The Stewardship Reform In Banking Business

Improved Essays
As of December 2011, the Stewardship Code has attracted 234 contracting parties, including 175 asset managers, 48 asset owners and 11 service providers. This is a good beginning and a clear indication that the market is willing to take the concept of stewardship seriously. But some banking crisis changes are not effectiveness. For example, the ‘ring-fence’ policy in Vickers Report. Due to the isolation of the retail banking business, investment banking and wholesale banking services have lost relatively cheap funding sources. It will reduce the profitability of commercial banks as a whole. The recommendations of the independent commission on banking reform not only impose higher requirements financial regulation but also have some negative …show more content…
There will be two different situations. There are differences in the regulatory requirements for systemic important banks, such as differences in minimum capital requirements, differences in control measures that commercial banks participate in investment banking operations, and so on. These differences will lead to regulatory arbitrage behaviour of commercial banks. Commercial banks may change the registration, establish different business segments of the subsidiary in different countries or regions and other forms in order to avoid its negative regulation. Or, according to Barnabas, Shearman & Sterling (2012) notes, ‘Foreign banks with small retail banking operations but a larger wholesale and investment operations will be adversely affected by restructuring costs. These banks may not be able to economically viable division of their business, leading to exit the UK market’. In addition, when financial institutions engage in retail banking, corporate banking and investment banking, structural separation of the ring-fencing alone can not prevent the risk of mutual transmission. Moreover, Stewardship Code is not a binding …show more content…
Many businesses and consumers had lost confidence in banks. After the banking crisis, many companies significantly reduced the investment and led to long-term economic negative growth and rising unemployment. More seriously, the banking crisis caused a global economic recession. In order to address the negative impact of the banking crisis, the Financial Reporting Council released the Stewardship Code. And Independent Commission on Banking Reform published a Vickers Report. The UK regulatory authorities have also improved a number of measures to protect the rights of banks and consumers and to prevent banking crises. These measures reduced bank risk and helped the economy to develop stable. But there are several measures not very effective, for example, the ‘ring-fence’ policy. It will increase regulatory difficulties and regulatory costs. And the implementation of ‘ring-fence’ policy is difficult to achieve. There are no perfect changes for bank failures, the UK regulatory should continue to improve the policy based on the actual

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    One of the ways to avoid discretion, as outlined in the concept of organization literature, is to make the foreign banks only depend on “hard information”. This however decreases the significance of foreign banks for the economy as a whole, since one of the main tasks of banks is to utilize “soft information” which unknown marketplaces on their own would not be able to13. Private local banks do not have the advantage of foreign banks in terms of access to external liquidity. This raises the concern, particularly in emerging markets with fragile regulation and legislation, that private domestic banks would be prone to “looting” leading to banking crises and catastrophes (see e.g. Akerlof and Romer (1993)).…

    • 1138 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Within the current system as stated earlier on 97% (1) of money is in bank deposits which are effectively liabilities of the bank of the bank and are very dependent on how well the banks are doing and how their affairs lie. We have seen the most recent crisis that banks have failed often due to poor investment decisions which led to deposits within banks frozen, the banks then had to be saved so that their customers could avoid losing their money. It shows how the banks were more inclined to take risks in the knowledge that government intervention would be on hand in order to save them, this meant that economy was dependent upon banks who were willing to take risks in the knowledge they would be save, this is not a sustainable environment. This problem would be overcome under the sovereign payments system, investments and lending of banks would become entirely separate to deposits in banks in transaction accounts meaning that their money would exist in the central rather than a liability for the commercial banks. So if banks were to fail due to risky or poor investments then the transaction accounts balances could be easily transferred to another healthier bank as it was stored at the central bank and not lost in poor investments.…

    • 1050 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During this period banks funding sources dried up quickly and they found themselves short on cash to cover their obligations (Olagunju, Adeyanju, and Olabode, 2011). There is a general sense that banks had not fully appreciated the importance of liquidity risk management and the implications of such risk. As result, policymakers have suggested that banks should hold more liquid assets than in the past, to help self‐insure against potential liquidity or funding difficulties (BCBS 2010). Holding of liquid assets such as cash and government securities generally have a relatively low return which imposes an opportunity cost on a bank. In the absence of regulation, it is reasonable to expect that banks will hold liquid assets to the extent they help to maximize the firm’s profitability.…

    • 1188 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The advantages of debt finance are interest is tax deductible; and debt holders are limited to a fixed return and they do not have voting right (J. Chris Leach & Ronald W. Melicher, 2014). For our business plan, we all evaluate the debt-equity ratio at the optimal level, which offers a balance between business risk and financial risk. 2.2.5 Learning According to my personal perspective and group viewpoint, we learned the following aspects from the combined presentation. For traditional bank finance, credit conditions generally remained tight, especially for SMEs. For non-bank finance instruments, they are gaining some traction, but cannot compensate for a retrenchment of bank lending (ADB, 2013).…

    • 1088 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    (Brett Child, 2011) 2. Disadvantages Firstly is credit score and interest rate. Although the business has chance to persuade lenders to lend money to them, the interest rate will still be based on credit score. If the company has terrible credit, P2P may refuse the loan requirement, or give higher interest rate. At the same time, ignore the payment would also influence you credit rating badly just same as banks.…

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Great Recession began in December of 2007 and continued through 2010. This all began with the bursting of the housing bubble. The resulting loss of wealth led to sharp cutbacks in consumer spending. This loss of consumption, along with the financial market chaos triggered by the bursting of the bubble, also led to a collapse in business investments. As consumer spending and business investments dried up, massive job loss followed.…

    • 1549 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Financial crisis began with a big increase over the funding conditions in the money market which had a big impact on the commercial banks. The bank had a big reduction in lending volumes, balance sheets, and profitability. They also had competition for retail deposits, stronger lending cuts, changes in the bank’s policy, and binding zero lower boundary. This crisis begins in the year of 2007 in the month of August. During this time, the commercial banks’ behavior was not good, because it caused many countries to decline in growth and banks too have less profit.…

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    U.S. firms also began to borrow heavily to buy assets with relatively small initial out of pocket capital costs. When the market crashed in 2007, investors tried to sell their assets to pay for their debt, but that drove lower prices and greater losses. The rise and fall of U.S. housing prices was driven by three main factors: Low interest rates, unscrupulous sales practices, and incentives…

    • 2020 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Gfc Case Study

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In fact, 99% of the income of these entities was not come from the budget of creditors but instead from that of investment banking, there are perverse incentives for not providing accurate ratings. On that account, should CRAs provide investment banks with lower credit rating; they, the investment banks, can and will loiter around other agency who could give them a more buoyant rating. Thence, CRAs with the fear of loosing their attraction, will bias towards a more optimistic rating hence provide investor with the misleading information for making decision. Although, the impact of CRAs on GFC would have been lessened if there had not been a heavily reliance of investors on these entities or if there would have been another external entities to regulate the rating of CRAs, the fact that securitized assets are far more unpredictable and extremely intricate makes this nearly imposible. On the one hand, as most of CDOs, MBSs or CLOs are combinationsof different tranches of mortgage debts and there is also asymetric between originators and investors, it is impratical for investors to access the rating by themselves.…

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Companies who are dependent on imported inputs for the further processing of their goods will gain less profits and are less competitive on the market. Thus, small and medium-sized businesses might go bankrupt and jobs will get lost. To add to this, Great Britain will not only lose economic benefits and further growth opportunities from trade with the EU but it will miss out on further trade agreements between the EU and other countries such as the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership. This would imply that Great Britain has to negotiate trade agreements by themselves with other non-European countries. However, this might turn out to be difficult due to having a low bargaining power in comparison with an economic union such as the EU.…

    • 746 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays