatsby ultimately fail in achieving his American Dream, it is his pursuit for it that eventually kills…

    • 1397 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gatsby was dead in his pool and it was George who had shot him so it is easy to see why George could be most responsible. George, though, was convinced by Tom that it was Gatsby that killed Myrtle when he was “distraught with anger” as the prosecution had said. This could show that George would not have killed Gatsby if only Tom had not convinced it was. Then again, Daisy could also be blamed for Gatsby’s death because if she had told the authorities, George would not have killed Gatsby. These are the reasons why a majority of the jurors decided that there was no person wholly responsible for Gatsby’s…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gatsby Desire Quotes

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Gatsby made all of his decisions based on Daisy, this lead to his death because he was so blinded by his love for her he couldn’t make clear decisions. Nick is explaining Gatsby's larger than life view of Daisy when he ponders,”There must have been moments even that afternoon when Daisy tumbled short of his dreams- not through her own fault, but because of the colossal vitality of his illusion” (Fitzgerald 76). Gatsby had become so obsessed with Daisy that she couldn’t even satisfy him because of how much he made her to be. This lead to Gatsby basically going insane because all he could think about or care about was getting Daisy. Gatsby is speaking to Daisy for the first time in 5 years when he states,”Look at this said Gatsby quickly,” “Here’s a lot of clippings about you” (Fitzgerald 99). Gatsby saved newspaper clippings about Daisy which is pretty creepy. He was so enthralled with her that he would save newspaper clippings about her. This shows his obsessive behavior that lead to his death. Gatsby is talking to Nick about who was driving when Myrtle was killed when Gatsby claims,”Yes,” he said after a moment,”but of course I’ll say I was” (Fitzgerald 151). Gatsby was so blinded by his love for Daisy that it ultimately lead to his death. Since Gatsby took the blame for killing Myrtle he was shot by Mr. Wilson, Myrtle's husband. Gatsby was also blamed for cheating with Myrtle even though it was Tom. Sometimes love…

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gatsby, so sure of Daisy’s love for him, challenges Tom by saying, “Your wife doesn’t love you. She’s never loved you. She loves me.” Displaying her selfishness, Daisy takes advantage of Gatsby by fraternizing with him while refusing to leave her husband. Nevertheless, Gatsby still believes love will prevail. Later, when Nick inquired about Daisy’s role in the hit-and-run, asking if she was driving, Gatsby replies with, “Yes, but of course I’ll say I was.” Selfishly, Daisy allows Gatsby to take liability for Myrtle’s death instead of taking responsibility herself. Soon after, Fitzgerald writes, “It was after we started with Gatsby toward the house that the gardener saw Wilson’s body a little way off in the grass, and the holocaust was complete.” The liability of Daisy’s mistake ultimately leads to his own demise. Firstly, Daisy refuses to take the onus for her actions,…

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He also manipulates George Wilson, who is rendered emotionally unstable by the tragic death of his wife, by implying that Gatsby used Myrtle as his mistress and is thus responsible for her death, in his vendetta against Gatsby. Even though Daisy is in control of the car when the accident unfolds, she willingly allows Gatsby to assume accountability and remove the blame from her shoulders. In doing so, she exploits his romantic infatuation with her and readiness to do anything that will please her. It is this fraudulence that subsequently results in George Wilson being convinced that Gatsby played a role in the killing of his wife and leads to the murder of Gatsby in retaliation. They demonstrate complete disregard for the value of the lives of others, remaining indifferent and apathetic towards the havoc they have wreaked in the wider society. Through the ability…

    • 669 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tom Buchanan shows great sympathy towards Wilson when Myrtle dies. When Tom is there for Wilson when Myrtle dies, it is actually because he wants to keep his wife out of trouble. Daisy was the one to hit Myrtle with the car, but Tom convinced Wilson that it was Gatsby who hit her. Tom Buchanan’s lies to Wilson lead to the shooting of Gatsby. Tom admits to Nick that he lied to Wilson when he said “‘What if I did tell him? That fellow had it coming to him. He threw dust into your eyes just like he did in Daisy's, but he was a tough one. He ran over Myrtle like you'd run over a dog and never even stopped his car.’ There was nothing I could say, except the one unutterable fact that it wasn't true (Fitzgerald. Pg. #) ”. Readers think it is a redeemable moment for Tom to stick up for Daisy and acting like he cares about her but it is just to get her out of the trouble. Tom sticks up for Daisy by lying, just to get back at Gatsby. When Tom does this and gets Gatsby killed it, it concludes how Tom lied for an awful reason. Tom has the wrong motive and reasoning to back his wife up which makes this moment not…

    • 917 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “She accidentally kills Myrtle Wilson while driving Gatsby’s car, and agrees to let Gatsby take the blame” (Tate 97). Not to mention, there is a whole separate theory on whether it was quite accidentally or not, and if it was her plan all along: to get rid of Myrtle, so she can go back to Tom. Even if it was accidentally or not, Daisy should have just owned up to it and not let Gatsby take the blame. After the accident, Daisy and Tom were sitting in their house eating cold fried chicken, because everyone thought that since it was Gatsby’s car, he was the one that killed Myrtle. Nick sees Gatsby outside, and asks Gatsby if it was Daisy was the person driving the car. He revealed “Yes, but of course I’ll say I was” (Fitzgerald 143). Here, after Daisy’s reckless driving, she is so careless, she doesn’t even own up to it. In fact, Gatsby almost feels responsible to clean up her mess once again, take the blame, and clear any footprints Daisy may have left behind. This backs up the fact that Daisy is careless, because it ends up costing Gatsby to stay in his home for weeks, and eventually leads to his own…

    • 1543 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the novel, The Great Gatsby, the driven, love stricken, and enigmatic character, Jay Gatsby, was shot at the end of the novel. Many would believe that the one most responsible for Gatsby’s death was George Wilson, the one who pulled the trigger, or the one who advised Wilson that Gatsby was responsible. Considering all the events leading up to that event, the unknown past of Gatsby, character’s decisions, specific settings, and the decisions of Gatsby and other key characters, there are other characters that are more responsible for Gatsby’s death including Gatsby himself and Daisy Buchanan, his love. Due to Daisy Buchanan’s unethical mentality and the decisions she made, long-term and short-term, that lead to Gatsby’s death, she was ultimately…

    • 1403 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Firstly, Gatsby’s emotional state was largely to blame for his demise. He showed too much hope for his dream to come true therefore exiting reality and unknowingly putting himself in grave danger. Gatsby orchestrated every single one of his parties for Daisy…

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In New York, Gatsby had caused for Daisy to leave in an unstable emotional state. Gatsby had been triggered by Tom, Daisy’s husband, after Gatsby had declared that Daisy never loved him and that he loved Daisy. Tom triggered Gatsby by making his own accusations that Gatsby was a bootlegger and that he was never from a rich family. This all goes back to Gatsby making up his own backstory. Gatsby’s lies and untold corrupt life caused him to emotionally react violently which caused Daisy to get scared and run with Gatsby in the fast car. Daisy, the driver of the car, was emotionally unstable at that moment which caused her to speed up and eventually killing Myrtle. In the end, Gatsby would be accused of killing Myrtle which would only put himself at…

    • 621 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Nick could not told explain all that happened at the crime scene, but he did manage to told him that he should stay low because he could be traced back from the wreck by his car. But Gatsby was sure that Daisy will call in the morning and they will go run away together. The next morning Gatsby was in his lawn waiting for Daisy call but Daisy was long gone with Tom away from trouble. Wilson, desperate and enraged, showed up to Gatsby’s mansion with a gun. He shot Gatsby and then himself. Later on, everything was blamed on Gatsby. The affair with Myrtle, the hit and run, everything, except the one and honorable fact, that nothing of it was true. Nick tried to contact Daisy but he was blocked and was told that they had gone away. Nick was the only person who attended Gatsby’s funeral. No one who enjoyed his luxurious parties when donated flowers or sent a card. Gatsby died alone and his memory died with…

    • 1588 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Tom pulls over to see what has happened and sees that Myrtle has been killed by a hit and run. He comes to realize it was Daisy and Gatsby in the car that hit Myrtle. As Tom speaks to George Wilson, Myrtle’s husband,” Tom blames the death on Gatsby though the real driver at the time was Daisy” (Inge, M. Thomas, and Eric Solomon). Gatsby who is scared of what will happen when Daisy goes home to Tom, stands outside of Daisy’s house most of the night to make sure Tom does not hurt her. Gatsby tells Nick, “I’m just going to wait here and see if he tries to bother her about that unpleasantness this afternoon” (Fitzgerald 144). After Gatsby realizes Daisy is not in any harm’s way goes…

    • 1339 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    As I read further into this novel, I was surprised by the fact that Gatsby was killed for a crime he did not commit. In the scene where Wilson is ran over, it was shocking to read that Daisy is the one who hit her. Daisy was under a lot of pressure and stress that night, and to add onto all the things happening that night, she accidently hit a person. What was even more shocking was that Mr. Wilson shot Gatsby because he was told Jay was driving the car. Tom was confronted earlier by Mr. Wilson about the accident and he mentioned Gatsby’s yellow vehicle. All the things that could have went wrong that night did go wrong. Almost all of these events were an accident and a misunderstanding, and the result was what was so shocking for me to read.…

    • 143 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays