The Robot's Rebellion Book Review

Superior Essays
In the animal kingdom species survive through natural selection, meaning they must adapt and pass upon the information to next generations to ensure the survival of a species. Humans, like all organisms, have complex mental modules that evolved to keep the genes from extinction. This concept is explored in Keith E. Stanovich book, The Robot's Rebellion: Finding Meaning in the Age of Darwin. Stanovich refers to the concept that humans are merely robots created by our genes to protect them and to promote their survival. He expands on the universal Darwinian view of human psychology, that humans are vehicles for self-replicating genes and self-replicating memes, acting upon their own interests to replicate themselves rather than in their human hosts’ interests.
Stanovich explains the fact that the evolution is programmed into our brains, much like how a robot is coded. Within humans are two minds in one Brain. One is called; The Autonomous Set of Systems: short leased genetic goals that are relatively stable. This system evolved much earlier in evolutionary history than did the second mind. While the system, the analytic control system, it draws upon rationality to help us fulfill our goal as humans. The analytic system is the key to our rebellion. It allows us to recognize TASS prompted behavior and conduct self-evaluations. Through reflection, TASS can be overruled and instead humans can behave in a way which is beneficial for the ‘host’, not the genes. We are robots in the sense that large parts of our behavior are controlled by these Darwinian 'modules' that have been survived through natural selection in order to take care of our genes. Usually, TASS serves the interests of our gene's, not of humans, with the sole purpose to replicate. Unlike other species within the animal kingdom, humans have the ability to become aware of their robotic programming and can choose to override it through higher level rationality through the help of. This rebellion is what Stanovich refers to when he states the Robots rebellion. An example touched upon in the book Riveted by Jim Davis is the way humans react to prepackaged cupcakes. The new part, or analytical control system, realizes that the prepackaged cupcakes have no beneficial value for our health. However, the old brain, or TASS, creates the human impulse that you should eat many. This originates from our ancestors. The old brain, TASS, is programmed to optimize on sugar and fat, believing they are scarce and should always be eaten when the opportunity arises. Sugar and fat are a source of energy intake, which made sense in our ancestors' environment but which is no longer relevant present day. This creates internal mental conflicts the pulling between TASS and analytical system.
…show more content…
The analytical system thinks more logically, in a step-by-step way. TASS is not deliberative; it is intuitive. It is important to remember to ensure that when going against TASS the reason is beneficial for the ‘host’ and that they are not the result of successful memes. As Stanovich puts it, Memes, just like genes, can also make us behave in a way that benefits their reproduction. The term 'meme', was created by Dawkins. Memes are pieces of cultural information. They are considered cultural replicators while in contrast genes are biological replicators, and transmission to as many individuals as possible is a meme's first and foremost goal. Memes have a main focus for their propagation than for Humans. So although at times Humans have to establish their interests and goals to pursue, in contrast to their genes, The goals may not necessarily be good for them. Such as an alcoholic may want to drink, but that is not what is best for them. The capacity to overrule TASS is a process of higher-order rational reflection of our own personal desires and is the reason behind humans ability to successful rebel. The Robot’s Rebellion was essential to cope with the complexity of environmental challenges. Without this ability, humans could not rationally evaluate their personal desires, or determine what is best for them personally. Humans would be at the mercy of what was the desired interest of their genes. TASS-prompted behavior tends to lead to suboptimal results, and when subjected to various tests of rationality, humans often exhibit irrational behavior. According to Stanovich,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In Robots and Minds, William Lycan tries to show that it is feasible that robots can have the same kind of mind that humans do, under the condition that machines are able to have consciousness just like humans. He further expounds this theory by introducing AI, claiming that researchers have already designed machines that can do human-functioning activities (such as reading books, playing chess, etc.) Lycan concludes that all of these actions are considered to be intelligent behavior in human standards. However, Lycan perceives the word “intelligent” as too generalized, and goes to compose his own definition: where intelligence is the ability to provide responses and to be able to adapt to unexpected situations.…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Edmond Hamilton’s story “The Man Who Evolved” is an exploration of what might occur in the chain of human evolution in the distant future. Despite a lack of actual science, or even actual scientific possibilities to back up the experiment presented, the story is considered an example of Science Fiction. The reasoning for this classification is that the story explores more than just evolutional possibilities. Hamilton presents a look at the reactions of un-evolved humans to the newly evolved Dr. John Pollard. Their horror and awe at each stage of his evolutionary transformation gives readers a reflection of their own aversion to different types of people, or the proverbial “other”.…

    • 1627 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Herd Mentality Tiger Breedlove GMC As human beings, we seem to be the at the top of the food chain solely based on our superior intelligence. We have evolved to a point of self-awareness with a desire to learn and better ourselves intellectually. However, we still cannot shed some of our more instinctual traits, such as our needs, fears, and reproductive desires. Moreover, there are certain psychological traits that are similar to those of the rest of the animal kingdom.…

    • 862 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Evolution is a natural process that occurs throughout the history of time; this process allows the Earth and it’s inhabitants to adapt to current environments to survive. Humans are physically and mentally subjected to evolution, although humans have ceased from major physical evolutionary changes since the dawn of Homo Sapiens, their minds are ever-changing to further progress the human race. Throughout the course of human history, every generation had a different sense of purpose, beliefs, and ideologies. Every era is unique to it’s own, people from each era learned from the previous generations’ successes and failures to build the most ideal society for themselves.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Merriam-Webster dictionary explains evolution as a theory of changes that occur because constant change that excel naturally over a long period of time. (Merriam-Webster) This means that over a long period of time there were changes made from all the species and as time progressed we all started to break up into different categories and then different branches of those categories. It is said that we, as humans, share the same category as the primates. Though, over time we started to evolve into a category within ourselves, we share similar features to our brothering primates.…

    • 1099 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Bill ****** Professor Aaron ******* Philosophy 100 Creating Ourselves So many questions loom when we think about how we are what we are. Do we all know what makes us…us? Are we just the shell for something inside to control us? Are we all driven by what our minds create us to do?…

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Darwinian Evolution is gone. Some may dispute it has changed. We can suspect that it has been changed in a drastic manner, and in a quite small period, so as to describe our modern-day understanding as a modification of Darwinian theory instead of an addition to it. Bawazer’s enthusiasm concerning human selection and engineering are remote from Darwin’s theory of Natural Selection. People-manufacturing genomes through a method of controlling the fitness of genes is sacrilegious by comparison.…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    However, this concept turns out to be only an illusion for most. Charles Darwin’s theory of the survival of the fittest limited these dreams for…

    • 1573 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    How does this idea of a static unchanging design account for the evolutionary…

    • 1166 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Why Is Evolution Important

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Riley 1 Why is Evolution so important? Some might ask this because of the confusion drawn over the topic. However it is one of the most intriguing scientific theories that exists today. Evolution is far more interesting than the Theory of Gravity, or Germ Theory. This one addressed many age old questions, such as what is our place in this world, and where did we come from.…

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Evolution is the theory used to describe exactly why life on earth changes the way it does. It is evident that all things change throughout time, but understanding the reason behind these changes can be infuriating. In Evolution for Everyone, David Sloane Wilson bonds the basic concepts of evolutionary theory with different disciplines such as: art, religion, language, and pro-social behaviors. Wilson establishes a unity between the evolutionary theory and the development of culture, language, art, and other disciplines. Wilson describes the basics of evolutionary theory for the readers who may not be well acquainted with it.…

    • 1026 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Being products of evolution, nearly all living things are, in essence, products of their environment. The environment influences which traits are successful and get passed on. Before long, those organisms are directly products of their environment. This phenomenon chiefly occurs when the environment holds all the power over the organism. When it comes to humans, however, we are social animals, we influence and are influenced by those around us.…

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The school of Functionalism, influenced by Charles Darwin (1809-1882), dealt with the utility of consciousness and behavior in adapting to the environment. In essence, Williams James promoted the idea that consciousness has a purpose: to help us survive. Phillips presents Piaget’s theory as both biological and constructive: “The organism inherits a genetic program that gradually…provides the biological equipment necessary for constructing a stable internal structure out of its experiences with the environment” (p. 7). Because of this, Piaget can be labeled as a constructivist. Piaget’s theory was a contrast to nativist theory, promoting the idea that we inherit our mental attributes.…

    • 917 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Google It The world may wonder how people ever survived without the Internet before it came into their lives. They have grown accustomed to the easiness the Internet provides. The work that used to take someone hours or even days and weeks to accomplish can be achieved within minutes. In the article “Is Google Making Us Stupid?”…

    • 1618 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    For somehow this theory seems to be well in a way that the genes have surely an impact on the living species behavior and beliefs. The way of thinking, the approach use for the solution of problem and the way of adapting to new learning and beliefs usually comes from the genes of ancestors of the living species. For example, a woman or female is supposed to give birth to the children and men are not for sure. If we think to reverse this natural system as we create such belief and environment in which the men are supposed to give birth to the children, is it possible!! No, it’s not possible because of the genes the female got transfer from their…

    • 2042 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays